Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • ep138 final.mp3

Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Inspired by the culture’s latest cheating scandals, the girlies unpack monogamy as a social norm and explore what happens when we break the rules. They explore theories of mononormativity, investigate the psychological consequences of being cheated on, and try to answer a pressing question: why are we still attempting monogamy if people keep having affairs? Digressions include the NYC earthquake, kindhearted midwesterners, and one listener’s love of Hoop.

SOURCES:

Comments

Athena111

New episode and a blunt 🤙🤙

alexis

soooo excited for this one i feel like i have to save it like a little treat

Lily Stein

FINALLY!!!!!! FINALLY BINCHTOPIA POLYAMORY EPISODE!!!!!!

Catie Bowland

i literally oscillate between thinking if i ever get cheated on ill be devastated or i literally wouldn’t care all the timeeee this’ll be interesting

Cierra H

Perfect right as I sit to knit 🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼🫶🏼

Luteal Swan

The way this episode dropped the day after my dad asked me what monogamous meant because he “has a friend” and when I asked what he meant by “a friend” he responded with “don’t start” 💜🙏🏻✌🏼

Emma Tilley

Oil fracking! That’s how we are at fault for earthquakes

soph

my take on cheating is that it’s actually way worse than most people say it is bc it violates the conditions of sexual consent that are set up b/w you and a monogamous partner. and i say that as someone currently dating polyamorously

Y

ooo yay!! new episode

meep

on a TUESDAY

K8

So excited to listen to this to indulge the part of me that wants ppl to have critical and truthful discussions but also trigger the part of me that’s going to be sooooo deeply nauseous while listening/participating in that convo 🤭👍👍👍👍

meep

i think i manifested this

Michaela Humby

OmGGGGG my first godly wife shoutout I am BLESS-ED

Yves_ell

Pro cheating individual here! I've never felt sincere love

fiona

Delete if not okay! I have 2 tixx to Eliza’s 4/12 Seattle show if any binchies wanna snag! Selling them for what I paid ($16 each). So sad to miss show but want others to enjoy 👼

Bridget Cook

Just took a lil edible and saw this was out I’m giddyyyy 🤤

bug

R/binchtopiapod might be a good place to try too <3

bug

thank u mommies

Nora bedard

Guys this is my favorite topic im so excited to listen to

fiona

Idk how to message ppl on here lol! Do you have insta? feel free to dm me there it’s @fionapelkie

Mary B

Pole dancing girlies rise up!!!!

Narcisa

I think for a lot of people cheating feels very traumatic because cheating isn’t actually the whole picture. Usually if someone is cheating on you they’re also lying and manipulating to keep the cheating hidden. This can cause you to feel so crazy and then when the betrayal is discovered that’s just one more thing. I personally think that even if monogamy isn’t hardwired in our brains it’s still a social contract you sign with someone else and violating that social contract is pretty unforgivable. It shows extremely poor character to me and a lack of healthy communication skills and boundaries. I’d leave my husband in an instant if he did it to me because especially in our relationship he has the safety to be able to speak up if something is bothering him or express unmet needs so it would literally just be cruel and disrespectful to me and I’m not tolerating that

Jamo

This episode makes me wonder about if any of the current monogamy standards came about with the creation of contraception methods, making sex more accessible for pleasure alone as opposed to for reproduction

soph

also imo the reason friends drop cheaters is bc they think "if you could do that to someone ur dating, who wouldn’t you betray?" and besides in situations of abuse or cheating where the person immediately fesses up and breaks things off, i think that’s a good code of conduct. i.e. don’t cover up for friends who cheat!! if you want to stay friends, help them take accountability

M

Omg I read “Sex at Dawn” about 5 years ago.

Darien Austin

Came at exactly the perfect time thank you

Ritsa

i found out via third party and the experience was so humiliating it was akin to being tar & feathered in the town square 😭😭😭

Luteal Swan

OKAY MILWAUKEEEEEEE🫶🏼

Mahek Ghelani

Polygamy has been a thing since ancient civilizations but it was usually the men who had multiple partners. Sex has been seen as an activity for pleasure for a long long time. But you do raise a pretty good point with the advent of contraceptives

stonefruit

I’d be really interested to hear you gals’ opinions on Clementine Ford’s recent book I Don’t — The Case Against Marriage. I feel like the things she discusses, while not necessarily new or groundbreaking, would make for interesting conversation and align with a few of the episodes you guys have done already. Though not perfect and definitely cheesy at times, i think she synthesises some disparate ideas about the topic well. Her digging into the historical/legal/political basis of modern traditions surrounding marriage, love, proposals, etc (and why it’s beneficial for men to make women believe that marriage is something aspirational) definitely has a slight Binchtopia feel. It’s basically a vindication of the single woman from a marriage abolitionist point of view. Id recommend the audiobook version over the written, as I feel her kind of colloquial and millennial internet-brained way of writing lends itself much better to being spoken out loud as a sort of extended rant. PLUS she is quite kooky and expressive in that format. Thank you ladies!!

