Last War in Albion Volume II Epilogue: The Cuddled Little Vice (First 10,000 Words) (Patreon)
Content
Lots more to come on this, but I think this is a long enough chunk to give a clear sense of what I'm doing.
----
In terms of import, at least, the War is by some margin Watchmen’s biggest side effect. It was not, however, its only significant one. Moore drew the magical theories that fueled Watchmen from Burroughs, but Burroughs drew them from L. Ron Hubbard and the Church of Scientology, and there were debts to be paid.
And so it was that when Grant Morrison made their February 1987 pilgrimage to London to pitch Karen Berger and Dick Giordano there was another writer, also recommended by Moore, who made the same trip. This was Neil Gaiman, a journalist who had struck up a friendship with Moore after interviewing him. And while Morrison would find no shortage of commercial success across their battles with Moore, neither of them would come anywhere close to Gaiman, who is straightforwardly the most commercially successful writer ever to emerge from comics.
Gaiman was born in November of 1960 in Hampshire, above his family’s grocery store. He was a third generation immigrant, his grandfather (who opened the grocery store) having been of Polish-Jewish descent. In 1965 his father David decided he wanted to go into business for himself, and moved to the town of East Grinstead in West Sussex, in part to open a vitamin shop, which grew into a major vitamin manufacture company called G&G, and in part to study at the Scientology Center in town. David Gaiman quickly rose through the ranks of Scientology, eventually becoming the the Church’s primary media spokesman in the UK.
In the official version of Gaiman’s biography—the one he offers to Hayley Campbell in her coffee table hagiography The Art of Neil Gaiman—he has what seems a largely happy childhood defined almost entirely in terms of his engagement with arts and language: dictating poetry to his mother before he even knew the alphabet, into Enid Blyton’s Noddy, British comics like Sooty and Pippin, watching the 1966 Adam West Batman series and Doctor Who at his grandparents, then reading Marvel reprints in Odham’s titles like Smash! and Pow!, getting The Penguin Charles Addams at age seven along with the Narnia books and Ray Bradbury, then Gilbert and Sullivan, proper American comics, Michael Moorcock, Lovecraft, Tolkien, Vonnegut, Burroughs, and then into proper literary fiction like Shakespeare, Oscar Wilde, and, as he finished school in the late 70s, finally into punk. It is a story that seeks, first and foremost, to explain how someone became a writer. Conspicuously absent from it, however, is any sense of texture to his childhood. The only story of his schooling is one of him nearly being expelled from school for repeating a joke with the word “fuck” in it, and even that is framed in terms of him learning about the vast and totemic power of words.
Gaiman has repeatedly drawn from his childhood in his fiction, however, and this paints a markedly different picture. His earliest work to engage with it was Violent Cases, a 1987 graphic novel that begins with its narrator, drawn by Dave McKean to look like Gaiman, lighting a cigarette and looking straight out of the panel to declare, “I would not want you to think that I was a battered child,” a declaration that undermines itself remarkably. Indeed, Gaiman’s accounts of childhood are all ominous and haunted affairs, unreliably narrated from the perspective of his childhood self and filled with strange terrors that hover just on the edges of his awareness and understanding.
Ultimately, however, one needn’t have details to draw conclusions. There is no plausible way that Gaiman, as the only son of the most prominent Scientologist in the UK, was not severely abused throughout his childhood for the simple reason that Scientology is one of the most comprehensively abusive organizations ever to exist, and David Gaiman spent much of his life perpetuating that abuse.
The Church of Scientology was established by L. Ron Hubbard in 1953, but has its roots in the 1949 publication of “Dianetics: A New Science of the Mind” in John Campbell’s Astounding Science Fiction, some three years after his successful fleecing of Jack Parsons. Hubbard was a regular in the pages of Astounding, and indeed in the pulps in general, having been writing stories like “The Trail of the Red Diamonds” for Thrilling Adventures and “The Blow Torch Murder” for Detective Fiction Weekly since 1934. “Dianetics,” however, was a different sort of work, purporting to be a new model and theory of psychiatry that would not merely cure various ailments but bestow outright superpowers such as eidetic memory. The essay and subsequent book version Dianetics: The Modern Science of Mental Health were enormously popular, in part because of the enthusiastic backing of Campbell, who had cultivated a reputation for publishing science-minded stories, largely inventing the genre that is now referred to as “hard SF.”
Unfortunately Dianetics was in practice one of the first major developments in a Campbell’s gradual slide into outright pseudoscience. None of Hubbard’s theories received a favorable reception in mainstream scientific journals, culminating in public humiliation when he held a public demonstration in Los Angeles in which he presented a woman who had undergone his therapies and developed “full and perfect recall of every moment of her life” only to have her botch a subsequent memory test. This, however, can hardly be called a surprising development given that L. Ron Hubbard was a pathological liar of the first order. As early as his teenage years he was penning multiple contradictory accounts of his dropping out of high school in his own journal. In his early pulp days he would spin elaborate fictive tales of his supposed explorations of the world, claiming to have spent years spent exploring the Amazon basin or hunting in Africa—so many different tales that the pulp writer Frank Gruber eventually pointed out that if you added them up Hubbard would have to be eighty-four years old; in fact he was just twenty-three.
The Los Angeles humiliation was a significant setback, and Hubbard subsequently lost the rights to the word “Dianetics” in a bankruptcy proceeding. This was followed by his split with Parsons’s ex-girlfriend Sara Northrup, during which she sought medical advice that concluded Hubbard was a dangerous paranoid schizophrenic. Nevertheless, Hubbard regrouped, regaining the rights to Dianetics and incorporating the Church of Scientology in 1953, paying off a claim he’d been making ever since parting ways with Parsons, which was that starting a religion would be an excellent way to make money.
Much has been made of the occult roots of Scientology, not least because Hubbard’s estranged son Ronald DeWolf made extensive claims about Hubbard’s involvement in the occult, including that Hubbard viewed himself as assuming the mantle of the Great Beast after Aleister Crowley’s death. This is dubious for many reasons, and it’s easy to overstate the connections between Scientology and the occult. Large parts of Scientology have their roots in an unpublished 1938 manuscript called Excalibur, which Hubbard claimed emerged out of a near death experience following a bad reaction to anesthetic. Although given that Hubbard also claimed that the manuscript drove many of those who read it insane, that should probably be taken with the usual compliment of salt. Whatever its origins, however, it’s clear that many of the ideas predated Hubbard’s acquaintance with Parsons.
