Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Once again, we return. This is the fifth part of an annual blog series analyzing the worst comic strip ever made. Previous installments include Exegesis, The Devolution of the Funny Pages 1895-2022, The Only Thing that Stops a Bad Guy with an Emotion is a Good Guy with an Emotion, and, last year, the rather more succinctly titled Rose. But this year, let’s start at the beginning. 

Billy DeBeck was born in Chicago in 1890, the son of a newspaperman turned office-worker for the meatpackers Swift & Company. He went to art school, dreaming of becoming a modern day Dutch Master, drew cartoons to make ends meet, and quickly determined that he liked having ends meet and so kept at it. He worked his way up to prominence, starting in a short-lived Chicago entertainment paper called Show World and moving his way through regional papers like the Youngstown Telegram and the Pittsburgh Gazette-Times before finally returning to Chicago to join the Chicago Herald where he launched a strip called Married Life in 1915. This caught the eye of William Randolph Hearst, who, according to legend, bought the Herald purely to acquire the cartoonist. One suspects this legend was spread by DeBeck himself, who proved adept at it—another story says that when World War I ended DeBeck rode through Chicago upon a white horse before falling asleep on the desk of feared editor Arthur Brisbane. Brisbane chased him out in the morning, only to have him return shortly thereafter and interrupt a meeting to fish his socks out of Brisbane’s dictating machine.

It was just seven months after this, on June 17, 1919, that DeBeck launched the work that would come to define his life. Initially titled Take Barney Google, For Instance, it was, like Married Life, fundamentally a comedy about domestic relations, only spun to render it suitable for the sports page upon which it was published. Its title character was a sports fan beleaguered by a disapproving wife.

DeBeck gradually refined the strip, most obviously the name, which shortened to simply Barney Google. He also reworked the visual appearance of the title character, who steadily diminished in size so as to play up his pathetic nature, especially in contrast to his wife, who now dominated him physically as well as emotionally.

It was not until 1922, however, that the strip truly took off in popularity. The turning point came in July, when DeBeck began a storyline focused on Barney Google’s unexpected acquisition of a horse named Spark Plug. Nominally a racehorse, Spark Plug was a scrawny wreck decked out in a massive blanket with his name scrawled on the side—a solid design that manages to be funny from his first appearance, a concluding panel in which Barney enthusiastically phones his wife to inform her that “all our troubles are over now, sweet woman—I gotta race hoss!” as Spark Plug stands behind him, plainly a hilarious disaster in waiting.

DeBeck milked the gag, penning an extended storyline—an oddity in comics at the time—in which Barney scrambles to get money to enter Spark Plug in the Abadaba Handicap, then to train him, and finally, a full month after his debut, to race him. The setup is for a complete disaster—the ever hapless Barney Google having bet “every cent I could borrow, beg, and swipe” on his horse, who faces hundred to one odds, and the strip ends with Barney sitting and drinking, clutching a gas line with the plain intent of killing himself upon his horse’s inevitable failure.

Spark Plug, of course, wins, and Barney Google abruptly finds himself a rich man. DeBeck had intended this to be a single arc, but quickly pivoted, writing Barney’s wife out of the strip and memory (she basically never appears after Barney’s phone call about Spark Plug until she’s brought back for a couple of gags about how she’s been forgotten, at one point showing up married to one of Barney’s friends) and letting the strip become an extended comedy about a man and his unexpectedly successful horse, with DeBeck stringing out the suspense of upcoming races and their inevitable effects on his protagonist’s fortune, which is amassed and blown over and over again. (In a move that is consistently funny both as a visual conceit and as a timesaving hack, DeBeck never actually draws a race.)

The strip became a pop culture smash, in part on the back of an aggressive push to create ancillary merchandise. In 1923 Billy Rose and Con Conrad composed a pair of novelty songs, “Come On, Spark Plug” and “Barney Google,” the latter of which became a hit recorded by a bevy of artists including Spike Jones and the Andrews Sisters, happily introducing “the most important man this country ever knew,” the famous “Barney Google with his goo-goo-googly eyes” and “a wife three times his size.” And DeBeck rode the wave, a becoming a playboy socialite who flitted around the country and, later, the world, settling for two years in Paris with his second wife/third marriage. 

[Embed https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=03SMVwTnEsk ]

But Barney Google was more than simply popular; it was influential. DeBeck proved to have an adept ear for language, coining a number of phrases that permeated the Jazz Age argot and stuck around into modern English—”sweet mama,” “time’s a-wastin,” and “heebie-jeebies.” A less enduring but perhaps more notable coinage was the tendency of 1920s comics nerds to be dubbed “Sparky,” which became the nickname of Charles Schulz, the creator of Peanuts.

The most notable linguistic coinage to emerge out of Barney Google, however, was not actually DeBeck’s. It came instead when the mathematician Edward Kasner took a walk with his nephew, and asked the nine-year-old what one might call the number ten to the tenth power (aside from its proper name, ten duotrigintillion). The child, an evident comics fan, proposed a google, which Kasner ended up using in his 1940 book Mathematics and the Imagination, albeit in the alternate spelling of “googol,” where it became a standard example of a farcically large number. (It is, notably, considerably larger than the number of protons in the universe.) This term was in turn employed by tech entrepreneurs Larry Page and Sergey Brin when they set about naming their new search engine company, although they, failing to appreciate Kasner’s spelling, reverted it back to its original Google.

