LWIA v2 Epilogue: Season of Mists (Patreon)
Content
Beginning with a slightly reworked outro to Dream Country, because I realized I should probably deal with Books of Magic, not least as I already had a perfectly salvageable essay on it.
----
Vess quickly followed the gig six months later with an issue of Gaiman’s The Books of Magic miniseries. This series arose from Karen Berger wanting, as Gaiman recounts it, “a book which would be a Who’s Who and a guide and a history for all our magical characters, and which has a story. Instead of a Who’s Who of the DC Universe, it would be a comic and it would have a plot.” Gaiman initially viewed this as an unappealing prospect, but after a day or so of thought he came up with an idea and called Berger back to pitch it.
The broad strokes of Gaiman’s idea were to have the series focus on the introduction of a new character, a young boy named Timothy Hunter who “has the potential to become the most powerful human adept of this age.” Because this was a new character who merely had the potential for magic, he would need to have this whole magic thing explained to him, and by extension to the audience. The series would be structured as four issues, each of which would see Tim given a tour of magic by a different person. In one sense there’s not a lot more to the comic than that. Tim is largely a cipher, existing to have things explained to him as opposed to as a character who emerges from a coherent backstory. The reader is not given a ton of information about him besides that he skateboards and a couple glimpses of his family. He’s a plot function, enabling Gaiman to offer a tour of his larger subject.
For guides, Gaiman assembled a quartet featuring John Constantine (who dubs the group the “trenchcoat brigade”), Jerry Siegel and Joe Shuster’s Dr. Occult, Mr. E, who was created by Bob Rozakis and Jack C. Harris in 1980 for the Secrets of Haunted House anthology, and, at long last after getting rejected at his initial pitch meeting and then having an issue of Action Comics Weekly that would have featured him go down in flames, the Phantom Stranger. The Phantom Stranger would give him a tour of history, Constantine of the present day, and Mr. E the future, while Dr. Occult filled in for issue #3 to take him on a trip to Faerie, complete with a cameo of Hamnet, now a servant in Titania’s court. This was the issue that Vess drew, although, ironically, he was far from the first artist considered—he notes that “they’d been through four artists before they got to me” including Dave McKean, Kent Williams, and Ted McKeever. Still, the one-two punch quickly established Vess as the premiere fantasy artist of the era. And once the story won the World Fantasy Award Gaiman quickly secured Vess for a pair of follow-up engagements, noting that they’d have to do an issue covering Shakespeare’s other play for Dream, as well as pitching him on an idea he had for an illustrated fairy story—though neither of these projects would emerge for several years.
With a rotating cast of trenchcoated supernatural guides and a lack of a main character, The Books of Magic was forced to become a collection of isolated moments. The first issue, for instance, breaks into several pages of text set over John Bolton’s vibrant painted art. The second culminates in a pleasant set piece in which John Constantine stops an entire club of evil magicians from hurting Tim just by threatening them, with nothing to back him up. The third gets much mileage from Baba Yaga capturing Tim, while the fourth culminates with Mr. E betraying Tim, leading him to the end of time and trying to kill him before finally being stopped by Death, on her way to closing up the universe for good, and finally making her inevitable high profile cameo.
For the most part, however, it’s Gaiman talking about magic in a fundamentally lecture/tour-based way. This isn’t insignificant—in many ways, Gaiman develops the structure that Moore will use in later career works like Promethea and Providence, although Gaiman in turn knew well what Moore was doing with From Hell by this point, so the influence runs both ways. Still, while the causality runs backwards, Gaiman is still performing his usual role here, taking an approach that Moore would use to be dramatically obtuse and audience-winnowing and being more populist about it: instead of complicated stuff about the Kabbalah and ceremonialism, magic turns out to mostly be about DC continuity.
Which, given that Gaiman is not actually one of the participants in the War to conceive of himself as a magician, is not entirely surprising. That said, Gaiman’s discussion of magic is not without substance. Indeed, Gaiman takes a Faustian view of magic that once again emphasizes its price. Gaiman is adept as ever describing the wondrous aspects of magic—the description of the Witch-Queen as “she sits beneath a dead king, hanging from a tree branch, and will show you all manner of elegant charms,” the Spectre saying that “I fell from grace. Now I am condemned to walk the shadow world. Once, it was I who cast the shadow,” the description of a world where “dinosaurs walk and time deforms and twists upon itself,” or an account of a future where “they have forsaken the gleaming chromium and steel future of space taxies and atomic knights, for a future of madness.” And the comic ends, inevitably, on a beat of Tim’s ecstatic embrace of magic. But in truth, this beat feels unearned—on the whole, the price and the weight of magic that feels most emphasized, rather than the sense of wonder. In the end, the series comes off as a slightly sympathetic cousin to conservative moral panics about satanism and the occult—one that broadly gets the appeal, while still mostly thinking that magic is a bad idea, only coming around to it because of the needs of the larger franchise.
To some extent, this is simply a reflection of a larger truth: the comic is pretty thin. For better or for worse, Gaiman clearly knows this, saying that “There was a level on which [Books of Magic] was an artists’ book. Sandman is a writer’s book. It doesn’t matter who’s on it,” a line that is only partially redeemed by his subsequent clarification that “With Sandman, I’m at the front. I work out every panel progression, every line where everyone is standing. There’s nothing accidental in Sandman, and if something is there, it’s because I want it to be there. I am a benevolent dictator as far as Sandman is concerned. Those are the terms that it’s done on. If you want to do an issue of Sandman, you’re going to get 48 pages of closely-written script from me. That’s how I want to do it. With Books of Magic, I sat down and wrote something that was vaguely like a film script. It was a film script written for them to tell the story as they wanted.”
