Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Alright! As I mentioned in the poll that went up yesterday, I have the Halfway Broken entry ready today...and its nearly 11,000 words. Meaning that, despite not getting its update on the 1st, it still got pretty close to its usual total for the month. A bit over two thirds of the usual, at least.

I can also now say that I've read the Manga all the way through the end of the Whole Cake Arc. Since I'd already watched (to much suffering and frustration) most of Wano via the Anime, I really only need to read the Levely Arc, after which I'll be into the Final Saga. Honestly, while the Manga was better than the Anime, I can't say I was overly impressed with any of the story arcs. Zhou was the closest to actually good, and the shortest unfortunately. Dressarosa was okay, mostly because it was the only place where the training the crew did in the timeskip actually seemed to matter.

Punk Hazard and Wholecake Island were both fucking awful, as far as I'm concerned. I hate, absolutely loathe, lazy ass writing by authors who constantly depict a protagonist getting beat like a drum despite supposedly training to get good. It's particularly common in shonen, and annoys the hell out of me. You have a character train their ass off and get good, then immediately have them stomped all over and only pull last-minute victories by durability and grit. Because, apparently, that's the only thing that matters. Not skill, or smarts, or preparation, or literally anything else. Just slamming your face into the wall over and over until the wall breaks.

Ugh.

Anyway, enough about that! Wholecake Island did at least give me a basic feel for Jinbe. I'm honestly still not sure he's going to join the crew, as I'm not convinced he's honestly a great fit for the way I've shifted Luffy and Co around. But I can at least write him successfully now, I think. Which is good since, while he only spoke a little bit in this set of chapters, he'll play an important role in next month's releases. For reasons that should be obvious once you've read this releases chapters ;-).

Enough jabbering from me, though! As always, the new content is attached to this post in the various different formats, and new master files with the entire story will be added to the Pinned Post shortly. Author's notes will follow in the comments when I have a few moments to actually write them :-). Enjoy more of One Piece: Halfway Broken!

Files

Comments

Novus's Fanfiction Works

This comment is for author's notes! Beware spoilers! And if you want to comment on one of them, please do so in a separate comment NOT nested here, in order to keep these orderly!

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Chapter 107 A/N 1: Whew. This was a long chapter with a lot of back-and-forth. Hopefully, the political/alliance discussion wasn't too boring. I tried not to drag it out, but it kinda needed to happen, in order to outline just how much each side was potentially getting out of the deal.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Chapter 108 A/N 1: So, Luffy's little scene with Handcock? That would likely have been where I tagged in a slow-burn romantic buildup if she'd won in the relationship polls. I decided to keep the basic idea in, even though she didn't, since it still helps explain her attitude toward Luffy and the crew turning positive enough to be useful later. It's...a LITTLE heavy handed, I admit, so hopefully it didn't come off too unbelievable. A/N 2: Anyone that doesn't want a lap pillow from Robin is clearly a monster. This I stand by with all the seriousness of a thousand fluffy puppies. Which, admittedly, isn't very serious, but the cute level is super dangerous!

Orchamus

Excellent job Vivi!! 💯👏🏼 Proves her bonafides yet again as an excellent negotiator. What a champ 🏆 Also super stoked Hancock and her sisters got helped with their marks, that a seriously big deal for them and I'm very happy to have read it. Thanks for your hard work as always! 🙏🏼

WhatAFungi

My text to speech I’m using keeps correcting Alabasta to Alabama and it makes me chuckle every time. Great chapter drop! Can’t wait to see where this shin-dig goes

twilightwanderer

Thanks for the update. Not much to comment on here, just solid foundation-building. I am impressed that you went from Punk Hazard through the end of Whole Cake in 2 weeks on top of writing 25k+ words and whatever else you have going on. I do tend to agree with you regarding power scaling and stubborn underdog protagonists. I understand where it can come from (pacing, mostly), and I can usually deal with it if it's not egregious, but it's not my favorite trope, and I much prefer competent characters intelligently applying narratively developed skills/powers.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Yeah, these weren't the most glamorous chapters, but as you said its foundational setup for future stuff. Thankfully, the next set will be more action oriented :-). Underdog protagonists are fine...for a while. Once they go through a major training arc and Git Gud, as the internet would say, THAT is when I get annoyed that they still get their ass beat like a drum as if nothing changed.

