Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

And now, with this out, I get to go pick up my comb bound copy of the Bootstrap Edition of the Blake book from Staples, and then come home and start reading Kindly Ones. See you all on Christmas.

----

Brief Lives was paced to conclude with issue #49, as Gaiman had standing plans for issue #50. This was an oversized issue to be called “Ramadan” and return to the “Distant Mirrors” branding used for the short stories between Season of Mists and A Game of You. On art duties was P. Craig Russell, a longtime veteran of the industry (he joked that he was “probably the oldest Sandman artist ever,” although in fact he’s a few months younger than Charles Vess, and a fair few years younger than Duncan Eagleston, who illustrated “The Hunt” in the “Convergences” run of shorts). This ended up sparking Gaiman to take a different approach in scripting. As Gaiman tells it, “Because I was trying to capture the spirit of an Arabian Nights tale, however, I decided to first write out ‘Ramadan’ as a prose short story, so I could concentrate on capturing the appropriate rhythms and poetry of the language.” About halfway in—at the point in the story where Dream makes his first appearance—Gaiman recalls phoning Russell before breaking that half of the story into a full script, reading it over the phone to him, and Russell asking him to finish it as a prose story. 

Russell remembers things differently. In his account, having inked an issue of Season of Mists, he was familiar with Gaiman’s Moore-derived style of highly detailed scripts, and knew his preference “to just have the single words and to have to really think about it and then tell” the story, so he requested it. Gaiman agreed to “do it for the first half of the script, until dream appears, and then he was going to do it tighter,” which Craig accepted as better than nothing. After Craig successfully drew the first half, however, Gaiman was reassured that this approach would work, and ended up writing the back half in the same style, although Russell disputes that this style was a short story, describing it as more akin to a play, with all the dialogue alongside a “couple of stage directions.” Regardless, it was left to Russell to actually decide on the panel breakdowns and individual page structures, resulting in a number of interesting decisions such as a caption written on a scroll of paper that winds its way across three panels as a character travels through some catacombs, or a panel featuring a stunning 118-word dialogue balloon—a decision Gaiman freely admits he “wouldn’t have even attempted,” along with  Karen Berger’s approval of a bonus payment to Todd Klein for successfully lettering all of that and a successful retirement for Russell adapting various Gaiman prose projects into comics.

The resulting issue, with its nice round number, metallic ink cover, and gallery of Dream pinups featuring John Totleben, Scott McCloud, and Todd McFarlane, proved to be the best-selling of the run, selling more than two hundred and fifty thousand copies. Unfortunately it’s also one of the pieces of Sandman to have aged most poorly, and certainly the one to have done so for reasons other than Gaiman’s abusiveness. The plot of the issue concerns Haroun Al Raschid, ruler of the city of Baghdad in a mythic, Arabian Knights-infused past where it is universally recognized as the greatest city on earth. Haroun, concerned with the reality that all such cities will eventually fade, calls upon Dream and offers to sell him the city to preserve forever in dreams; Dream accepts, and Haroun awakens to a crumbling and far more mundane city before the story cuts to a previously unrevealed frame story in which a young boy is being told the story by an old beggar in a bomb-ravaged modern Baghdad. 

Gaiman’s motivation in this is easy enough to discern. He started work on the script in early 1992, a year after the Gulf War. Much as he’d attempted to humanize trans women in A Game of You, it’s clear that “Ramadan” was intended to do the same thing for Arab people. But where Gaiman was able to base Wanda on the actual experience of trans people he knew, his only seeming frame of reference for writing about the Middle East is having read One Thousand and One Nights in some translation or another. As a result his description of the mythic Baghdad is a wall to wall expanse of tediously orientalist tropes—a harem of “concubines from every land, infidel and faithful, with skins white as the desert sand; skins brown as the mountain seen at evening; skins yellow as smoke; skins black as obsidian: all of them adept at the arts of pleasure. Also there were many beautiful boys, their chins still hairless, their dark eyes wanton and lustful, savory as apricots plucked in the dew,” or a marketplace full of haggling connivers, or a too clever for its own good line describing Christians as “a dirty folk, who will not bathe, and who venerate the dried dung of their leader, whom they call the Pope.” Contrasted with a portrayal of the real world Baghdad, both in antiquity and modernity, as a crumbling city in ruins, and the portrait of the Middle East becomes starkly condescending, polarized between fetishized and exotic myth and the cruel barbarism that allegedly constitutes reality. 