Equally, it’s clear that his time with Parsons and resultant familiarity with occultism shaped his thought. There are clear similarities between Scientology and Thelema’s teachings, and more to the point between Hubbard and Crowley’s respective cults of personality. Perhaps most obvious is Scientology’s OT levels, a tiered secret society for daevoted Scientologists whose similarity to the O.T.O. levels is evident. There are also obvious elements of gnosticism in Hubbard’s cosmology, which posits that humans are immortal souls fallen into material bodies. Hubbard even admitted to many of these connections in a series of 1952 lectures, albeit in a typically self-aggrandizing and exaggerated style that included referring to Crowley, who he’d never met, as a personal friend.
Perhaps the most important similarity comes in the basic concept of Dianetics, however. Hubbard’s main contention is that the human mind is divided into two parts, the analytic and reactive minds, the latter of which is plagued by engrams, which are recordings of pain and trauma that get stuck in the reactive mind. This is recognizable as a lightly reskinned account of Freudian psychology and its thoughts on trauma, but Hubbard makes the distinctive move of focusing on engrams as images or ideas.The central claim of Dianetics and Scientology is that engrams can be resolved through a process called auditing, in which a Scientologist asks a series of questions to someone while they hold the contacts of an E-meter, a Hubbard-designed device that functions as a crude measurement of the electrical resistance of the subject’s skin, but which Hubbard insisted revealed the responses of the reactive mind. Once this is completed the subject will attain “Clear” status (at which point they will be funneled towards the OT levels), and be declared free of haunting engrams.
Of particular note is the notion of “implants,” which are a series of harmful engrams planted within everyone’s reactive minds in order to render them susceptible to mind control. These implants are logged over more than a hundred pages, in Hubbard’s own handwriting, which one has to audit their way through as part of the OT II level, and are simple words and phrases—“to betray is to be faithful,” “seize no,” “invent an arriving universe to stop a departinged universe” and the like. As William S. Burroughs notes, this amounts to a belief in magic words, as does the belief that talking through them via auditing will prove transformative. The underlying claim is that the way in which one talks about the world directly and materially shapes the world. To quote one of Hubbard’s favorite aphorisms, “what is true is what is true for you.”
It is not so much that this is an extremely convenient belief for a pathological liar as it is a cogent account—certainly more cogent than the OT II documents—of how pathological liars experience the world. This is born out by a series of documents typically known as the Affirmations, which Hubbard penned while working with Parsons. These amount to an effort at self-hypnosis via a series of short declarative statements. Some of these amount to simple validations—“I believe in myself and am poised and dignified whenever I wish to be,” for instance. Others reveal a startling megalomania, including the proclamation that “I am not susceptible to colds’ and that "You will live to be 200 years old, both because you are calm and because of modern discoveries to be made in your lifetime.” In several one can see a belief that Hubbard had spoken things into being before, such as his declaration that “Your stomach trouble you used as an excuse to keep the Navy from punishing you. You are free of the Navy. You have no further reason to have a weak stomach. Your ulcers are all well and never bother you. You can eat anything.” Perhaps most interesting are the handful of declarations in which Hubbard is aware of his worst tendencies and endeavoring to push against them, telling himself that “You never illustrate your point with bogus stories. It is not necessary for you to lie to be amusing and witty,” and, perhaps most ominously and tragically, that “I only have friendship for Jack Parsons.” But they all demonstrate the same underlying belief that, as he puts it, “you can will a fact into being with ease.”
Certainly that was what turned out to happen with his declaration that starting a religion would make him money. The Church of Scientology charged hefty fees for the auditing services that comprised its bread and butter, with fees increasing the deeper one got—the OT levels eventually ballooned into requiring hundreds of thousands of dollars, with Hubbard taking a 10% cut of all of it. In the earliest days, at least, all of this was further tax exempt—which Hubbard openly admitted was the primary purpose of pivoting from offering Dianetics as a psychiatric treatment into Scientology as a religion. But in 1958 the US Government made the understandable conclusion that the operation was in fact set up to funnel money towards Hubbard. The next year Hubbard purchased the Saint Hill Manor in East Grinstead, and relocated there.
By the time David Gaiman arrived in East Grinstead six years later Hubbard’s operation had grown increasingly paranoid and authoritarian, with a bevy of abusive tactics to assert deep control over members’ lives so that they could continue to be fleeced for money. In 1960 Hubbard introduced the practice of security checks—an interrogation-based audit in which subjects would be probed about criminal and sexual activity. Like all auditing this was conducted with an E-meter, which would inevitably provide arbitrary responses that purported to reveal the truth within the reactive mind, giving the auditor license to probe and bully confessions out of people regardless of their truth. The practical effect of this was that the Church amassed substantial blackmail files on its members that could be leveraged against them if they eventually turned on Scientology. And Hubbard’s policy on such people—deemed within Scientology jargon as ‘suppressive persons“—was one of brutal and wholesale hostility—as one expression of the so-called “fair game” policy put it, they could be “deprived of property or injured by any means by any Scientologist without any discipline of the Scientologist. May be tricked, sued or lied to or destroyed.” In the event that a Scientologist’s friends or family were deemed suppressive persons the policy was called “disconnection,” and involved the complete cessation of all contact with them.
Gaiman and Hubbard only overlapped briefly in East Grinstead, with Hubbard departing in 1966, eventually establishing the Sea Org—a fleet of Scientology ships with pseudo-military structure that Hubbard ran with increasingly abusive and despotic control—punishments for misbehavior included being locked in ships’ bilge tanks for days or weeks, or simply being thrown overboard. Hubbard lived at sea for a decade before returning to the United States in 1975 following a heart attack, and lived out his final decade in hiding with increasingly ill health until his death in 1986. But Saint Hill Manor remained an important hub of Scientology, especially in the UK, and David Gaiman soon became one of the most important figures within it.