Camille

Thanks for the update! As previous commenters have already stated, this was solid foundation-building. It was nice to see how each different participant of the summit could contribute differently. Vivi being a boss-level negotiator and other powerful parties beginning to understand how dangerous Alabasta is planning on becoming was awesome too. I feel the same with them being incredibly impressed by the Strawhats thanks to the many avantages Luffy has revealed, and the fact that they must have realised that he is still keeping a lot of other important cards hidden was really satisfying. Just one thought, I would have liked to see Robin (Yamato too) to be show-business to contribute more to the summit. I know that they probably did during the week of negotiations, but from what we have been shown, they were quite useless to the initial discussion. This is strange considering Luffy really fought to have both of them present in addition to Vivi. I understand why you didn’t, since that discussion didn’t really involve them, but it did feel a bit jarring since Luffy had emphasised their importance previously, so not having proof of that felt strange when reading those chapters. But anyway, that’s just a little nitpick that you can disregard if you want. Nice characterisation of Jimbe! I would love to see him on the crew, but I do understand if you don’t want to go in that direction. I would just like to say that Jimbe isn’t always 100% serious, and has had some comical interactions with the Strawhats since joining in the canon manga. I’m not sure if you got to see that since I think it was mostly seen when the Strawhats arrived on Onigashima and while sailing towards Egghead. Perhaps that helps with your reservations? Lastly, are you planning on having any new crewmates post timeskip? (Apart for Jimbe if you do end up having him join up.) You obviously don’t have to answer if it’s to spoiler for you :) Thanks again for the update!

Novus's Fanfiction Works

Ugh. Yeah, I honestly wanted at least Robin to speak as well, but the truth is I was already having trouble juggling the number of speakers without things getting awkward. As well as actually including each faction naturally. I almost forgot about Sabo and Jozu on the first pass, and had to go back and alter things to include them properly. As it is, just that initial meeting drug out for over 5k words, which I was worried was going to start boring readers. So adding even more, just to get a line or two from some of the secondaries like Robin or one of Boa's sisters, ended up not being worth it. I'm sort of leaving the decision on Jinbe until after I work through their initial stop at Fishman Island to finalize the Alliance. We'll see a lot more interaction with him there, and a lot will depend on how easy or hard I find writing him. So far it was fairly easy, but he didn't speak all that much. Honestly, the only two post-timeskip crew I ever considered (aside from Jinbe) were Rebecca and Carrot. Rebecca I ultimately decided against, now that I've properly read her whole arc, as she's not really a fighter and is already kinda gotten her happy ending in canon. Carrot I was considering mostly because I had a LOT of requests for it, but didn't know much about her since I hadn't read/watched the arcs with her. I'm still undecided on her.

Camille

Makes sense :) For Carrot, can we maybe have Pedro instead? The Brook-Pedro duo is awesome, he is a competent guy in general, and your crew is really female heavy so adding Carrot as well would make it worse. Of course, this is all assuming that you find a solution to restore his lost lifespan via spiritual energy or something. I would also be fine with having both if you want! But if we can only have one, Pedro is definitely my no.1. We don’t see him join ever in fanfics because of his removed lifespan problem, but your AU might be able to solve that problem 🙏 Oh and were you considering Carrot/Chopper? That would be sweet actually. (Obvs no lemons but yk)

Chris7A

Good chapter! Yamato becoming an icon in Amazon lily makes so much sense!! The boa sisters getting their brand off makes it easier for them to get character development Nice! I still hope you enjoyed some of the highs of the series! Sanjis backstory and Pedro’s sacrifice! I hate punk hazard so much that I sometimes forget it exists. At least law cut a mountain to try to salvage that arc. The final arc is pretty good actually. Except a revelation that triggers me and compounds on the biggest flaw in one piece, I won’t spoil. Are you going or have watched the OPLA I personally love jinbei, but if he doesn’t join, he doesn’t. Still I hope at least a fishman or mink do join (Pedro).

Chris7A

If after whole cake you are still undecided that’s not a good sign for carrot. I was genuinely angry when carrot didn’t join. But that’s me. Good choice on Rebecca. What fanfics are you speaking of Camille? I haven’t found any of them that cover post timeskip all the way to zou. Except Coby’s choice (awesome fic btw)

Camille

Yeah I was so annoyed Carrot didn’t join after Pedro’s death :( She fit the crew so well! As for the fanfics, you’re right that they don’t cover post-timeskip. However, some time travel fics transport post timeskip characters etc., and so you see Jimbe, Yamato, Reiju, some of the Charlotte children sometimes for example. They’re not very memorable fics though so I don’t really have recommendations unfortunately. Coby’s choice is great! It’s rather frustrating that >95% of One Piece long fics don’t ever go beyond Alabasta.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

@Camille Huh, I actually hadn't considered Pedro before, simply because I literally didn't know he existed prior to my recent reading spree. He might not be a bad option, given that you're right in thinking Luffy/Kaya could probably do something about his lost lifespan. Particularly given that they've been studying Brook's Devil Fruit, which interacts with the soul similarly to Big Mom's, and has a pre-disposition towards longevity. Something to consider, at least. Though the fact that this Luffy isn't Joy Boy and isn't being loud about his desires might make it less of an obvious fit for the Minks? Hmmmm, that's something I'm going to have to consider, actually. Though I've just had an idea that might fix it. Thanks for the idea at least, we'll see how it works out :-p. As for your second comment about fanfics often dying before the timeskip. Ugh. I'm just as annoyed as you about that...buuuuutttt...I always (as a writer) understand why it happens. The closer you get to poorly-defined content, the harder things get to juggle. Since One Piece doesn't have an ENDING, it's hard to plan for certain things. Just one example from Halfway Broken itself, recent(ish) revelations in the Manga show a viable reason why Shanks might have lost his arm ON PURPOSE. But that information didn't EXISIT when I first wrote that section of the story, so I 'fixed' the ridiculousness that was him losing his arm. @Chris7A I haven't read the Levely arc yet, and I skipped around some in Wano when I covered it as, at the time, I was mostly trying to get a handle on Yamato so I could introduce her early. So I wasn't paying attention to carrot in that arc. That said, a lot of my 'undecidedness' on characters is also how hard they end up being to WRITE. I'll have a better idea with Jinbe after the next set of updates, for example, since he'll be more more heavily involved in them. If I find writing him easy, that's a strong point towards including him more, whereas if I struggle with him, he doesn't offer enough to be worth complicating the crew more. Same thing with Carrot, though I think I'd actually have a fairly easy time writing her.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

