Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

1/13 Dave Matthews Band’s 1994 Under the Table and Dreaming

I know every note, beat, and lyric on this record. I was eleven when Crash came out, and I’d liked it a lot. It opens strong with “So Much to Say,” an extremely fun jazz rock piece whose chorus is about the most fun to sing along to thing imaginable. The record goes straight from that literal bop to “Two Step,” which opens on a simple but enchanting guitar line that explodes out into something with a rhythm and structure unlike anything else I knew before remembering that it was a rock record 6 minutes later. By the time the record’s lukewarm title track crashes into you, it’s more than earned the good will it needs. Throw in the grime-coated guitar line on “Lie in Our Graves” and I was hooked.

I got it at the same time as Matchbox Twenty’s new record, Yourself or Someone Like You. Both would spend more time in my new 3 disc CD player than out of it, making the two artists a lot more connected in my mind than I believe they entirely warrant. (Although, I suspect the picks do say a fair amount about me in that era.)

When I next had a few bucks, and saw Under the Table and Dreaming in a store, I went home with it. I remember listening to it, sat on the floor in front of my CD player, tethered to it by the headphone cable—one ear out so that I could hear if anyone was coming, of course. Maybe I’d have my homework spread out and abandoned on the carpet in front of me, but all of my attention was on the music.

At first, it was just to sing along. I was a singer, and more to the point a future trans man, so his vocal range was intoxicating. More than that, he’s fun to sing with. Between his languid, and swinging rhythmic choices (“Would you SAY you’re feeling LOW and SO/A GOOD IDEA would be to get-it-off-your mind?” or the staccato emphasis that lands on nearly every word on the verses of “Ants Marching.”) and lyrics that were just poetic enough to spark intrigue (“My head won’t leave my head alone/And I don’t believe it will/Until I’m dead and gone,” is quite the lyric for a kid with OCD, you know?), I was into this record. 

This was, as I mentioned, the CD era, so albums nearly always came with lyric booklets. I really miss those things—there’s a real sensual loss to the physical artifacts of music, even if the greater access streaming allows is a good thing. But this was the mid 90s, so I’d open up the jewel case and follow along with my eyes as I listened. I was also, notably, an undiagnosed dyslexic, and I suspect that practice was a fair amount of my unconsciously learning the workarounds and coping mechanisms I’d use to keep that nice and undiagnosed. The result was, however, a deep, intentional listening process that really informed my relationship to music, and media at large.

But as time went on and I learned the lyrics well enough that they just sort of emanated from within me when the record was playing without my conscious input; the practice developed into something more meditative. I’d turn the lights off, press play, and lay down on the carpet—still with the headphones. Always with the headphones. I had a pretty nice-for-an-eleven-year-old pair of speakers, but I liked the privacy and containment that headphones provided. In the dark, my whole world could be the music, and the whole world was mine.

I won’t pretend that this is the only record I did this with, because it clearly wasn’t going to be. But it was the first, and it never really fell out of rotation—there’s simply so much to listen to. Maybe this time I’m paying attention to the bouncing, changing rhythm of the drums, in concert with the lyrics and bass. Another time it’s the guitar, and how it laces into the melody and dances around the bass. Or I’m listening to the horns or strings, or thinking about the shape the music is taking. And, of course, the bass. (Y’all want to guess what my first instrument was?)

The record ends with “#34,” an instrumental piece that only has lyrics when they play it live. It, on my CD, came after about a year of silence after the last vocal track, in the form of blank tracks 12 through, predictably, 33. It opens delicately, but it ramps up to something with such clear jazz implications—the horn, at one point, seeming to break out of it’s confinement, throwing a curse to the wind as it escapes. Fuck me, I loved it.

Today, having not really thought about them much in the intervening years (Some illusions you just don’t want to risk breaking, you know?) I learned that Dave Matthews Band is decidedly uncool. Even retrospectives that are nominally on the side of the band have qualifying statements (“The Dave Matthews Band seemed lame from the start.” lol, thanks Pitchfork). But I stand by it. This record taught me how to listen to music. It’s layered, interestingly composed jazz and blues adjacent rock and roll, and it’s 

Perfect for: listening to in the dark

Comments

Shannon Shea

I didn’t love where Dave Matthews Band went later, but those first few albums were magic. My kid really liked this album for a while when he was little because of the swings on the album cover. I was more than happy to oblige.