Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This was, in fundamental ways, unlike anything else that occurred in the War. It is not simply that Gaiman had entered his imperial phase. He had, and would remain in it for just over a decade, but that was nothing new. Moore had a similar phase in the 1984-86 period, when Swamp Thing was already established as a hit and he was simultaneously working on Marvelman, V for Vendetta, The Ballad of Halo Jones, and Watchmen, but at no point did he achieve the kind of  white-hot stardom that characterized Gaiman—a stardom that was, in key ways, no longer straightforwardly about the work. Sandman was no longer functioning primarily as a comic, but as a cultural event. Neil Gaiman wasn’t competing with Moore or Morrison, or even with his influences and contemporaries in his genre like Diana Wynne Jones or Emma Bull; he was competing with Donnie Wahlberg and Kurt Cobain, as a pop idol. Sandman was was no longer merely a thing to experience on its own artistic terms, nor even merely a thing to be a fan of, but rather a tool with which to define yourself. 

This was fortuitous in many ways, as Sandman was, in practice, quite rocky during its second arc,  entitled The Doll’s House. As with much of Preludes and Nocturnes, the problem is not that the arc is bad. Rather, it is simply that nothing within it approaches the lightning in a bottle charge of “The Sound of Her Wings,” or even, by and large, issues like “A Hope in Hell.” For all that it introduces a number of important and memorable parts of Sandman, most obviously another of Dream’s siblings, the malevolent Desire, there is an obvious tentativeness to it—a lack of confidence in what Gaiman was capable of. This is most obvious in its narrative structure, which, like Preludes and Nocturnes, is at its heart a three-item quest narrative, this time seeing Dream hunt down a trio of escaped dreams. Gaiman’s approach is slightly more elegant than the sheer linearity of Preludes and Nocturnes, with Morpheus declaring that due to the presence of a “dream vortex” the errant dreams will be naturally be drawn towards it.

Or, rather, towards her. The dream vortex is a young girl named Rose Walker, who, in the arc’s most interesting decision, serves as its main character in place of Dream, whose appearances are considerably more sporadic—he only shows in a single four-page scene in the first part, for instance. Indeed, Gaiman has said that he “saw the Doll’s House as an opportunity to begin training my audience to accept a broader range of material than they may have been used to seeing in comics. The Doll’s House isn’t focused on the Sandman at all but on a girl named Rose Walker. Dream pops up periodically in the story, but his participation is scaled way back.” This also allows Gaiman the space to engage in some worldbuilding—the story is bookended, for instance, by a pair of scenes introducing another one of Dream’s siblings, the sexually ambiguous Desire, who will prove to be the closest thing Sandman has to a primary antagonist. Similarly, issue #13 in the middle of the arc, “Men of Good Fortune,” is a self-contained one shot illustrated by Michael Zulli so as to allow Dringenberg time to handle the double-sized issue that followed. That issue swerves from the present-day setting of The Doll’s House to begin in the 14th century, where it introduces one of Sandman’s most memorable recurring characters, Hob Gadling, a man who Dream and Death contrive to make immortal out of little more than idle amusement, with the issue following the centenary meetings between Hob and Dream until it reaches the present day.

