El: The Kindly Ones (Patreon)
Content
One more chunk after this. It will, I suspect, be a big one.
----
This was not a small ask, and indeed The Kindly Ones is not a small arc, spanning fully thirteen issues. And its heft was far from the only imposing thing about it. By Gaiman’s own admission, he “knew the entire storyline would end up being collected in book form” and so “chose to pace the story in a way that would work perfectly for a book–but that would not work very well for a monthly comic.” Adding to this, he abandoned his usual practice of making sure to “attempt to reorient the reader at the beginning of each issue or to periodically reintroduce various characters.” All of this meant that the arc was, at least when it was coming out, quite divisive.
Much of this been rectified with age, once the book was collected in the trade paperback format Gaiman was in reality writing for. But even there the book has a certain austere and alienating quality to it. This is down to Gaiman’s choice of artists for the arc, Marc Hempel. This was a deep cut choice to say the least—Hempel had a smattering of credits to his name, and was probably best known for drawing Breathtaker, a deeply idiosyncratic noir miniseries published by DC in 1990 and reprinted in trade by Vertigo a few months into the Kindly Ones, or perhaps for Gregory, his even more idiosyncratic black comedy about a triangle-headed child in a mental institution. It was, to put it mildly, not a choice made with an eye towards populism.
Gaiman’s justification for this choice was that “The Kindly Ones is about shadows and shapes, form and fire. I therefore wanted someone with a simple, lucid style.” And it’s true that Hempel is a very clear artist, in part because he’s a comparatively minimalist one. But his style is sharply angular and expressionist—at once cartoony and like a stained glass window. Hempel also involved himself heavily in the coloring—colorist Daniel Vozzo recalls that he “was literally on the phone with him for every issue” to discuss what he wanted. The result was that much of the coloring was done in large single color blocks, with relatively few gradients, further enhancing the sense of austerity in the art and making the arc seem off-putting and challenging.
But this was by and large for the good. For all that Gaiman got considerable mileage out of his big populist moves like Season of Mists and Brief Lives, much of what made Sandman work was the fact that Gaiman was also willing to go in more alienating and challenging directions, doing things like “24 Hours,” The Doll’s House, and A Game of You. The only way its denouement had any chance of success was if it continued with this sense of confident ambition instead of the coasting victory lap that had been Worlds’ End. A challenging arc with a radical art style that unapologetically made demands of its readers was very much what the book needed.
Not everything about The Kindly Ones was so offputting, but it has a habit of managing to make even its populist moves somewhat austere and unapproachable. Much of its vast length is simply because Gaiman goes to such lengths to bring back past characters. Some of these are obvious—one could safely have predicted that most of the Endless would be making a reappearance, although Delirium’s lengthy subplot about looking for Barnabas, her missing dog gifted to her by Destruction at the end of Brief Lives, is perhaps rather more sizeable than one might have expected, and feels like a fairly straightforward reaction to her popularity following that arc. But reappearances by Lucifer, Hob Gadling, Alex Burgess, Thessaly, Titania, and the Corinthian were all, to varying degrees, more of a surprise. Most of these characters can fairly be described as fan favourites, but cramming them all in necessarily slowed things down. Gaiman, defending the arc against criticisms of its digressions, sniffed hat he “found that very weird, because there aren’t any digressions; every panel in the Kindly Ones is plot, moving the story towards its inevitable ending.” But this is, to put it mildly, hard to credit. The most obvious counterexample comes in the form of Rose Walker, the protagonist of The Doll’s House, who has a major subplot running through the latter two thirds of the arc. This plot certainly starts adjacent to the main plot, but it quickly veers off into its own thing with no real impact on the main plot, and continues taking up a substantial page count even as the arc approaches its conclusion.
But it would be strange, in many ways, if The Kindly Ones were anything other than decadent. It’s been suggested that Gaiman originally intended the arc to run six issues, but this is hard to believe. For one, the actual length sets the series up to end cleanly at issue #75—a nice tidy milestone akin to how Brief Lives wrapped in issue #49 so that “Ramadan” could happen. For another, it’s just absurd to imagine that the big tragic finale of Sandman would take place in an arc shorter than The Doll’s House. This was a series that had built its name and reputation on mythological grandeur. There was only one way it was going to go out.