Leaving aside the troubling implications this has for Gaiman’s relationships with his artistic collaborators, another way of looking at this is to simply note that Books of Magic was clearly not something Gaiman considered an a-list project, and was instead something he was doing a minimum of work and letting other people finish. Indeed, not long after doing Books of Magic Gaiman remarked how “in an alternate past, I would have said ‘This is how you do it, now go and find someone to do it,’” although he concedes that “it turned out very well.” Indeed, that would eventually be exactly what Gaiman did, lending his name as a “curator” or “consultant” to a number of DC projects spinning off from his ideas, a reliable minor income stream requiring very little work on his part, and certainly not requiring two hundred pages of elaborate DC continuity riffs to little actual end.
Books of Magic launched the same week as the next major arc of Sandman, entitled Season of Mists, which would arguably prove to be the comic’s definitive storyline. It was not the first arc of Sandman to be collected as a trade—that was in fact The Doll’s House, which came out (with “The Sound of Her Wings” appended to the strat) a week after “A Midsummer Night’s Dream.” Collections of the first arc, retroactively titled Preludes and Nocturnes, and of Dream Country followed a year later, alongside the start of A Game of You. But it’s notable that when Season of Mists was released in the summer of 1992 it came out first in a $30 hardcover edition before the cheaper paperback followed two weeks later. Gaiman was heavily involved in the design of this deluxe edition, wanting to ensure that it looked like “a kind of Victorian object,” and going so far as to choose the typeface for the introduction. And its existence spoke volumes about the degree to which Sandman was a runaway success for DC.
But by the end of 1990 when the arc launched it was increasingly clear that Sandman was merely the flagship within Gaiman’s burgeoning career. It was not simply Books of Magic that suggested this—by that point he’d already taken over Miracleman—a job Moore famously described as a poisoned chalice, but one that nevertheless further marked Gaiman as his true successor. But Gaiman clearly had his sights set on higher ambitions. He remained active in the UK scene, commencing another collaboration with Dave McKean entitled Signal to Noise, but this time placing it not in a comics magazine but in Nick Logan’s iconic fashion magazine The Face. But he also retained an active prose career, publishing numerous short stories and, in early 1990, his first novel.
This was entitled Good Omens, or, more properly, Good Omens: The Nice and Accurate Prophecies of Agnes Nutter, Witch, and was in fact a collaboration with Terry Pratchett, best known for Discworld, a series of forty-one humorous fantasy novels set on the eponymous planet, a flat disc born aloft by four elephants who in turn rest upon the back of a turtle (an image drawn from Hindu mythology). These would soon grow to be a publishing sensation in the UK, where Pratchett would eventually become the best-selling author of the decade. In subsequent years, Gaiman has attempted to downplay the impact of this, noting that “Terry wasn’t ‘Terry Pratchett’ back then. He wasn’t this continent-sized, vast, one-in-every-three-books-bought-in-the-UK-is-a-Terry-Pratchett-type author. He’d done half a dozen or so books, and was doing okay.” This isn’t quite fair—Pratchett was at eight novels in Discworld alone, and had also done a couple of science fiction novels and children’s books as well as a humor book of cat anecdotes entitled The Unadulterated Cat—but it’s true that, as Pratchett puts it, “he was barely Neil Gaiman then, and I was only just Terry Pratchett.”
Still, this was a typically savvy choice of collaborators on Gaiman’s part. They’d become acquainted back in Gaiman’s journalist days when Gaiman interviewed him in the wake of the first Discworld book—in Gaiman’s recollection, “it was Terry’s first interview as an author where somebody took him out to lunch and asked him questions. I was interviewing him for Space Voyager magazine, a magazine so poor I had to take the photos of Terry after the lunch.” As with many of his interview subjects, Gaiman struck up a friendship, and when he found himself with the first five thousand words of a humorous novel entitled William the Antichrist Pratchett was one of the people he sent it to.
The book was initially intended as a parody of Richmal Crompton’s Just William series—a sprawling series of short story collections about an eleven-year-old schoolboy who Gaiman meant to reimagine as the Antichrist, although his opening scene cut off before that, mostly concerning itself with a demon named Crowley tasked with delivering the infant Antichrist to a hospital. Gaiman quickly abandoned the idea, however, in part because he didn’t know how to continue it, and in part because he feared it might typecast him as “the guy who writes funny horror novels.” Gaiman largely forgot about the idea until Pratchett phoned him in 1988 to say that he had an idea for how to continue it and offering to co-write it.
The initial draft of the book emerged in a nine week frenzy of writing coordinated via phone calls and mailing floppy disks back and forth. As Gaiman describes it, “I’d wake up in the early afternoon and there’d be this message from him on the answerphone saying, ‘Get up, you bastard. Get up. Get up. I’ve been up since seven o’clock in the morning, and I’ve written all this.’ Then I’d ring him back, and then we’d talk. And then I’d work on Sandman and Books of Magic and stuff like that until about two o’clock in the morning, as I remember, and then at two, no matter where I was at or what I’d done, I would go over and do about five hundred words of Good Omens,” a schedule that meant, as Pratchett noted with delight, “always someone, somewhere, physically writing Good Omens.”