“Men of Good Fortune” serves, in practice, as the hinge of The Doll’s House ’s structure, with the rest dividing into what are essentially two three-issue arcs split around it. The first arc sees Rose locating her brother Jed while Dream simultaneously rescues him from the first of the escaped dreams. The second, meanwhile, serves to resolve the plot of Rose being a dream vortex. But while this is reasonably elegant and allows Gaiman to ensure every issue has a relatively clear focus, the arc remains a bit of a hot mess. Gaiman, for his part, has attempted to suggest that the moment in “Men of Good Fortune” where Dream acknowledges that Hob is his friend “is thematically the heart of The Doll’s House,” while also clarifying that “I liked that Rose gives away her heart to her grandmother; and then, when she’s reunited with her mother and brother, kind of gets her heart back again. I also like that the ending takes us back to the beginning, with Desire in Desire’s heart. If you leaf through the series, you’ll find either an image of a heart or the word heart in virtualy every issue. Hearts are a major part of what Sandman is about.” Charitably, this is twee and a bit superficial. It is not that this is not an element of the story, but to suggest that The Doll’s House is primarily about this, or indeed primarily about anything at all is a stretch. For the most part, The Doll’s House is about getting the somewhat fearsome amount of narrative work it has to do accomplished. Nothing intrinsically unites its Little Nemo in Slumberland pastiche, riffs on old DC superheroes, serial killer convention, invocation of G.K. Chesterton, queer themes, the introduction of Desire, the backstory on Nada, and of course Hob Gadling other than a sort of sheer force of will and a trade paperback cover. 

That is not to say that the arc doesn’t work, although it comes closer in key ways than any other point in Sandman. But it works largely as a collection of moments, few of which rank among the series’ highlights. The exception to this comes in the double-length fourteenth issue, titled “Collectors” and featuring one of the most giddily macabre ideas of Gaiman’s career: the Cereal Convention. Far from being a collection of breakfast aficionados, however, this is actually cover for a get-together of serial killers. Hijinks, of course, ensue. 

Gaiman describes the origins of this idea as coming during the 1988 World Fantasy Convention. “WFC isn’t a fan gathering,” he explains. “It’s mostly attended by writers and editors. So at 2 a.m., I looked around the bar and—in a strange, glistening moment of clarity—realized a convention is just a bunch of disparate people getting together for a long weekend to feel special. These people have nothing in common except for the one shared interest that unites them—be it Barbie dolls, or a 1960s TV show, or comic books. And I thought, ‘What if serial killers had conventions too?’” The central joke that animates this, after the initial pun at least, is the aggressive demystification of serial killers. The banality of the convention setting turns them from fascinating monsters to little more than generic nerds nattering on at panels like “Making it Pay” and “Women in Serial Killing.” This tone is established from the start, when Nimrod, the convention’s organizer, suffering from stage fright, gives an opening speech in which he offers a faltering joke about a woman who calls the police pleading, “Help, I’ve been reaped!” “Don’t you mean raped,” asks the officer. “No,” she clarifies. “He used a scythe.” The deliciously unfunny joke is augmented by a caption box in which he frantically thinks, “Laugh you bastards laugh at my joke laugh or I’ll…” before the crowd erupts into a polite chuckle. And this is the note Gaiman ends the issue on, as Dream strips away the attendees illusions, forcing them to confront their abject patheticness.

A subplot of the issue involves the ill-fated journalist Philip Sitz, who attends the convention under the assumed identity of the Bogeyman (in reality killed off in an issue of Moore’s Swamp Thing), who is of course found out and brutally murdered. Explaining this subplot, Gaiman wryly noted that “I felt every convention should have at least one fan.” And this gestures at the other central joke behind the Cereal Convention. Although neither it nor the World Fantasy Convention at which Gaiman came up with the idea were fan conventions, within the larger context of the American comics industry that’s absolutely what the word “convention” evokes. The connection between it and serial killers, and the fate of the one fan within the narrative, provides a wry comment on the predatory nature of those events.

In one sense there is nothing special about comics fandom and conventions. Large social gatherings have always had a libidinal undercurrent of flings and hookups. But the comics convention centered on the parasocial relationship between fan and celebrity. More than that, it focused on minor celebrities. Gaiman’s observation that the convention existed to make people feel special was apt. In day to day life Gaiman was a recently married freelance writer who’d just half-escaped a cult. But at a convention he was a veritable star—the creator of Death, decked out in leather jacket, sunglasses, and a shock of black hair almost as moody as his protagonist’s. 