Similarly, while Rose Walker and Lucifer might have been mildly unexpected returns, Sandman’s resolution was always going to be backwards looking. Gaiman had committed the story to being a tragedy, which structurally necessitates past decisions coming back to haunt. And while Dream’s killing of Orpheus is a key inciting incident, in that it means that the eponymous Furies can punish him, it is not ultimately the decision that most proves his undoing. That goes back to The Doll’s House, and the long simmering thread of Lyta Hall and her dream-gestated child Daniel. This, after a couple pages of the Fates offering ominous prophecy laced with metafictional commentary, is where the story begins. Its inciting incident comes when Daniel is kidnapped while Lyta takes a rare solo trip out of the house (Rose turns out to have been the babysitter on duty, which is her entrance into the story), sending Lyta into a dissociative spiral which, after she’s informed that the police have recovered Daniel’s badly burnt body, takes on mystical and visionary characteristics. Whilst wandering the streets in a strange waking dream (a sequence Gaiman takes particular pride in, describing how Lyta is “eating one of the Golden Apples of the Hesperides, and in the next panel we see her sitting behind a Dumpster [sic] eating a pale, rotting apple. In each case, these parallel events are happening simultaneously—both of the views being presented are true. By presenting that idea visually, I thought we did something very special”) she eventually meets the Furies, who she sets upon Dream.
The jaws of this trap close with meticulous slowness, however. The Furies are not set upon Dream until the end of the seventh issue—the rough halfway point of the arc—and their assault is a slow one. It’s not until Dream has to leave the Dreaming after being summoned to Faerie by Nuala, who leaves his service early in the arc, but to whom he promises that he will come and offer a boon if she calls, that his situation actually becomes wholly untenable, and even then there’s three more issues before his actual death.
All of this unfolded over eighteen months, from December 1993 all the way to May 1995, and much else happened over that time, not least including several other Gaiman projects. He penned three issues for the short-lived Marvel Music imprint, writing a comic adaptation of Alice Cooper’s concept album The Last Temptation, along with a three issue miniseries featuring the character Angela who he had created for Todd McFarlane’s Spawn in 1993, and who, improbably, would end up being a key factor in the eventual sorting of the rights around Miracleman. His most significant work of the period, however, came in the form of a standalone graphic novel for Vertigo that he did with Dave McKean entitled Mr. Punch, or, more properly, The Tragical Comedy or Comical Tragedy of Mr. Punch.
This was an overt follow-up to Violent Cases. Where its first page opened with a flash back to when its narrator was four, Mr. Punch opens with a description of how “My grandfather Arthur once took me fishing. I was seven.” But from this first page it’s also clear that much has changed since that earlier volume. Where Violent Cases began with an intricate thirty-five panel grid of monochromatic lines, Mr. Punch opens with a nearly full page image of a proscenium arch that McKean has rendered primarily out of photographs of physical objects. A gaping mask at the top has lilies sprouting out of its top, while the top-right of the arch is adorned with the slightly corroded dial of an old grocer’s scale, while the top-left has a weathered image of a moon onto which McKean has digitally inserted a human eye to unsettling effect. The curtain is closed on one side, but hooked open on the other, revealing an expanse of pure blackness on the actual stage set. It’s a vastly more opulent visual than anything in Violent Cases, harkening back to the early Sandman covers in its sense of unsettling scale and photographic vividness.
McKean in fact uses an elaborate visual language for the comic. As the narrator explains, he quickly grew bored, and began to wander the beach where he discovered a small tent featuring a Punch and Judy show. These scenes of the narrator on the beach are rendered in a more abstracted style—full color, and with distorted and out of focus photographs providing some of the backgrounds, but with the actual people rendered in ink, drawn in a lightly cubist style. But once the narrator arrives at the Punch and Judy show the photographic style returns—McKean has fashioned actual Punch and Judy puppets and photographed them in various poses to depict the show. The result is that the Punch and Judy world feels more real and vivid than the narrator’s actual childhood memories.
This persistent symbolic parallel narrative speaks to Gaiman’s growth as a writer as well. Describing the book, he noted that “it’s as If I was trying to do Violent Cases with the knowledge that I’ve accumulated in the six years since then—and that’s been six solid years of writing fiction.” And Punch and Judy provides ample fodder for that—a bit of British cultural detritus that was already fusty and old in the UK, and borderline inscrutable (without actually being unheard of) to Americans. The show is a descendent of the commedia dell’arte with the typical British spin of a beloved villain—the same cultural tension that Moore exploited in V for Vendetta. Its plot sees Mr. Punch murder his child, then his wife Judy, and then ascend his way through a policeman, a judge, and finally the devil himself in a blur of ostentatious comic violence. As with the best of classic British children’s media, it’s plainly horrible, and McKean’s rendering of it as a series of hyper-real grotesque terrors looming over childhood is entirely apt.