In practice the collaboration was lightly dominated by Pratchett, who wrote about two thirds of the initial draft, both because Gaiman still had a monthly comic to produce and because, as he notes, “I’m a selfish bastard and tried to write ahead to get to the good bits before Neil,” and by mutual agreement maintained the master copy, noting that “if it had been a graphic novel, it would have been Neil taking the chair for exactly the same reason it was me for a novel.” This suited Gaiman, who fondly noted that the collaboration “was like going to college. Even at that point Terry was a master craftsman, like a Wedgewood chair-maker or whatever. He could do it. And I had never made a chair before.” And in practice, over the months of revision, both of them went over each other’s sections heavily, and “made a point of going in and writing at least one or two scenes with any of the characters that up until then we hadn’t written.” Still, each of them had their favored scenes, with Pratchett writing most of the scenes with the Antichrist (now named Adam Young) and his gang while Gaiman, along with originating the characters of Crowley and his angelic counterpart Aziraphale, took the bulk of the storyline featuring the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse. In practice, this meant that Pratchett largely handled the human scale, while Gaiman stuck to the more metaphysical aspects of the book.
Ironically, given that Pratchett was the more experienced writer, this meant that the strongest bits of the novel were largely Gaiman’s work. Certainly Crowley and Aziraphale proved to be the book’s standout characters even before the 2019 television adaptation cemented this status by casting David Tennant and Michael Sheen to play them, and the book can fairly be described as grinding to a halt at the 1/3 mark when they drop out of the plot so Aziraphale can spend two days reading a book, leaving much of it in the hands of Pratchett’s characters. And the Four Horsemen sections demonstrate Gaiman’s usual deftness at the mythic register, with clever beats like the fourth horseman being Pollution instead of Pestilence, the latter having quit in a huff with the invention of antibiotics. In contrast, Pratchett’s sections run a bit flat—especially the bits focusing on Adam and his gang, which Pratchett admits he “seldom let Neil touch,” but which suffer from a distinct sense of interchangeability among the supporting cast. Likewise, Pratchett notes that “Neil’s had a major influence on the opening scenes, me on the ending.” In practice, the beginning of the book is witty and compelling, whereas the ending is a slight rushed thing in which all of the characters are brought together at a nuclear base only to have the vast majority of them be wholly irrelevant to what happens.
More than the plotting, however, the real issue is simply that Pratchett lacked Gaiman’s killer instinct for a truly memorable beat, whether a moment of gruesome horror such as a scene involving maggots that Pratchett notes that “Neil proudly claims responsibility for,” or a more mythic one like the Pollution/Pestillence idea or a section in which Crowley reflects on his distaste for Satanists, noting that “It wasn’t just the things they did, it was the way they blamed it all on Hell. They’d come up with some stomach-churning idea that no demon could have thought of in a thousand years, some dark and mindless unpleasantness that only a fully-functioning human brain could conceive, then shout “The Devil Made Me Do It” and get the sympathy of the court when the whole point was that the Devil hardly ever made anyone do anything. He didn’t have to.”
Indeed, that bit was so good that Gaiman reused it shortly thereafter in Season of Mists, where he has Lucifer complain that humans “use my name as if I spend m entire day sitting on their shoulders, forcing them to commit acts they would otherwise find repulsive. ‘The Devil made me do it.’ I have never made one of them do anything. Never. They live their own tiny lives. I do not live their lives for them.” This is hardly the only point of overlap between the two stories. Season of Mists sees Gaiman return to the thread of Lucifer’s parting threat in “A Hope in Hell,” and in turn to the long-simmering plot thread of Nada and his spiteful decision to condemn her to hell.
As with “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” it’s easy to see why this was such a success. Gaiman is never stronger than when he’s working in the mythic register, and Season of Mists gives him an almost untrammeled expanse of opportunities to do so. The first issue, flagged as a prologue or part 0, opens in Destiny’s garden. Destiny is not a completely new character—he appeared in a fleeting cameo back in Preludes and Nocturnes—but this is his first substantial appearance, and Gaiman proceeds to unfurl a stately monologue about how if you visit the garden “you will be forced to choose, not once but many times. The paths fork and divide. With each step you take through Destiny’s garden, you make a choice; and every choice determines future paths. Hpwever, at the end of a lifetime of walking you might look back, and see only one path stretching out behind you; or look ahead, and see only darkness.” After a visit from the Three—Gaiman’s take on the maiden/mother/crone triple goddess, who had previously been sought out by Morpheus and showed up to give cryptic advice to Rose Walker—Destiny is compelled to call a family meeting. He goes through a gallery of paintings and one by one summons his siblings: first Death, then Dream, Desire, Despair, and a final sibling, previously unseen, who is revealed to be Delerium. (A seventh sibling, unnamed, is said to exist, but Destiny declines to summon him, declaring that he’s “made his wishes on the matter perfectly clear.”)