Most notably, East Grinstead was the headquarters of the Guardian’s Office, which Hubbard established around the time of his departure as the Church’s own intelligence agency, responsible for enforcing the fair game policy against Scientology critics. Gaiman became a significant figure in this office. In 1969 he was a major figure in Scientology’s attempted entryist coup against the National Institute for Mental Health, intended to legitimize Scientology’s hostility to mainstream psychiatry, and in 1975 he was involved in “Operation Cat,” an attempt “to plant grossly false information in governmental agencies, especially security services files,” with the idea that they would subsequently file Freedom of Information requests to uncover the information and humiliate the agencies in question. He was also among the Scientologists to wade into a battle of letters with William S. Burroughs after he turned on the organization, penning a 1970 essay in which he defended Scientology from Burroughs’s accusations of racism by declaring that “I am a Scientologist, a member of the Church of Scientology. I am also a Jew by race, religious practice, and cultural background. I am equally proud of my membership in both groups.”
Gaiman was in no way above using his son in the course of his public advocacy for Scientology. When, in 1968, the younger Gaiman was blocked from enrolling at Fonthill School by the headmaster, who noted that “the family belongs to an organization described as socially harmful. Once their name is cleared I would accept the boy,” David Gaiman arranged for him to do a BBC Radio interview in order to attract sympathy and attempt to paint the Church as non-threatening. The resulting interview paints an unsettling picture, with the seven-year old Gaiman dutifully reciting Scientology talking points describing it as “an applied philosophy dealing with the study of knowledge,” although he rather cutely admits that he’s forgotten what philosophy is. When asked where he learned that meaning of Scientology Gaiman simply makes a non-sequitur response, saying that “In clearer words, it’s a way to make the able person more able.” Subsequently he offers a definition of engrams as “a mental image picture containing pain and unconsciousness,” and rattles off a strangely complicated story about walking down the street and tripping while a car horn blares and a dog barks. It looks and sounds like it is: a child who’s spent the last several years, since he turned five, being indoctrinated into a cult.
1968 was also the year of a rather more dramatic series of events stemming from the Gaimans’ involvement in Scientology. During this period the family periodically hosted lodgers who came to East Grinstead to study Scientology. One of these was Johannes Scheepers, a South African man who, in August 1968, died of carbon monoxide poisoning in the family’s Mini in what was ruled a suicide. Although his alien registration card said he had come to the UK to study Scientology David Gaiman testified on oath that he was uninvolved in Scientology, claiming that he came to the UK to gamble. This was hardly the only eyebrow raising detail about the incident either—Scheepers had, rather inexplicably, taken the time to cancel his return flight to South Africa before his death, and wrote no fewer than two suicide notes that went out of their way to insist that Scientology had nothing to do with his decision. Neil Gaiman was unaware of this at the time—as he put it, “All we knew was that the Mini had gone away—and here’s another car”—although he would eventually use the incident as the inciting incident for his novel The Ocean at the End of the Lane, maintaining his father’s claim that the suicide was motivated by gambling debts.
Gaiman has said little to nothing about his experiences growing up in Scientology—when pressed on the topic in an interview, he demurred that “The easiest way for me to answer your question is that I don’t have a control version of me who did not have Scientology growing up” before noting that “What I do know is that I definitely grew up in a world in which being a science-fiction writer was a good thing. As far as my parents were concerned, that was an incredibly esteemed profession.” Nevertheless, it formed the backdrop of virtually his entire life prior to his meeting with Berger and Giordano. He moved away for a brief period at the beginning of the 1980s, although he remained active in Scientology, at one point traveling to Clearwater, Florida for auditing, by which point he had already achieved OT III within the Church’s hierarchy. In 1983—the same year as the birth of his first child with his future wife and fellow Scientologist Mary McGrath—both he and his father were declared Suppressive Persons. While his father worked to get back into the Church’s good graces, Gaiman settled into a more liminal relationship. He repaired relations enough to have moved back to East Grinstead in 1984 and marry McGrath in 1985 (they divorced in 2007, but McGrath remains active in the Church), but largely settled into a polite distance where he avoided upsetting the Church to the point where his family would have to disconnect from him, but declined to rejoin himself, instead focusing on establishing himself as a writer.
Nevertheless, its scars—the bastard spawn of Watchmen’s magic—remained.
Gaiman’s career began journalism, moving from the fanzine scene to writing for British skin magazine Knave, which suffered massive financial problems almost immediately after he started working for them. It was ultimately bought out by its printer, who were desperate not to lose a major account, but who had no real experience with the editorial side of magazine making. Accordingly, they leaned heavily on existing staff, which meant that Gaiman was largely left alone to fill the articles section of the magazine however he pleased. Mostly, this meant doing a lot of interviews with people Gaiman found interesting.
From the start Gaiman displayed an extraordinary degree of career savvy. It is not quite that he was ruthless about it so much as it is that it is clear he learned about the world from ruthless people. He had career goals, and he made sure that his actions advanced them beyond simply providing a paycheck. He made sure both to establish himself as a clear presence within the interviews—the same trick Moore and Morrison had both used within the British scene to build their public personae. More importantly, he used the interviews in order to network and befriend a myriad of figures who he would later turn to in order to establish his career. A friendship with Terry Pratchett, meanwhile, meant that when Gaiman found himself stuck five thousand words into a satirical fantasy novel he could find himself a cowriter and establish himself as a novelist with Good Omens. He similarly parlayed a friendship with Douglas Adams into writing Don’t Panic: The Official Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy Companion in 1988, and later one with Lenny Henry into developing the TV series Neverwhere for the BBC. But it was the friendship he struck up with Alan Moore that would prove most decisive in launching his career.