As with Violent Cases, the narrative is not quite autobiography—Gaiman describes it as “an autobiography full of lies. It is unreliable autobiography, thronged by analogs of my family. Here’s a thing that really did happen to me; here’s a thing that should have happened to me if things had happened to me the way things were in the story; here’s something that didn’t actually happen at the time I say it did—it was a family legend that happened 15 years earlier but I’ve moved it up. All that kind of stuff.” The story focuses on his paternal grandfather, who in later life was a successful grocery owner, but who had, years before Gaiman’s birth, operated an amusement park in Portsmouth. This was one of the things Gaiman moved forward, setting the entire story around this and a macabre drama of half-known relatives and half-glimpsed violence, the details of which are deliberately hazy in the comic and, given that the entire setting around his grandfather’s amusement park is fictionalized, clearly not actual features of his childhood. Scientology, of course, does not come up.
But if the precise events are not true, the underlying landscape plainly is. The climax of Mr. Punch is an act of violence witnessed in shadow—McKean portrays it as a hand-drawn narrator peeking under a photographed swath of burlap, upon which silhouettes are cast—a Punch and Judy show with shadow puppets. And there is no serious question that this captured the emotional reality of Gaiman’s childhood. Perhaps it was poor Johannes Scheepers. Perhaps it was some other incident the echoes of which didn’t reach the public record. Perhaps it had nothing to do with Scientology except inasmuch as abusive men rarely limit their behavior to a single area. More likely it wasn’t a single incident so much as the basic character of growing up as a scion of Scientology.
Mr. Punch ends with the narrator, an adult now, visiting the annual May Fayre and Puppet Festival in the garden of St. Paul’s. A vendor offers him the opportunity to try out a Mr. Punch puppet for himself. (Interestingly, this puppet is rendered in ink, as opposed to photographed.) The narrator considers. “I almost put it on,” he says. “It would have whispered its secrets to me, explained my childhood, explained my life…” But instead he flees, stopping briefly by one of the many Punch and Judy shows, which is reaching its conclusion as Mr. Punch slays the devil. “HOORAY! HOORAY” the puppet shouts, rendered in disturbing, fractured closeup. “THE DEVIL IS DEAD!” Now everybody is free to do whatever they wish!” The narrator moves on. “I left the churchyard then, shivering in spite of the May sunshine, and went about my life.”
Gaiman wrote Mr. Punch some time in the vicinity of 1992—he discusses having gone through two drafts already in an interview in the January 1993 issue of The Comics Journal. McKean, meanwhile, recalls the first draft having been “written at a difficult time in Neil’s private life.” Again, it’s difficult to discern exactly what this refers to, but it’s striking that it is the same period in which he made his move to the United States, at once putting distance between himself and his family and enmeshing himself further in Scientology via his wife—a situation hinted at in the text when the narrator offers the cryptic aside “I am lonely now and very far from home.” Whatever shadows had haunted his childhood, they plainly loomed still, no less terrifying for the passage of time.
Dave McKean followed Mr. Punch with the design work for the Vertigo Tarot, one of the most unusual projects to emerge out of Karen Berger’s imprint. Gaiman takes credit for first suggesting the idea, saying that it was an occasional theme of fan letters, but the project was spearheaded by Sharon Kattuah, who, as Gaiman puts it, went “into high, dark places [to] persuade some very skeptical people in suits that a Vertigo Tarot really would be a cool, practical idea, and really, people honestly would buy it.” Kattuah, Gaiman, and Berger convened in the fall of 1993 along with Rachel Pollack, one of Gaiman’s mentors, to start figuring out how to do the deck.
That Pollack would be involved was in many ways inevitable. She was at the time writing Doom Patrol following Grant Morrison’s landmark run on the title, and was well-regarded as a fantasy novelist, most significantly at the time for her 1988 novel Unquenchable Fire, which won the Arthur C. Clarke award. But Pollack was always a polymath, and her best known work was on the Tarot, most obviously Seventy-Eight Keys of Wisdom, first published in 1980, and one of the landmark surveys of the subject. With her involvement the project instantly shifted from a chintzy comic book tie-in to a project with serious heft and credibility.