It is not clear when, exactly, Gaiman began taking advantage of this position, but it was plainly an early and frequent activity. In September of 1994 Dave Sim, in the course of the infamous Cerebus #186, makes passing mention of Neil Gaiman’s convention affair being the “best-known secret” of the 1993 WonderCon. In a 2011 interview Grant Morrison, when discussing their personal policy of not sleeping with fans, went out of his way to bring up Sandman, noting that “I love the little girl-ness and the whole idea that they were really bright and they read Batman and Robin or they read Death from the Endless. It meant something to them and you don’t want to ruin that and make them think that the guys that do this stuff are sleaze bags and mess up their lives”—a choice of examples that speaks volumes about Gaiman’s behind the scenes reputation even before the full scope of horrors emerged into the public view. There is reason to think that the behavior grew from the merely sleazy into the sorts of horror stories that would eventually come to define him, but it is clear that this development followed the overall course of his career.

The theme of predation is, necessarily, a key element of the Cereal Convention plotline. Its climax comes when one of the serial killers, Fun Land, attempts to rape and murder Rose Walker, precipitating Morpheus’s involvement. Gaiman depicts this with a sharp effectiveness, capturing the  cognitive dissonance of a pedophilic serial killer as he veers from saying things like fretting about how the convention organizer “said that dirty stuff at the beginning about what we don’t do where we eat. Wash his mouth out with soap, momma” to telling Rose “You—you can take off your dress, you know. You won’t need it any more.” But this is of a piece with how Gaiman depicts all of the serial killers’ interiorities, from the guy who talks about steadily escalating from his shame over masturbating to following women around with a knife in his pocket to murdering them, noting that “I know it’s not normal for a man to go out and dismember a woman just because he wants to have sex with her. Emotionally, I don’t know how much longer I can handle it” to the serial killer who’s also a famous doctor, who “collects leather neckties. They wrote about it in the New York Times. He wears a new one at every media event he attends. He has over a hundred. He makes them himself” to the multiply disturbing Connoisseur, who notes that “there’s something about preoperative transsexuals that makes the connoisseur uncomfortable. Something brittle and bright in the back of their eyes. He loves them. But he always feels like they’re laughing at him. He’s only ever found eight that he’s been able to talk to. Really talk to.”

Indeed, the theme of predation lurks throughout The Doll’s House. In the first half Rose’s brother Jed, turns out to be being kept a prisoner by his abusive foster parents, who are in turn being influenced by one of the escaped dreams, the duo Brute and Glob, who are using his dreams for their own schemes. The second dream, meanwhile, is the Corinthian, who’s become a serial killer and is at the convention. The arc’s prelude, meanwhile, tells the story of Dream and Nada, an African woman he falls in love with, is rejected by, and ultimately spitefully condemns to hell. It’s not quite enough to be called a theme, especially as it’s not especially present in the arc’s denouement (one could stretch to include Desire’s machinations to trick Dream into killing Rose or, for that matter, Dream’s hunt for her, but it would be a stretch), but it’s still clearly, and frankly understandably, on Gaiman’s mind. 

Perhaps the most interesting instance, however, comes in a two page sequence in the Cereal Convention issue where Rose is told the “original version” of Little Red Riding Hood, complete with a sequence that sets up her assault by Fun Land in which the wolf has Red Riding Hood undress, telling her as she takes off each garment to “throw it on the fire; you won’t need it any more.” Gaiman clearly means to position this story as a kind of ur-myth underlying all the subsequent serial killers. But it’s notable that in 2004 he wrote a blog post about his own identification with the wolf, arguing that he “represents an awful lot of stuff—the danger and truth of stories, for a start, and the way they change; he symbolises—not predation, for some reason—but transformation: the meeting in the wild wood that changes everything forever,” and notes that “when I was a boy, when I grew up I wanted to be a wolf,” concluding that “The wolf defines Red Riding Hood. He makes the story happen. Without him, she'd just be another girl on her way to her grandmother's house. And she'd leave her goodies behind, and come home, and no-one would ever have heard of her. But he's not just her wolf: he's all the wolves on the edge of the world, all the wolves in all the stories, all the wolves in all the dreams of wolves; flashing green eyes in the darkness, dangerously honest about what he wants: food, company, an appetite.” Even leaving aside his dubious assertion that the wolf doesn’t symbolize predation—a particularly implausible claim given that he clearly uses the wolf for exactly that purpose in The Doll’s House—this is striking in its apologism—its strangely alarming claim that the wolf is in some sense doing Red Riding Hood a favor by making her into a story.