During a 1985 convention that provided Gaiman’s first opportunity to meet Moore in person, Gaiman asked to be shown how to write a comics script. Moore obliged, and Gaiman proceeded to write a short John Constantine story about horrible things growing in his fridge while he was away. Moore read it and broadly liked it, though objected to the ending. Gaiman attempted another, “Jack in the Green,” featuring a 17th century incarnation of Swamp Thing. That script—eventually drawn by Bissette and Totleben for the Midnight Days anthology—won Moore’s approval, and is indeed a perfectly competent imitation of his style. (Indeed, Gaiman is one of the few writers whose scripts approach Moore’s in verbosity.) Armed with the crucial knowledge of how to be an Alan Moore clone, Gaiman began breaking into the industry, starting with the supposedly obligatory run of Tharg’s Future Shocks in 1986. His first, “You’re Never Alone With a Phone,” was the most notable, serving as the debut for the astonishing John Hicklenton, but what is in some ways more remarkable is that he quickly bailed on Fleetway, writing only four Future Shocks. There were several reasons for this. For one, Gaiman found their editorial practices frustrating, especially after they removed all the jokes from his Future Shock “I’m a Believer,” which he’d originally written as a Douglas Adams pastiche. He also took issue with the fact that he didn’t get any royalties off of American reprints, reasoning that “I always had this theory which was: I should bet on myself. And invest in myself. And it seemed to me like writing something that you were never going to get royalties on, no matter what happened or what success it had, was not betting on yourself, was not investing yourself. That’s one-off. That seemed wrong.” On one level this was similar to the logic of his mentor, who similarly stopped writing for Fleetway over issues of creator’s rights. But for Moore this had been at heart a moral position rooted in his larger beliefs about art and creative freedom. For Gaiman, the reason was more prosaic, implicit in the words “bet” and “investment”: it simply didn’t make financial sense.
A more productive early effort came when Gaiman hooked up with a comics magazine called Borderline, not because of the work he did for it—Borderline was a debacle that never got published—but because it led him to meet Dave McKean, with whom he went on to create Violent Cases. And it was with this astonishingly meager portfolio—four Future Shocks and the unfinished Violent Cases—along with a recommendation from Alan Moore that Gaiman, with McKean in tow, set out to pitch Karen Berger on her UK scouting tour in early 1987. Gaiman recalls that McKean was dubious about this, saying that “I practically put a gun to his back, forced him to bring his portfolio up,” and that “Poor Dave was just walking around behind me going ‘They don’t mean it.’ I’m going, ‘Sshhhh. Don’t look down. We’re okay.’ He went through that entire first meeting with DC Comics just baffled. ‘I think they’re just saying this to be polite.’ No, they think we’re great. We’re doing this. I was very good at it.” Gaiman opened with a pitch for Phantom Stranger, which, like Grant Morrison’s pitch earlier in the day, was rejected due to Paul Kupperberg’s much maligned effort, then worked his way through a number of other options, mostly DC horror characters of various levels of obscurity, before eventually settling on Black Orchid, a character sufficiently obscure that Karen Berger hadn’t heard of her and misheard Gaiman as pitching the Black Hawk Kid. Dick Giordano, meanwhile, noted that he liked her costume and invited Gaiman and McKean to write up a proposal.
Gaiman sat on the train back to Sussex and plotted the story, connecting the character to the Swamp Thing mythology that Moore had established, then called McKean on the payphone at McKean’s art school dorm to run down the pitch. (Gaiman recalls that “It was about forty-five minutes… thirty people were lining up behind him in the hallway waiting to use the phone. And he didn’t say a word,” leading McKean’s classmates to assume this was some bewildering piece of performance art. Eventually, McKean simply said “Alright,” hung up, and two days later had six paintings of sample art that Gaiman delivered to Berger and Giordano along with his pitch just before they returned to the US—a speed of turnaround that proved the pair’s professionalism sufficiently for them to get the job despite their slender portfolio.
Initially DC saw Black Orchid as an experimental, artsy book focused more on respectability than profit, but as pages came in they grew convinced they had a potential hit on their hands, and sought to bolster the profile of both creators. For McKean this meant pairing him with Grant Morrison for Arkham Asylum, although ultimately that would come out after Black Orchid. Gaiman, meanwhile, was offered an ongoing series, with Berger picking up on one of his pitches from the February 1987 meeting to revamp the Golden Age character of The Sandman, a gasmask wearing vigilante who used his gas gun to put villains to sleep. Gaiman had wanted to use him for a story that would be set mostly in dreams, which Berger liked, but felt that he should create a new character for it. Gaiman began with a simple image: “a man, young, pale, and naked, imprisoned in a tiny cell, waiting until his captors passed away, willing to wait until the room he was in crumbled to dust; deathly thin, with long dark hair, and strange eyes: Dream. That was what he was. That was who he was.” A year later, and just four weeks after the debut of Black Orchid, DC released the first issue of Sandman.
Back in November of 1988, this must have looked like the less significant event. Black Orchid, after all, was a lushly painted prestige format book priced at $3.50. Sandman, meanwhile, even though its first issue was just as long at forty-eight pages (though only forty pages of this were story pages), was still just a staple-bound book priced at $2 (and falling to $1.50 with subsequent issues) with a conventional penciler/inker/colorist process. And while there are plenty of comics whose first issues were incendiary and world-changing revelations, Sandman is not one of them. Its first issue is competent, but nobody mistakes it for the reason the book would eventually catch fire. Nevertheless, it is revealing.
Gaiman has suggested that the early issues of Sandman consisted of him “exploring genres,” with the first being his riff on Dennis Wheatley’s classic occult exploitation novel The Devil Rides Out. And this is true enough. But there is another obvious element in play. The core plot of the issue hinges on the relationship between the occultist Roderick Burgess—an Aleister Crowley pastiche in the same vein as Wheatley’s villainous Mocata—and his son Alex. The plot spans decades, from when Burgess summons and imprisons Dream in 1916 through to his eventual escape in the 1988, over which Alex goes from a young child to an old man who has inherited his father’s occult order. Roderick is a cruel and capricious man, while Alex is appreciably more timid, clearly afraid of his father.
It would be a bridge too far to suggest that any of this is intended as a direct commentary on Scientology—although DeWolf’s claims about his father’s relationship with Crowley had come to prominence just a few years earlier, and so were plausibly on Gaiman’s mind. Nevertheless, it’s hard not to notice that Gaiman begins the comic by depicting an abusive father/son relationship within the context of a cult. Indeed, he even situates Burgess in Wych Cross—a location undoubtedly chosen primarily for its ominous name, but that nevertheless lies just five miles down the road from East Grinstead.
