[MM#28] The Purpose of the Character Contest and Its Promotional Impact (Patreon)
Content
After the release of Mega Man, I gradually began to feel that it was starting to reach children. Thanks in part to additional shipments, its name began appearing in sales rankings in game magazines. The ranking itself was still low, but Mega Man was at least beginning to make its presence known.
As we began work on the sequel, there were many things about Mega Man that needed to be improved. Of course, this included the game system itself, but there was another problem as well: because it was still an unknown game, its level of recognition was very low.
CAPCOM was already a long-established game company with a proven track record of creating many arcade games. Because of that, bringing those games to the Famicom(NES) was the most effective approach. When such a title was released, it could be promoted with a catchphrase like, “Now you can play that arcade game at home on your TV!”
Other companies were also releasing many games based on well-known IPs such as manga and anime. Regardless of the quality of the games themselves, there were many titles that increased their sales through the power of those famous properties. In the middle of all this, Mega Man had little recognition, both as a character and as an action game. The initial production run had also been small, so we still needed to make many more children aware of it.
The Idea of a Character Contest
The idea of holding an open call for character designs came to me while I was casually looking through a fashion magazine. I was looking at an advertisement for a beautiful wristwatch with chic colors when I remembered a job from my days in advertising, when I had been asked to design a watch face.
It was not an expensive watch. It was a low-priced, unbranded wristwatch aimed at young people, the kind that was sold in the trendy variety shops of the time.
Most of my work usually involved things like pasting phototypeset text onto printing layouts or carrying finished artwork to the printing company. So the work of actually drawing and designing the watch faces was something I enjoyed very much.
Other than the shape and size, I was free to draw whatever I wanted. Even within the fixed concept of a wristwatch, there was room to create freely. A city at night, a blue sky and ocean, a forest filled with sunlight filtering through the trees... I found it fascinating to think about what kind of design would suit each situation, and I kept drawing day and night.
In the end, only two or three of my designs were selected from among many. Even so, seeing the finished products displayed in stores gave me a feeling I had never experienced before.
Just as with Mega Man1, the advertising schedule for Mega Man2 before its release was limited to around three one-page advertisements in game magazines. Advertising was normally left to outside agencies, but because I had worked in advertising myself, I understood how important it was. So I began thinking about what kind of message we should put into those precious full-page ads.
Unlike the action games of that time, Mega Man had a major feature: the stage boss characters were shown to the player from the very beginning. They also appeared on the package design and on the stage select screen. I began considering an advertising design that would make use of this feature.
For example, one idea was to put the boss characters front and center, explaining their characteristics, the effects of their weapons, and what those weapons would become when Mega Man acquired them.
Then I remembered my experience designing watch faces.
What kind of watch would it become? What kind of person would wear it? ...There was something uniquely satisfying about seeing something I had designed become an actual product. I wanted children to experience that same excitement. Those thoughts came together and led to the idea of asking children to design the boss enemies themselves.
This was another project that could only be realized because of Mega Man's unique game system. It was the moment when the idea of putting the boss enemies at the forefront became connected with the promotional power of advertising.
What could I do to make children happy? Even if I could not truly understand how they felt, I was convinced that if I created something based on experiences that had stayed with me and moments that had made me happy, those feelings would surely be conveyed to them.
And if the thoughts and ideas of those children could become part of a game called Mega Man, I hoped that it might grow into a great wave and spread even further.
With that, the concept for the full-page advertisement was decided. Dr.Wily would make a direct appeal to children, asking them to design his new enemies. It was exactly the kind of promotion that suited Mega Man.
Most game advertisements focused on the player character—the hero—or on the game's world. This was the complete opposite approach. But there was also a synergistic effect: the enemy's attack power and methods of attack would eventually become Mega Man's weapons.
The problem was the time required to carry it out and create everything. I was about to insert such a large-scale event into a development schedule that was already pushed to its absolute limit. And because it was deeply connected to the contents of the game itself, we would also have to reconsider the production schedule.
Whenever I come up with an idea, this is what always happens. ...
INA (development name: INAFKING), who was in charge of the boss enemies, widened his eyes with an expression that seemed to say, “You can't be serious!”
Even though it was my own idea, it was beginning to look like an outrageous production schedule. Still, it seemed that the additional work would mostly fall on me rather than increasing everyone else's workload.
This absurd schedule would continue to grow as more and more tasks piled up. And because the development deadline was fixed, it meant we would have to handle several different tasks simultaneously. It was becoming an emergency situation.
