Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Halfway Broken - Boa Hancock Poll

  • Yes! Add Her! 208
  • No! Leave the Harem as it is! 46
  • I'm indifferent, do what you will! 95
  • 2026-06-02
  • —2026-06-17
  • 349 votes
{'title': 'Halfway Broken - Boa Hancock Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes! Add Her!', 'votes': 208}, {'text': 'No! Leave the Harem as it is!', 'votes': 46}, {'text': "I'm indifferent, do what you will!", 'votes': 95}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 17, 0, 29, 2, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 6, 2, 22, 12, 53, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 349}

Content

Alright folks! As I mentioned in yesterday's Halfway Broken release, I find myself seriously considering something I really didn't expect to. Specifically, expanding the harem for Halfway Broken by one more character. I genuinely did not expect Boa Hancock to click so well with my version of Luffy. Of course, back when I was thinking that, I hadn't written her yet.

Like with Sanji and Usopp, Boa's over-the-top traits in canon annoy me. Which means, like with them, I tweaked her character a little to level her out a bit, as well as give her some actual depth that Oda just never bothered with. Yes, he gave her a tragic backstory...and then that was about it. Like with many of his characters, he never really properly let her grow. (Honestly, he only seems to let villains and Robin grow. Everyone else is perpetually the same, forever).

It ended up that the version of her I created with those tweaks really clicks well with Luffy, as well as other members of the crew. Vivi in particular. To be honest, she legitimately seemed to click better with him better than any of the other girls save Nami, much to my chagrin. As such, I'm seriously considering adding her to the pairing, and want to know what you all think.

The one thing to keep in mind, is that I locked the harem at the number of girls I did for a reason. Adding Boa will slow down the story, at times, due to the need to properly develop her relationship and juggle additional crew interactions. Already, a few of the crew (such as Chopper) don't get a lot of attention. Though, at least in her case, she'll only be sometimes present, so it won't be as bad as adding someone fully to the crew.

With all of this in mind:

Do you want me to add Boa Hancock to the pairing?

Files

Comments

Starfall20

The question is does it work with the characters and the story?

Carac

NO 4 girls are enough, may be as a one night stand but that's it, the harem is big enough That's my opinion

BookDragonling

Putting an image like that on a poll about adding someone to the harem is basically asking for it to happen.

Captain2003Rex

I certainly wouldn’t be complaining about adding her, that’s for sure lol. But I also would be totally fine with not adding her, or even with her only being a one night stand, so I say do what you want to do. You’re the Author after all!

Crescent Sunrise

When you give the option, the horny always wins. XD

swift arrow

I don't mind it slowing down the story at times it just give me more chapters to read and enjoy some stories I've read have way to fast plot lines

Orchamus

As a longer term love interest she works, she does have responsibilities of her own and while Vivi's Fruit helps she can't be full time so should be workable Up to you really. Ye or ne works for me

Ototsu_Yume

She fell for canon Luffy, it's only right that she falls for this one too. :)

Jay Emberhowl

We all know majority of us are pervs and will vote yes espeacially with image you posted, at end of day though your the author the boss the head honcho the big cheese what you decide goes

Chris7A

She doesn’t have to join. However I don’t see a scenario where she doesn’t fall for this version of luffy. In many ways he is far more appealing than canon, plus he has helped her too much. At the very least she should suffer from love sickness like the rest of the empresses. She can’t really follow the crew around though. Not with a kingdom to protect. So the relationship looks little difficult.

Novus's Fanfiction Works

*shrug* Vivi Express makes visiting her, or her visiting them, fairly easy. That said, any relationship would likely be a bit slower to get serious, due to only periodic contact.

BomeranG

You had me at "Adding Boa will slow down the story".

Camille

If it were anyone but Boa Hancock I would have said hell no... But she just fits way too well with this Luffy and I've been praying for this pairing (along with Robin) since the beginning of this story so yes please!

Dickevin

As others have said before, thé décision is ultimately yours and I would respect it. But personnaly, I am all for adding Hancock to thé harem, first because I do enjoy Reading about the lemon, dates and interaction surrounding all of this. But also because since it could lead to interesting subjects, like the fact that Hancock know that they would not bé able to go togethers, so they would have to actually say goodbye, perhaps asking to Luffy to let her with a little "gift" in case he didn't return. Thé fact that due to Hancock past, she is probably a very good seductress, but will probably bé a mess if she has to actually be in a relationship, due to her never having to actually think to enter into a lovers relationship, with thé vulnerabilty and emmotionnal storm it implies (which could actually be a reason to make her behave, at least a little l'île she do in cannon toward Luffy. She don't know how to handle something so alien to her). It could also actually lead to great character and strenght improvement in her, both because she could actually train with peoples in her levels, but also open thé possibilitie that she uncousciously stunted her own devil fruits powers due to her trauma over being a slave raised to be a living sex toy and behaviors resulting in her not being bale to easily trust and having a very manipulative way of doing things (Hancock fruit is the Love Love fruit. But what exactly is love ? Does it affect her also, meaning that it could actually stronger thé more she feel loved ? There is so much potential in there which could bé trapped, both for thé stories and lemons). Otherwise, have a nice day and good luck for the next chapters !!! :)

Novus's Fanfiction Works

??? I have to admit that I'm unsure why you would consider slowing down the story a good thing...

BomeranG

The old it's about the journey, not the destination argument. I'm perfectly happy reading random adventures and interactions of characters. Even if they don't advance the plot or the characters. It's okay to not advance the plot, give new abilities, new options, character development etc. I realize most readers (or authors) would find that boring so that's why I'm happy.

Chris7A

It’s a good story, he wants more!

Chris7A

Good point, I keep forgetting the door door fruit.