This was further increased by the decision to have Dave McKean do the art for the cards. Pollack had considered working with McKean on a Tarot previously, only to end up creating the resultant deck, the Shining Woman Tarot, on her own, but her recollection on how he came to be involved in the Vertigo Tarot was that “Neil recruited Dave, I guess?” Pollack, Gaiman, Berger, and Kattuah spent the weekend deciding how the twenty-two major arcana would be handled and what Vertigo characters they’d represent (Gaiman recalls that “We all immediately agreed that John Constantine was the Fool. After that our opinions were spirited and varied…” although there’s another card it’s difficult to imagine there was much argument about), and sent that along to McKean, along with some information from Pollack on the basic meanings of the minor arcana, and he proceeded to get to work, with Pollack returning at the end to write the guidebook.
In terms of how it introduces the deck at large, Pollack’s guidebook amounts to a slimmed down version of Seventy-Eight Keys to Wisdom—both open with an account of the Tarot’s history as a game, make much of the Hanged Man’s beatific expression, offers a brief account of the Kabbalistic parallels of the Tarot, drawing a link between the four suits and court cards and the Tetragrammaton, then acknowledge the clearly constructed nature of these links before pivoting to Pollack’s preferred understanding of the Tarot as a set of symbolic archetypes. It’s not a complete overlap—the Vertigo Tarot book contains a riff on Tarot and comics that is original to it—but she sticks to her distinctive choice of structure for understanding the deck, most especially her division of the Major Arcana into three groups of seven cards (with the Fool standing outside the system).
When it comes to the descriptions of individual cards, things are more of a mixed bag. In some places the guidebook sticks closely to Seventy-Eight Keys to Wisdom—virtually everything in her account of the Moon, for instance, can be found in her earlier book, right down to her comment that “Many emergency room nurses and doctors maintain that they see more violence, accidents, and suicides during the full Moon” and a concluding pivot away from the more unsettling readings with the suggestion that one not resist the card’s influence. Elsewhere, however, she finds herself departing from her earlier work, sometimes quite significantly. These departures generally have one of two causes.
The first of these is simply Dave McKean’s often astonishing artwork, which at times makes major departures from traditional Tarot iconography. McKean’s Ten of Swords, for instance, completely abandons the Rider-Waite-Smith image of a corpse with ten swords sticking out of its back, in keeping with Crowley’s naming of the card “Ruin.” Pollack’s interpretation of this in Seventy-Eight Keys to Wisdom is subtle—she notes that “It takes only one sword to kill someone. The ten swords int he man’s body, even including one in his ear, suggest hysteria,” and notes that the card’s dark sky gives way to sunlight on the horizon, suggesting that “The situation is not so bad as it looks.” But McKean’s art has none of the underlying imagery—his card features features an out of focus face, eyes closed, and ten swords arranged above his head, all pointing upwards, and thus posing no threat. The imagery more closely resembles the traditional Four of Swords (which McKean, correspondingly, takes a somewhat more sinister approach to). Pollack, accordingly, treats the card as being about a dreamer creating a “universe of thought,” and offers an interpretation with no resemblance to the standard occult one. While this may pose a challenge to people seeking to use the deck as a traditional Kabbalistic Tarot, it correspondingly helps the deck stand out from the dozen others in most Tarot afficionados’ collections, and fulfills the basic iconoclastic promise of setting a startlingly innovative artist like Dave McKean upon the task of designing a deck.
The second reason Pollack has to depart from her standard interpretations is unique to the deck’s Major Arcana, which is that the basic premise of the Vertigo Tarot requires those cards to be based on characters from the line. Pollack does not let this fact keep her from taking the cards seriously—her interpretation of Justice, for instance offers a nuanced and clever analysis of the way in which the notion of justice has changed between the 1930s, when its subject Wesley Dodds was first developed, and the 1990s when he had been revived by Matt Wagner and Steven T. Seagle, and on the way in which Dodds’ iconic gas mask complicates the card’s traditional emphasis on observation and discernment. Similarly, it’s still Dave McKean art, and so the cards in question are still vibrant and suggestive (and that’s when McKean is actually coherently drawing the character requested in the first place, which is decidedly not always true; one would be hard pressed, for example, to say exactly which part of his design for the World is meant to be Swamp Thing).
