Penn: Morning Album Reviews — Eluveitie (Finale Part two, day three) (Patreon)
Content
1/12 Eluveitie’s 2009 Evocation I: The Arcane Dominion
What even is metal, anyway? It’s a neat question, because you categorically can’t ask metal fans for an answer. Hop onto any metal-based subreddit, and you’ll soon discover that literally nothing is metal by consensus. And certainly nothing with a front-woman—not that they’re sexist or anything. (In fact there are whole sub-genres of metal seemingly designed to silo the women off into something the real metalheads won’t have to see.)
I was introduced to Eluveitie (pronounced “el-VAY-tee,” and not something more like “el LOO vee tay,” because I got that wrong for ages) in college. In fact, I saw them live around then, or just after—although, I will admit, while I’ve been to a lot of metal shows, I’ve only ever been a casual metal fan. Unless you’ve got topless vikings (Týr), a head banging woman with miles of hair and a corset (Leaves Eyes), or a literal faerie playing flute on stage, they tend to run together a bit. Wait… were these the guys with the faerie? It would fit… no… no, that was Metsatoll. But like I said, they run together a bit. (Which is not remotely to say that all metal music is the same—its that all metal concerts are. Fair, really, since they’re all having to prove at all times that they are For Real Definitely Metal 🤘)
But this band is neat, whether or not it’s metal enough for BeelzeButthole88. They’re usually somewhere on the folk to death metal spectrum (any two genres are a spectrum, if you squint) with a death growl man, heavy electric guitar and bass, and a drummer with approximately five arms and legs, in addition to their hurdy gurdy, flute, and melodic vocalist (who does a perfectly good growl of her own, when called upon). These are in my opinion well integrated (although I’m sure Mr. Butthole88 will disagree), throwing little Celtic interludes in where a guitar solo might otherwise be, or perhaps there’s just a flute filling in some empty space. The two paradigms respond to each other and build out to that massive, interconnected assault of sound that characterizes metal.
Evocation, though, is doing something different. They’d just put out a couple of records and really given people something to expect, so as my boy Neil Young will tell you, that’s the best time to run straight into a ditch. The record’s (and, frankly the band’s) secret weapon is Anna Murphy—the aforementioned hurdy gurdy player/melodic vocalist.
She and the guitarist fuck off in 2016 in solidarity with the drummer, who was fired without “the opportunity to debate” the decision, over matters Murphy would describe as being of “grave personal conflict.” (“My corresponding proposal was declined,” she says. Instead, they go and create Cellar Darling, which is, on quick inspection, both more and less deniably metal than Eluveitie.) This sparks the shuffle of band members you’d expect, as “metal hurdy gurdy player” is, it turns out, a specialist role.
But back in ‘09, Murphy steps into the lead role for Evocation I. (There is a sequel, but it is released post-flounce, and has nothing like the energy of the first, although if you like one the other will probably also do you.) It’s an acoustic concept album “setting pure gaulish mythology into music,” per Glanzmann (the growler), and in fact the lyrics are in Gaulish, based, in part, on archeological finds. (That metal fans will complain about what language the lyrics are growled in will never cease to amuse me.)
So is it metal? I think so. It certainly has metal. Take, for instance, “Voveso in Mori.” It’s got a straightforward prog structure, a bassline that could come straight off of Metallica’s Black Album, and a slow, methodical build to a guitar solo. Except that solo is given, dizzyingly, to a soft spanish guitar. Then, while you’re still off balance, they give you a three minute instrumental number showcasing the Hurdy Gurdy at full blast.
The track right before both of those is traditional—around a third of the album is—set to a slight spooky angle. Glanzmann makes a cameo in the middle, but you’d be hard pressed to call the tracks like this metal songs. But does every song on a metal album need to be metal? They certainly add to the atmosphere the band is going for here, and they make something truly interesting with what they’ve got.
Perfect for: the Sexy Goth Renaissance Faire