Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Here, at last, the conclusion. I'm going to take a revision pass on all 56,392 words of this (Literally 26% of Volume 2 is now epilogue) and post an omnibus version down the line, but for now I'm going to fall over, or maybe eat something.

----

The jaws of the trap closed slowly but inexorably. Sandman wrapped with six final issues, collected as The Wake although only the first four form an actual storyline with that title. Illustrated by Michael Zulli, this told the story of Morpheus’s funeral and did the work of introducing Daniel as a character. In some ways they’re even more of a cameo cavalcade than The Kindly Ones had been, with Gaiman delighting in visual jokes like having Rose Walker and her brother seated between the Emperor Norton and Darkseid, or a panel featuring the Alder Man, one of Destruction’s old friends who evaded his doom by turning into a bear, who is seen giving a eulogy for Morpheus, still in bear form. Some of these are legitimately entertaining—there’s a bit in which Superman and Batman reflect on their recurring dream of being “an actor on a strange television version of my life,” agreeing that everyone has that dream, to which Martian Manhunter (who’s never had a TV show) responds that “I don’t.” And the arc’s serious beats largely as well. The structure of it means that Gaiman is usually left to write one or two pages of wistful melancholy, and he delivers reliably with moments like Thessaly’s eulogy, which ends with her breaking down as she notes that “I swore I would never shed another tear for him.”

Gaiman is aided in all of this by Zulli, who Gaiman pushed to be allowed to do the art in straight pencils, without an inker. The result, aided by a beautifully soft coloring job by Daniel Vozzo and a healthy dollop of technical wizardry from Todd Klein, both of whom worked closely with Zulli, is one of the most breathtakingly gorgeous runs of issues not just in Sandman but frankly in American comics. The pages positively glow, while Zulli’s linework is intricate, soft, and expressive. The result is a storyline that soars into some of Gaiman’s best mythic grandeur, culminating in a sequence in which Death’s eulogy is described instead of depicted, the reader being told that “her words make sense of everything. She gives you peace. She gives you meaning. And she bids her brother goodbye” before, in a sly pun on the arc’s title, having the reader themself wake from the dream through which they’ve nominally been experiencing the story. A coda, once more drawn by Zulli, grounds the story back in the human register with the delightful conceit of Hob Gadling attending a renn faire.

The final two issues of Sandman return to the short story format, both sequels to previous issues. First is “Exiles,” which revisits the iconography of “Soft Places” back in the Convergences arc and sees Jon J Muth invert Zulli’s art process to do an issue entirely in inks. The second, meanwhile, finally returns to Shakespeare and his bargain with Dream. Gaiman had been planning for this to be the final issue of the series for some time, saying “I’d originally planned on doing ‘The Tempest’ about a year after ‘A Midsummer Night’s Dream.” But I later realized that because the play is all about storie and endings, it would be an appropriate subject for the last issue of the series.” This is thematically sound, but it also just provided a way for Sandman to end on an unambiguously strong note, with a reprise of one of the issues that had been most key to its rise and reputation.

Where “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” had focused on the performance of its eponymous play, “The Tempest” focuses on the play’s writing. It opens with a half-page panel of the opening scene—a ship in a storm, rendered not as a dramatic presentation but as a storybook illustration rendered with minimal inking so that when the story cuts to Shakespeare, alone at his desk, writing the contrast is clear. The issue stays with Shakespeare as he writes his final play, looking at his life and what his bargain with Dream got him. As befits The Tempest and the fact that this is the end of Sandman, the answer is melancholic—Shakespeare assures Ben Johnson that “I shall be pleased to put down my pen,” and scoffs to Morpheus, “Look at me now: a fat old man, lustless and lackluster, with my two-score years and seven. I dream of being nobody at all. My every third thought is of the grave.” He describes his life as a dissociative blur—“My son died,” he explains, “and I was hurt; but I watched my hurt, and even relished it a little, for now I could write a real death, a true loss.” 

All of this is set up in “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” where Morpheus muses on the subtle curse of getting what you once wanted. But when Gaiman, by now years into his practice of sleeping with fans when traveling away from his wife, has Anne Shakespeare upbraid her husband for claiming to be a “practical man” with a sarcastic retort that “Of course you do, my dear. Practical men always desert their wives and run away to make up pretty tales; and write pretty sonnets to pretty girls and pretty boys,” it’s hard not to see the parallel, and it’s not one that would have existed so clearly in 1990 when he wrote “A Midsummer Night’s Dream.” 

