Penn: Morning Album Reviews — the Mountain Goats (Finale Part one, day seven) (Patreon)
Content
1/9 The Mountain Goats’ 2005 The Sunset Tree
This record is actually a double returning character. Not only have we seen the Mountain Goats before, we’ve seen the producer as well, as curated by Alex a couple weeks ago. He gave me John Vanderslice’s 2004 record, Cellar Door. I loved the record, of course, and declared it perfect for cozy paranoia, noting that there's no surprise that he produced my favorite Mountain Goats record. John Darnielle is no stranger to comfort in the uncomfortable.
This, it turns out, is not my favorite Mountain Goats record—a judgement I smugly assumed I’d have no reason to ever clarify. Vanderslice produced this one, yes, but the year before he also produced We Shall All Be Healed. Which is in no way to say I don’t love this record. This is solidly the era of Mountain Goats I know best, instead of an album about his misspent youth with methamphetamines—a topic I have no personal grounding in—it’s him doing childhood abuse and domestic violence in that raw way that Darnielle does everything.
The record, per the liner notes, was “made possible by” his step father, who had passed that year with Darnielle kindly saying “may the peace which eluded you in life be yours now,” before dedicating it to victims of abuse stuck in homes with their abusers:
“you are going to make it out of there alive
you will live to tell your story
never lose hope”
Writing this now, I’m struck by that. I think about my own father, whose death I will surely be informed of some day. Perhaps I’ll cry, suddenly feeling years of pain and a longing for a father I’ve not had since I was six that I’d long assumed I’d sorted out. Perhaps I’ll be angry anew: how dare that man invade my life again, and with grief of all things. Perhaps I’ll write my own kind of Sunset Tree, telling stories that veer from Jimmy Buffett records (“Delaney Talks to Statues,” was the one he used to say reminded him of me. See, it’s a song about an imaginative little girl, adored by her father—Shells sink, dreams float, and all that. When he was chastising me for that very same behavior, he’d call it being in “la la land”) to him picking a thing to bully me about for weeks or months on end as I increasingly broke down whenever I saw him. (“Am I pissing you off?” he’d taunt, having slipped a note out of my bag once in which I wrote that he, in fact, was. Oh, but he’s just teasing. He wants you to tease back.)
In the last verse of the last song on the album, “Pale Green Things,” he describes the call that set this album into shape:
My sister called at 3 AM
Just last December
She told me how you’d died at last
At last
“At last,” you know?
Perfect for: maybe it’s just a bit too close to home to be my favorite
Finale Part 1, ranked solely on whim:
Radiohead, OK Computer
the B-52s, Cosmic Thing
the Mars Volta, De-Loused in the Comatorium
Merzbow, Scene
the Mountain Goats, The Sunset Tree
Aerosmith, Rocks
Shania Twain, Come On Over