Georgia

would love a full episode about polyamory/ethical non monogamy for all of us poly queens

✨

I definitely agree!! It takes peoples ability to make an informed decision to consent to sex and I do believe that it is not real consent, especially if they agreed to unprotected sex based on those terms. This is why I actually do push back on the "it's not the woman's responsibility if the man is cheating" narrative. If the "other woman" is AWARE that the man is cheating on a relationship that was agreed to be monogamous, she IS party to violating his primary partner in this way. So no it's not her responsibility, but yes it's wrong and bad and not equivalent to sex positivity.

Olivia Toles

I live in Belgium and those bitches are WAY WORSE about these shame behaviors than Americans imo

Olivia Toles

Also I’m not sure if she’s French or Flemish speaking Belgian but in Flemish they do say he/she is a victim of cheating (overspel which means like playing over the lines)

Carley Gougeon

Ornithologist here! What yall are talking about with the black birds is called "extra pair copulation". It's a behavior used to maximize the chances of passing on genetic information - so you don't put your eggs in one sterile basket and end up without a clutch! While it's cool to learn about the reproductive strategies of other animals, they aren't human and we have different social rules and goals. Thanks for indulging some bird science on the pod, love ya!

Jaelyn Wratchford

oh my word i’ve always been in a place of convincing a man to be monogamous with me

Kara

maybe being a lesbian gives me a different perspective on this idk but i always find it SO strange when people speak about monogamy as if you’re seeking one person to fill ALL of your needs. i do not understand how that is the case. i have many friends and sources of love, which is a circle my partner is included in. however she’s the only person i bond with sexually. not even “romantically”, because i think there’s a certain romancing that happens in friendships too. how is that expecting one person to meet all of your needs, assuming you’re a person with friends and additional community? and if not, isn’t that just as equally a question of making more friends as opposed to exploring sexually/romantically outside of a set relationship? loved this episode so much genuinely just adding to the discourse because that’s one of the main arguments against monogamy i hear & i’ve always pondered !

Salem

Baby’s first Patreon comment 🥹. Anyways, I am currently in a monogamous relationship with someone who identifies as aromantic and it has completely changed my view on family and relationships. Mostly in the destruction of the nuclear family structure, and how living with friends who are family is perfectly valid and in fact, ideal.

Salem

What I love about our monogamous arrangement is how we talk about our romantic attraction. My partner does not know if they feel romantic attraction, but despite that we both choose to love each other every day. It’s about the intention for connection more than anything else. That commitment is beautiful when paired with healthy communication

Oana Diaconescu

I think polygyny may rhyme with misogyny

olivia

Not 10 minutes after the earthquake I the below text came across my desk. The devil works hard but the people who make these work harder

olivia

Are you SHAKING with excitement?! 🤔🤔🤔Are you MOVING those hips?! 🤭🤭🤭Are you QUAKING for dick?!! 🤤🤤🤤You set my dickter scale to a 6.9, let’s crank it up to a TEN! 😤🥵🔥🍆💦 Send to 🔟 ground breaking baddies whose ass is so big, the earth is ALWAYS QUAKING around them 🗣️🍑🍑🍑 Stay safe. ❤️

Macey C

guyssss you should do an episode about byu/religious schools in general

Sofia Mattson

Eliza in Milwaukee!!! Go to Atwater beach!

Erin Healey

as a fellow lesbian, i think in heterosexual society partnership is SO emphasized as the be-all end-all of emotional fulfillment. i also think of how so many straight men can only be vulnerable and emotional with their female partners. there's so many women who traight up forget their friends when they partner up because it is so emphasized in society that yr partner is The One Who Can Meet All Your Needs. it's nutty

Kara

this is such a great perspective. my little heart has always been gay, so even when i was in hetero relationships prior to coming out my partner was NEVER my everything. but that’s a totally unique experience compared to a lot of my straight friends. thanks for replying bestie ❤️

Ann

If women have friends once they get married they might end up unionizing

Kara

going to add straight women making more adult friends to the lesbian agenda for this purpose

Keely Riggs

can’t wait to see you friday in seattle eliza!!

