Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Choices Choices Choices

  • 1 - WIDE AT CAMERA 180
  • 2 - WIDE LEFT ANGLE 174
  • 3 - WIDE AWAY FROM CAMERA 89
  • 2022-01-05
  • 443 votes
{'title': 'Choices Choices Choices', 'choices': [{'text': '1 - WIDE AT CAMERA', 'votes': 180}, {'text': '2 - WIDE LEFT ANGLE', 'votes': 174}, {'text': '3 - WIDE AWAY FROM CAMERA', 'votes': 89}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2022, 1, 5, 14, 34, 50, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 443}

Content

Friends! Make your mouse clicks and finger taps heard! I'm torn like an old sweater about these thumbnails for youtube. Help a fella out and let me know which one you like the best - thanks!

-G

Files

Comments

DnD Addict

I actually really like all of them

Christopher Watson

I feel like 2 and 3 feel more natural... so I voted accordingly.. but I think 1 might be better for the video on youtube.

Åse M Bruun Lagnestål

There’s no bad choice. I like when the clones look at each others. Picked no 2.

Angie Woollard

I like #2. Geoff 4 is still engaging with the camera but the other three are at interesting dynamic angles. The third picture is also a contender for me, but not #1 because it looks like everyone is engaged with a different camera…If that makes sense. Geoff 2 and 3 are gazing off to the left of the camera taking the photo.

Debs Badger

I like that you've consistently learned how to set up polls now. 😜 I like the left angle one, since it's different, but I don't like how piano Geoff looks in that one. Hrm.

María Gabriela

I like the third one, particularly. But any choice would work, at the end!! PS. To be fair, what a polarizing poll. 😆

Carol Franklin

Torn between 1 & 2 not that there’s anything wrong with 3! Voted for no 1. I took less time voting in our last General Election 😄🇬🇧

Jacklinka

Thumbnails set to give maximum visual information from the first sight, even when minimized for the mobile. I think the first one is more static and therefore more "readable". But I maybe would change the font to something similar without the "gaps" in letters (but still quite olde looking) for the same reason. Hope it helps and sorry to be this boring nerd 😂🐱😉

Sina Sörnsen

I like #2 best, no particular reason, it just speaks to me most

Tine

You are making these more and more difficult🤣I can see why you're torn about them. I love the font of the title!

Angelic

I like 1 and 3 the most, but there isn't a bad one!

Gretchen G

I like 2 best, and 1 is a close second. They're all good. Looking more closely though, I'm a little concerned about the placement of some of the letters in relation to the Geoffs . . . For instance, it looks like that first letter "a" is piercing your thigh. Also slightly concerned about the "d" in two of them. But overall they're all very pretty, maybe just change the font or reposition the text a bit.

Hunter

Personally I would have just thrown everyone off and posted a pic of you playing the awful piano 😂 But I’mma go number 1 😊

Jacklinka

I upvote this idea! They wouldn't know how terrible was that piano 😂 Also close-ups are always better-er 😊

Blair Toblan

The 1st one with all the Geoff's looking at the camera has a bit too much "The Geoffs are coming for you!" vibe. The last looks a bit like right Geoff has gotten bored and his attention is wandering. Go with no 2. :-)

Barbara Binney

Man, this is tough. I like the angle of #2, but I like all 4 Geoffs facing the camera in #1. I went with #1 because while the middle Geoffs in #2 and #3 are engaging with Piano Geoff, rightmost Geoff looks a little disinterested.

Sarah Reach

Picking a favorite out of these is like trying to pick my favorite song of yours (there are no bad choices - I like them all and each time I look a different one stands out as my favorite 😅)

Hunter

You think you’re getting a beautiful ballad? Nah. 😂

David K Ragsdale

In the first one, all of the Geoffs looked more cheerful and inviting. In the other two, I agree with Barbara - some Geoffs looked disinterested and a couple of them even looked a bit miffed. #1 got my vote.

Sophie Plourde

I like #1 because I like that camera angle better, and I just think it feels more like a thumbnail when you are looking at the camera, but honestly #3 would be awesome too!

Lillan Gravli

#1 looks like 4 identical copies of Geoff. The other two have more diversity to the Geoffs. In #2 none of the Geoffs look straight into my (our) eyes, but the silhouette of piano Geoff is to die for. However #3 is my favorite.