But for all its melancholy, “The Tempest” never has Shakespeare come close to deciding he wishes he’d not taken the deal. Indeed, Dream tells him that had he not he “would not have been satisfied with your life; and, from time to time, you would have bored your children with the tales of your years in London, your days on the stage.” The story has much to say about the price of the deal, but at the end of the day it is not a critique of Shakespeare’s actions so much as a romanticization of the supposedly great burden of creating art. And when it comes to the story paralleling Gaiman’s life, the fact that he and Shakespeare were both adulterous cads who spent much of their time away from home rather pales before the basic fact of Gaiman using the consensus greatest writer in the English language as a self-analogue. 

Alongside the end of Sandman Gaiman penned a second Death miniseries for Vertigo. This was by all appearances intended to immediately follow Sandman as a tacit (and, ultimately, false) reassurance that Gaiman wasn’t going anywhere—its first issue is dated April 1996, while Sandman #75 is dated March. But the end of Sandman was marked by delays—just as The Kindly Ones saw thirteen issues over eighteen months, the final six issues of the series took nine months to come out, and the final two were sufficiently delayed that they were actually coming out the same month as their cover date instead of the traditional two months before (an artifact of the days of comics being sold on newsstands and magazine racks, where they’d be culled from sale when their dates passed). The result was that in practice the first two issues of Death: The Time of Your Life were already out when Sandman #75 hit, whereas the last one suffered a three month delay and came out in June. 

These delays appear to have been almost entirely down to Gaiman. Chris Bachalo, who returned to draw the second Death miniseries. He had by that point taken work at Marvel, but cleared a few months from his schedule to fulfill a promise to Karen Berger that he’d return for it. As he describes it, “what was happening was that I was getting one to two pages a week to draw. Four months went by and we had an issue done.” Ultimately Bachalo ended up departing the series halfway through the second issue, with Gaiman’s Miracleman collaborator Mark Buckingham, who’d been on inks, stepping up with a Bachalo imitation so good as to be functionally seamless. 

Bachalo’s theory for Gaiman’s slow output was that “at that point, Neil was receiving a lot of opportunities and he was probably taking a lot of stuff on. I don’t believe that the Death series was a priority with him.” And it’s certainly true that, as Sandman wound down, Gaiman began turning his attention to non-comics projects. But Gaiman’s scripts had begun slowing down long before Death: The Time of Your Life. A quick perusal of the numbers for each full year of Sandman’s run shows that Gaiman went from producing eleven issues a year to an incredible fourteen issues in 1991, both double shipping in January and penning the Sandman Special to, in the latter years, falling off sharply—1994 saw only nine issues produced, and 1995 saw seven. Beyond that, there’s a sense of being rushed to Gaiman’s work in this period—both Sandman #72 and the final issue of Death: The Time of Your Life saw Gaiman fail to get his script to work in the requisite number of pages, resulting in their climaxes being redone in the trade paperbacks—Sandman #72 had Michael Zulli cram a four page sequence into two, then redraw it as four for the trade, while The Time of Your Life has four extra pages spliced into its closing sequence. All of this points to a writer who was getting increasingly frazzled by the grind of comics production.

In the script for the second issue of The Wake, Gaiman reflected on this, noting that “I wish I were still a fast writer. I’m not slow, by any rational criterion, but I’m not fast anymore. Thinking takes longer—particularly on Sandman, where I’ve done it before. I’ve done it all before.” But Gaiman’s notion of repeating himself, at least at this stage of his career, seems to have been idiosyncratic. He describes how, around halfway through Sandman, “my scripts began taking longer and longer to complete. I’d start to lay out a page and then say, ‘No, I already used that panel sequence in The Doll’s House’ or ‘I already exploited that image in Season of Mists,’” which are both fairly hyper-specific things to fret about. Indeed, Gaiman admits that “after the first round of awards I began freezing up, getting terrifying writer’s blocks,” and periodically feared that he had simply lost the capacity to write entirely. This process, it turned out, would only accelerate as his career advanced.

Death: The Time of Your Life returned to Hazel and Foxglove, previously of A Game of You and then as significant minor characters in Death: The High Cost of Living, where Foxglove had a music career begin to take off. The Time of Your Life rejoins her on the publicity tour for her second album, by which point she’s become a major star who appears on Letterman and gets scolded by her manager about how she needs to upgrade to a stadium tour. The plot concerns Hazel and their son Alvie, who dies of SIDS in the story’s two page opener, but, it’s revealed, is kept alive for several more months after Hazel makes a deal with Death.

