El - Frigid Media: A New Year's Manifesto (Patreon)
Content
There’s an essay I’ve been thinking about, as Penn and I wrap up the last bit of Britain a Prophecy for the foreseeable future, about how comics need to look worse. And then, a week ago, I saw an article in the New York Times headlined “Video Games Can’t Afford to Look This Good,” and I realized it was making every single argument I wanted to make about comics, only about another medium. And then I started thinking about Doctor Who, and about Russell T Davies’s comments about how the BBC needs to partner with a streamer now because doing a show like Doctor Who just needs a certain level of expense and budget in the modern age. Or about the various posts I’ve seen on social media about how the current generation of college students are largely illiterate. Or about how the project I’m most passionate about right now is my desire to create a lush, gorgeous edition of William Blake’s illuminated works, and how making a beautiful physical book feels like an antidote to the waves of AI slop getting dumped on the world. And I realized that there’s a much bigger point I wanted to make. And since I just love to start a piece on New Year’s I figured I’d have myself a bit of a manifesto.
The Canadian media theorist Marshall McLuhan, some sixty years ago, theorized a distinction between hot and cold media. He explains it thusly:
A hot medium is one that extends one single sense in “high definition.” High definition is the state of being well filled with data. A photograph is, visually, “high definition.” A cartoon is “low definition,” simply because very little visual information is provided. Telephone is a cool medium, or one of low definition, because the ear is given a meager amount of information. And speech is a cool medium of low definition, because so little is given and so much has to be filled in by the listener. On the other hand, hot media do not leave so much to be filled in or completed by the audience. Hot media are, therefore, low in participation, and cool media are high in participation or completion by the audience.
McLuhan’s actual categorizations of media are arcane and often inscrutable—paper, apparently, is “a hot medium that serves to unify spaces horizontally, both in political and entertainment empires,” whereas ballet was a cool medium until the development of pointe work in the 19th century. But the underlying distinction is still useful in understanding the present age, which is, I would argue, best understood as one in which the media ecosystem has become catastrophically overheated.
Let’s return to the essay I was originally going to write about comics. My argument there was going to be that comics, in their pursuit of visual quality, have accidentally sabotaged the medium. Once upon a time a penciller could plausibly draw the entirety of a monthly comic. But these days the level of detail involved in popular comic art styles renders that impossible. Likewise, comics used to be printed with a limited palate capable of only sixty-four unique colors, on cheap-ass newsprint. Now they’re given lush computer color with millions of possibilities, on high quality paper. But all of this has served to devastate the basic cost/value proposition of the medium. The first X-Men comic cost twelve cents, and had twenty-three pages of story. According to inflation, that cost should have risen to about $1.25 today. In reality, the most recent issue of X-Men cost $5, and had only twenty pages of story to boot.
In McLuhan’s terms, what happened here is that comics became a much hotter medium. But perversely the result of that was eventually that they overheated. A modern comic book is a shockingly wasteful value proposition—perhaps fifteen minutes of reading for a cost nearly half of most streaming services. The medium has, in other words, become so hot that it began acting like a cool medium, offering very little actual information. Crucially, this is not because it’s become lower definition. The amount of actual data in comics remains considerably higher—the art is richer and more detailed than it used to be. It’s just that this data signifies considerably less. A tremendous amount of the content of a modern comic is little more than gorgeous noise—lushly rendered cityscapes and intricately drawn figures that are just quickly paged past.
Crucially, this is not what McLuhan imagined the endgame of hot media would be. He quotes Kenneth Boulding’s idea of a “break boundary”—a phase shift in a larger system whereby its nature fundamentally shifts. McLuhan specifically imagines this working in the form of a reversal. He gives the example of how “the road beyond its break boundary turns cities into highways, and the highway proper takes on a continuous urban character. Another characteristic reversal after passing a road break boundary is that the country ceases to be the center of all work, and the city ceases to be the center of leisure. In fact, improved roads and transport have reversed the ancient pattern and made cities the centers of work and the country the place of leisure and recreation.” In other words, McLuhan imagines that once a medium begins to overheat there will be a cultural shift towards cooler media. But what we’re seeing in comics is something else—a medium entering a fundamentally new state that is neither straightforwardly hot nor cool.