Children's Ideas and Designs
The idea for the character contest was approved immediately and announced in a full-page advertisement in a game magazine. I created the layout for the advertisement and then asked a design company to produce it. The design placed Dr.Wily, Mega Man's enemy, prominently in the center as he called out directly to the children.
The illustration of Dr.Wily was drawn especially for this advertisement by INA (development name: INAFKING).
By inviting children to submit character ideas, they would begin to feel that they were taking part in the creation of Mega Man. The ideas for the boss enemies were important not only for the designs of the characters themselves, but also because they would influence the image of Mega Man's weapons and even the stages themselves.
Children who had played Mega Man1 already understood the characters' styles, settings, and abilities, so they generally had a shared understanding of what we were looking for. Because of that, a simple explanation—“Please draw your character and weapon idea on a postcard and send it to us.”—was all we needed.
This was actually quite important. There were very few cases of children misunderstanding the requirements or submitting something completely different, so the work involved in managing the contest did not become unnecessarily complicated. You could say that this was only possible because Mega Man's world and image had already been firmly established.
Before long, children's designs began arriving every day.
On busy days, more than 200 postcards were sent from the general affairs department to the development room. Together with the other busy staff members, I picked them up one by one and looked through them.
Everyone already had their own work to do, and finding the time was not easy. But more than that, we were deeply moved by the pictures the children had drawn.
For us, spending every day facing computer monitors inside our small workspaces, those moments were a tremendous source of encouragement.
Character Design and Its Effects
Now, from this point on, the story may be a little disappointing for those children at the time who came up with their designs full of hope and submitted them with excitement. However, the purpose of the character contest was to raise awareness of Mega Man, so I would like to talk about the actual effects of the character contest and how it contributed to the development of the game.
When I came up with this idea, I felt that it could have several different benefits.
A Wealth of Diverse Ideas
One of the major purposes of this character contest was, of course, to make use of the ideas created by children. But there was actually something else I was hoping for as well.
I saw it as a way to compensate for our extremely short development schedule.
It may sound contradictory, but when you think about it carefully, it was actually a very rational approach. It would allow us to incorporate better designs while making the most effective use of the situation we were in. Given the circumstances of this development, it was an ideal event.
If we had not held the contest, INA would have had to come up with all of the character designs himself. Just as we had done with Mega Man1, I would check the pixel designs INA created, and from there we would begin adjusting our ideas to match.
“Make it a little simpler.”
“Make the attack method easier to understand from the design.”
“Make it look like it can move quickly.”
...I would make changes and corrections like that.
But that kind of process was no longer possible.
We were in a situation where even the smaller enemies needed to be turned into pixel designs directly from my rough sketches in order to keep up with the required speed. The boss enemies were no exception.
Of course, I could not simply draw rough designs for such important boss enemies in the design documents. Under those circumstances, even someone as talented as INA would have found it difficult to create eight excellent and appealing designs that could be approved in a single attempt.
And if even one of them had to be redone, the entire project would inevitably fall behind schedule.
There was no room to go back.
So I decided that we would have children come up with strong character designs and weapon concepts, and treat those ideas as rough designs that INA would then complete and refine.
INA was only one person. No matter how talented he was, he was still only one person. It would have been impossible for him to come up with 200 different designs every single day.
But we had a huge number of ideas in our hands.
Many of them could be adopted with almost no changes at all.
That's right. The character contest was the only way we could overcome this difficult situation: improving the quality of the game while also making absolutely sure that development did not fall behind schedule.
Some people thought it was strange to hold an event like this when we were already so busy. But I dismissed those concerns. Every day, as I held the children's designs in my hands, my heart was filled with gratitude.
The children's ideas were extremely diverse and bold. There were many ideas that we would never have thought of ourselves.
However, I had also made several preparations to ensure that the development process would move forward smoothly.
I had already begun creating the images and level designs for the first half of the stages.
While I was expecting a wide variety of ideas from the children, I also predicted that there would be a certain amount of overlap. They were not professional designers. So even if there was a great variety of ideas, it was only natural to assume that many similar ones would be submitted.
This was both one of the strengths and one of the weaknesses of an open character contest.
Because this was the first time we had opened character design submissions to the public, I assumed that the entries would consist of both a wide variety of ideas and a large accumulation of similar ones. From among those similar ideas, I planned to select the ones that stood out the most.
And what kind of ideas would overlap?
The answer was the enemies from Mega Man1.