Nominally “Ramadan” was the only short story between Brief Lives and the next arc, entitled Worlds’ End. In practice, however, Worlds’ End was a short story collection dressed up as an arc via a framing narrative in which a variety of characters from all manner of realms and worlds congregate at an inn (the Worlds’ End) to shelter from a reality storm and pass the time by telling stories. As Gaiman explains it, “I love doing short stories because of the variety they provide, and I saw Worlds’ End as my last chance to explore a bunch of different genres in Sandman. I’d previously found it arduous to begin every story from scratch, however, so this time I used the inn to provide framing sequences.” The framing sequences—which are substantial parts of the first and final issue of the arc, and two or three pages of the middle four—are illustrated by Bryan Talbot and Mark Buckingham, while the short stories, as usual, feature a rotating selection of guest artists.

It is worth comparing the stories in Worlds’ End to those of the three earlier runs of short stories. The stories in Dream Country at times extended from existing bits of Sandman’s lore—“A Midsummer Night’s Dream” unpacks the brief appearance of Shakespeare in “Men of Good Fortune,” but the arc also featured “Dream of a Thousand Cats,” an issue that existed purely to explore its own ideas. “Distant Mirrors” similarly features “Thermidor,” including the reappearance of Joanna Constantine to introduce Orpheus, and “Three Septembers and a January,” which, while deeply charming on its own merits, also runs through a cavalcade of guest stars. But it also features the wholly self-contained “August” and, retroactively, “Ramadan.” Convergences, meanwhile, contains only “The Parliament of Rooks” offering large arc significance, while “The Hunt” and “Soft Places” are genuine standalones. 

Worlds’ End contains stories in each of these moulds. The first story—a fourteen-and-a-half pager called “A Tale of Two Cities,” is in fact genuinely self-contained—indeed, the only thing tying it to Sandman is a single panel appearance of Dream, who gets no dialogue and could easily have been excluded with no harm to the larger narrative. And the fourth story, “The Golden Boy,” also largely stands alone, although it is riffing extensively on DC Comics history. The fifth, meanwhile, is very much akin to “Thermidor” or “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” unpacking bits of series lore. But the second and third stories offer something distinctly different, in that they are stories anchored by the return of fan-favorite characters. The first is the rather straightforwardly named “Cluracan’s Tale,” which reintroduces Nuala’s brother Cluracan for a standalone tale of swashbuckling adventure, while the second, “Hob’s Leviathan,” offers an adventure of Hob Gadling from “Men of Good Fortune.” The titles even foreground the central pleasure here, putting the returning character right up front for readers. 

This approach isn’t quite unprecedented—back in Dream Country there was a story, “Façade,” which traded entirely on the appearance of Death, who was its only tie to the rest of Sandman. But for one thing, that was Death—Sandman’s one unambiguous superstar character. For another, she wasn’t foregrounded in the title—she wanders in (literally) on page fifteen of a story that had previously focused on a depressed and immortal superheroine. Worlds’ End is operating very differently, and in a mode that only a long-running and beloved series could. As with The High Cost of Living, it’s a victory lap, and a transition towards Gaiman writing stories that cash in on past glories.