Molly Kerrigan

First mailbox moment was so beautifully written I got actual CHILLS

Zoë Grenier

Maybe I’m just old but I’ve lived in New England my whole life and experienced many an earthquake. They’re just usually weak and don’t have many aftershocks

Kara

Art therapists are usually trained specifically in trauma as that’s what art therapy is primarily used for!

Grape Surgeon

Neeeeeed y’all’s thoughts on hillaria Baldwin potentially joining real housewives of Beverly Hills

Claire

Omfg went to drop a like on this bc agree incredible episode and realized it was you heyyyy funny seeing you here

abby reddy

there’s definitely a difference between infidelity/cheating and consensual non-monogamy. cheating is a break of trust and of course the difference between that and cnm/enm is consent. and probably cheating would decrease if monogamy weren’t the norm, but i don’t think that lessens the pain due to the break of trust with infidelity. i’ve done both monogamy and non-monogamy and i think more people should try non-monogamy for sure.

Hannah

Ooh you just summarized my thoughts on this so well. I realized i’m a lesbian after dating men for a long time and in addition to the obvious that comes with that, it illuminated that a lot of what I thought I wanted in a man are attributes I want for myself but believed I needed a man to embody for me. For me a lot of this had to do with economic resources but it very much included my confidence to provide those things for myself. It made me realize how fundamentally toxic it can be to put expectations on a partner that are really more appropriate to have for yourself and extend to the people in your life beyond romantic partnership.

KiffyBlenky

I can’t wait to listen to this episode at work today! This topic reeeeally interests me. After being in a relo where jealousy consumed me, I decided to learn more and read “the ethical slut” (i think that’s what it’s called). Really helped me break down some ideas between relos and ownership? I’m in a LTR with a woman and it has been so freeing having open conversations about what our boundaries are in our relationship . I feel like the more we communicate, we’ve reached such a solid trust and understanding that the idea of us flirting with other people/ kissing other people has become kinda exciting - in a way that it’s sexy to see your partner feel sexy!! Rambling… but yes so excited to listen.

Lily

SO INTERESTING! i read American Hookup: The New Culture of Sex on Campus by Lisa Wade a few year ago and might be a relevant read in relation to the changing culture around romantic relationships and fidelity !

Brynn Tarbell

Polygyny is actually pronounced with a J sound as opposed to a hard G sound! Loving the sociology/anthropology moment tho🫶

drea

am i wrong that i heard them say there's a bouns ep. talking about andrew huberman? i dont see it anywhere. does anyone know where it is bc i have to listen lol

Ania Kastrava

needed this because my dad just cheated on my mom with his coworker and moved out within a WEEK of screenshots emerging

Olivia Smidel

I am a wedding planner and have a polygamous throuple as a client!They can’t legally marry where we live but it’s been a really cool experience and I absolutely love their relationship.

Hannah

If anything I would argue for the inverse of the Esther Perel quote where she posits that cheating used to not be a traumatic thing but we’ve made it a traumatic thing. Human survival relies on interdependence, which is why exile was such a big deal punishment back in the day. Going off the idea in sex at dawn that monogamy came about with private property during the agricultural revolution, I think that community interdependence has been concentrated into individual family units as that’s spiraled into the late capitalist hell we find ourselves in today. If you can’t trust the person you rely on to help run your house, raise your kids, and regulate your nervous system (if you’re lucky lol) that IS a threat to your survival and I understand how that can be traumatic. Especially in the context of societies with male preference primogeniture where a husband’s illegitimate son could have more of a claim to his properties than the wife (and legitimate children if they’re daughters). Considering that women couldn’t take out credit cards in their own names in the US until the 70s, I’d argue that it’s a relatively recent development (since the advent of private property at least) that a cheating spouse does not inherently put a woman in a precarious position regarding resources. I think those same factors in history also meant that some women were willing to put up with philandering to avoid losing resources; that doesn’t mean the betrayal wasn’t traumatic for those women, though, and I wonder if that’s more the experience Esther meant to speak to.