All of this hangs uncomfortably over the first issue of Dream Country, a set of four stand-alone stories between The Doll’s House and the next arc. Called “Calliope,” the issue focuses on a writer, Richard Madoc, who, stuck and flailing on his second novel, makes a deal with Erasmus Fry, an aging writer, to acquire the muse Calliope, who Fry captured in the 1920s and had been using to fuel his own career. Madoc uses Calliope to catapult himself to an immensely successful career across numerous media and genres, ignoring her tearful pleas to be set free. Eventually Calliope contacts Morpheus, her ex-lover (as with Nada and, it will eventually emerge, literally every single romantic relationship over the course of Morpheus’s billions of years of existence, it ended badly), who frees her by cursing Madoc with an uncontrollable flood of ideas that drives him mad. 

In 1990, this struck as an effective horror story—enough so that DC included the script for it in the Dream Country trade paperback. With hindsight, however, what proves most unsettling about it is the degree to which the story prefigures so much of Gaiman’s own story. It’s not just the basic dynamic of a writer and a young, beautiful woman he treats as his muse while simultaneously abusing—a phenomenon that is hardly unique to Gaiman. It’s the specific details, from the way Madoc flits among genres and mediums to the way he insists that “I do tend to regard myself as a feminist writer” to the detail of Erasmus Fry insisting that the captured Calliope call him “master.” Gaiman even sent artist Kelley Jones photos of his office to use as reference for Madoc’s. 

What’s crucial to note is that this is not Gaiman telling on himself. It’s not just that Gaiman was still a decade away from the sort of outright abuse being allegorized in “Calliope.” The issue is plainly aware of the horror of its subject. The line about Madoc considering himself a feminist is followed immediately by him being asked where he gets his ideas from, pointing very directly to the bitter irony of that claim. And Gaiman takes pains to linger in the awful sadism of Madoc’s behavior, most especially in the beat immediately after he gets Calliope back to his house in which he rapes her “nervously, on the musty old camp bed. She’s not even human, he told himself. She’s thousands of years old. But her flesh was warm, and her breath was sweet, and she choked back tears like a child whenever he hurt her.” Even the use of Gaiman’s office as reference is plainly a wry joke about the fact that the script for the issue proved a nightmare after he was forced to abandon his original idea, which he later described as “a story titled ‘Sex and Violets,’ in which the hobgiblin Puck is very, very old and is hanging on to the only youth he has left by consuming flowers native to England. He runs a brothel in London that has one whore: a succubus. Rock stars, writers, artists, and so on come and give Puck native English flowers, and in exchange they’re allowed to visit the succubus. And they leave with ideas, but only after the succubus drains away a year or so of their lives.” It was only when that story—which as described focused more on the price of creation—failed to work out that Gaiman switched to a story about writer’s block and poked fun at himself for suffering from it.

No, “Calliope” is far more disturbing than the comic book equivalent of that monologue from the serial killer who started following women around with a knife in his pocket before escalating. It’s a warning of what’s to come, yes, but the warning is not a comment on the author’s private fantasies. It’s a comment on the degree to which he fundamentally failed to understand the magic he was taking hold of, and what its consequences might be. He understood the broad strokes—that if he could survive the tightrope grind of monthly comics for long enough and create a work of sufficient quality and impact he could change his life decisively enough to get him fully out from the towering shadow of his upbringing. He understood that writing this story, about the King of Dreams and his tragedy, would allow him to also rewrite his story—to become Neil Gaiman instead of David Gaiman’s son. But he did not understand what that meant. 