At this point Gaiman breaks into three pages of prose, arranged in six columns over single-color portraits of the six Endless, each of whom get a brief introduction. It’s a striking sequence, in part because of how casually it flies in the face of expectations, including basic ones of what comics are. Gaiman notes that “I’d presented the reader with a number of the key characters in the series, and I was about to have them interact, but I hadn’t really explained who most of them were yet. It seemed to me a good idea to first stop and provide a little piece on each of them, as if I were writing entries in a very weird encyclopedia. It was one of those strange techniques that shouldn’t have worked but somehow did.” But it is not nearly as mysterious as Gaiman suggests. The emphatic pattern break of three prose pages serves to emphasize the decision to have them, and Gaiman ensures that each of the descriptions has a sharp, memorable, and often compellingly idiosyncratic moment. Desire, for instance, “smells almost subliminally of summer peaches, and casts two shadows: one black and sharp-edged, the other transluscent and forever wavering, like heat haze,” while Despair is said to have once had a sect that “declared her a goddess, and proclaimed all empty rooms her sacred places. The sect, whose members called themselves The Unforgiven, persisted for two years, until its last adherent finally killed himself, having survived the other members by almost seven months,” Destiny is speculated to have “travelled far beyond blindness, that indeed he can do nothing but see: that he sees the fine traceries the galaxies make as they spiral through the void, that he watches the intricate patterns living things make on their journey through time,” Delerium is revealed to have once been known as Delight, and to have a shadow whose “shape and outline has no relationship to that of any body she wears, and it is tangible, like old velvet,” and Dream is described as someone who “accumulates names to himself like others make friends; but he permits himself few friends.” The section ends with a portrait of Death captioned simply “And there is Death.”
For all the evident weight of this meeting, however, it is only the inciting incident. The real story begins when Desire angers Dream with a snide comment about Nada, sending him storming out of the room. Death goes to console him, but ends up telling him that Desire’s criticism is not, in fact, entirely off base, noting, with some understatement, that “condemning her to an eternity in hell, just because she turned you down… that’s a really shitty thing to do.” The issue ends with a chastised Dream deciding that he will journey to hell in order to free Nada, setting off the real plot of the arc.
There is a stately deliberateness to this that continues over the rest of the arc, although, ironically, this was in part imposed upon him. His original intention had been to jump straight from this prologue to Morpheus’s actual trip to Hell in issue #22. But the week before that issue was to come out Alan Grant and Val Semeiks’ take on The Demon was slated to wrap up a three issue arc in which Etrigan took over Hell, and so Karen Berger insisted Gaiman push his plans back a month. Gaiman, as he puts it, “blew my top,” sending Berger a fax arguing that there was no overlap in readership between Sandman and The Demon and accusing her of “upsetting the master plan.” Berger was resolutely unimpressed, and Gaiman quickly backed down and apologized, but the incident speaks volumes about the degree to which Gaiman was starting to see himself as something bigger than just another jobbing comics writer.
Instead Gaiman crafted an issue’s worth of build-up as Dream prepares to travel to hell. He begins with another sprawling page of narration describing “a place that wasn’t a place. It had many names: Avernus, Gehenna, Tartarus, Hades, Abaddon, Sheol… It was an inferno of pain and flame and ice, where every nightmare had come true long since. We’ll call it Hell,” then continues with Dream explaining to his subjects why he must leave and dispatching Cain to warn Lucifer of his coming while he makes a visit to Hob Gadling in his dreams and stops to visit Lyta Hall, a minor character in The Doll’s House whose child he ominously proclaimed he would one day come for. It’s plainly an issue of filler, but it has three major advantages. First, as mentioned, it helps establish a certain stateliness to the arc’s pace—something that will prove tremendously useful in the latter portions.
Second of all, it gives Gaiman the opportunity to have Lucifer quote Milton’s line that it’s “better to reign in hell, than serve in heaven” to Cain, who, improbably, fails to recognize it in spite of it being among the best-known lines in English literature not to be written by Shakespeare. Born in 1608, eight years before Shakespeare’s death, John Milton took to poetry at a young age, studying at Christ’s College, Cambridge to be a priest but feuding with his tutor and growing frustrating with the stifling curriculum. After graduation, he moved back in with his parents and committed to several years of private study, followed by several years of travel in France, then Italy, writing some of his early notable works like “Lycidas” and Comus. Returning to England as the Bishops’ Wars broke out, prefiguring the Civil War, he became a pamphleteer, penning a series of anti-episcopal tracts, followed, after an unfortunate marriage, with a number of tracts advocating for divorce and, when these got a frosty reception, Areopagitica, an anti-censorship tract.
With Cromwell’s victory, Milton became one of the Commonwealth’s staunchest defenders, becoming Secretary for Foreign Tongues within Cromwell’s government, although this became a sinecure following his 1652 blindness. Sent into hiding and poverty by the Restoration, he set out upon his magnum opus, the epic poem Paradise Lost, from which Lucifer quotes. In some senses a precursor to the revisionist reboots that would become the hallmark of post-Moore comics writers, Paradise Lost was a biblical epic that wove the serpent in the Garden of Eden together with previously only hazily connected figures of the Devil and Satan to create a single coherent figure, the rebel angel Lucifer who was cast out of heaven to rule hell—an image so preposterously compelling that, despite having no real Biblical grounding, it has become an almost unquestioned piece of Christian lore.