But while the issue is an interesting lens on Gaiman as he began to extricate himself from his abusive upbringing, the truth is that it is not an especially strong debut. At forty pages the story is baggy. The issue is structured as an ever-winding spring of tension, but this means that fairly little actually happens over the bulk of it. It is not until the three quarter mark that Dream finally mounts his escape, and he offers only eighteen words of comment (all directed to the reader) over the decades of his captivity. And in the absence of what will eventually become the main character there’s relatively little to hold onto. Roderick Burgess is a monster, of course, and when he dies halfway through Alex, in an ominous bit of foreshadowing, proves to simply be a more cowardly monster. Even after Dream escapes, the issue merely resolves the issue of his revenge, with him trapping Alex in an unceasing nightmare of eternal waking. Not only is this somewhat underwhelming as a horror, it fails to give the issue any real forward momentum—there’s nothing pointing towards the actual plot of the series.
Stylistically, Gaiman shows himself to be the deft student of Moore that he is. He employs a narrator so that he can occasionally cut from the main story to give fragmentary, couple of panel descriptions of the wider ramifications of events and emphasize the mythic scale of the story. But where Moore’s captions leaned into a sort of grandiose excess such as his famous “clouds like bloodied plugs of cotton wool dab ineffectually at the slashed wrists of the sky,” Gaiman remains in a more prosaic register with descriptions of how “Unity Kinkaid finds it harder and harder to stay awake. She now sleeps for almost twenty hours a day. She used to dream; to shift in her sleep, muttering and sighing, locked in half-remembered fantasies.” But while his language is simpler, he retains the heavily iambic rhythm that pulls the reader along through the captions. The effect is to take Moore’s already popular signature techniques and streamline them into an even more populist version.
Indeed, the shadow of Moore looms large over the first seven issues of Sandman. This is scarcely a surprise; Swamp Thing homages were what British writers headhunted by Karen Berger were supposed to do; Morrison had done it on their early issues of Animal Man, and Gaiman had done it in Black Orchid. But there, of course, Gaiman played directly in Moore’s sandbox, offering a story rooted deeply in Moore’s Swamp Thing work, complete with a first issue in which the protagonist is killed. In Sandman he takes a more cautious approach. There are occasional moments in the first seven issues of Sandman that directly touch material that Moore did. The second, for instance, heavily features Cain and Abel, who were originally the hosts of DC’s House of Mystery and House of Secrets series. The latter of these was where the first Swamp Thing story was published, and Moore had both characters cameo in his run. The third, meanwhile, features John Constantine. And there are smaller moments too—a sequence in the fifth issue in which a villain contemplates letting a young woman love then declines to owes clear debt to Kid Miracleman’s killing of the nurse in Miracleman #14.
But these are exceptions, and more to the point, exceptions in which Gaiman can avoid being compared too heavily. Yes, Cain and Abel appeared in Swamp Thing, but as throwaway characters. Constantine may have been a Moore creation, but Sandman #3 is blatantly a riff on Jamie Delano’s Hellblazer, not Moore’s work. The one place where Gaiman actually feels like he’s nicking something from Moore saw him drawing from outside Moore’s DC work. Instead, Gaiman spent the early portions of Sandman doing something subtler: finding horror stories that could be told in the same broad style that Moore used for Swamp Thing, but that Moore never really came close to—Dennis Wheatley, the aesthetic of DC’s 70s horror aesthetics, or slasher films, all of which allowed Gaiman to avoid overly direct comparison. And over the course of them Gaiman is able to develop his own distinct style.
His first major success comes in the fourth issue, “A Hope in Hell,” which sees Dream journey to Hell in order to retrieve one of the three artifacts Burgess stole from him and then lost, a quest that forms the backbone of the first arc. Moore wandered by Hell, but Gaiman lingers there for an extended Milton riff. The issue’s climax sees him battle the demon Choronzon (a name first attested by John Dee and Edward Kelley, but more prominently associated with Crowley), who engages him in the game of reality. This involves a sort of back and forth poetry battle in which Dream and Choronzon each declare themselves to be various entities, each one trying to one up the other. They start as animals—a wolf, a hunter, a fly to throw the hunter off his horse, a spider to eat the fly. But soon they escalate upwards, with Dream declaring himself an entire world while Choronzon proclaims himself a nova. Eventually Choronzon escalates to “anti-life, the beast of judgment. I am the dark at the end of everything. The end of universes, gods, worlds… of everything,” a move he clearly expects to bring him victory. Instead, however, Dream calmly retorts, “I am hope,” to which Choronzon has no answer.
It’s a phenomenal sequence—enough so that Gaiman repeats it almost verbatim on the next couple of pages as Lucifer attempts to prevent Dream from leaving hell with his prize, pointing to the host of demons and boasting that Dream is powerless, asking “what power have dreams in hell,” to which Dream replies that hell is powerless without the dream of heaven, stunning all the demons into silence. And it works the second time in four pages as well. The reason it works so well is that Gaiman manages to occupy the mythic register in an accessible, human way. The reality game, for all its cosmic implications, unfolds in a grotty demonic nightclub called the Hellfire Club, which Dream even notes “feels like a bad joke,” and consists of little more than talking. Lucifer’s subsequent challenge, meanwhile, hinges on what is in effect a riddle, with a page turn reveal so that its eminently guessable answer hits with sufficient impact.
The fourth issue was also designed, in part, as a gift for Sandman’s initial penciler, Sam Kieth. Unfortunately, by the time they got to the issue the working relationship with Kieth was in tatters. The decision to hire Kieth—at this point an up and comer mostly known for his inking—had initially been suggested by Karen Berger, who he’d previously reached out to hoping to get work on Swamp Thing. Gaiman, however, readily accepted the suggestion. For his part, Kieth was incredulous upon being offered the job—Gaiman recalls him “doing that thing where he’s going ‘Well, who turned it down before? Did lots of people say no? Is that why you’re calling me? We had to convince him that we knew who who we was, and we had seen his stuff.”