Nevertheless, the fact remains that this is a Tarot deck in which the Major Arcana are comic book characters, which is in several regards unfortunate. For one thing, it makes the deck a strangely dated thing—one card, the Chariot, is based on Peter Milligan’s Enigma, a comic that’s since moved with Karen Berger to be kept in print by Dark Horse. Even beyond that, characters like Chantinelle and Tali from Garth Ennis’s Hellblazer run or the Tower of Babel as depicted in Rachel Pollack’s Doom Patrol arc “The Teiresias Wars” were simply not parts of the Vertigo line that retained cultural cache in the decades since the deck’s printing. For another, largely more significant thing, it’s just very silly. There are undoubtedly people who legitimately think the Tarot would be improved if the Hermit were the Phantom Stranger, but it’s hard to imagine why one would ever want to get a reading from them.
There is, however, one card that transcends the goofiness inherent in the premise to offer something with meaningful appeal—the card whose assignation was surely even more straightforward than that of the Fool, for the simple reason that it shares its name with the most iconic and popular character in the Vertigo line. It is not, of course, that putting Death on the Death card is less silly than making Brother Power the Geek into the Emperor. There is always going to be something slightly tawdry about taking a complicated set of mystical symbols and slapping a “Vertigo and all other characters, the distinctive likenesses thereof and related indicia are trademarks of DC Comics” notice on it. But the fact remains that Gaiman’s Death is a significant new perspective on the concept itself. Having that perspective reflected in a Tarot deck has merit, just as McKean’s at times radical reworkings of the Minor Arcana do. And while any Tarot deck could slap a cute goth girl on its Death card without requiring a note that “Sandman characters created by Neil Gaiman, Sam Keith, Mike Dringenberg,” everyone would recognize this as the knockoff that it is. McKean’s version, which sees Death peering out of a deep black hole, the image of a ribcage ominously superimposed on her, largely reduces the comic book elements to her basic signifiers—the makeup around her one wholly visible eye and her ankh, the only thing that meaningfully distinguishes her black tank from the darkness that surrounds her. It’s a tasteful execution of a card that only something called the Vertigo Tarot could ever do.
Ironically, for all that Pollack has to spend a lot of time distinguishing between the traditional “mysterious and terrifying” portrayal of Death and the “intimacy and playfulness” of the Vertigo one, nothing about this especially requires her to rework the underlying meaning of the card. Her section on it in Seventy-Eight Degrees of Wisdom pivots on the claim that “Contrary to what many people believe the card of Death does not actually refer to a transformation” while her Vertigo Tarot one instead has to note that “Contrary to Hollywood movies, Death in the Tarot does not actually predict anyone dying,” but she arrives at the same place—“the end, or death, of some old way of life which has grown meaningless” in favor of “a time of change.”
This also proves to be the major theme of The Kindly Ones. Dream is not ultimately killed by the Kindly Ones. As they rip the Dreaming apart, Death comes to visit him. They talk for a bit—Dream manifests a loaf of bread for her to throw at him, though she declines. Then she orders the Kindly Ones to cease their threats and leave, which they do. She tells Dream to give her his hand, there’s a flash of light, and that’s that. This, interestingly, only marks the halfway point of the final issue of The Kindly Ones. The remainder of the issue is spent in a series of brief scenes checking in on the arc’s secondary characters—Nuala, Delirum, Lucifer, and Rose. There’s a scene in which Alex Burgess finally wakes up, and one where Lyta wakes up in Thessaly’s apartment and is told to run, as “lots of people are going to want to hurt you or kill you for what you’ve done. Including me.”
But then the comic returns to the Dreaming, with a wide shot of Dream’s castle that, over a page, pulls in on a single illuminated window in which Daniel sits, playing with a green stone. Morpheus had called for this stone to be brought to him shortly before he journeyed out to the solitary outcropping where he met with his sister. The stone, he explained to Matthew at the start of the penultimate issue, is “one of the twelve Dreamstones,” along with the stone that sustained Barbie’s dreamworld back in A Game of You and the ruby that provided much of the plot back in Preludes and Nocturnes. And then he gave it to Daniel with a cryptic comment that he and the child “have spoken.” As the arc closes, the stone morphs in Daniel’s hand into a necklace, while Daniel’s hand changes from an ordinary child’s hand to an alabaster white one with long, spindly fingers. The hands attach the pendant around their neck, and Daniel stands revealed as a new version of Dream, his body and clothes all stark white, and his speech rendered in the same lettering style as Morpheus, only now black on white instead of reversed.