The dramatic core of the story is Foxglove and Hazel’s rapidly disintegrating relationship, which is suffering under the strain of Foxglove’s celebrity. Talking to Death, Hazel reflects on how “it was like she wasn’t just mine. She was everybody’s. I mean. I’d hate it. I’d love her when she was at home, with me, with Alvie But I didn’t love her when she was in a crowd. I didn’t love the star. I didn’t love the person they all loved. They didn’t know her. I knew her,” and how “it wad like she was going up in a balloon. And she was getting further and further away from me. And I just felt stupider and stupider. And I mean I am pretty stupid. I mean, I’m not, but I never knew much except cooking.” Foxglove, meanwhile, has been cheating on Hazel while on tour—a one point she reflects on how she started kissing a woman “before I had a chance to think about what I was doing—because I was so far from home—her head between my legs—stuttering my lust into the night—knowing somewhere down deep that I could take whatever I wanted, but that one day it would all have to be paid for.” As with Shakespeare in “The Tempest,” it’s difficult not to see Gaiman’s own marriage reflected in this, nor the ominous shades of what was to come in the dissociated but power-hungry comment about being able to take whatever one wanted. (To say nothing of the scene where Foxglove initiates sex with Hazel while Alvie is still in the bed with them.) 

The Time of Your Life ultimately sees Hazel and Foxglove reconcile. There’s a climactic beat in which Foxglove confesses to Hazel that “for a while now, I’ve been, well. Not as faithful as maybe you thought I was. And there’s a girl who’s going to the magazines about it. I didn’t want to be outed. I don’t think I ever wanted to be inned. And I don’t know what’s going to happen. But I don’t think I love you anymore,” to which Hazel laughs and, not unreasonably, points out that Foxglove just spent three issues following her “into Death, because I needed you. What do you think love is?” And with that and a heroic sacrifice from a side character all is well. It’s plainly a fantasy, and almost heartbreaking in its innocence—Gaiman imagining a sort of idealized peace that might be waiting for him if he came clean to his wife. Perhaps he even did, and Mary McGrath gave him that sort of perfect acceptance, though if so, it plainly didn’t change his behavior.

In the comic, however, it all works out. Foxglove renounces art and celebrity and runs away with Hazel and Alvie, disappearing so thoroughly that the non-trademark infringing World Weekly News is running stories about her playing shows with Buddy Holly in an Arizona ghost town. As she puts it, “I didn’t become a singer because I had something to say. I didn’t do it for the money or the fame or the glory. I did it because it seemed like a good idea at the time, and I was so tired of being poor.” She’s not entirely serving as a mouthpiece for the author here—Gaiman at least did have things to say, and a pile of ideas he’d been collecting since adolescence to use. And yet when pushed on why he became a professional writer, as opposed to someone who was writing things purely for himself, his answer is not all that far away from Foxglove’s: “I was in bed imagining my life, and I got to the point in my imagining when I was old and dying, and I thought if I die and I haven’t been a writer, I will lie on my deathbed going, ‘I could have been a writer. Really could have been a writer.’ Whatever it is that I’ve done—if I’ve been any of the things I wanted to be or the things I didn’t want to be, or the things I thought were inevitable, like becoming an English teacher—I’d be lying there on my deathbed going, ‘I could have been a writer,’ and I wouldn’t know if I was kidding myself. I wouldn’t know if I really could have been a writer. And the thing that would kill me would not be having failed, it would be the idea of having this life and having had this idea that this was the thing I wanted to be and this was the thing I could have been, and not knowing if I was lying to myself.” And now he knew. If he’d wanted it, the ending he wrote for Foxglove was available to him, albeit probably not with quite as much beatific grace as he has Hazel give Foxglove.

But he didn’t. He wanted to be a famous writer. And so, with his obligations to DC completed, he got to work. The latter half of the decade proved both fruitful and varied for Gaiman. He expanded his earlier collection Angels and Visitations into a new short story collection called Smoke and Mirrors. He handled the script localization for Mirimax’s English-language dub of Hayao Miyazaki’s Princess Mononoke. He wrote an episode of J. Michael Straczynski’s cult classic space opera Babylon 5—the only writer other than Straczynski to do so over the show’s final three seasons. He even made a brief return to Sandman at the decade’s end, penning a novella-length prose story riffing on Japanese mythology that DC put out with illustrations by Yoshitaka Amano. These, however, were side projects. His primary work in the aftermath of Sandman was to successfully break out as a novelist.

His first major step towards this was, in fact, well in progress when Sandman concluded, although at first glance it had little to do with that goal. Back in 1991, while judging the Arthur C Clarke awards, Gaiman ran into the comedian Lenny Henry, who he’d recently met while working on the Comic Relief charity comic with Richard Curtis. Henry had been talking to the BBC about developing a fantasy television show, and offered Gaiman a vague idea about tribes of people (there’s some dispute over whether Henry specified homeless people) living in London. Gaiman was reluctant to glamorize sleeping rough, but came up with the idea of London Below, a shadow city of people who fell through the cracks of London proper. The idea developed at the slow pace of BBC development, but in the spring of 1996 production began on a six episode series called Neverwhere.