Written, as Milton put it, to “justify the ways of God to men,” Paradise Lost quickly ran into what is, depending on your perspective, either a problem or one of the most fascinating ambiguities in literary history. Milton attempted to cast Satan as a tragic figure brought down by his hubris, making sure that Satan was a figure the reader could understand. To some extent this was necessary—Milton’s overall story is about Eve’s temptation in Eden, after all, and if Satan were not at least somewhat compelling then it would simply not work. And Milton takes to this problem with verve, giving Satan arguments that sound very much like the republican arguments that Milton had endorsed. It is Satan who talks of freedom, declaring upon crashing down to hell that “The mind is its own place, and in itself / Can make a Heaven of Hell, a Hell of Heaven. / What matter where, if I still be the same, / And what I should be, all but less than he / Whom thunder hath made greater? Here at least / We shall be free.”
The problem arises when compared to the God that Milton claims to be justifying. Milton’s God comes off as a stultifying bore at best, and an elaborate sadist at worst. His lengthy explanation of how he created Satan and humanity with free will and thus the ability to fall and be damned purely because were they compelled God could not derive any pleasure from their obedience, for instance, is difficult to read without a faint sense of horror at the vast cosmic cruelty of creating a system where people can be damned to hell purely for one’s own pleasure. Whereas Satan is one of the great and most compelling characters in all of literature. For all Milton sought to glorify God, what he wrote in practice was the archetypal story of the tragic, doomed rebel and his struggle against the tyrant father—a dynamic that would echo downwards through the ages as the essential paradigm of all of the Albionic wars.
This contradiction went on to vex centuries of critics none of whom ever mustered a better take on it than Blake’s assertion that “The reason Milton wrote in fetters when he wrote of Angels & God, and at liberty when he wrote of Devils & Hell, is because he was a true Poet and of the Devil's party without knowing it.” Blake, of course, could so easily have been the Devil to Milton’s God, locking horns across the century that separated them in another iteration of the War. Early in his career he even played at this role with in The Marriage of Heaven and Hell, where he reimagines hell as a source of inspiration and productive defiance, a position that was in many ways alarmingly close to edgelording. But Blake would never let himself be so enslaved by another man’s system as to simply be the petulant rebel, and he evolved his position later in his career, eventually providing a set of twelve illustrations for Paradise Lost itself. This was at once an act of devotion to a work of art he had profound respect for and an opportunity to remake it in its own vision, allowing hell’s demons to ripple with idiosyncratically proportioned but coruscatingly homoerotic musculature, and imbuing Eve’s temptation and fall with a strange sensuousness as she literally eats the fruit out of the serpent’s mouth. Finally, Blake settled on shaping himself into a truer version of the role than Milton had been capable of. To this end, he eventually wrote Milton a Poem, summoning the poet himself out from Eternity, working with him to heal his incomplete vision and establish a new myth in which Milton has fused with his rejected feminine self.
Another interesting take on the underlying problem comes from the literary critic Stanley Fish, who makes the case that Milton is engaged in a “programme of reader harassment” in which he seeks to reveal to the reader their sinfulness and put them on a path to redemption. Fish, for instance, makes much of how Satan’s emphatic and rousing speech is followed by a description, “So spake th’ Apostate Angel, though in pain, / Vaunting aloud, but rackt with deep despair,” suggesting, not unreasonably, that Milton intended to make the speech seductive and then to wrongfoot the reader about it. But what is truly interesting is the way in which Fish’s argument evolved over his career, until, late in life, he was making the argument that Milton was in fact situating himself against the very idea of poetry, expressing horrified outrage at the ambiguities and imprecisions that form the basic magical capabilities of language, seeing their power as a rejection of the absolute truth of God. In this interpretation, Lucifer’s fall was not simply a matter of free will, but an inevitable consequence of the very act of Lucifer’s reasoning, thought, and speechmaking. In a real sense, if sin is understood as separation from God then Lucifer, created with freedom and choice, as something separate from God, was created to fall, as indeed was humanity.
Such an argument has interesting implications within Blake, who would view such single vision not as divine truth but as a source of pure and utter horror. Much of Blake’s art, such as the glorious and deliberately irreconciliable variations he produced in The Book of Urizen over his career, exists to do the precise opposite of what Fish views Milton as doing, rejecting not language’s imprecision but its fixity and trying to create a new vision of poetry that resists all singularity. Fish’s Milton would, far from being a beloved precursor that Blake could summon forth to heal the world, be the very embodiment of Urizen himself, although that observation must be taken in light both of the fact that Blake’s overall artistic quest was Urizen’s redemption and that Urizen was always more closely aligned with Blake himself than one might think. (For his part, when Fish’s interpretation of Milton was put to him in a 2023 seance Blake scoffed that it “sounded like projection” to him.)
This interpretation of Milton, however, has obvious similarities to the the bastardized Thelemic ideas that L. Ron Hubbard developed into Scientology, and which William S. Burroughs bastardized again to create a prototypic version of chaos magic. Scientology’s idea of an engram, for instance, offers a similar sense of language as something that is inherently harmful and destructive. It’s also worth considering the warning at the start of all of Hubbard’s books that commands the reader to “never go past a word you do not fully understand,” proclaiming that “The only reason a person gives up a study or becomes confused or unable to learn is because he or she has gone past a word that was not understood. The confusion or inability to grasp or learn comes AFTER a word the person did not have defined and understood. It may not only be the new and unusual words you have to look up. Some commonly used words can often be misdefined and so cause confusion,” an injunction that, in practice, amounts to a baldfaced demand that the reader simply avoid the ambiguities of language in favor of precisely the sort of direct and absolute truth that is, as Fish/Milton realize, plainly impossible.