Kieth brought an expressive quality to Sandman—one clearly inspired by Bernie Wrightson’s inventive grotesqueness. This gives his issues of Sandman what is at times a strange quality compared to the later series. Sandman #2, for instance, has a beat in which Dream comes upon the decayed ruins of his castle, and what’s clearly supposed to be a beat of tragedy instead takes on a strangely comedic bent purely due to the way that Kieth’s depiction of Dream—tiny pupils set in deep black eyes, long face, and gaping expression—is faintly cartoonish. Elsewhere, however, Kieth excels, most obviously in the hell sequence, where he spent weeks on a double page spread showing the assembled demons of hell, to the point of insisting on inking it himself instead of letting the usual inker, Mike Dringenberg, do it.
This was one of many contentious points between Kieth and Dringenberg, who were friends (Kieth in fact suggested him for the role), but who were struggling to work together due to the fact that, in reality, Kieth was the better inkier and Dringenberg the better penciller. nd this tension is visible in Keith’s issues, which seem at times to veer wildly from his more expressive style to something that’s much more recognizably in line with the later issues of Sandman that Dringenberg penciled. As Kieth details it, “I said, ‘This is not working, Mike.’ And Mike said, ‘Why don’t you let me pencil?’ I said, “I’m not gonna let you pencil it. I want to pencil it. I don’t know how yet, but I gotta learn on this book. So I’m gonna try to learn how to pencil on this book.’”
Kieth’s relationship with Gaiman was similarly fraught. The issues are perhaps best summarized by Kieth’s recounting that he looked at the script for Sandman #1 and told Gaiman, “‘It’s a P. Craig Russell story. You should get Craig.’ He said, ‘Yeah… I know.’” Worse, however, was Kieth’s relationship with Berger, which began to sour a few pages in, when he wanted to add an extra panel into the storytelling, a move that “became me facing off with Karen about whether my storytelling was competent, whether I had a right to try to challenge this. She was like, ‘No. This is the way it is.’ I had an enormous power struggle with Karen, and Neil sided with her. I felt really betrayed, but the reality was: that was the way. I didn’t get it until then.” The situation deteriorated further when Berger had Kieth redraw the bulk of the first issue with no additional payment, and the relationship was already in tatters by the end of the first issue, with Gaiman trying to play peacemaker between the two. As Kieth described it later, “everybody was trying to get me to quit, and I was trying to get myself fired.”
Instead Kieth decided to depart the book after the fifth issue, a breakup most often related with Kieth’s description of himself as feeling “like Jimi Hendrix in The Beatles” (though Kieth notes That was not my line. That was Neil’s”). Gaiman ensured, however, that Kieth and Dringenberg both received co-creator credits on Sandman along with an ongoing stream of royalties. Kieth moved on to Marvel, and in 1993 Kieth migrated to Image where he created The Maxx, which proved a smash hit in its own right even though Kieth described the title character as “pretty much an excuse to draw a circle and a triangle and add some arms,”) going on to be adapted as an animated series by MTV and to attract Alan Moore to pen dialogue for an issue. And while the Hendrix line may have been an invention, there were at least no lasting hard feelings,, with Kieth reuniting briefly with Gaiman and Dringenberg in 2011 for a benefit book for the Hero Initiative, with the two illustrating Gaiman’s poem “My Last Landlady” (later released as part of An Evening with Neil Gaiman and Amanda Palmer) with a series of abstract and moody images.
Kieth was replaced by Dringenberg, who immediately found himself drawing one of the most singular issues not only of Sandman but of Gaiman’s entire career, “24 Hours.” The first arc of Sandman is steeped in horror, but “24 Hours” is unique. The setup sees Doctor Destiny, a minor supervillain that Gaiman retconned to be the owner of Dream’s final relic, sitting in a diner over the course of a day and slowly driving the patrons mad before killing them. It is not quite that this is unusually extreme or gruesome. Sure, it features a scene of hammering nails into his own hand, and another of someone gouging her eyes out, but even the latter is pointedly framed to avoid actual injury to the eye motif visuals, just as the most straightforwardly violent beat, when one character, turned into an animalistic alpha male, rips the throat of another out with his teeth, is given a muted, surreal tone by Robbie Busch’s constrained color palette. (Busch’s coloring, much maligned, including by Gaiman, shows its virtues more clearly when contrasted with Daniel Vozzo’s lifeless and overlit reworkings in later editions.) It’s unquestionably a violent and gory comic, but far more violent gore has been done by plenty of people in the course of the War.
Where “24 Hours” finds its horror is instead in a vivid sense of emotional sadism. The scene in which a man is hammering nails through his hands, for instance, is more upsetting for the man’s monologue during this, as he tells the waitress at the diner about how his late wife knew about their affair, that this began her fatal alcoholic spiral, that he had in fact deliberately left her with a crate of vodka and skipped town so that she’d drink herself to death. “I’ll tell you something else,” he says immediately after. “When I was in the pen, I saw your son. Little Bernie. He’d been hustling his ass in Gotham, got picked up for knifing his pimp. You could have him for a packet of cigarettes,” he says, taunting the distraught waitress with this information about her estranged son as she holds the next nail for him. “Bette…” he finishes. “I did.” It’s absolutely brutal material—a level of cruelty that largely drowns out the physical mutilation.
Once again it is impossible not to think of Gaiman’s time in Scientology. This is not because of the emotional sadism; at the end of the day Scientology’s cruelty was a far blunter instrument than this—a case of the student exceeding the master. But the most basic currency of its systematic abuse was always blackmail over the confessions extracted via auditing, and the key beats of “24 Hours,” over and over again, come when characters have their worst secrets and fantasies revealed. The initially sympathetic lesbian Judy is revealed to be physically abusive to her partner. Garry, initially introduced as one of a pair of “lovebirds,” dreams of “having a $20 hooker in the convertible. Then he’ll beat her up, throw her out of the car, drive off. He gets such a kick out of doing that.” His wife Kate, meanwhile, in a particularly staggering sequence, describes her necrophilic experience and fantasies.
It’s visceral and unsettling—a shot across the bow that established a conceptual limit point in much the same way that Miracleman #15 had a few months earlier. “24 Hours” goes as far in the direction of cruel, cynical emotional torture as it is possible to go. As with Miracleman #15, it would not be recognized as such, and the world would instead be subject to a myriad of ill-advised imitations, often written by Mark Millar, for whom the two comics seem almost to provide an origin story. But also like Miracleman #15, the original stands largely unharmed by its imitators. “24 Hours” is still a piece of shocking and brutal elegance.