What is most ironic about this is that a mere two issues later Gaiman would pen a story that was largely about this precise magic. The story had been set up back in the “Men of Good Fortune” issue of The Doll’s House, in a scene where, during one of his meetings with Hob, Morpheus is taken by a conversation between at the next table in which one playwright takes another to task for his mediocre verse, taking particular exception to a couplet that ends with the instruction to “scourge the bad, revolting stars.” This is, of course, a monologue from Henry IV Part I, and the playwright is none other than an early career William Shakespeare, who is being mocked by Kit Marlowe. Shakespeare, referring to Marlowe’s own work, expresses that he “would give anything to have your gifts, or more than anything to give men dreams, that would live on long after I am dead. I’d bargain like your Faustus for that boon.” Concluding his business with Hob, Dream approaches the young playwright to make him an offer, but Gaiman opts to stay with Hob as the two walk off, leaving the implications of this unseen for the time being.

The payoff would come six months later, with Sandman #19, “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” where it becomes clear that Dream offered Shakespeare a simple deal: that he could have all of the talent and success that he asked for in exchange for writing two plays for Dream. The issue depicts the debut of the first of them, which Dream has commissioned for the Fay, who have departed the Earth by Elizabethan times, but return for the performance. 

There is a bracing and earnest exuberance to this, along with a brash confidence that’s captured by the credits on the issue, which, in a bit nicked from Blackadder, proclaim it to be “Written by Neil Gaiman, with additional material taken from the play by William Shakespeare.” In picking Shakespeare for his subject Gaiman is going to the heart of the British literary tradition (“Fuck off,” said William Blake in a 2025 seance), applying the same willingness to work on a mythic scale that he did to hell and the concept of death. But that is largely necessary for the story Gaiman is telling—one that is not simply about the lust for financial success or the creation of good art, but for a notion of greatness. Confiding to the real King Auberon, Dream explains that his reason for commissioning the play was so that “they shall not forget you. That was important to me: that King Auberon and Queen Titania will be remembered by mortals, until this age is gone.” And this is very much the point. There’s a real hubris to what Shakespeare asks of Dream—a form of outright immortality. 

Gaiman is aware that this comes with a price. One of the threads of “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” concerns Shakespeare’s son Hamnet, who died some eighteen months after the issue is set. Gaiman reworks this, having Hamnet catch the eye of Queen Titania, who gives him an apple and tells him of how, in Faerie, there are “bonny dragons that will come when you do call them and fly you through the honeyed ambered skies. There is no night in my land, pretty boy, and it is forever summer’s twilight,” and ends the issue with the note of Hamnet’s death shortly thereafter. This isn’t simply positioned as a side effect of Shakespeare’s deal with Dream either—Hamnet’s vulnerability to Titania’s seductions extends out of his dissatisfaction with his father, who he notes “doesn’t seem like he’s really there any more. Not really. It’s like he’s somewhere else. Anything that happens he just makes stories out of it. I’m less real to him than any of the characters in his plays. Mother ays he’s changed in the last five years.” 

Indeed, Gaiman even gives Dream a monologue about how Shakespeare “did not understand the price. Mortals never do. They only see the prize, their heart’s desire, their dream… but the price of getting what you want is getting what once you wanted.” Perhaps Gaiman thought that because there was no ashen-faced cosmic entity standing before him and offering him escape, no incantations and summoning circles, nothing save the labor of scratching out script after script after script for the better part of seven years that what he was doing was different—that there needn’t be a price. Then again, Dream’s monologue continues, “And had I told him? Had he understood? What then? It would have made no difference.” And perhaps it wouldn’t have. 

Or perhaps once Gaiman realized more than mere escape from Scientology’s grasp was on offer he simply got greedy. “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” proved another crucial rung on the upward ladder of Gaiman’s success. All that brash swagger and ambition paid off with a massively acclaimed issue that wound up winning the World Fantasy Award for Best Short Fiction—an unprecedented level of renown for a comic book.