Indeed, Gaiman comes to a conclusion much like this when he has Lucifer muse on “how much of it was planned. How much of it He knew in advance. I thought I was rebelling. I thought I was defying his rule. No… I was merely fulfilling another tiny segment of His great and powerful plan.” Lucifer is, in this moment, becoming somewhat aware that he’s a character in a story, and that this has an intrinsic horror to it. Indeed, this horror is one Hubbard conceptualized directly in one of his best known works of science fiction, Typewriter in the Sky, in which the protagonist becomes aware of the presence of an author in his life, literally hearing the sounds of a typewriter in moments when he is compelled to take certain actions. But the horror, as Milton and eventually Hubbard realized, does not emerge from the presence of a tyrant demiurge with some great and powerful plan. To be conceived of in language is a horror in and of itself.
The third advantage is simply that by having an issue of build-up and anticipation, Gaiman was able to have the subsequent issue spend twenty-four straight pages on a single unbroken scene depicting Dream’s journey to Hell. It is a truism in comics that space constitutes importance, and by taking care of beats like Dream’s departure, the introductory monologue about what Hell is, and Lucifer’s initial reaction to news of Dream’s visit—all essential beats that would have existed, albeit in a presumably compressed form, in any first issue of the arc proper—Gaiman is able to give the actual confrontation between Morpheus and Lucifer a dramatically increased weight. This is fortunate, because the confrontation results in what is probably the single most jaw-dropping plot beat in all of Sandman, and one of the all-time greats of fantasy literature.
When Morpheus arrives at the gates of Hell he is stunned to discover not only that Nada isn’t there, but that Hell is completely empty save for Lucifer, who, grinning maniacally, informs Dream that he’s quit. The pair travel through Hell as Lucifer finishes closing up shop—informing the last tortured soul, Breschau of Livonia, who, among a vast number of other crimes, had his unfaithful mistress “sewn to her lover, and, skin to skin, I left them in the desert to be eaten by ravens, and I laughed as I heard them scream,” that “no one today rmembers Breschau. No one. I doubt one living mortal in a hundred thousand could even point to where Livonia used to be, on a map. The world has forgotten you,” driving out the last couple of demons, and finally travelling to lock up the last couple of gates. As they do, Lucifer explains his actions to Dream, explaining simply that he’s grown tired and bored of his role. Finally, after they lock up hell, Morpheus has Dream cut his wings off and then, reminding him of his promise to destroy him, hands him the key to Hell to do with as he pleases.
The remainder of the arc (save for an interlude issue akin to “Men of Good Fortune,” a standalone story about an English boarding school and what happens when the dead kicked out of Hell make their return) charts the consequences of this remarkable development as a parade of mythic figures arrives at the gates of the Dreaming to petition Morpheus to grant them control of Hell. This, of course, plays ridiculously to Gaiman’s strengths, ensuring that there’s always a new bit of mythic grandeur to work with. He gets to do a lore-accurate version of Odin, Thor, and Loki (a drunken Thor delightfully propositions Bast, “D’you want to play with my hammer? Eh, Miss Pussy-Head? It’s called Mjollnir. I fI rub it, it gets bigger. S’true.”), delve into Japanese myth for Susano-O-No-Mikoto (riffing on Japan’s only just ending period of economic dominance, he has Susano note that “we are expanding—assimilating other pantheons, later gods, new altars and icons. Marilyn Monroe is ours now, as are King Kong and Lady Liberty”), explore angels, demons, and the fae (represented by Cluracan and his sister Nuala, who is surprised and dismayed to discover that when her brother offered her as a gift to Dream this was not conditional, and that she is obliged to remain), and to concoct mythologies of his own like Lord Kilderkin, a “manifestation of Order” in the form of a cardboard box carried around by his personal slave, and Shivering Jemmy of the Shadow Brigade, a Princess of Chaos who manifests a an adorable young girl carrying a balloon.
The sheer weight of all this has a strangely distorting effect on the story. First Gaiman has to move through an issue that’s largely spent giving each of these characters a nice, suitably poetic introduction, then one spent having each of them make their individual pitches to Morpheus, and then, upon reaching the arc’s climax, simply implodes his plot into nothing by having the angels convey a message from “The Name” directing Dream to cede control of Hell to them, which he agrees to. This sparks a brief confrontation with Azazel, the head of the demonic delegation, who had brought Nada to offer Morpheus, and who threatens to devour her before being stuffed in a glass jar by Dream. But it is, on the whole, a surprisingly muted conclusion, especially after a couple of issues that either felt overburdened by the sheer number of moving parts or simply fucked off to tell a side story. On paper, this really shouldn’t work.
