Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

A Complete Unknown, 2024 film

A Complete Unknown is nominally a film about the early years of the career of Bob Dylan. It follows him from his first steps into the New York folk scene of 1961, to his infamous electric act on the Newport Folk Festival stage in 1965. I suspect it fails rather spectacularly at selling that story, much less the emotional content of why playing rock and roll on a folk stage was such a big deal in that place and in that time, if you come to Bob Dylan yourself as a complete unknown. It certainly fails at the task of getting to know Bob Dylan as a character, except in as much as “entirely too cool and detached” does seem to be Bob Dylan’s actual character. It makes him an odd pick for a film, if you assume the film is about storytelling. As Baez points out… Dylan is kindof an asshole, (“Yeah, I guess,” he replies.)  But for all that it is a film about him, it is never that concerned with Dylan as a man.

A Complete Unknown both opens and closes with Woodie Guthrie’s music playing on the radio. Guthrie spent the sixties in the hospital with ALS. It is where Dylan will meet him and Seeger in an early, often mirrored scene. In fact, Guthrie is the reason Dylan has come in the first place. He’s written a song for the man, and has travelled all this way to play it for him. Regardless, he’s still caught flatfooted when Guthrie, who as the business card he hands Dylan proclaims is “not dead yet,” taps Dylan’s guitar case. He wants to hear what the boy can do.

“Are you shy?” Seeger asks him. “Not usually,” Dylan admits, and performs the song like he came to do. The camera is just as interested in Seeger and Guthrie watching Dylan play as it is in Dylan himself. Likewise, it spends some time carefully framing Guthrie’s comatose roommate as if he were also part of Dylan’s audience. Whenever we go back to that hospital room later, he is always there, not quite watching in distinct parallel to Guthrie, who is able to do little else, and so watches everything quite carefully. (I’m very impressed by the amount of acting Scoot McNairy is able to do with little more than his eyes. Also loved him in Halt and Catch Fire–as an actor, he’s well equipped to a particular kind of oddness, and manages to bring a lot of it to the role.)

Seeger, (whose first scene is attempting and failing to convince a judge that “This Land is Your Land,” was not, in fact, unpatriotic, only to play it to the waiting crowd gathered outside of the courthouse instead) had been playing Guthrie’s “So Long, It’s Been Good to Know Yuh,” to the man when Dylan wanders into the ward. We get another moment here, before Dylan has so much as touched a guitar, to spy on this intimate moment between friends; the camera tucked behind Dylan so we can see him take the scene in.

This has another parallel in the last scene—this film loves some poetic repetition. Dylan would become close with Guthrie across the movie, and in real life for that matter, visiting the man in the hospital often. I said the film ended on a Guthrie song, right?  It’s the same song, and the same hospital room, only this time it’s Dylan playing it for him on the radio, accompanying it on Guthrie’s own harmonica. Dylan stops. No, Guthrie does not want his harmonica back. The men look at each other for quite a while,  sharing a silent moment, before we watch Guthrie as he watches Dylan drive off into the credits. 

“So long. 
Been Good to know yuh.”

It’s that silent moment that forms the emotional heart of that last scene, and it’s the most intimate reflection of its theme the film has to offer. This is not so much a movie about Bob Dylan, as it is one about watching Bob Dylan.

No, really, from the very opening, this film is all about the gaze. Although, at first It shows you how it is going to work by following Pete Seeger from his audience with the judge, to the cameras and crowd outside the courtroom, and finally then to his dying friend and our main character. Seeger takes young Dylan home after that hospital visit, and the film stops being about watching Pete Seeger, when, he next morning, Dylan is poking at a song he’s writing (“Girl from the North Country,” which I believe to be a bit ahistorical, but not by more than a year) as Seeger’s wife and children mill about breakfast. Behind Dylan, and out of focus, you see it is Seeger’s turn to watch Dylan play unaware, as he wanders out with his toothbrush still in hand.