Like most cartoonists of the era, DeBeck made use of assistants—first Paul Fung, then Joe Musial, and, starting in 1934, the seventeen year old Fred Laswell, who he hired off the back of a poster he’d designed for the Tampa Chamber of Commerce Jamboree. By this point the strip had fallen from its peak popularity—even a cartoon impresario like DeBeck couldn’t stay at the top of the heap for a decade—and was in need of another refresh. And so, in November of 1934, a few months after Al Capp had launched the instantaneous hit strip Li’l Abner, DeBeck and Laswell debuted their own take on Appalachian comedy in the form of Snuffy Smith.

As with the strip’s previous breakout character, Spark Plug, Snuffy is built up to—this time beginning before his first appearance, as Barney travels around what would eventually come to be named Hootin’ Holler hearing legends of the volatile Smith before his debut. And it would be weeks before the two would finally ally themselves in troublemaking.

DeBeck took the task of creating this entire new setting for his comic seriously, collecting a library of Appalachian lore and touring Virginia and Kentucky to interview residents and make sketches of the landscape. But much of the creative energy came from his young assistant, who spent the first ten years of his life on a ten acre chicken farm on Hogtown Creek south of Gainesville, Florida with neither electricity nor running water, and who drew on his oft idyllic memories of rural life to shape Hootin’ Holler. 

Just as the arrival of Spark Plug had pushed the original concept of Take Barney Google, For Instance to the margins and eventually out of the strip entirely, Snuffy Smith gradually came to dominate the strip, which in 1939 renamed itself Barney Google and Snuffy Smith. Following DeBeck’s death in 1942 Laswell took over, and continued this trend, eventually writing the title character out entirely in 1954, reasoning that “I was very comfortable with country people. I just fell into the spirit of the type of people Snuffy and Loweezy were. I really don’t know beans about the racetrack world of Barney Google and Spark Plug, and that is why I changed it to a Snuffy strip exclusively.” 

Laswell’s take on the strip never reached the pop cultural heights of DeBeck’s, but it had a heft of its own—a line of vinyl figures from the Louis Marx company in the 1950s, a variety of attempts to spin off a comic book with companies like Gold Key, Dell, and Charlton, and an aborted attempt from a Georgia-based franchiser to get a series of Snuffy’s Shanty restaurants off the ground. But Laswell was not reshaping language or scoring pop hits—he was writing a competent newspaper strip over the decades of the medium’s steepest decline. All the same, he had clear skill. He was a sharp, crisp cartoonist, with a bolder line than DeBeck’s, and he showed an aptitude for visual gags that DeBeck never did.

Laswell was, in other words, a cartoonist’s cartoonist, and it was no surprise that he was embraced by the industry. In 1964 he won the Reuben Award from the National Cartoonist Society, where he was fondly known as Uncle Fred. Starting in the 1970s he began producing a number of “Draw and Color” educational videos under that moniker, winning praise from Carter-era Secretary of Education Shirley Hufstedler, and eventually adapted the approach to a series of web-based instructional slide shows that are still online some twenty years after his death.

A curious detail through all of this, however, is that the strip retained its DeBeck-era title of Barney Google and Snuffy Smith even after one of those title characters vanished from the strip. It is not that Barney Google was wholly abandoned after 1954—Laswell brought him back for occasional one-offs. But the last of these came in 1997, the year before he hired John Rose as his assistant, and Rose initially made no moves to bring him back.

This would finally change in February of 2012, when Rose ran a weeklong storyline in which Barney returns to Hootin’ Holler, the seemingly deathless Spark Plug still in tow. Rose made semi-regular use of the conceit, eventually re-establishing Barney as a full-fledged supporting character by having him move to Hootin’ Holler in 2021. 

But this return, notably, came five months after the Cartoonists Remember 9/11 strip, by which point Barney Google’s connection with the strip had become so vestigial that, as evidenced by the clip of it at the top of this essay, some papers were dropping his name entirely and simply running the strip as Snuffy Smith. And yet he was still there, at least in any papers that ran the full version of the Sunday strips, a small typeface ghost haunting the strip’s logo.

There is something strangely potent about this, especially given the way the 9/11/11 strip itself evokes the absent dead in its punchline. Barney Google, after all, may be marginalized and spectral in the strip, but he is not a minor force. John Rose may make typically humor-devoid jokes about the similarities between his name and the tech company, but it’s not as though that’s a coincidence. Stare into those Goo-Goo-Googly eyes and the twentieth century gazes back, a force raw and brutal enough to give anyone the heeby jeebys. 

There is much to understand here. But no ghost can be understood without first understanding what is being haunted, and while we have come to understand the strip at large, there is still much to understand about Snuffy Smith himself and the palimpsest of Appalachian iconography that came to obscure DeBeck’s creation. After all, it is hardly as if Barney Google is the only monster in the hills of Appalachia.

Next Time: Bigfoot, Mothman, and Bob Murray (A Study of Appalachian Monstrosity)

Comments

Sean Dillon

So I take it people of 2026 (or 2025, if you're here) are going to enjoy a delightful musical number.

Doctor Memory

This is amazing— I worked at Google for several years, and while the relationship between the name and the number is well established as official company lore, the fact that it was in fact a reversion to the spelling of a name coined for a now little-loved golden age comic strip was… not mentioned at all. Indeed the ghosts of the 20th century gaze back at us from the most improbable mirrors.

Daibhid Ceannaideach

Interesting that Mrs Google just disappears from the strip without explanation, but the song claims she divorced him. An early example of fanon?