Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi All,

I'm hoping to release a new video in under twelve hours. As usual, I'd love to get your input on title and thumbnail. I'm using a google form this time because on Patreon polls it seems like the results aren't hidden before you vote.

https://forms.gle/a3VKjTkNMrj9GhvK6

Please accept my apologies for the similarity of the options. I think we have a few good ideas but in which combination is not clear to me. I look forward to your feedback.

Best,

Derek

Files

Comments

CharlieRose

I like different thumbnails and titles i voted based on thumbnail but my favorite title has 60 days in it, sounds super impressive

Christian Leichsenring

"3D printing an entire rocket" as the title and a simple "3D printed rocket" in the thumbnail

Allan Kristensen

I didn't get my "fix" of seeing the results thus far after voting :) Also, it seems like I can vote multiple times (I did, on "Surprisingly Genius", two in total).

Michiel Stikkel

I think the “would you fly in it?” and “surprisingly genius” are to vague to get people interested. Especial with the image that is not clear on first look what it is. I notice that I often only read the title if the image grabs my attention. But that is my point of view.

Sven Mueller

I'd prefer the "3D printed rockets" thumbnail with the "60 days title". Makes _me_ much more curious and likely to watch the video than the "would you fly in it" thumbnail (not enough info/excitement to get me to read the title) or "surprisingly genius" (same). And I find printing a rocket in 60 days more interesting than "world's first X".

Rafał

I second that. Those are the two most exciting and important things about it - 3D printed rocket in 60 days. "would you fly in it" and "surprisingly genius" are more of a click baits in my opinion. But hey, the algorithm might "think" otherwise ;)

Vincent Zalzal

I find the background image of the thumbnail hard to understand, things are too small. I feel like it should be zoomed in and have fewer elements in it, or maybe be more "schematic"? Not sure... but the current image does not entice me to click, as I don't understand quickly that there is a rocket, or a 3d printer.

Quasitling

I didn’t like the image title “Would You Fly In It?” that much, but I liked it better than the others. Of the two with that image title, the text title “3D Printing an Entire Rocket In 60 Days” sounds much better than the other, maybe because “3D Printing” is more active than “3D Printed” anything. The image title “3D Printed Rockets” sounds boring to me, maybe for the same reason. And “Surprisingly Genius” is clumsy. I think the word “surprisingly” is a mouthful and “genius” is stronger without it. I just realized that all of the titles I dislike are based in adjectives rather than nouns and verbs. Isn’t cutting two thirds of the adjectives common writing advice for a reason?

marenoodles

I went with "3D Printed Rockets" for two reasons: that's the only one not blocked by the timestamp, and the other lines weren't thought-provoking for me.

Leonardo Aguiar

As a science channel that dives into maths, I wish you had given a playful title option that toys with the “additive” term from additive manufacturing. “Rockets made by adding” :0

Vishal Bondwal

My thought process: I have never heard of 3D printed rockets before, so "World's first" is kind of assumed (even if erroneously). The thumbnail clearly shows a really large cylinder, so it isn't a toy rocket. Doing an entire rocket at that scale in 60 days sounds impressive, so chose that. Aside: "Surprisingly Genius" sounds fishy grammatically.

Caleb Higginbotham

I cast my vote. Alternate idea: Thumbnail: Imagine 3D printed rockets. or (Imagine 3D Printed 🚀) Title: Unlocking the Genius Behind It. Whatever you decide, looks interesting and I can’t wait to watch it!

Patrick Kennedy

I'm sure clickbaity titles and images get more views, but they feel gross. They make me not even want to watch your videos and I know they're (generally) really good. My two cents is "3D printing an entire rocket in 60 days" and literally any more detail in the thumbnail instead of "SURPRISING" or "OMG IS IT SAFE?!?!?!?" :/

Patrick Kennedy

"WOULD YOU FLY IN IT?" uh. no? Nobody would, it's the first rocket of its kind and hasn't been flight tested, I assume, certainly not human rated. You have TEN MILLION SUBSCRIBERS you don't need to do clickbait. Stick to what got you such a huge following.

red

Watch Derek's video regarding clickbait and the YouTube algorithm and you'll understand why it is vital that he adapts to the ever-shifting requirements of the system in order to reach viewers. His approach is to create headlines and thumbnails that accurately represent the content while also creating a sense of curiosity in potential viewers, generating what he calls "legitbait"—personally, I think this is an excellent compromise in a profession that demands (and rewards) sensationalism. As a fan, I want to support him making more awesome videos, regardless of what kinds of titles and thumbnails he uses to generate awareness through the distributor.

Scott Ludwig

I always thought of clickbait as being a sensationalist title or thumbnail that leads to content of dubious value or accuracy. Veritasium doesn't have content like that.

Patrick Kennedy

His titles are clickbait. His video about clickbait is clickbait because it's just him trying to justify using clickbait. There are dozens of examples of channels that "create a sense of curiosity" that are not bait. Vox, Steve Mould, WIRED, Business Insider, NightHawkInLight, Maker's Muse, Kurzgesagt, Tech Connections, Just Have A Think, Project Farm, even CGPGrey. But titles like "Math has a fatal flaw" (It doesn't, it just can't answer all of it's own questions, that doesn't -break- math) and "The biggest myth in education" (Is it? Is it really? He doesn't attempt to demonstrate that fact, just talks about -A- myth) are clickbait. They're sensationalist and aren't really honest about their content.

Patrick Kennedy

Titles like "Math has a fatal flaw" (It doesn't, it just can't answer all of its own questions, which doesn't -break- math) and "The biggest myth in education" (Is it? Is it really? He doesn't attempt to demonstrate that fact, just talks about -A- myth, and, tbh, it would have been a better video if he just summarized the paper) are clickbait. They're sensationalist and aren't really honest about their content.