Boss enemies have certain attributes. Those attributes determine the nature of their weapons, which in turn shape the image of the stage itself.
I assumed that many of the overlapping ideas would have attributes similar to those of the boss enemies in Mega Man1.
Scissors, ice, bombs, fire, electricity, and rocks.
Assuming that multiple enemy ideas with similar attributes would be submitted, I created eight images from them:
Cutting, water, bombs, fire, light, leaves, wind, and speed.
Ideally, we should have adopted ideas that were completely different from those in the previous game. But that would have required more time, more people, and more technical resources.
For this contest, our highest priorities were improving the quality of the game, quickly establishing the necessary images, and immediately turning them into enemies.
Even if we received an extraordinary idea that no one had ever thought of before, we simply did not have the time to design and create a stage that fully made use of its unique characteristics.
That is why, in terms of their overall impression, the boss enemies ended up having attributes somewhat similar to those in Mega Man1.
This was actually the part that worried me the most.
I kept wondering what we would do if we received nothing but completely unexpected ideas and none that fit the boss attributes for which we had already begun development.
Fortunately, just as I had expected, many overlapping designs began to arrive.
This was the kind of tightrope walk we were constantly performing during development.
The eight images also had to work together with the structure of their respective stages.
For that reason, I had already begun the level designs for each stage even before the character designs for the smaller enemies were completed.
On paper, I was working with nothing more than square shapes with no visual identity yet, assigning them behaviors such as firing bullets, lying in wait, or charging directly at the player.
With a stopwatch in one hand, I used those plans to determine the movement speed of each character and the speed of its projectiles as they would actually move on the screen.
When I created the enemy movements for Mega Man1, I also avoided vague instructions such as, “Move quickly and jump when the player gets close.”
Instead, I wrote everything in numerical specifications.
For example:
“Move at ○ dots/seconds, and when the distance to the player becomes ○ dots or less, jump toward the player by ○ dots in height and ○ dots in distance.”
By doing this, there were very few misunderstandings between myself and the programmers.
Most of the adjustments could be completed simply by changing the numerical values a few times.
This was also one of the ways we saved time.
Creating Buzz and Raising Awareness Through Word of Mouth
There was another reason why I chose from among the many overlapping and similar ideas rather than focusing only on unusual or completely unique ones.
It was the spread of information.
In those days, before the Internet existed, game magazines were virtually the only source of information for children.
Under those circumstances, I wanted to spread information not only through the power of advertising, but through other methods as well.
One of those methods was word of mouth.
The announcement of the contest in a game magazine and the fact that children would see it and talk about it was one effect in itself.
But I was also hoping that the locations where the selected children lived would leave a strong impression.
Ideally, I wanted selected children to be spread throughout the entire country, from Hokkaido to Okinawa.
Most children would not be selected. That was unavoidable.
But if there was someone who had been selected in a nearby prefecture or town, I hoped that the possibility of their own ideas being chosen would feel much closer to them.
I wanted them to talk with their friends and feel that this was not some distant dream. That they, too, had truly taken part in the creation of Mega Man.
To make that possible, we needed many overlapping ideas rather than a single, completely unique one.
There might be dozens of entries based on essentially the same idea.
The designs could be different, but the weapon specifications might be almost identical. Or the concepts themselves might be the same.
From among those ideas, we selected several of the best ones.
They were all of high quality, and they also matched the images of the stages that were already being developed.
From among them, we selected one child as the official winner.
That child became the representative of all the children across different regions of Japan who had come up with the same basic idea.
There were many children who had created the ideas behind those eight boss enemies.
From among them, we chose representatives whose selection would be spread across different regions of Japan.
Of course, quality was always the highest priority.
We did not simply assign winners to different regions for the sake of regional distribution.
As a result, there was still a slight concentration in the Kanto region, where we received especially large numbers of submissions.
Even so, in making the final selections, I tried to ensure as much as possible that those selected representatives would be spread across all regions of Japan.
The character contest also included honorable mentions.
These were the children who had created ideas that were used in developing the eight boss enemies. They did not become the official representatives, but they had provided ideas that were equally strong.
Most children would not be selected. That could not be helped.
But I did not want the initiative they had shown by submitting an entry, or the time they had spent creating it, to feel as though it had been wasted.
The character contest was not only a way to create a connection with children. It was also a means of increasing its promotional impact.
I believe that we, as developers, need to think deeply about both of these things and approach the creation of games with sincerity.
(Automatic translation by AI)