And it’s happening across the board. Look at that article about video games in the first paragraph and what you’ll note is that graphical realism is seemingly crowding out other aspects of the games. Gameplay isn’t just less important, it’s being squeezed to the margins by an endlessly proliferating succession of cinematic cut scenes. A few years ago, when I reviewed Cyberpunk 2077 for a startup magazine—a game that was at the time firmly on the cutting edge of graphical power—I noted that none of the actual gameplay mechanics were terribly thought through or developed, and large swaths of the game were actively boring in ways that must have been plain to the developers. Again, all of this is wholly consistent with McLuhan’s account of hot media—as games become higher and higher definition they also become less participatory. But the result is that they also become less substantial.
Or take television—a medium McLuhan identified as cool, but that has unquestionably become increasingly hot as it advanced from black and white screens that maxed out at 21” to an age where nearly hundred inch screens in ultra high definition hooked up to surround sound systems are perfectly ordinary. Television is now distinguishable from film primarily in length and the detail that some films have brief theatrical runs before arriving in the home. And, of course, all of this is fed by streaming services that put mind-boggling quantities of film and television at the tips of our fingers. And yet in response to this the increasing mantra in television production is to create “second screen” content—shows simple and fluffy enough that they can be watched while distractedly browsing your phone. Once again the medium has become so hot that it’s dissolved into noise.
It is, however, ultimately unhelpful to think of this process in terms of individual mediums. The problem is in fact systemic. It’s not that all these different modes of communication are becoming overheated—it’s that media at large is overheated. That second screen—a strange repurposing of the old cool medium of the telephone—is impossibly hot, the entirety of the Internet, the fire-hoses of social media, all crammed into a six inch rectangle weighing less than half a pound. And what do we do with it? Flick our way through an infinite scroll of vapidity—Facebook reels of brainteasers that are alternately nonsensical and trivial, Russian disinformation tweets about vaccines, and TikToks full of glamour shots that are little less than porn without tits or pussy, which is, of course, in bio. Indeed, if the Dead Internet Theory is to be believed—and it’s at worst an exaggeration of the truth—then the Internet is perhaps the ultimate example of an overheated medium—a vast global network of bots vomiting AI-generated advertisements for scams at each other.
Every generation argues that the next one is illiterate. And yet it’s plain something is actually happening here. Here’s a fun statistic, for instance. In the 1970s, all ten of the Academy Award for Best Picture winners were also in the top ten box office gross for the year; in three cases, they were the top grossing film outright. In the 1980s, that fell to five films that were also in the top ten, and only one that was the top film of the year. The nineties ticked up back to seven, with again one that was the top of the year. But with the turn of the millennium that falls off a cliff—the 00s have only two Best Picture Winners in the top ten, although one was still the number one film of the year. That film—the third Lord of the Rings movie in 2003—was also the last time the Best Picture winner was in the top ten of its year until the fluke of Oppenheimer twenty years later. Oppenheimer was also notable for being one of only a handful of films in the past ten years to make the top ten without being a sequel, remake, or adaptation of an already existent property. The Oscars are a flawed measurement to be sure, but it’s still shocking to see such a comprehensive divergence of popular and critical taste, and more to the point to see popular taste become so focused on the empty reenactment of past glories.
The obvious apex of this is, of course, Trump—a political candidate whose appeal is almost entirely dependent on medial overheating. He functions by reducing the actual content of politics to the bare essence of emotive anger. There are no longer facts, issues, expertise, debate, or even really information to politics. And yet this is not accomplished by people being unexposed to political media. Instead vast sums of money are spent maintaining a news environment that talks constantly without saying anything, providing no actual understanding of the world save for whatever the current lie is–a lie that will be discarded without ceremony or acknowledgment as soon as circumstances dictate it’s time for a new one. Sound and fury signifying nothing, as one of those books nobody apparently reads anymore puts it.
It is not that the kind of reversals imagined by McLuhan aren’t happening. Perhaps most significant is the medium of music, which was one of the first to overheat as listening habits shifted to a streaming-based approach in which passive algorithmic discovery is the norm. But in response this we got the vinyl revival, in which the long dead medium of the phonograph lurched off the slab and became a cultural force. Vinyl is an extremely cool medium—it forces music to become participatory, literally requiring manual intervention every twenty minutes or so. And while capitalist consumption is a deeply problematic lens, it also requires a degree of financial participation. One must curate a record collection, and generally spend more on a single album than you would on a month or two of Spotify. It may be a minority position compared to streaming, but it’s still a vital and revealing counter-reformation to medial overheating.