Dylan stops. “That’s all I’ve got so far,” he tells the family, finally turning to acknowledge the Seegers watching him. One little girl cheerily replies that it’s a good start. And it is.

Later you see him picking up a girlfriend, Sylvie Russo-playing the approximate role of Suze Rotolo, Dylan’s girlfriend of the early sixties, who Dylan requested not be named in the film. Sylvie is an artist herself, and clearly cares a lot for Dylan, but is not a terribly fleshed out character. I would make the argument that mostly she exists, as does most of the film’s cast, to look at things, but she also provides a nice framing for the theme, and is the character that gets to foreshadow Dylan’s emotional arc.

They are on a date, early in their acquaintance, and Sylvie is talking to Dylan about a story where someone is going out and finding herself. Dylan scoffs, saying that she didn’t find herself, she became something different—she became “what she wanted to be in that moment.” It is a sentiment that will haunt Dylan through the film until a culminating moment where we watch him, his by-then iconic sunglasses off, playing his acoustic guitar to himself in a mirror. This is the other scene in the film that really exemplifies its theme. For the first time he is his own audience. He holds his gaze, and we watch as he decides in that moment who he wants to be in the film’s final act: Bob Dylan.

It’s also laced throughout the visuals in the film. A shot of a camera watching Dylan on stage will also be layered with the audience, and a camera man or three, and a look to the side of the stage where the drama is being played out in eye line. But it’s not just camera work and audiences this film is willing to use to make its point. There’s also a bromance conducted over mutual fan mail, and radios casting a neighborhood in shared anxiety as news of the war plays out every window. Hell, Dylan’s lies about his past are even exposed by a photo album. And you can’t forget the near back to back scenes of Dylan being photographed after he became famous. First, where he has Sylvie pose for a photograph with him (Suze Rotolo would famously be photographed with Dylan for the cover of his ‘63 Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan.) followed closely by a scene on a different photo shoot in which a terse “You’re in the shot, sweetheart,” is thrown at her after Dylan leaves the room.

Once, a giant spotlight pins Dylan in place as he plays “The Times They Are A-Changin’” on the ‘64 Newport Folk Festival stage. Seeger makes puppy dog eyes at Dylan; his dream of bringing folk to the people is coming true right before his eyes. Everyone is watching. Cameras flash. Out in the crowd, the only person whose eyes are not on Dylan are Sylvie’s disapproving sister, who is watching her sister’s heart break yet again.

But the times were, in fact, a-changin’, and it turns out change is very scary. The title drop, a line from “Like A Rolling Stone,” is set to boos and trash being thrown at Dylan and his band for daring to bring an electric act to that same folk festival in ‘65. “Judas,” they cry, (again, a touch ahistorically, the Judas heckling incident seems to come from Manchester, but print the legend.) and which of his colleagues, as well as who, what, and even IF the crowd was booing is debated to any extent—but feathers were definitely ruffled, and all eyes were on Bob Dylan.

I don’t know, but if only someone had already made that grumpy penguin “Now I will not do the thing,” meme, perhaps all this could have been avoided.

—Penn

El, meanwhile, would like to offer a review of the Joan Baez biopic being shown in the same theater and the same time as the film I just discussed:

The fundamental folly of a biopic, of course, is that Joan Baez’s voice is simply unreplicable. You can’t do it justice because an actor cannot possibly capture the actual thing she did. In this regard alone Baez is nearly outshone by her costar, Timothée Chalamet’s unshakably driven performance of Robert Zimmerman in the moments that he creates Bob Dylan being aided by the fact that passable Dylans are a dime a dozen. Monica Barbaro does as well as can be done—which is ironically quite well on the Dylan songs, but “Silver Dagger” thoroughly finds her out. But this is the axis upon which she is set up to fail. On all others she fulfills the most fundamental requirement of playing Joan Baez: she rules.