The result is a fascinating case of a tremendous amount of talent failing comprehensively to make good television. Gaiman’s script is a Campbell-by-Numbers piece of classic urban fantasy, but it fizzes with clever ideas. The cast is stellar, with Peter Capaldi, Patterson Joseph, Tamsin Greig, and Laura Fraser headlining a collection of up and comers and fine grizzled veterans of the British industry. Gaiman and Henry were even able to draft in Brian Eno to compose the score. The problem is simply that the BBC picks up where they’d left off producing Doctor Who seven years earlier. (Indeed, Patterson Joseph’s performance of the Marquis de Carabas, a cunning trickster in an excellent coat, would ensure he was in the rumor mill for playing Doctor Who for much of the first decade of its eventual revival.) The original plan had been to shoot the series on video and then filmise it, and it was lit accordingly, only to have that decision abandoned in post-production, leaving everything badly overlit. Gaiman, meanwhile, for all his cleverness, was a television neophyte, and badly misjudged the capabilities of the BBC, creating concepts like the Great Beast of London, a terrifying monster living in the sewers of London that, once scaled to the budget available, ended up being a perfectly ordinary cow.

But Gaiman did something enormously clever, which was to retain the right to pen the novelization of the series, which came out from BBC Books in September 1996, midway through the series’ transmission, then in the US from Avon Books the next summer. Unlike the TV series, the book version was a triumph, picking up solid reviews across the board and quickly becoming the consensus “real” version of the story, with the BBC series little more than a curiosity for Gaiman fans that would have faded into obscurity had Gaiman not written the novel. 

Something similar happened with Gaiman’s next major project, which was called Stardust. Gaiman had first developed the idea for this in 1991, at the World Fantasy Convention where he and Vess won for “A Midsummer Night’s Dream,” when he saw a shooting star out in the desert and came upon the idea of the star in fact being a girl. As he tells it, “I went back to the hotel, found Charlie who was at a different party, hauled him out of the party—holding a bottle of celebratory champagne. I said, ‘Okay, let me tell you this story. I think I’ve come up with something.’ I told him everything that was in my head about the story, and then at the end he smiled and said, ‘I can’t wait to draw it,’” although, burnt out on comics, he suggested it might be an illustrated novel instead.

In practice Vess had to wait several years to draw it—Gaiman didn’t start work on the manuscript until 1994, and it finally came out in four prestige format volumes from Vertigo in 1997 before being collected into what Gaiman and Vess had viewed as its intended form, a single illustrated volume that could evoke Victorian fairy stories—Gaiman, in fact, wrote the manuscript in fountain pen to try to bring himself back to a 1920s milieu. It is, to be sure, a gorgeous package. Vess’s illustrations are predictably lush—an early double page spread of a fairy market exists almost entirely to show off his capabilities, allowing him to absolutely pack the page with details like a woman walking a pair of red dragons, a surly looking rodent vendor, or a cameo from Hayao Miyazaki’s creations of Kiki and Totoro. But the story is plainly a trifle, and Gaiman is open about the fact that it was meant to be, noting that “there seemed to be a general consensus that it was the most inconsequential of my novels. Fantasy fans, for example, wanted it to be an epic, which it took enormous pleasure in not being,” and explaining that {it’s like an ice cream. It’s to make you feel happy when you finish it.” 

Stardust would likely have become a minor bit of DC’s back catalog, except that once again, Gaiman retained the rights to the underlying text of the story, and in 1999 it was brought out as a standalone novel, shorn of Vess’s illustrations. And so as the twentieth century wound itself down, Gaiman found himself in the unusual position of having three novels out along with a short story collection, all without ever having actually gone and sold a novel as a solo author. More than that, he’d built a body of work that was not only significant, it was surprisingly diverse in audience. Neverwhere was urban fantasy, but it had an ample tinge of horror that was picked up by many of the short stories in Smoke and Mirrors. Good Omens, meanwhile, was a comic novel where he was still second fiddle to Terry Pratchett, at least in terms of marketing heft. Stardust, on the other hand, was effectively cross-marketed to romance fans. And, of course, there was still the horde of Sandman fans, whose ranks expanded yearly from DC’s continually in print trade collection. And while it’s undoubtedly true that many, perhaps even most readers of these books stuck to whatever genre had brought them there, plenty of them became general Neil Gaiman fans.

When he did finally write and sell a novel, this fact was crucial to the promotional campaign. On February 9th, 2001, just over four months before its publication, Gaiman took the then extremely novel step of starting a blog to promote his upcoming novel, to be called American Gods. Gaiman had experimented with this before, spending a year on early social media site the Well conducting an ongoing conversation with readers, and he was good at it, posting every couple of days at a minimum. Although the blog nominally existed to promote American Gods, Gaiman quickly realized that he could only get so much drama out of checking copy edits and learning that Dumpster is in fact a trademark that should be capitalized (March 2nd) and discovering he’d sent a permissions request for a poem he quoted to the wrong people (March 5th), and let the blog expand to a more general discussion of what he was reading (March 7th), the former exotic dancer who tried his patience at the post office (March 14th), or a lengthy essay’s worth of advice for attending a book signing (April 11th), before eventually settling into a primary format of an ongoing reader Q&A.