I'm glad people seem okay with the Brand removal :-). It's a BIT heavy-handed, but it's also a good way to get, as you said, character development for them. The canon method isn't viable, since Boa isn't going to fall in love with this version of Luffy. So an alternate reason for them to think positively about and grow more attached to the crew was needed. Removing the Brand is the sort of emotional kick start that can get that going. Pedro, honestly the Minks as a whole, was 100% the high point. I liked the Minks, especially Wanda, Pedro, and Carrot. Honestly, the only part of Punk Hazard I actually liked was Smoker. His actions showed a surprising amount of growth for him. Prioritizing doing good over his personal vendetta. As well as showing self-awareness that the Marines weren't always 'good.' OPLA?

Chris7A

One piece live action. It was surprisingly good. Minor problems, b it enjoyable. Raizo is safe reveal is one of my favorite moments in the series. With how you have written luffy and Yamato, I do see unrequited love from Boa developing. Because of something that gets revealed afterwards. Luffy ticks all of Hancocks boxes. Minor Spoiler Below We know it’s an affliction of the kuja to get attracted to strong men that don’t desire them. Its a thing especially with empresses.

Chris7A

Carrot shares some similarities with chopper’s personality, both being from young, isolated communities. Though she is a fighter, which I like. She might be the easiest to write. Pedro set sail to find all poneglyphs. A crew that wants to do that and go to laughtale is a perfect fit. However he might be the most difficult to write since he only appears in whole cake and zou. Jinbei is a lot like Zoro, serious and with a certain samurai honor about him. This is the opinion of someone that hasn’t written anythint in a long time. So whatever you end up doing is good! @Camille, thanks, I got excited for a second thinking I missed a good story. Oh well.

Camille

I also enjoyed OPLA! Sanji and Usopp are better than in canon which is great, and Nami and Zoro as awesome as always (Zoro’s Whiskey peak scene was insane! Nami also has better fight scenes actually). However, although Luffy is better in some ways, he is also much weaker physically, which is a bit of a problem. Also, the Loguetown execution scene is cursed… I love that OPLA isn’t afraid to kill off characters when needed. Robin and Chopper are also awesome! It’s seriously amazing how they’ve managed to bring the One Piece world to life. That’s why although there are some issues as you said, I don’t mind disregarding them in favour of appreciating what they’ve managed to accomplish. Btw what were your unexpected favourite characters this season? Mine were Dr Hiriluk (INCREDIBLE acting), and Miss Valentine and Mr.9 who were definitely better/more interesting than their canon counterparts. ——— Raise is safe reveal is SO insane, give me chills just thinking about it.

Chris7A

Dr hiruluk deserves his own category honestly. Dalton and kureha also were standouts in drum island. Brogy and Mr 3 for sure. Also loved yorki and of course smoker. As you said most of the crew nail it this season. Zoro and ussop in particular (which I think was intentional given that they suffered the most in season 1). Chopper and robin are perfection. Sanji and Nami also nail it, but they have less chances this season to show their skills. Thank god for their talk in drum, it gave them something to do. In between all the Zoro and ussop arcs. Luffy was the worst for me this time, he was the best in season 1 though. I’m confident the live action team will listen and improve all the issues we have with luffy. They listened with Zoro after all.

Dan W

“Since Boa isn’t going to fall in love with this version of Luffy” NNNOOOOOOOO!!!!

The Foreign Traveler

Glad to see that disgusting brand won’t plague the sisters any longer… Edit 1: …positive reputation with “the Whitebeard”. …positive reputation with the “Whitebeards.” Or …positive reputation with “the Whitebeard Pirates”. Edit 2: …together “than” they had… …together “that” they had… Edit 3: …as “it” hadn’t really done anything… …as “he” hadn’t really done anything… Edit 4: …likely with “Macro”… …likely with “Marco”… Edit 5: …things like “Virve Cards”. …things like “Vivre Cards”. Edit 6: …it had Vivi… …it had “been” Vivi… Edit 7: …as Alabasta, Chopper and Kaya… …as Alabasta. Chopper and Kaya…(?) Edit 8: …as he “keep”… …as he “kept”…