Hannah

Also this is already an essay lol but I realized I have more to get off my chest about that quote 🥲 To the binchies’ point about how human brains have developed over millennia and we can’t make a 1:1 comparison between ourselves and pre-historic people, I don’t think we can discount the way that the relative normalization of infidelity in past generations when we talk about our own feelings about monogamy on an individual level. When I say relative normalization, I mean the Don Draper/JFK thing where it’s fine for men to sleep around as long as they provide for their wife and don’t embarrass her in society. My parents’ marriage ended due to infidelity and as a result I developed an attachment style that feels safest in monogamy. I’m sure there are people with similar experiences to mine who came away with an attachment style that’s most comfortable with non-monogamy, too. Attachment styles can change throughout your life so maybe I won’t always feel that way, but for now I can accept that it’s not a switch I can flip and i’m not a bad queer/bad feminist/bad progressive for not wanting to do something that would make me feel unsafe in an intimate relationship. Kind of like the old but good Julia take about how it’s wearing makeup can’t be inherently feminist because even our enjoyment of makeup can’t be separated from what ppl perceived as women internalize under patriarchy.

Abbey W

omg my mom (republican, unfortunately) had said she couldn’t stand hillary for many reasons but distinctly said she didn’t respect her because she stayed with bill through all of his cheating 💀 maybe disrespect the cheater mom!!!

tulip

I felt the earthquake in maine!!!

Brianna Bogucki

Omg wow thank you SO much, I was so anxious to submit but it was v cathartic to hear them read it because this pod really helped me through that breakup :') full circle moment

Jasmine

Esther P’s not a licensed clinician? I’m a gasped (as a licensed clinician)

Vivienne paduch

random q for the binchies but does anyone know any podcasts similar vibes to binchtopia but in german? want to get on my language immersion grind but do NOT want to listen to men talking 😌😌

Meg

look at “auf eine tüte”!!!! — from someone getting a phd in german 🫡

Ella

GWS girlies reuniting in the binchtopia comment section 💖💖

stonefruit

After finishing the episode I have two other recommendations that I think really tie in with this episode: the documentary “The Disappearance of Shere Hite”, and the French TV show  « En Thérapie » I hope you check them out!! :)

Vivian Englund

Wait did I miss the Patreon ep where they talk about the Huberman article??

Emily Coffey

I’m so happy this is main ep. I’m sending it to EVERYONE

Kara

YES! this is so real. not to go too far into my background but i was also raised by a mom who was VERY dependent on men in every way so i thought that dependence was just …. love ! learning that self care (in a literal sense) and ownership of responsibilities was a major tipping point to realizing i was a lesbian after identifying as bi

Katie Davis

The John mulaney fries reference

Rachael S

i don’t think non monogamy should be seen as inherently deviant but also cheating within a monogamous relationship is still breaking an agreed upon boundary and breaking trust and focusing on that part of it is genuinely anti social behavior

Rachael S

so slay for consenting non monogamous relationships but also having clearly defined and agreed upon boundaries is at the heart of where the issues arise

Edith Philip

sufi & anjali was truly the 9/11 for south asian queers i fear

Erin Reinhart

This episode reminded me of how I & a lot of people (both people I know and what I’ve seen on Twitter, etc) thought tiger woods was a horrible person, had committed crimes etc, when in reality he cheated - I was too young to fully understand what he did when the news broke, but it’s interesting how so many people around my age thought tiger had done something truly horrific - not to say that his cheating was “good” but interesting in terms of how we think about cheating, the moral judgement around it, etc

Katlyn Dillane

My mom is the same but will literally find any reason to hate a democratic woman. She hated Michelle Obama for having visible party lines ☠️

Poppy

No you’re so right 8 year old me was acting like he murdered those women

Sam Haimowitz

vogueing to the intro whilst sat upon my throne (the toilet)

Emily Nelson

Please please pleaseee do Things We Never Got Over by Lucy Score for the next bad book club!!! Sneak peek: she wakes up from being literally strangled and the first thing out of her mouth is “coffee”

syd

first email made me tear up thank you for the positive spin from one binchie to anotha

Kathryn

got mildly cheated on by my long term bf a couple years back. we’d been together for three years (18-21) and he kissed someone at his graduation party while i was on tour for three months. he came clean and it was so hard, but we also learned TREMENDOUSLY from the experience. i think people make mistakes, and especially when it’s in a younger relationship, staying can be really the most wonderful learning experience. i tend to not talk about it because i KNOW people will immediately judge us for it and will not believe me when i say it’s the best thing that could’ve happened to us and teach us to be real adults in a relationship. both of us had never dated before. the judeo-christian idea of punishment is still huge, and there’s the implication that something is wrong with you if you don’t want revenge. anyways, we’re now 25 and getting married next summer, and i couldn’t be more grateful for ignoring the few who judged me for staying with him.