The issue also marks a transition in Gaiman’s thought about the series—he describes it as “the first time I realized on a gut level, not just an intellectual one, that I was writing a story about stories,” as opposed to one that is simply about dreams. The comic opens with five pages devoted to the first of its twenty-four hours, which serve both to introduce all of its characters and to give the one point in the comic where it spends an extended period of time offering interiority for one of its victims as the narration describes Bette, the waitress at the diner, who spends her spare time writing stories about the people around her. She imagines how “One day she knows she’ll package the pads up, bind them in brown paper, send them to Dear Abby, or Earl Wilson, or Jackie Collins. They’ll read them, and they’ll publish them and everyone will marvel at her depiction of happy, happy small-town life.” The key part, however, comes when she reflects that “All Bette’s stories have happy endigns. That’s because she knows where to stop. She’s realized the real problem with stories—if you keep them going long enough, they always end in death.”
It’s a good line, and Gaiman is predictably proud of it, remarking that it’s “the nearest I came early on to giving away the overall plot of Sandman… That’s a major theme of Sandman—you get happy endings only by stopping at a certain point.” In the postscript to the trade, meanwhile, Gaiman goes further to describe the issue as “an essay on stories and authors.” This overplays his hand dramatically, but not unstrategically, repositioning the issue away from its poison legacy of edginess and into part of Gaiman’s eventual play for literary respectability—a concept that simply did not enter the equation back in 1989 when his main—indeed only—concern was making sure DC didn’t cancel his comic and leave him unemployed. (See also the almost comically milquetoast reworking of the story in the 2022 television series, which pulls back on essentially every single point of actual horror in the comic.)
While “24 Hours” and “A Hope in Hell” were both major milestones in Gaiman’s development, they do not hold a candle to Sandman #8, a postscript to the first arc entitled “The Sound of Her Wings.” All of the major figures in the War have comics like this—moments where they with which they announced themselves ax major figures. For Moore, the one-two punch of Marvelman and V for Vendetta in Warrior #1, at least in the UK, and “The Anatomy Lesson” in the US. For Morrison, “The Coyote Gospel.” For Ennis, Dangerous Habits. All of these are comics that ensured that the world sat up and took notice of their creators. They are not merely good, nor even merely great; they are instant classics—comics that signified the arrival of a creator seemingly fully formed, already a giant.
None, however, come close to the seismic blast that is “The Sound of Her Wings.” Much of the War consists of its various participants creating works with significant but fundamentally niche appeal, even if that niche varied between literary comics readers with subscriptions to The Comics Journal and convention-going superhero fans. Even Watchmen was, in the end, more important than popular, its crossover appeal rooted more in an argument about the artistic value of comics as a medium than in people just being head over heels for Night Owl. “The Sound of Her Wings” is different. Sure, arguments have been made about Sandman’s literary worth, and Gaiman at times openly pandered to the sorts of critics who might make those arguments, but “The Sound of Her Wings” is not important because of its philosophical heft or technical adeptness. It is important because it was a massive, populist crossover hit—a comic that was important to literally millions of people, many of whom were not comics readers by default. It is loved not with mere fandom or appreciation but with the incandescent passion unique to teenagers looking at art and seeing a vision of who they want to be.
The issue is a straight arrow showpiece. It has precisely one purpose—to introduce Death—and everything that is not that purpose is pushed off to the side. Dream is present purely as a lens upon Death—a familiar perspective with which to reveal the new. The issue opens with Dream sitting by the fountain in Washington Square morosely tossing bread to the pigeons as a young boy plays with a soccer ball, nearly hitting him with it before he catches it with unearthly efficiency. A young woman, similarly starkly pale and dressed in all black, walks up and sits near him, where she proceeds to go on a two page monologue describing the film Mary Poppins in a level of enthused, slightly manic detail. “Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious!” she exclaims, and then, when Dream expresses confusion, explains, “Super-cali-fragil-istic-expi-ali-docious. Utterly fantabulous word, huh? It means, y’know, great. Wonderful. Ginchy. Gnarly. Peachy keen!”, this final definition of Supercalifragilisticexpialidocious offered as she puts on a set of sunglasses she’s been fidgeting with.
Through this scene—done primarily with open bordered panels over a white background—Dream sits, politely, a bit confused, but mostly non-responsive—he has six words over two pages, compared to a hundred and twenty for her. There are as of yet no real clues who this character is—the stark white skin suggests, certainly, that she is in some sense related to Dream, but her speech bubbles lack Todd Klein’s famous white-on-black effect, so even that’s inconclusive. But the level of focus—the fact that two pages are spent on this woman nattering on about Mary Poppins—speaks volumes about her importance.
A page turn. The panels are still open, but the background has shifted from white to a soft purple. A silent, wide shot of the two of them extends the pause, clearing the deck from her previous monologue, and then Dringenberg offers a large quarter-page panel—a full body shot of her, cross-legged, running her hand through her Siouxsie Sioux explosion of jet black hair, the simple ankh necklace she wears finally on front and center display, as she asks “OK. So, what’s the matter.” A matching panel of Morpheus clearly establishes them as equals, as she prompts him to explain why, exactly, he’s moping in the park with a bunch of pigeons.
What follows is two pages of monologue—a gloomy and self-obsessed recounting of the preceding seven issues, as the woman listens. Dringenberg’s art largely keeps the focus on her as Dream talks, maintaining the balance, but this section is nevertheless an opportunity to clearly sketch Gaiman’s protagonist, in all his broodingly Byronic glory—two dialogue laden pages to the effect of “I’m very depressed.” The woman asks if he’s finished, then inquires as to why he didn’t call her, to which he responds, “I didn’t want to worry you.”
At this point, the comic cuts to a close-up panel on the woman’s face, tight and immaculate eyeliner wings and black lipstick on full display. “I. Don’t. Believe. It.”, she says, and then, grabbing the baguette that Dream was feeding to the birds, she proceeds to berate him, telling him that he is “utterly the stupidest, most self-centered, appallingest excuse for an anthropomorphic personification on this or any other plane! An infantile, adolescent, pathetic specimen! Feeling all sorry for yourself because your little game is over, and you haven’t got the—the balls to go and find a new one!” as she hurls the bread at his head, a panel for which Dringenberg reverts from his far scratchier and impressionistic style into something much more cartoony as Dream, eyes wide-open and white-irised, cowers and covers his face while a loaf of bread bounces off his head with Todd Klein’s impeccably rendered “BIP!”