Gaiman developed a wry and avuncular voice for the blog—one capable of taking news like the fact that Harlan Ellison made an exception to his categorical refusal to give blurbs for the book and making it sound like a charming anecdote instead of just like bragging. (The trick is to bury it more than 1500 words into a post about blurbs and some six hundred words after the fact that Harlan Ellison doesn’t do blurbs has been established in one of several amusing anecdotes about the process.) He was adept at giving a carefully managed illusion of openness—his kids, especially his youngest, were frequent and amusing characters, but a more detailed perusal will reveal that he essentially never talks about Mary McGrath except in a couple of fleeting mentions. But it was more than enough to foster a strong parasocial connection with his fans. Just as he’d savvily transformed Sandman into an auteur project with him at the center, now he was expanding the strategy into a broader career one, acquiring readers from all sorts of places and converting them to Neil Gaiman fans who could follow him directly and get helpful updates when there was something new to buy.

This would, of course, eventually become commonplace. But at the beginning of 2001 Gaiman was profoundly far ahead of the curve, and he maintained the strategy for more than twenty years after, at first on the blog and then, as that became a more sporadic affair, with an active presence on various social media platforms such that his 2013 novel The Oceana t the End of the Lane bore an affectionate note in its acknowledgments that “The good folk of Twitter were extremely helpful when I needed to double-check how much blackjacks and fruit salad sweets cost in the 1960s. Without them I might have written my book twice as fast.” And more to the point, when it came to American Gods at least it was an unequivocal success—the book debuted at #10 on the New York Times bestseller list, instantly establishing Gaiman as one of the top fantasy writers of the era.

The book itself is a curious thing. In one sense it can be fairly described as a retread of Sandman. Its central premise—that immigrants over the millennia brought their gods to America, where they became lost and wayward figures as belief in them waned—is absolutely in the same vein as the casually mundane mythology of his breakout project. Indeed, the Ishtar sequence in Brief Lives, in which the ancient Sumerian fertility goddess is working as an exotic dancer who explosively reveals herself, is so close to the novel’s approach that it could trivially have been rewritten to fit into it. When American Gods fires on all cylinders it’s clearly offering the same basic pleasure that Sandman did at peaks like Season of Mists. 

Gaiman also plainly leans on his comics experience in structuring the novel. Its three act structure can just as easily be read as three arcs, especially as the middle of the novel takes an unexpected detour to leave its protagonist, Shadow, cooling his heels in a tiny Wisconsin town called Lakeside, providing an effect not unlike The Doll’s House swerve to focusing on Rose Walker or A Game of You’s even more aggressive detour. Gaiman also peppers the novel with interludes that are, effectively, short stories akin to those in Convergences or Distant Mirrors. He even makes a move akin to “24 Hours” with the first of these, telling a story in which the semi-Biblical Bilquis devours a man whole through her vagina during sex that serves to put the book’s most extreme moment early on, both to make a strong impression and to quickly define a limit point that everything else will fall within.

But while American Gods was clearly trying to get Sandman’s lightning to strike twice, there are clear points where Gaiman is pushing himself in new directions. The largest of these is, ironically, also the least successful: his attempt to grapple with the notion of America. As he puts it, “I moved to America in 1992. Something started, in the back of my head. There were unrelated ideas that I knew were important and yet seemed unconnected: two men meeting on a plane; the car on the ice; the significance of coin tricks; and more than anything, America: this strange, huge place where I now found myself living that I knew I didn’t understand. But I wanted to understand it. More than that, I wanted to describe it.” And yet Gaiman has relatively little to say about America itself. The novel reiterates, like a mantra, that America is “a poor place for gods,” but there is no reason given for this save for a monologue from Wisakedjak, an indigenous figure, in which he explains that “we never built churches. We didn’t need to. The land was the church. The land was the religion. The land was older and wiser than the people who walked on it,” which is, to put it mildly, an extremely dubious account of indigenous American theology. Its concept of what America offers instead of gods, meanwhile, is almost comical in its datedness—he creates a pantheon of new gods who oppose the old gods of traditional mythology like Media, a goddess of television, or the Spookshow, a version of the shadowy men in black working for nameless government agencies. There are gods of airplanes, cars, UFOs, and drugs. But these are all painfully twentieth century notions. He nods to computers and the Internet in the form of the Technical Boy, but he’s little more than a parody of 90s cyberpunks. For all that Gaiman was anticipating the future in promoting the book, his account of America could not be more stuck in the just departed twentieth century if it tried.