It is perhaps unsurprising, then, that Worlds’ End marks something of a stumbling point for the series. A Game of You may have been the least popular arc, but that’s by design—it’s a deft execution of an idea designed to alienate a portion of the audience, and there are undoubtedly Sandman fans for whom it’s a favorite. This is harder to believe about Worlds’ End, which is simply a weak arc. Short stories had never actually been Sandman’s strength—while classics like “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” and “Three Septembers and a January” exist, taken as a whole they’re markedly uneven in quality. This would be one thing if that were because Gaiman used the short stories to take ambitious risks, but he generally didn’t—things like “24 Hours” or A Game of You took place in the main arcs. His short stories tended to fall short by just being a bit insipid. And the victory lap conditions of Worlds’ End were hardly suited to challenge that. Even Gaiman is uncharacteristically critical of it, complaining of the first story, the Lovecraft/Calvino pastiche “A Tale of Two CIties” that artist Alec Stevens drew a character too similarly to Death, saying that “it’s unfortunate that she does, because it adds overtones that don’t belong to his almost instinctive decision to run from her touch.” He’s similarly critical of “Cluracan’s Tale,” which he says “turned out rather horribly” due to his attempt to cram too much story into a single issue, saying that “I ended up trying to do a swashbuckler Errol Flynn movie in fifteen minutes, and fell flat.”

But Gaiman is hardly the only party at fault. Indeed, there’s a sense of a sort of general malaise settling over the book in this period—a common phenomena as long runs approach their conclusions. “Hob’s Leviathan,” for instance, is drawn by Michael Zulli, who’s an incredible artist with a soft, subtle line. Zulli is, by his own admission, “not easy to ink,” but here he’s inked by Dick Giordano, who bleeds the nuance out of Zulli’s pages, threatening to make him indistinguishable from any other penciller. (Zulli, diplomatically, notes that Giordano was “a fairly inspired choice at the time.”) Even Dave McKean found himself burning out, describing the arc as his “lowest point during the seventy-five Sandman covers. The images in my head and the poor relations that ended up on paper had never been further apart.”

It is not that the arc is a wholesale failure. Indeed, its fourth issue, “The Golden Boy,” is among the finest short stories in all of Sandman. It sees Gaiman dusting off what was, at the time, one of the most obscure characters in DC history, Prez Rickard, who starred in Prez, a 1973 comic by Joe Simon and Jerry Grandnetti that lasted all of four issues before it was cancelled—an outcome that feels more than faintly inevitable given its absolutely gonzo premise of documenting the life and story of the United States’ first teenage President. The comic was a deeply strange piece of pop art—its antagonist was the slumlord Boss Smiley, whose face was just the same Harvey Ball smiley face that would eventually find itself upon the cover of Watchmen #1, and who had assistants like Misery Marko, an ad man who lives on a garishly colored boat in Pollution Cove because he “thinks best when he’s unhappy,” and portrayed a world where international diplomacy was conducted through chess matches with living pieces. 

Gaiman leans into the strangeness of this, casting the story as the gospel of Prez as narrated by one of his adherents after he’s died and become a figure of multiversal veneration. In many ways Gaiman skews more towards a realist mode than Joe Simon’s original conception—the broad strokes of the story are in place. But there’s no Misery Marko or Pollution Cove, nor, mercifully, Eagle Free, Prez’s painfully stereotypical Native American friend who speaks to animals and teaches Prez how to wield their powers. (Well, mostly; a character who’s plainly Eagle makes a single panel non-speaking appearance.) Instead Gaiman leans on a fair amount of existent real-world culture—the issue features appearances from Richard Nixon and John Belushi, and sees Prez appear on the cover of Newsweek, all of which grounds the story in something like the real world. (The storyteller, in introducing his tale, inquires who the President was in his audience’s world, following history back to Carter before saying, “Ah, you come from one of those Americas. You have my sympathy.”) 