More than any issue of Sandman thus far—arguably more than any issue of Gaiman’s comics career save for his work with Dave McKean—this success is due to his choice of artists. “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” is simply unthinkable without the art of Charles Vess. Vess was an up and comer—he’d spent the 1980s doing a variety of odd jobs for Marvel Comics—work in Epic Illustrated, Kull the Conquerer, and Conan the Barbarian, generally favoring fantasy comics because, as he put it, “I’m very attracted to the curvilinear, rhythmic forms of nature. It makes me happy to draw it, whereas I can struggle through drawing a building or drawing a spaceship or a robot.” Prior to linking up with Gaiman his best known work was the cover to the debut issue of Web of Spider-Man when Marvel debuted the tertiary Spider-Man series in 1985, although he wrote and illustrated the graphic novel Spider-Man: Spirits of Earth around the same time as Sandman #19. But it was his illustration for Donning/Starblaze’s 1988 illustrated edition of A Midsummer Night’s Dream that caught Gaiman’s eye. Gaiman made a point of coming to his table at the 1989 San Diego Comic Con—Vess recalls that they “had a nice conversation about James Branch Cabell,” the early 20th century fantasy writer, while Gaiman recalls that “he showed me some other work that included these amazing fairies,” which convinced him that he’d found his man. 

It was a typically savvy pick for Gaiman. Vess has a painterly, art nouveau style that draws heavily from Arthur Rackham’s take on fairies, and he takes to them like Sam Kieth did to demons, coming up with an impressive range from the humanlike and noble Auberon and Titania to the positively bestial Puck and Peaseblossom. And he’s aided by Steve Oliff’s warm and sunlit colors, which make the issue a stark contrast from the eighteen issues of horror comic that precede it. And Vess quickly followed the gig six months later with an issue of Gaiman’s The Books of Magic miniseries exploring the realms of Faerie (including a cameo from Hamnet, now a servant of Titania). Ironically he was far from the first artist considered—Vess notes that “they’d been through four artists before they got to me” including Dave McKean, Kent Williams, and Ted McKeever. Still, the one-two punch quickly established Vess as the premiere fantasy artist of the era. And once the story won the World Fantasy Award Gaiman quickly secured Vess for a pair of follow-up engagements, noting that they’d have to do an issue covering Shakespeare’s other play for Dream, as well as pitching him on an idea he had for an illustrated fairy story—though neither of these projects would emerge for several years.

Comments

Thomas Tyrrell

This is extremely good. And I like it a great deal more than the 'write around it' strategy you were taking, a la Flux, with the whole Doll's House arc. The criticism bites, the digressions fascinate.

Andrea Lankin

The Calliope story has been coming sharply to mind, and I really appreciate the depth with which you explored how it does, and doesn't, prefigure Gaiman's choices. It would be so easy to make a simpler argument, but yours is more convincing.

Sean Dillon

[Looks at the wolf quote] That "for some reason" sure is trying to do a lot of heavy lifting and failing.

Christopher Brown

I didn't know that Charles Vess made it big on Sandman - coincidentally, the collected Earthsea edition with his illustrations has been sitting next to me while I've read this.

Paul Mason

The is a tour de force. I wondered, in the 'wolf' part, what with 'company', 'feminist' appearing, whether Gaiman might have been twisting Angela Carter to his own ends? I'm only a wee bit younger than him, and both the movie The Company of Wolves, and the collection The Bloody Chamber which inspired it was quite a powerful influence, back in the 80s.

HARNAIK KAHLON

Agreed. The critical eye on Gaiman’s greatest comics, coupled with the depth of research into his personal history, made this a fascinating read (though, as expected, a depressingly saddening one, about someone whose art I once loved very much).

Roy Berman

This hits so hard. Your original stab at the Sandman material was certainly worth reading but, as you yourself said, was a bit searching for a hook. You found the hook, and Gaiman helplessly wriggles on it.