This is not to say that there are not interesting components of his portrayal of America and spirituality. It’s just that these are largely not the innovative aspects of the book. The Technical Boy, for instance, makes the Burroughsian claim that “we have fucking programmed reality” and that “language is a virus,” but of course he does; cyberpunks loved Burroughs almost as much as magi did. More interesting, and not entirely unrelated, is his understanding of how the old gods function in America—as old stories and patterns that recur and shape things long after their meaning and context has been forgotten—which is plainly a reiteration of Scientology and engrams. 

But there are no shortage of other innovations. Gaiman’s protagonist, for instance, is a mixed race ex-con who begins the novel in prison—a character very much unlike any Gaiman had previously written. The result is not some striking portrayal of the American carceral state or anything like that—indeed, Shadow ends up being something of a cipher—but there’s a clear ambition to the decision; it shows Gaiman pushing himself to do new things.

The book’s most significant innovation, however, came in one of Gaiman’s interpretations of mythology. The book’s antagonist is Mr. Wednesday, Shadow’s employer, who is revealed to be running a complicated ruse in order to spark a war between the old and new gods so that he can harvest the energy of the blood sacrifice. Wednesday is in fact Odin, and his partner in this is Loki, hiding in plain sight as Shadow’s old cellmate Low Key. This interpretation of Odin and Loki is reasonably supported by the lore—Odin and Loki are attested as blood brothers, and both are known for their cunning. But the idea of Odin and Loki as con men engaged in a two man con is wholly Gaiman’s invention. Nevertheless, in the wake of American Gods it quickly took hold in modern germanic pagan spaces as a common interpretation of the gods, more often than not with the idea that Ragnarok is some sort of inside job and that Loki’s murder of Balder is in fact at Odin’s behest—a notion that closely parallels Gaiman’s plot, where one of the key reveals is that Wednesday is in fact Shadow’s father. 

This is no small thing. For all of Moore and Morrison’s accomplishments, neither can honestly be said to have transformed the cultural understanding of major and well-established gods. It’s a testament both to the legitimate weight of Gaiman’s talent and to the potency of the underlying magic he’s wielding. For all that he never subscribed to the overtly mystical paradigm of Moore, the seventy-six issue sweep of Sandman was a staggeringly large working, considerably vaster in scope than anything else in or around the War save perhaps Jerusalem, and American Gods, as its realization, was an object of tremendous power in its own right. Gaiman did not simply make it as a writer—he did so by harnessing the forces that had ended the Cold War and that would define the shape of the twenty-first century and the millennium it birthed.

What he had failed to consider—the fatal mistake that ultimately caused such vast ruin and pain—was that you cannot escape Scientology with the bastard fruit of L. Ron Hubbard. In one of his few public comments about the influence of Scientology, Gaiman noted that he “grew up in a world in which being a science-fiction writer was a good thing. As far as my parents were concerned, that was an incredibly esteemed profession.” And now, as he swept the genre awards for that field, picking up nominations for practically every Best Novel award there was and winning the Hugo, Nebula, Locus, and Bram Stoker awards, the engrammatic patterns implicit in that incredible esteem took hold. 

Indeed, it was at the 2002 World Horror Convention in Chicago at which the latter of those awards was presented that the earliest account of his abuse took place. It is almost certainly not fair to treat American Gods as the singular point where Gaiman became abusive. His victim’s account of what happened notes that Gaiman “seemed to have a script” that he slipped into during the encounter—a description that suggests she was not the first person that he treated this way. And, more prosaically, it’s simply unlikely that one of the victims brave and secure enough to come forward would also happen to be the first person he ever did this to. Indeed, there’s an accuser from the mid-80s, though her story is more that of an ill-advised drunken pass than an iteration of the script. 

And it’s clear that Gaiman’s script moved in iterations. More to the point, it escalated steadily over the years, first through increasing sexual violence, and then into financial abuse and active exploitation of power imbalances. Implicit in this fact is an escalation up to the first known instance of abuse as well. In 2007, Gaiman told one of his victims that he’d been introduced to BDSM by a woman who’d asked him to “whip his pussy.” His victim recalls him saying this happened in his early twenties, but he recounted the same basic story to Jason McBride when interviewed for his biography of Kathy Acker, describing it as happening while Acker was living in New York, which would be somewhere between September of 1989 and the summer of 1990. In both recountings, Gaiman portrays himself as stunned and scandalized by the request—he told his victim that he was so naive that he assumed she meant her cat, whereas when telling the story to McBride he’d already been aware of Acker’s history with S&M, but claims that he’s “very vanilla” and that he found the encounter “profoundly unsexual.”