And yet it did, and marvelously at that—Season of Mists is by most accounts the most unadulterated triumph in the whole of Sandman. There are several reasons Gaiman is able to get away with this. First is the fact that he has an epilogue, which allows him to end the arc not on the off beat of the Hell plot resolving into nothing but with an issue comprised entirely of emotional resolutions—the angels Remiel and Duma as they take over Hell, with a clever beat in which Remiel reassures a tortured soul that “there will be no more wanton violence; no further suffering, inflicted without reason or explanation. We will hurt you. And we are not sorry. But we do not do it to punish you. We do it to redeem you. Because afterward, you’ll be a better person, And because we love you,” only to have the sinner whimper “You don’t understand… that makes it worse. That makes it so much worse…”; a beat of Lucifer on a beach in Australia talking to an old widower who notes that “I’ve had a shit of a life, all things considered. It wasn’t fair. Everyone I’ve ever loved is dead, and my leg hurts all the bloody time. But I think, any god that can do sunsets like that, a different one every night… ‘strewth, well, you’ve got to respect the old bastard, haven’t you?”, a point Lucifer grudgingly concedes; and perhaps most obviously, a scene resolving the by now long-running Nada plot in which Morpheus finally apologizes, first tentatively, saying that “I might have acted wrongly. I think perhaps I should apologize,” only to get slapped in the face and to meekly offer a more substantive one. These are substantive scenes, carrying considerably more weight than the cosmological detail of who is going to run Hell, and they ensure the arc ends on a note strong enough to do justice to its earlier fireworks.
Second, however, and perhaps more important, is simply that the plot wasn’t the point of Season of Mists. Other than the weight given by resolving a pair of threads that had, by the time the final issue came out, been running for two years, the plot was simply a means to an end. The point of the arc was to create a situation where Gaiman could maximize the amount of time spent doing mythology, and the result is eight issues of the best there is doing the thing he’s the best there is at. It’s a demonstration of virtuosity, and one that serves to effectively glorify the virtuoso. It’s notable that Season of Mists marks the point where any idea of Sandman as a book with a regular penciller is abandoned. Mike Dringenberg handles the prologue and epilogue, but these are his final contributions to the comic. The bulk of it is drawn by Kelley Jones, who had previously handled “Caliope” and the subsequent issue of Dream Country, “Dream of a Thousand Cats.” It’s a deft choice, of course—Jones has a sense of the macabre akin to Sam Kieth’s, and he does a magnificent job both on the Hell sections and the larger mythology, which he parlayed successfully into an iconic Batman run and, later, being successfully tapped to take over a Frankenstein comic from an ailing Bernie Wrightson. But Jones is a hired gun for one specific arc, as was every subsequent penciller on the book.
The effect was to highlight Gaiman as a singular auteur, and Season of Mists was precision engineered to highlight that. This went well beyond its extended mythological riffing. The decision to pay off long-running arcs served to further emphasize Gaiman’s status as the only constant presence on the book. Gaiman proves an ostentatiously visible author, preening with formalist touches like the Morpheus/Nada scene in the final issue using the same panel layouts as the prologue to The Doll’s House where Nada’s backstory was introduced and proleptic moves like, when Dream deposits the imprisoned Azazel in a chest, having a variety of other strange treasures like a pocket watch and a Middle Eastern city in a bottle, both quietly setting up future issues of the comic so that, on a second read, readers will be reminded anew just how clever the author was. It is as though, after his fight with Karen Berger at the arc’s outset, Gaiman’s conclusion was not that he should be more humble and deferential to his bosses, but that he needed to acquire dramatically more clout so that he could no longer be subjected to DC’s editorial whims.
Gaiman returned to the Biblical themes of Good Omens and Season of Mists one final time in the period, penning a short story called “Murder Mysteries” for a 1992 horror anthology called Midnight Graffiti headlined by Stephen King and Harlan Ellison that served as a sort of origin story for Lucifer. It is the story of the angel Raguel, the Vengeance of the Lord, back in the earliest days of creation, when the universe was still being designed—Raguel describes it, somewhat nebulously, as “a blueprint; but it was full-sized, and it hung in the Hall [of Creation], and all these angels went around adn fiddled with it all the time. Doing stuff with Gravity and Music and Klar and whatever. It wasn’t really the universe, not yet. It would be, when it was finished, and it was time for it to be properly Named.”
Raguel begins his story with the moment of his creation in the Silver City (a name shared with Season of Mists, slyly positioning “Murder Mysteries” as, if not canon to Sandman, at least explicitly adjacent), and describes waiting in his cell in the Silver City until the eventual arrival of Lucifer, who informs him that “There has been a… a wrong thing… The first of its kind,” and takes him to the body of a dead angel, instructing him to find who was responsible and take vengeance on him. It ultimately emerges that the angel, Carasel, was murdered by his partner Saraquael. The pair had recently designed Love, and had become lovers in the course of working on the project, but when they moved on to their next project, Death, Carasel lost interest, and Saraquael, jealous, killed him. Raguel destroys Saraquael, but Lucifer, watching, is appalled, weeping that Saraquael “loved. He should have been forgiven. He should have been helped. He should not have been destroyed like that. That was wrong.” (Raguel notes that “Perhaps saraquael was the first to love, but Lucifer was the first to shed tears. I will never forget that.”)
Subsequently, Raguel speaks with another angel, Zephkiel, who he recognizes as a disguised God, accusing him of having arranged all of this. Zephkiel admits this, explaining that “Lucifer must brood on the unfairness of Saraquael’s destruction. And that—amongst other things—will precipitate him into certain actions. Poor sweet Lucifer. His way will be the hardest of all my children; for there is a part he must play in the drama that is to come, and it is a grand role.” Raguel departs, troubled, and Zephkiel offers to wipe his memory, noting that “forgetfulness can sometimes bring freedom, of a sort,” but Raguel declines.