Sophie Llewellyn Smith

Because I love the way the Geoffs interact in the video, I'm going to go with #2. You can see their faces better as well. Love the font!

Gretchen G

I agree about lowering the text

Gamesz

My favorite is 2 or 3, because you connect with „yourself“, which is a nice content of the video too

Eileen Parkman

#1 seems a bit confrontational and #2 is just a bit awkward, missing the face of piano Geoff. #3 seems most pleasant, relaxed and inviting to viewer to join in listening to the song

Jacklinka

(finished to cackle) Yup, the Ballad of the Freaking Piano 😂😂😂

Jennifer L. Cramp

I like #1 best. I feel all the Geoff's seem better engaged with the audience and I prefer all of their expressions. That's my humble opinion. I'm looking forward to this premiere. Greetings from snowy Northern Virginia. 🌨️🌨️🌨️

ObscureReferenceWoman

Wow, this is hard to choose! I went with #2, but agree about lowering the text a smidge. Best dynamics. All drool-worthy, lol!

Cindy Barber

This one is a tough choice for me. I'm going to go with 2 or 3, they are the ones where the majority of the Geoff's look engaged, which makes me want to know more. 1 just feels too much like most of the Geoff's are just staring off to a specific point but with no real purpose. Which works great in a video where there is other stuff going on and you need to have somewhere to focus, but not really for a still, and Geoff 4 just looks, I guess hazy (although that one feels the most 'engaged' since he is looking directly at the camera. At least that's the feeling I'm getting)

Katie D

...you don't like to make things easy for us, do you? 😂 I voted for #1, though now I'm reconsidering my choice 🤔

Peter Gregg's Patreon Page

Number 1 is the only one where you are looking at your audience with most of the fellas. Number 2 is OUT, Geoff 4 is staring out into space, I am over here, hello!! :) Number 3 doesn't connect with the people who will see the thumbs. So that leaves number 1. That one connects (eye contact) with the folks who will see the thumbnail. It would even be better if the piano Geoff could also have looked at the potential thumb viewer and even made a face lol.

Tara Congo

Decided to go with my gut choice at a quick glance of the three and connected best with #2. So thataway I went. Edited to clarify, since I see some confusion in the comments about the poll and order of the uploaded files: by #2 I do mean the one with Thumb 2 in the name as I assumed that's how Geoff meant those to match up. Sorry Geoff, I have a feeling this poll might not have been super helpful in your decision-making!

Jill Weimer Koeninger 🐱

Notice the number of the downloaded pictures are NOT in the same order of the poll. I, personally, really LOVE the photo taken from the far left. All the Geoffs are engaged with the song and two are looking at piano Geoff, while piano Geoff is looking at the two Geoffs who are looking at him. THIS ONE is BY FAR THE VERY BEST of ALL Geoffs (HUBBA, HUBBA, HUBBA!!! - I'm sure Kathy will agree. She's one super-dee-duper, gorgeous, fantastically, blessed woman to have an equally talented handsome man by her side. Not to forget to mention having an ADORABLE and talented son as well).

Jordi S

Tough tough choice. I agree with people suggesting lowering the letters a little and also with the comment about Geoff #4 looking a little hazy. He was a little hazy in the video too at times.

Janine

Like all of them. Its a hard choice. I agree with maybe lowering the lettering a bit.

Rosie Boughen

I like the way more than one Geoff is looking in the direction of the audience (pic #1), making us the focus, rather than all of them staring at Piano Geoff. (On that note, get you a man who looks at you the way Geoff2 looks at Piano Geoff ☺️ Lol!)

Clare Corre

I'm usually of the camp that simple is better. I think #1 is the most simple and most cohesive.

Amanda Hovendon

I like the lighting in this one. In the other two, there’s extra light coming from the window behind Piano Geoff and I feel like that’s a little distracting. I love it in the video, but not so much when I’m looking at just a picture from the video. I feel like my eyes are being drawn to more than just one spot in the picture. You have the two Geoff’s looking at Piano Geoff. Then you have Piano Geoff looking at the farthest Geoff sitting in the corner. Does that make any sense?😅 Anyways I just think that’s what makes this thumbnail kind of more fun to look at🤷‍♀️

Debs Badger

I'm voting for #4, which is when Geoff takes all our comments and comes up with a different thumbnail altogether. 🤣🤣🤣

Huldra Draco

I'm sure you have noticed already, Geoff. But some of us discovered that clones #3 and #4 are saying what looks to be "cut" at around 7:15 in the preview. Just in case you hadn't noticed I thought I would let you know 😊

Dominique

I will vote for the one that is not an option! The best one for me is when you play the piano that is flat at the end of the video for us. The blue sweater you are wearing pops out a lot more and your hair is stunningly gorgeous!!!! Just my 2 cents

Rachael Heidi

I picked 1 ❤️. Just looks "right" I don't know why lol. As usual though, whatever you pick I always love. Can't wait for this one 😊.