But if Gaiman was telling the truth about this being a turning point—and the assumption that he was being honest with someone he was abusing is, to state the obvious, a dubious one—then it can only have been a transition from thought to action, given that by September 1989 he’d already penned “24 Hours,” a story he elsewhere describes as the point where Acker “decided I was a Real Writer and not a groupie,” and that demonstrates a chilling familiarity with the psychological logic of sexual sadism. The only possible thing he could have gained out of his encounter with Acker is the actual knowledge of what it felt like to inflict sexual violence—a fact that’s highlighted by the fact that McBride recounts Gaiman having “found the depth of her need both startling and sad,” which is to say that his primary emotional takeaway was centered on Acker’s abjection in the exchange.

The contours of Gaiman’s sexual sadism are tediously cliched. The seemingly tightly scripted nature of them, Gaiman’s claim to one partner that sexual violence is “the only way I can get off,” and the fact that his reaction to being asked questions about his childhood and Scientology was such an intense shutdown that “he would curl up on the bed into a fetal position and cry” all sound like details from a particularly heavy-handed intro psychology textbook. But while occasional details of Gaiman’s behavior echo Scientology—his demand of one victim that “she promise him her soul” evokes the infamous billion year contract that members of Scientology’s SeaOrg are expected to sign, pledging their loyalty not merely until death but through all subsequent incarnations—the abuse does not seem to have centered on the actual content of Scientology. Its defining characteristic is simply its astonishing cruelty.

It is worth voicing the specific nature of this cruelty, lest one be tempted to consider Gaiman’s actions in euphemism, allowing the particulars of his psychology to serve as a euphemism for the horrors. One victim reports having informed Gaiman of a painful urinary tract infection, drawing an explicit line that she did not want to be vaginally penetrated; Gaiman ignored this, penetrating her first with his fingers and then, after she reiterated her explicit lack of consent, escalating to using his penis. Another reports Gaiman suddenly grabbing her, beating her, and then anally penetrating her, first without lubrication, and subsequently with butter, while she screamed “no” the entire time. Afterwards, he made her lick up her own feces. Multiple victims report him forcing them to have sex with him in front of his child. And these are simply the worst details to have made it into the public sphere. Just as it would be a mistake to assume that the earliest instance of abuse to have emerged is coincidentally the actual first, it would be profoundly naive to assume that these examples actually represent the apex of Gaiman’s brutality.

But beyond the raw horror of the violence there is a clear thread of Gaiman relishing in the level of power he commanded. One victim was a recently divorced woman whose husband had been working as the caretaker on Gaiman’s eighty acre estate; Gaiman explicitly wielded his control over her continued access to housing in their relationship, telling her “I like our trade. You take care of me and I’ll take care of you.” Another he assaulted while she was at his house working as a babysitter—her first time meeting him, although she’d been previously employed as a babysitter by his estranged wife—pressuring her to take a bath in his garden and then joining her in the tub and anally penetrating her; she was never paid for the work until after she agreed to sign a non-disclosure agreement barring her from discussing his behavior. In perhaps the most grotesque instance, one victim remembers him explicitly telling her that “I’m a very wealthy man, and I’m used to getting what I want.” It feels at times like a bad parody of L. Ron Hubbard—as if Gaiman were simply trying to be the most cartoonishly abusive rich man it was possible to be. 

And if American Gods does not clearly mark the line between Gaiman as an adulterous rake who slept with fans and Gaiman as a violent sexual sadist, it does mark a significant turning point in his ability to say shit like that. More interestingly, however, it marks a clear dividing line in Gaiman’s writing. Up through American Gods he demonstrates aesthetic ambition. Throughout Sandman he challenged readers, withholding easy pleasures in favor of unfamiliar and potentially alienating directions. In both Neverwhere and American Gods he is plainly going all out, cramming in good ideas, making every effort to ensure that the story is not merely enjoyable but an outright classic. And in his collaborations with McKean he plainly aimed for outright highbrow respectability. 

But as soon as he reached the career summit of American Gods and was unquestionably a bestselling and famous author he not only seems to have embarked upon a spree of abusing that position, all traces of adventurousness departed his work. The next novel he wrote, Anansi Boys, was a lightly comedic sequel to American Gods focusing on the titular West African trickster god, followed by a young adult novel whose premise—a young boy adopted by the ghosts in a graveyard—feels like the sort of thing a generative AI would come up with if asked to write a Neil Gaiman story. He wrote a screenplay, which Dave McKean brought his all to the task of directing and designing, but which was never anything more than a cut rate Labyrinth knockoff. He wrote a handful more comics, but these were cash-ins on his existing reputation—a pair of Sandman nostalgia volumes called Endless Nights and Sandman: Overture (the latter managing to take two years for six issues, none of them interesting except for the art by J.H. Williams) and a pair of series for Marvel Comics that demonstrated no ambitions beyond allowing Marvel to advertise that Neil Gaiman was working for them. Beyond that his output consisted of things like a series of throwaway picture books about a sneezing panda, a book of plot summaries of Norse mythology, and a pair of episodes of Doctor Who, the good one of which was heavily rewritten by the showrunner. (Reputedly he pitched ideas for a third, none of which were workable, before getting frustrated and starting a conversation with his own hand about how “the nasty man won’t commission my scripts.”) There are a bare handful of exceptions, most notably The Ocean at the End of the Lane, the closest Gaiman ever came to grappling with his Scientology background through means other than sexual assault, but for the most part the latter portion of Gaiman’s career consisted of timid attempts to cater to his existing fanbase and maintain his status as a famous author; eventually he settled into a career of overseeing television adaptations of his earlier work, having already cashed in on them a second time by having P. Craig Russell (or, in the case of Neverwhere, Glenn Fabry) adapt them to comics.