isabella

should i send the hey girly message?? this mans matched w me on hinge last year then i found out he had a gf, now he is trying to get w me again. when i asked if he had a gf he said "u see me imma have two atleast" 😭

Leanne Hays

✨thoughts on the higher education industrial complex: what makes a therapist a therapist?✨ Esther Perel got her MA from Lesley University in Expressive Art Therapy which the university lists as a Clinical Mental Health Counseling program. (From my understanding that would qualify as graduate experience in counseling/therapy? Does only a PhD qualify someone to develop/expand theory? If so why?) She is also certified through ASSECT as a Sex Therapist & Supervisor of Sex Therapy. The critiques of Perel’s work in this episode definitely have merit! But it got me thinking about the elitism of higher education at large. I believe there is value in bach, grad, & phd programs; but at what point do they become elitist? Is it when we discount someone’s work because they don’t have a degree we assumed they did have or *should* have? *Side note - obviously when it comes to therapy it is very important that someone is licensed and qualified to provide clients the necessary care. Maybe an episode that goes into different types of therapist credentials? LCSW/MSW, LPC, LMFT, Psychology PsyD vs. PhD, etc. What are the limitations that surround the different qualifications? (I would be interested in an episode like that as a veteran of reg therapy & a PHP trauma program)

claire

MKE MY CITYYYY

Franki

“🤨🫸 you fucked up and defiled my property. 😠👊sexually.”

Lily

If you guys are doing a show on polyamory, maybe talk about the show on peacock called "couple to throuple" where they basically just bring in a bunch of couples to unicorn hunt and use single people, lots of the single people discuss feeling like they are being used in the moment and then thrown to the side once they've had sex. It was crazy for me and my boyfriend of 3 years to watch and consider ourselves in the shoes of the couples or the single people. Lots of fun drama tho if you love a good reality tv show trash moment <3.

Lily

We also love watching Temptation Island, also on peacock where monogamous couples go on to basically split off into separate villas with 12 singles of the opposite sex and cheat on each other while their partner gets one out of context clip a week of what their partner is doing in the other villa. They do this in the name of "finding out if they are really meant to be together forever". they are obv not lol. Two different seasons have guys having threesomes with two women who are not their girlfriend, while their girlfriends are forced to watch clips of it because the couple came in with "no rules". very interesting and I think it shows a very interesting dichotomy of how men and women cheating is perceived. (A good season to watch is season 3 if you want to see a man being truly despicable).

Kayl Ward

VOTE FOR BAD BOOK CLUB: twisted love. Genuinely bad. But also so encapsulating.

Michaela Liesching

On a slightly unrelated note the book Bitch: On the female of the species by Lucy Cooke is a phenomenal book on biological myths and the anthropomorphism of females within multiple animal species

hal m

As a poly individual I would love to hear an ep on polyamory that has a poly person on- everyone feels differently about it but I think something that I believe and many people around me who practice ENM believe is that it's not about having sex with whoever you want, it's about building strong connections and trust and wanting (for yourself and your partners) to be able to experience all of their relationships in ways that feel like natural progressions of the intimacy they have with those people. Being poly has changed me into a much more gentle and understanding individual and my definition of love has shifted from what I was taught (that it's a feeling and unspoken promise) to what I believe (it's also an active choice and platform of trust you build with others), and I'd love to hear what someone who practices it would have to say on the topic. <3

avery

hi girlies!! i know i’m incredibly late to this ep, but i just wanted to push back a little on the references to evolutionary psychology. i think that field is often INCREDIBLY dangerous for women, and regularly used to justify sexist and gender essentialist perspectives (men being more “visual”, men being attracted to younger women, women having a “need” to reproduce that makes us less “rational”). the field also relies on the idea that there is a prediscursive or pre-social self that is driving our unconscious instincts, which imo is simply not true. we have no idea what we’d be like outside of society and the constructs in which we live (coconut tree etc etc). using “evolution” or “biology” to explain concepts that can just as easily be traced to patriarchy or capitalism is just another way to phrase an appeal to nature, and is shooting ourselves in the feet as feminists. there are a ton of really great writers on epistemic injustice (sally haslanger, miranda fricker, alison wylie) that cover this and evolutionary psychology specifically. anyways, love the pod, i just wanted to offer up an opinion on using these studies in relation to feminist issues!!