Her introduction, with the camera nailed firmly behind her, the world existing entirely in her point of view, exemplifies the basic theory of the character. Whatever else might be going on in the film, Barbaro simply never allows for the possibility that she is not in a Joan Baez film. She is imperious as she maneuvers through the space around this vague outside context problem for the world, never seriously considering any approach other than loving and learning from him. Peter Yarrow doesn’t get an arc across the final Newport concert in which he processes Dylan’s new musical direction and realizes what she’ll have to do next, turning towards her labelmate Peter Schickele to create a musical direction every bit as distinctive as Dylan’s goofy little whistle.

Many reviews of the film have focused on Chalamet’s performance and the portrait it paints of Dylan, generally coming up empty. This is perhaps unsurprising from people who mistake the film for a Dylan biopic, but in fact the film’s thesis about Dylan is straightforward. He is a man driven by a single motivation, which is the task of being Bob Dylan. The same is true of Baez. In one sense, she starts the film knowing how to perform this job. She’s already an absolute star, her records flying off the shelf while Dylan’s misguided first effort sits untouched. Nowhere in the film does she doubt or second guess herself. And yet she clearly finds some lesson in Dylan. As Penn notes, many of her shots in the film are of her watching him, understanding who and what he is.

Mostly that’s, never mind kind of, an absolutely glorious asshole. Their second meet-cute, in the shellshocked daze of the Cuban Missile Crisis as the simmering fury of “Masters of War” swells, is incendiary, as is Baez’s slowly dawning realization of the other woman the next morning. Barbaro’s inability to channel an authentic Baez performance gets put instead acting with her singing, as when she conducts a methodical assault on “Blowin’ in the Wind”’s possible harmonies, an exploration of all that she can do in and around this song while Chalamet quacks stoically through his recitation, all the issues that their relationship would eventually have in perfect miniature. But at no point in the performance is Baez anything other than an absolute queen. Similarly, consider her intrusion into the closing credits, first sounding tentative as she pokes around the edges of the song, then finally stepping confidently into the mix. It’s her film; Bobby’s just the songwriter.

—El Sandifer

1/10 The Glitch Mob’s 2018 See Without Eyes

The Glitch Mob is an act that does what it says on the tin, and largely they have identified themselves most adamantly with their live act, and rightly so. Their shows focus on improvisation, the trio playing off of each other and triggering their samples in real time for the audience. It’s a point of pride for the band, and they even created “The Blade,” a housing for lights and their instruments as “a set piece and a visual element,” calling it “just a functional thing that lets us play our music the way we want to play our music.” Interviews with the band will often focus on their technology and live shows.

Mostly, though, they just kinda want to do their thing. The deep list of collaborators you’ll find on a Glitch Mob record are their friends, or close acquaintances, saying that they just like to let it all happen naturally. They wouldn’t, say, phone up Thom Yorke for a collab, but if he happened to wander by with an idea, they’d explore it, says Ooah.

“Part of our ethos is to ride the line between Dance music and listening music, right?” explains Justin Boreta, who has since left the band. “Clearly there’s a core of Hip-Hop, there’s a core of experimental electronic music – Jungle, Drum & Bass, Dubstep is all part of there – but really the listening and the emotion is really at the core of it…we’re dealing stuff in life: we have heartbreak, we have friends that have passed, we have our fans that really write heavy notes, and that’s sort of what we’re processing and working through – in our own dealings with life, that’s what comes through.” 

“We hope people connect with the music and feel something their own way, like the comfort looking at the stars,” says Boreta. As someone who’s agoraphobic—yeah, that checks out. I’d not call this comforting music, but it’s certainly large. Throw on a pair of headphones, and let the bass sweep you out into space.

But more than that, See Without Eyes is a clear attempt from the band to grow into something new without letting go of the energy and force they’d amassed—an album intended to be “a full body listening experience,” in record form, as well as something they could rock live.

Perfect for: “We’re just out there makin’ Glitch Mob music” -edIT

Comments

James Burt

I can't believe this is the first time I've been told about the Glitch Mob. But what a great record!