And yet the underlying strangeness is still well in place. Most obviously, Boss Smiley is still there, head marginally more three-dimensional and facial features marginally more human, but still fundamentally a Harvey Ball smile in a suit and tie. There’s also, as befits Sandman, a strangely dreamlike quality to everything. Nixon’s appearance, for instance, comes when he appears in Prez’s bedroom one night to tell him that he’s going to be the next President, and when this claim proves accurate it’s met with a “number of magnificent omens,” including that “during a 42nd Street screening of Hot Teenage Love Sluts, the climactic sex scene was interrupted by the couple replacing their clothes and performing highlights from Guys and Dolls to an outraged audience.” This tone takes over the narrative in its final pages, as a consensus sweeps America that the now former President Prez has died, although nobody exactly knows how and “there was nothing about it in the newspapers, no word on television.” The deceased Prez is greeted by Death (Gaiman specifically singling out artist Mike Allred—an inspired choice for riffing on the pop art sensibilities of Jerry Grandnetti’s original—for a “standout” rendition of the character), who finds herself troubled by the circumstances of where she’s taking him. This turns out to be Boss Smiley, reverted to a pure Harvey Ball form, who attempts to exert his control over Prez only to be stopped by Dream, who’s been called in by his sister, and who Prez gifts with a pocket watch seen back in the treasure chest at the end of Season of Mists. 

It’s clever and strangely moving—a poignant cracked mirror on American politics from a recent immigrant who had found himself “struck by how powerfully my friends reacted to Bill Clinton” and the way they “were genuinely heartbroken” when he did not simply fix everything wrong with the country after twelve years of Republican rule, “as if something deeply religious had gone wrong.” But perhaps more to the point, it’s a brash and decisive trump card in what was, by that point, the nearly decade-long game among the British Invasion writers of cleverly reinventing moribund concepts. Moore, of course, had kicked off the competition with his take on Swamp Thing, but more or less everyone to have moved to DC had taken a swing at it by late 1993: Morrison with Animal Man, Doom Patrol, and Kid Eternity, Peter Milligan with Shade the Changing Man, and Gaiman with Black Orchid, Element Girl, and of course the Sandman. But here Gaiman had ostentatiously taken one of the most obscure, unworkable, and plainly ridiculous concepts out there and made it absolutely sing. There was simply nowhere else to go with the game—no further escalations of improbable cleverness to be had. Sure, someone could try to dust off Green Team: Boy Millionaires or something, but for all practical purposes the game was over. The king had been crowned.

But as the issue and, in a different sense, Worlds’ End at large both show, the only thing a golden boy can really do is disappoint. Sometimes they badly let down their audience. Sometimes they try to climb too high. Sometimes they make a principled decision to stop working for the publisher with which they have found popular success in favor of being a more niche and esoteric creator, although that one’s a bit rarer. And sometimes they simply overstay their welcome, that golden sheen slowly fading and dulling until, one day, they wake to find that the world has moved on. By the time Worlds’ End wrapped at the end of 1993, Gaiman had already written over a year’s worth more issues of Sandman than his predecessor as golden boy had on Swamp Thing, and was already six issues past the point where he’d previously estimated the book would reach its conclusion. It was time to move on.

And more even than Brief Lives, where the implications of Dream’s decision to kill Orpheus could be pieced together but were not overtly stated, the final two issues of Worlds’ End directly set up the series’ denouement. Fist was “Cerements,” set in the Necropolis, a world that serves as a sort of interdimensional funeral home. Much of this issue is devoted to Gaiman being ostentatious with his “frame narrative” structure by having the story being related at the Worlds’ End feature various characters sitting down and sharing stories, several of which themselves feature acts of storytelling. In one of these stories within a story within a story within a story (within, it will turn out, yet another story, as the frame story of Worlds’ End is revealed at the end of its final issue to itself have a frame narrative) there’s even mention of “a coal full of prentices and a master, swept away from Litharge by dark magics, who took their refuge in a tavern, where the price of haven was a tale,” just to take the ostentatious structuralism to a maximal level.