But this is one media in a landscape that is comprehensively overheated, and one that has cooled itself down by becoming, in point of fact, considerably more expensive not only compared to streaming but compared to the CD era. Other green shoots of actual media cooling can be found—the recent critical darling TV show Shogun was actively described by its creators as “single screen” television, and, of course, Oscar-winning movies keep getting made. But these are all sporadic pockets of resistance to an overwhelming and systemic overheating. And while it’s easy to talk about ways things could be better—comics and video games should be less visually opulent, films should have fewer sequels, everybody should read more books—these are all plainly unachievable on an individual level, requiring massive shifts in consumer behavior to even become possible, and even then being dependent on large corporations actually deciding to respond to the consumer behavior and change their approach, which, in spite of the much vaunted rationalism of the capitalist market, is actually moderately unlikely.
And yet this is plainly unsustainable. The options are medial cooldown or human extinction. As there’s no point in planning for the latter, we may as well think about the former. I do not ultimately think “how do we cool the entirety of media down” is a useful question to tackle in an essay. “Put more billionaire heads on spikes” is probably still sound advice. But I do think that figuring out how to cool down our own mediated experience of the world is productive on a personal/indvidual level. For one thing, the constant overheating of our mediated experience is harmful, and it’s worthwhile to alleviate that damage. For another, if there is a future it will be a dramatically cooler one. We may as well get there first, so as to be ready when the world finally catches up to us.
That said, there is a difference between cooling down and unplugging. There’s much to be said for social media detoxes and deciding to live a less online life, but my goal here is not to isolate ourselves from the world, and that world is increasingly online and digital. The Internet does not intrinsically have to be an overheated medium any more than film or comics or video games do. And when one considers the “unplugging” approach more broadly, one quickly realizes the folly. Our goal isn’t to rid ourselves of media. It’s to get our media to stop sucking so goddamn much.
The defining nature of a cool medium is its participation. This does not mean interactivity, but rather the degree to which the audience is filling in gaps; think in terms of that old joke about the girl who liked radio more than television because the pictures are better. More than anything, the discipline that is required here is seeking out media that is actually challenging and requires work on our part. Difficult books, obtuse and symbolic films, experimental music—art that makes demands of its audience. Yes, this is less “fun” than just sitting down with whatever this season’s new Star Wars content is, at least where “fun” means easy and untroubled entertainment. People also tend to call that sort of fun escapism, though, and it seems to me that freeing ourselves from the spirit of these times means cultivating a relationship with depth, subtlety, and weight. It is the great works that are escapist now.
There is also much to be said for cultivating a relationship with physical media again. This ought not be fetishistic—the point isn’t to become a book hoarder, filling cheap particle board bookcases with titles like you’re racking up your Goodreads stats. There’s a line from Derrida about how he’s only read six books, but he’s read them really carefully, and this is the energy we need right now. On my desk beside me as I write this is a copy of Sandman: The Kindly Ones that I’ve had since high school. The spine is splitting—the cover and the first few pages beginning to tear off. There’s a half-peeled barcode sticker on the back, tape residue coated with some ten years of grime. And for all that I am deeply, furiously over it with Neil Gaiman, this object has power. This shouldn’t be a surprise. If we are going to demand that our media have weight again then we ought embrace literalist interpretations of that as well. For all that we were told the Internet is forever, the truth has proven to be that it is painfully ephemeral. The convenience of digital media cannot be denied, and will always have its merits, but this is a time for things.
My point here is not that we ought all become snobs who prefer physical media, although doing so would certainly not be a bad thing. It would be a mistake to confuse cool media with great ones, even if old-fashioned notions of aesthetic value have tremendous use here. There are more ways to increase audience participation than mere difficulty, though, and requiring the mild inconveniences of physical media is one of them. How many of our lengthy threads on social media would be improved by printing them up as a zine and making people send us a self-addressed stamped envelope for them? Sure, they’d reach all of five people, but every one of those five people would actually care. Which is to say that the moment requires mediocre and crappy cool media as much as it does great works. The lo-fi, the DIY, the marginal, obscure, and weird—all of these are the things that matter right now. In an age of AI slop, the human touch is everything.
What I am trying to describe here is not some vision of ideal media but rather a sort of personal spiritual discipline. Times as bad as these require becoming a man out of time. McLuhan makes much of the idea that media are extensions of ourselves, especially of our sensory organs. Our nervous systems, our dopamine receptors, our very patterns of thought—all of them are skewed, disrupted, and, to put it in obvious terms, just plain burnt out by constant exposure to overheated media. Our task is to reverse that—to move ourselves back to rhythms and textures that are not so fried. This is achievable on an individual level—we can retrain ourselves into different modes of engagement. A cooler world is possible.