Angie Woollard

I kinda really like the thumbnail of the Preview Screening video right below this post. 😀

Suzy Bailey

I liked them all for slightly different reasons, but decided on #2 as it's the one my eyes kept being drawn to most. I like the text but also agree that it would look better being lowered just a little!

Shirley B Karr

If the thumbs are numbered the same as the vote options, I'd go with #1 for YT, though I love the way middle clones are looking at piano Geoff in #2. And l agree about lowering the font or possibly changing it. The "a" is pinching your leg, and that's Kathy's privilege, not some random letter. Especially in #2 -- that "a" is getting a little, uh, personal there.

Shirley B Karr

I saw that too! Not gonna admit how many viewings it took to notice it, though. LOL!

Jojo Hale

I like the last option, camera straight on but the Castellucci Quadruplets all looking away/different directions.

Ilona Dever

The more Geoff's looking at me, the better!!

Hugmany Foemen

OK, as usual, I checked out the full-size versions then the thumbnail offered by hovering over the toolbar. In both I'd go for #2 as as the Geoff's are interacting, 3 with each other and 1 with us. Agree about lowering the title a smidge. Not enough to get lost in the time-stamp, but just a fraction, Maybe so the underscore bar mirrors the floor/wall joint? That gives enough dark background for the white lettering to pop without getting tangled in legs. Nice font, by the way.

Lady D Richter

I like 2. It looks like everyone is working except for far Jeff. That'd be me in choir. If the music hasn't started, I'm off in my own thoughts. Never miss my que, though!

Sarah Reach

Apparently this whole community is torn right alongside you. Usually by now there is one with a decent lead, if not a clear winner. 🤣 I eventually settled for #2 as my favorite, but I'm good with any of them.

Grim Grinning Tracy

I like #1 best with #3 in second place. In #2 you were not looking towards the camera and feels disconnected from audience.

Angie Woollard

WAIT WAIT WAIT I didn't realize the thumbnails weren't listed in 1,2,3 order! I've changed my vote to #3. I'm sure it's too late now, but...

Eileen Parkman

Geoff, I hope people are connecting the poll with the correct picture. On my phone, iPad, and laptop, the order of the thumbnails is 1,3, then 2 - people might not be reading the the names of the photos when looking at them, and simply voting as if they were in the order that are in the poll.

Karyn Morrison

Oh wow, so hard to choose. You don't like making things easy for us.

Debs Badger

I assumed the number in the poll corresponded to the number in the filename, regardless of placement.

Deanna M Coleman

I love #3, which is in the list as second. That is a little confusing to say the least.

Gary Wagner

No problem with any of them but would probably choose #3.

Amanda W

#3, I want someone to look at me the way Geoffs 2 and 3 look at Geoff number 1.

Suzy Bailey

Oooh, currently 162 votes for #1 and #2! You might have to be the tie breaker Geoff! 😉

Amanda Hovendon

I believe it’s like vote 1 goes with thumb#1. Vote 2 goes with thumb#2. Vote 3 goes with thumb#3

Amanda Hovendon

I mean that’s how I voted🤷‍♀️

Amy Cottrell

Three, Obviously But you didn't have me then, and that is an unfortunately thing But I'm here now Notes* number 3, of course But why is Far Right Geoff looking at the camera? Are you Oblivious to the Piano Man? 🤦‍♀️ 🙏 🤷‍♀️ I'll pray for you ..... We got work to do How's MY Song coming aloong

Amy Cottrell

🎶YOUR SONG🎶 ELTON JOHN 🥰 BUT ALSO MOULIN ROUGE EWAN MCGREGOR 🤩😍🥰 Nicole Kidman......🤷‍♀️🔥 Trash movie, They Did Not understand the assignment Amazing SoundTrack My boy can SING ALSO....WATCH big fish If you haven't already Do it now... Nothing matters more..... Well, maybe, SOme of the Things💞