It’s a bracingly effective contrast—a wholesale turning over of narrative authority from the title character to a goth girl whose identity was still very much unclear, although a page later she finally identifies Dream as her brother. But she has, by that point, pulled off a narrative coup. She is the most interesting, charming, funny, and delightful character in the book, and the entire audience is completely in love with her. A few pages later, it finally becomes clear that she’s Death.
The next few pages see Gaiman at his lyrical best, a series of tiny vignettes as Dream and Death attend to the passing of various people: an old Jewish man, a standup comedian literally dying on stage, an infant, a sick woman in a hospital, a shooting victim, and more. Gaiman is poetic, touching, full of sad ironies and moments of grace, while Death is kind, gentle, and loving. It’s exceptionally well done, but it serves mostly to reveal the depth behind what has already been established—a justification for why this exuberant goth girl could possibly have the narrative weight she’s already blatantly been granted.
The result was immediate and decisive. Death instantly became the signature character of Sandman—a fact only enhanced by Gaiman’s judicious use of her. After her triumphant debut, she appears in only twenty issues of Sandman, and many of those are fleeting cameos, although they’re also strategically spaced so that she has at least one appearance per trade. Gaiman has talked about how “I wanted her to always leave readers craving more. Whenever I considered using Death, I thought of Marlon Brando getting paid $4 million to appear in just ten minutes of Superman: The Movie. So I would bring Death on only when I really needed her, and I mentally paid her $4 million for each appearance—and made sure that she used the money.”
It’s also clear that everyone at DC knew exactly what they had the moment they looked at Sandman #8, which opened with three pages of blurbs from names like Ramsey Campbell, Alan Moore, Steve Bissette, Bryan Talbot, Emma Bull, Rick Veitch, and Clive Barker. These were followed by a four page illustrated text summary of the preceding seven issues. It is one of the most lavish and substantive efforts to make something new reader friendly ever expended on a comic, and a clear sign that DC understood that this was a comic that would be getting profound amounts of word of mouth.
Gaiman’s approach to creating the character was straightforward—he set out to create “a Death who I personally wouldn’t mind encountering when my time comes—who would come up to me one day and say pleasantly. ‘You know, you really should have had that mole checked out.’ Or, more probably, ‘Now, next time try and remember—it’s left pedal to go faster, right pedal to stop.” But he was also driven by more strategic concerns, recognizing that his lead character was already “pale, tall, brooding, dark, relatively humorless, and Byronic in a late adolescent way,” and so pointedly playing against expectations with Death.
Death’s actual design, however, was purely down to Mike Dringenberg. Gaiman’s suggestions for a design were, depending on who you ask, based on Nico from the cover of her Chelsea Girl album or on silent film legend Louise Brooks. Dringenberg, however, had his own ideas. As he put it, “I saw her walking down the street knowing she’s it. And I knew it in the pit of my gut. Every bell rang as loud as you could possibly say it, from the haircut to that perfectly sculpted face to the little speck of glitter she stuck to her teeth with superglue. Little things like that, you know? That was it, she was it.”
In the case of Death, however, Dringenberg drew from a specific source: his friend Cinnamon Hadley, a dancer and fixture of the Salt Lake City goth scene who Dringenberg viewed as having “real star quality in her presence and bearing. She was an ex-ballet dancer with an amazing body, a beautiful heart-shaped face, and a memorable haircut, and was prone to wandering around with a little black umbrella. I felt Cinnamon had the visual qualities we were looking for, so I drew Death to look pretty much like her,” to the point of reworking a specific photo of her into one panel of “The Sound of Her Wings.” As Hadley recalls it, “Mike Dringenberg, the original artist for the Sandman, was a good friend of mine. He asked me one day if he could use me as a character for a comic book. I said sure. I didn’t know anything about comics and I didn’t know it was even anything special. I certainly had no idea it would be what it is now. Funny story—About three years after Mike asked me if he could use my likeness, I was living in Houston, having moved from Salt Lake City, and I was at a friend’s house. My friend told me his favorite comic was the Sandman and showed me an issue. When I opened it I saw a picture of myself staring back at me. (It was one of the 2 photographs actually used and just inked over). I said, ‘oh my God, that’s me.’ I had no idea I was in the Sandman, and I had even forgotten about being asked by Mike to use me as the model.”
Gaiman was struck by Dringenberg’s drawing, and his conviction deepened when, the same day that he got the drawing, he went out to dinner with Dave McKean “at the My Old Dutch Pancake House and the waitress who served us was a kind of vision. She was American, had very long black hair, was dressed entirely in black—black jeans, T-shirt, etc.—and wore a big silver ankh on a silver necklace. And she looked exactly like Mike Dringenberg’s drawing of Death… I took that incident as an omen, and I silently replied to the powers that be, ‘Oh, okay. This is what Death looks like walking around. Cool. Thank you.”
But more than being another case of fictional characters bleeding into the world like John Constantine periodically did for Alan Moore, this highlights the key brilliance of Death as a character above and beyond her immaculate presentation in “The Sound of Her Wings.” It is not simply that Death is an immediately compelling presence that steals any scene she’s in that makes her such a foundational element of Sandman’s success. An oft-observed truism of Sandman was that it had wildly more women reading it than comics at large did. When one talks about Sandman being foundational to millions of people, one is talking not exclusively but substantially about teenage girls of the 90s and 00s who were into goth subculture. And a fundamental part of its appeal is that its best character—the one who gets all the good lines and who the reader is all but forced to love—looks like them. In contrast to Cinnamon Hadley, who was a bold fashion and makeup experimentalist, at the end of the day dressing up like Death required little more than a black tank top, black jeans, some boots, a cheap piece of jewelry, and a bit of practice with an eyeliner pen. It is difficult to think of another iconic character in comics that was routinely first encountered by people who were already cosplaying her. The effect of this was to give Gaiman a durable and adoringly loyal audience—one he would spend the rest of his career both catering to and preying upon.