It is a sobering cautionary tale. It is not, obviously, that the magics being wielded are intrinsically tainted by their fleeting association with L. Ron Hubbard any more than they are by their far more substantial association with the only mildly less abusive Aleister Crowley. But their power is, as Morrison attests and Moore demonstrates, vaster even than nuclear arsenals. Used well they can reshape reality, defy death, and wage spiritual war for the very soul of Albion itself; used carelessly, they can leave you a burnt-out hack who rapes his fans.

This is the thing that Aristotle knew
The single thing that brings all crashing down
That spreads the mortal plague around the town
Laws that apply no matter what you do
No matter all your virtue. It is pride
To think yourself exception, that your sin
The cuddled little vice you keep within
Will not corrode and everything will slide
Collapse like card house fall like dominoes
Endless slow motion of stern nemesis
Takes everything away and leaves you this
Regret for one first thing you poorly chose
Before. Not seen your sad friends turn their face
Your books and deeds slow line by line erase

-Roz Kaveney, untitled 2024 poem

Comments

Sean Dillon

That was a killer last line.

weronika mamuna

"Chris Bachalo, who returned to draw the second Death miniseries." – part of the sentence missing

Andy

I think you’re gonna get a Hugo for this.

Nathanael T. Booth

Much lower in importance than a lot of the things discussed here, but I read *American Gods* in grad school and felt generally let down by it except for the second act detour to the small town. This is probably because I was working with small town fiction, but I still think about that section occasionally.

David Gerard

jesus fuck el, i think you landed this

Thomas Tyrrell

Fun to see your own 'late Gaiman' theory given a good kicking in the final paragraphs. Who would have guessed it in the relative innocence of those Matt Smith Eruditorum days? Understandable you don't have space to discuss the Mike Carey spin-off, given the greatly truncated scope of the Gaiman epilogue. I do find it a fascinatingly conflicted text, doomed to follow the fate of its own title character in rebelling against, yet never superseding its patriarchal precursor. And finally facing the ignominious fate of being rebooted into oblivion and superseded by a novelty cop show.

HARNAIK KAHLON

Yes, you stuck the landing. Devastating and brutal, like the subject himself.

Richard Lyth

This was an incredible piece of work. Great that people are finally being honest about Gaiman's post-Sandman career, after many years of reading rave reviews for books which are mid at best. I always thought his short stories were much stronger than his novels, but I'm not planning to reread them any time soon.

James Burt

That was an incredible piece of writing.

Lester Xell

Had the shock of my life when I tried to find out if there was more to that poem, googled "Roz Kaveney" + poem line and the first result was gaiman's tumblr blog promoting her ...

Alex Watts

I subscribed to the Patreon to read your treatment of Gaiman in light of what we've learned over the last year, and especially since the article dropped, and it utterly surpassed even my high expectations. Properly remarkable, revealing work, and exactly the right balance of reading the texts in light of his biography without falling into looking for 'clues' about his true character and abuses. I think the journalism around his abuse (especially the big, detailed article that really brought the story into the public eye) has been pretty good, but I've found a lot of the secondary reporting, comment and debate quite thin and frustrating and this is a huge and welcome corrective.

Alex Watts

I know it's eccentric, but I've long preferred Mike Carey's Lucifer to the Sandman mothership. I'm not trying to be (or perhaps able to be) anything like detached or objective about it, but Lucifer is the one I found myself, wondering "what is this weird, fascinating thing" on the shelves of the library. It's sort of impossible to discover Gaiman like that these days. And I will hold that it's more coherent as a 75 issue series, structurally and artistically, its core cast of characters given better stories and with less tendency to direction less whimsy.

Alex Watts

Looking back at this comment...the journalism has been "pretty good" in the sense that it's been fearless and thorough, gave its sources the security to talk on the record, carefully demarcated BDSM practices from Gaiman's use of the terminology in his abuse, and explored the notion of generational cycles of abuse from his own childhood without letting him off the hook for the actions he's taken. "Pretty good" journalism that is a harrowing read.