Within this blizzard of sub-tales, however, two establish concepts that Gaiman would soon be relying upon. In one, Destruction stops by the Necropolis, and tells a story about the fall of the first Necropolis, which turns out to have been precipitated by the Endless coming to ask for the ritual tools needed to bury one of their own—the first Despair, who had been obliquely alluded to a few times throughout the narrative. In another, an elder in the Necropolis tells a story of her childhood, in which she accidentally wanders into a mysterious subterranean chamber. She describes how  “there were six silver cerements hanging in that room, shining in the darkness; and a huge book, locked closed, on a lectern,” as well as a disembodied voice that demands to know “which of them is dead?” All of which serves to actively establish not just that the Endless can die, but that it is an expected part of the universe. 

The final issue, meanwhile, breaks the structure (or, rather, subverts it via the reveal that the entire arc has a framing narrative) in favor of an issue set entirely inside the Worlds’ End, in which the nature of the reality storm is finally made clear—it’s because of a funeral procession consisting of basically all the major cast of Sandman and a host of smaller characters, all save for Morpheus himself.

Between these two issues came another interesting project for Gaiman—the first issue of a series called The Children’s Crusade. This project saw Gaiman stepping once more into the role of “good corporate citizen” by spearheading the first attempt to do a big crossover event under the Vertigo banner. It was also, as it happened, the last attempt, which gives a sense of how it went. This is not exactly a surprise, as the idea was fairly obviously misbegotten. Vertigo had, after all, been founded on the principle of its iconoclastic and visionary creators. This was a very useful thing when it came to creating a line of quality and era-defining comic books. It was markedly less useful when it came to getting seven different writers on the same page to coauthor a story.

One suspects that Gaiman was largely aware of this. While he wrote the first and last issues of the crossover, published as The Children’s Crusade #1 and #2, it’s notable that he largely kept anything related to Sandman far away from it. There’s no cameo of Death or Morpheus, or any of the Endless. It would, of course, be impolitic to have no connection with Vertigo’s flagship title, especially given that Gaiman was writing it, but it would be difficult to have picked a more marginal one than Charles Rowland and Edin Payne, the two ghostly schoolchildren who starred in the interlude issue of Season of Mists, and who had made precisely zero appearances since then. Eventually—ironically in part on the back of getting dusted off for this boondoggle—they’d anchor a couple of miniseries and a short-lived Netflix series, but at the end of 1993 they were as obscure a Sandman connection as they get.

The nominal justification for this choice came from the initial idea for the crossover, which Gaiman recalls being when “somebody not me had pointed out that if there was one thing all the Vertigo titles in question had in common, it was that they each had a child in them,” an anecdote in which the most telling thing is almost certainly Gaiman’s haste, even as the story was finally being republished as a trade paperback, to make it clear that this wasn’t his idea. But he got to work on it, setting up a story in which all of the children have disappeared from the small English villate of Flaxdown, which Rowland and Payne get to investigating. What they discover is that the children have been spirited away to the Free Country, a refuge “where there is no age or pain or hunger or death” established after the eponymous Children’s Crusade in the 13th century, and more to the point that the high council of Free Country is planning to take five powerful children who will in turn give them the power to take all of the world’s children. 

These children, as the core idea of the crossover suggests, were helpfully all characters in currently running Vertigo books. There was Suzy, the younger “daughter” version of Black Orchid, Maxine Baker, the daughter of Animal Man, Tefé Holland, the daughter of Swamp Thing, Dorothy Spinnell of the Doom Patrol, and Timothy Hunter, who didn’t actually have a currently running series, but would be getting a relaunched Books of Magic ongoing soon enough. And the middle portion of the crossover, over the next two months, consisted of each of these five titles publishing an annual advancing the storyline.