Gaiman leaves an unusual amount of ambiguity around key aspects of this. He does not, most obviously, delve into the metaphysics of exactly what it means that Dream has died and come back in this new form. As he puts it in the narration of the next issue, “there are some powers that no one, not even the Endless, seeks to inquire into too deeply.” More practically, however, there are a number of ambiguities around Daniel’s kidnapping. This turns out to be the work of Loki and Puck, but they in turn are revealed to be working for an unknown third party, the identity of whom is never actually revealed, although Puck’s declaration, when asked about it, that he “could answer you endlessly” is suggestive. There is similarly much to suggest that Dream is more aware of the big picture than the actual plot might suggest. He spends the first few issues of the arc recreating the Corinthian, who he immediately sends along with Matthew to find and retrieve Daniel, who Puck and Loki did not actually kill, but instead began ritually burning the mortality out of. Little is made of this, but it’s clear that Dream knows Daniel has been taken, and in fact knows he’s going to be taken, as his recreation of the Corinthian begins just before the kidnapping. Multiple characters remark on his actions as well—Odin, who visits Dream to scold him about freeing Loki back in Season of Mists, muses whether he’s “a spider who’s spun a web of cunning and deceit and now waits patiently for his prey to come to him” or “a deer, frozen by the light of a hunter’s flame as disaster comes toward you,” while Death accuses him of being devious, saying that “the only reason you’ve got yourself into this mess is because this is where you wanted to be,” to which Dream admits that he “had imagined that I would be able to keep events here in check,” suggesting that it was but a couple of stray misfortunes that doomed him. And Lucien, in the next arc, comments to Matthew that Dream “did a little more than let it happen.” The implication of all of this is clear—that Morpheus’s death and transformation into Daniel was something he actively planned.
In this, Sandman’s form and function aligned. Gaiman was an attentive student of Moore, and understood the magic that he had worked. In some ways he understood it better than Moore, who had been caught flatfooted by the consequences of penning Watchmen and found himself reeling in their aftermath. Not so Gaiman. Indeed, many of those consequences were for him the point of the exercise. His needs in writing Sandman were always brutally simple: to escape the reach of his abusive upbringing. In that pursuit fame, like money, was a tool—a blunt instrument of power. The Church of Scientology had both, and Gaiman needed his own.
It is easy to accuse this of being cold-hearted or cynical. Certainly it lacks the high-minded grandeur of ending the Cold War, although it’s not as though Moore realized that was the magic he was working. Nor is it anything like the battle for the soul of the twenty-first century that was already unfolding by the time Sandman concluded. There’s something unpleasant about taking the not entirely wanted side effects of becoming a great magus and making them into the explicit goal. But then, there’s something unpleasant about child abuse too. The scale and horror of what Gaiman was fleeing is clear. One can hardly blame him for his priorities, nor for the cynical efficiency with which he approached them.
And so Sandman concludes with the very act it was intended to bring about. For all that Gaiman is coy about the metaphysics of the Endless, he cannot avoid offering some explanations of what, exactly, Morpheus’s death and rebirth as Daniel entails. It is clear that Daniel maintains some continuity of memory with Morpheus—he tells Matthew that “you were my friend,” and that “I have existed since the beginning of time. This is a true thing. I am older than worlds and suns and gods.” And yet it’s equally clear that there’s a disjunct between them—he acknowledges that when he meets his siblings following his funeral that it will be for the first time. The clearest explanation is offered by Abel, to Cain’s predictable fury—that what died was a “point of view.” But this phrase has considerable nuance when talking about a prince of stories. It is perhaps more accurate to say that what died was a way of telling a story—an identity and an understanding of what that story was.
This is the magic Gaiman sought in Sandman. The man who wrote that first issue, with all its cruel fathers and terrible secrets, was not the man who wrote the death of Morpheus. The man who created Death was not the man who wielded such star power that DC Comics would yield to his wishes and end a landmark series, leaving characters they unambiguously owned fallow and giving him a veto over their future use. Sandman was a tool to end the story of a desperate abuse survivor who grabbed at a lifeline and begin the one of Neil Gaiman, internationally famous author.
It was, unfortunately, a tragedy.