This story, however, is positioned as a story within a story, told by a man who bums a cigarette of the frame story’s narrator. The frame story is of a British man stuck in Los Angeles due to snow storms in London, who goes and visits an ex-girlfriend, then returns to his hotel where he is told the story. Afterwards, Raguel kisses the narrator on the cheek. The narrator notes that he “felt like he had taken something from me, although I could no longer remember what. And I felt like something had been left in its place—absolution, perhaps, or innocence, although of what, or from what, I could no longer say.” Looking more closely at the frame story, it becomes apparent that the narrator in fact murdered his ex-girlfriend, along with her child and roommate, and that Raguel took his memory of that event. The story ends ambiguously—the narrator returns to London, but shortly after he arrives another blizzard kicks up, trapping him in a freezing elevator where he remains for long enough that the batteries on the alarm run out. “There wasn’t anything in there except me,” he ends, “but even so, I felt safe, and secure. Soon someone would come and force open the doors. Eventually somebody would let me out; and I knew that I would soon be home.”
On the one hand, this sounds like some sort of oblique account of the narrator’s death. But this is too simple. The language of it, notably, evokes Raguel’s description of waiting in his cell, which repeats the phrase “there wasn’t anything in it except me,” and similarly notes that “I don’t know how long I waited there. I wasn’t impatient or anything, though. I remember that. It was like I was waiting until I was called.” And the story opens with the narrator describing the trip to Los Angeles as being “ten years ago, give or take a year,” and describing how “looking around today at the parts of my life left over from those days, I feel uncomfortable, as if I’ve received gift, unasked, from another person: a house, a wife, children, a vocation,” which cuts against the notion that the narrator is dying at the end. The implication is instead that being trapped in the elevator is some sort of purgatorial experience—something like the process of forgiving and help that Lucifer demanded, as alluded to in the opening when the narrator muses, “If it’s true that every seven years each cell in your body dies and is replaced, then I have truly inherited my life from a dead man; and the misdeeds of those times have been forgiven, and are buried with his bones.”
Perhaps the most interesting part of this introduction, however, is the story’s opening sentence, “This is true.” It’s clearly not, but the timeline of decade old travel and the narrator’s description of himself as having been “barely out of my teens” at the time lines up with Gaiman, who traveled to the United States for auditing at least once in the early eighties, and who, a decade later, did in fact have a wife, children, and a vocation. It’s possible that Gaiman is simply using a couple of autobiographical details from his life to shape the story—certainly the narrator is not him, and he did not commit a triple murder in Los Angeles a few years before starting on his Duran Duran book. But it is more likely that the story is playing with a real sense of dissociation from Gaiman’s decade-old self and his time directly under the thumb of Scientology.
Certainly Scientology’s fingerprints are visible elsewhere in “Murder Mysteries.” At one point it’s said that the murdered Carasel believed “that what we do here in the Hall of Being creates patterns. That there are structures and shapes appropriate to beings and events that, once begun, must continue until they reach their end. For us, perhaps, as well as for them.” The narrators’ murder of his ex-girlfriend comes after an awkward encounter in which the conversation peters out because “a twenty-one-year-old boy has little to say to a thirty-two-year-old woman,” and the narrator’s sexual advances are at least partially rejected—his ex-girlfriend declines intercourse, offering oral sex as a substitute, and the narrator fumes as she runs to the kitchen to spit afterwards—a detail that parallels Saraquael’s anger at Carasel’s rejection. And this sense of people’s actions being guided by recurring patterns from long ago is, notably, an almost exact restatement of Scientology’s beliefs around engrams. It’s also notable that this is not the last time that Gaiman would embrace the notion of amnesia as a source of healing, nor that this idea would be situated in clear relationship to his experiences with Scientology.
It is this, in the end, that seems to be the core of Gaiman’s period of fascination with Miltonian myth—an interest in the idea not only that the universe was in some sense designed for suffering, as implied by the notion that Lucifer’s rebellion was preordained, but also by the strangely antihumanist vision of the universe in Good Omens, which notably ends with Crowley speculating that the real armageddon would be “all of Us against all of Them,” which is to say that Heaven and Hell are both fundamentally hostile to humanity. There is a clear sense of doom here, from Crowley’s musing that “nothing he could think up was half as bad as the stuff they thought up themselves. They seemed to have a talent for it. It was built into the design, somehow. They were born into a world that was against them in a thousand little ways, and then devoted most of their energies to making it worse” up through the narrator of “Murder Mysteries” being a murderer for seemingly no reason other than the fact that once, before the creation of the universe, an angel was murdered. It is as though the only part of Scientology he’s actually rejected is the idea that one can do anything about the engrams pulling one towards misery or cruelty.
It’s significant, then, that this is also the period in which Gaiman seems to have conceived of the endpoint of Sandman. In an early 1991 interview promoting Good Omens Gaiman noted that “Sandman is going to keep going for another two years,” a point he reiterated in the letter column of the final issue of Season of Mists where he notes that “somewhere between issues #40 and $50 (and it’ll probably be closer to #50) the story that began in Sandman #1 will be over.” Gaiman’s estimate was off by twenty-five issues and three years, but it’s clear that this is roughly where the ending came together in his head.