This was, unsurprisingly, where things went wrong. That the five annuals would be of deeply inconsistent quality is no surprise; that’s just how crossovers work. Perhaps these were weaker than some—it’s notable that Black Orchid and Doom Patrol would be cancelled about a year after the crossover wrapped, while Animal Man would limp on a few months longer. That’s not entirely down to the writers—Animal Man would change hands before cancellation, and Rachel Pollack’s Doom Patrol was eventually reevaluated as a minor classic, but these were not titles that were generally viewed as hitting it out of the park on a regular basis. But the bigger problem, as Gaiman recalls, was simply that “bits of plot that had been handed out to the other books weren’t actually in those books when they were done,” creating a mess of a situation when he returned to wrap up the story in The Children’s Crusade #2.

The result was a broadly incoherent narrative—things were so inconsistent that individual books couldn’t manage to agree what gender one character was. Gaiman, with assistance from Jamie Delano and editor Alisa Kwitney, but with the book needing to tame the chaos and explain all the stuff that had failed to make it into the annuals the result was a chaotic and unsatisfying jumble of a comic that was considered, at best, an interesting failed experience, and at worst an outright debacle. The entire affair was so unloved that it sat for twenty years without being given a collected edition—by far the largest piece of Gaiman’s DC writing to sit out of print. As Gaiman explained it, once it finally had come out, “It never made sense to collect The Children’s Crusade into one book. The chapters in the middle were all so very much part of their own stories. But there was a beginning then, and an end.” This is an odd assertion—component parts that tie into their own stories are a fact of life for crossovers, countless numbers of which were collected over those twenty years. Perhaps the most revealing part of it is the closing assertion that there was a beginning and an end, which is to say some bits Gaiman wrote.

The eventual solution was to simply tear out the middle five issues and write a new middle section. Gaiman, by this time, was long past that sort of thing, needing two years just to get out all six issues of the Sandman Overture prequel series he was doing then, and so Toby Litt, who was writing a short-lived Dead Boy Detectives series, stepped up to pen the replacement middle chapter, although he ended up keeping the script for a few pages from Rachel Pollack’s Doom Patrol Annual. The new middle did not radically change the plot so much as it just cut large amounts of it out—at one point one of Russell Braun’s panels from the Animal Man Annual is just straightforwardly redrawn. The result is not especially more coherent than the five original annuals, and seems to mostly have the effect of screwing the original creators—whose work is still plainly being drawn on—out of credit or royalties. Even Gaiman admits that the new version mostly just “shows that Vertigo, all those years ago, was not the place for a crossover.” 

But frankly, that was what the original version did too. Between it and the lackluster Worlds’ End, Gaiman went into 1994 in what was, in some ways, the weakest position he’d had since he was an actual up and comer at the start of Sandman. Equally, it was wholly straightforward what he needed to do turn things around. He just needed to stick the landing.

Comments

Sean Dillon

“Gaiman, with assistance from Jamie Delano and editor Alisa Kwitney, but with the book needing to tame the chaos and explain all the stuff that had failed to make it into the annuals the result was a chaotic and unsatisfying jumble of a comic that was considered, at best, an interesting failed experience, and at worst an outright debacle.” I think you need to rewrite this sentence. Or, at least, the front of it.

Eiden Tal

Honestly, World's End has always been my favorite Sandman TPB, and I'm pretty shocked to hear it's considered to be anything less than great.

Eiden Tal

Similarly, among my friends who have read Sandman (admittedly not that many) we all generally consider the short stories to be the highlights of the series.

Richard Lyth

I always thought Worlds End was a really strong collection. And it seems to have been an inspiration for Lilah Sturges' excellent House Of Mystery series, which was highly underrated.

Thomas Tyrrell

I'm not sure what's 'too clever for its own good' about worshipping the dried dung of the Pope when this is explicitly how Christian worship is portrayed in the 1001 Nights (it's a riff on the Catholic fascination with incense). I remember thinking it was fascinating to see some of the Crusader romance stereotypes inverted.