LEFT HAND PATH; or, The Night of The Hunter (1955) (Patreon)
Content

Pitched at the mid-century pivot of American filmmaking, 1955’s The Night of The Hunter is one of the few American films of that era to look backwards towards the earliest days of the art form, not only stylistically, but via its basic assumptions about how stories must be told with this visual medium. Even at a brisk 93 minutes, it rockets through its haunting tale of a misogynistic serial killer, come to manipulate and destroy a family whose father had hidden the $10,000 spoils of a crime he committed, and gave sole knowledge of that treasure to his children, who then become targeted by the killer. To cast Robert Mitchum, the most recognizable face of the film, as the central psychopath was a bold choice in Post-Hays Code Hollywood, which went to great pains to neuter any gruesome content or explicit sexual ‘deviancy’ in its industry since the mid-1930s. And yet The Night of The Hunter operates precisely in that Pre-Code fashion, taking cues from D.W. Griffith’s early innovations in silent cinema and German Expressionists like Fritz Lang, who are both artists that were overwhelmingly concerned with gruesomeness and that ‘deviancy’ that was now apparently removed from public films for the sake of ‘moral decency’. As Charles Laughton’s only directorial credit, The Night of The Hunter stands apart morally from the social conservatism that dominated the era with its overwhelming sense of palpable dread and evil, portraying a world in which goodness is the exception rather than the rule, where light is a delicate gleam amidst the vast waters of darkness.
Mitchum’s character, Harry Powell, is a strange figure. The film begins with us following him on a casual car ride while he rants to himself in biblical rhetoric, and one wonders throughout if Harry actually believes that he’s as holy as he wants others to think he is, which is quite capital-H Holy, as we come to find out. Tattooed on each of his knuckles are the letters composing the words ‘Love’ and ‘Hate’, and more than once does he use these tattoos to make a histrionic display to those he’s hustling, depicting the inevitable but fraught battle that the human being has between the good and evil parts of their soul. He’s so desperate to come across as an unironic do-gooder; when Shelley Winters’ Willa Harper hears news of her husband’s death, she hears it from Harry first, because Harry’s the one who finished that deed in jail. But to hear Harry tell it, he dutifully listened to her husband’s dying words, and came to console her with them, as only a man of God would feel compelled to do; and later, when Willa is pressured to become Harry’s wife for the sake of propriety and economic advantage, he refuses to have sex with Willa on the night of the wedding, instead mocking her and affirming the notion that sex should only be for procreation, to which Willa is hurt and devastated by such coldness on his part.
There’s something of a trickster in Harry, a classic American archetype of the con-man who wanders from place to place fooling the foolish and living by the skin of his wits, as seen in later films (also set in the 1930s) like Peter Bogdanovich’s Paper Moon. Harry is obviously a self-appointed preacher with a tenuous understanding of biblical scripture, just enough to sound confident in the words he sells to others, but the largest question that hangs over this Hunter is whether or not he actually believes in his own bullshit. Belief in higher powers is a big matter in times of suffering like The Great Depression, sometimes the only barrier that holds one away from self-destruction and poverty-induced nihilism, and Harry does care about his own well-being more than anything, otherwise he wouldn’t care at all about this possible $10,000 payday. The mask of the preacher feels so comfortable for him, and yet also eerily foreign, as if he’s going to burst into laughter any time he’s off the frame and away from those he’s trying to impress. Who does a psychopath have to impress? Anyone that gets between him and his goal, apparently. We’re told in the film that Harry has repeated this scheme of marrying vulnerable widows and making off with whatever wealth they have, repeated it again and again, so we know this is old hat for Harry, just how he does things.
But why this, of all things? Truly there are easier ways to make money, easier cons that require less set-up, less performance, less showmanship, less effort. The man has the obvious capability for violence that has given him a considerable bodycount with the amount of wives he’s killed; his favorite switchblade has seen many faces, so he’s not adverse to getting his hands dirty. But he only murders these women after he’s married them to have access to their finances. Theoretically, Harry could simply split after stealing from them, and given his existence as a wandering traveler in 30s America, there wouldn’t be too much trouble going from town to town and replicating this non-murderous route to easy money, as the ways of communicating this scheme between towns and law enforcement wouldn’t be that quick and omnipresent as it would be currently. Harry, if he so desired, could do this exact thing to his hearts content all the way to San Francisco, and he’d likely have an easy time of getting away with it.
Yet he doesn’t do that, Harry insists on the murder, so it’s not just the money that interests him. The process he undertakes is one of taking a perverse glee in deceiving others, it’s a game to him, a game to see if he can get away with the whole thing over and over, and he’s gotten very good at winning it. It’s this particular psychological indulgence that I think separates The Night of The Hunter from similar tales of its period, this notion that Harry not only benefits from what he does, but he enjoys it, enjoys the process of annihilating the wholesome idea of the American nuclear family, destroying it from within. He’s not just an easily quantified criminal who wants to make a profit, nor an externalized monster that represents an existential threat to the community as a whole. He’s a snake in America’s Garden of Eden, whispering whatever honied words he needs to infiltrate the lives of his wives, treat them with utter contempt and then toss their bodies into the gutter as soon as he’s extracted their nectar of cash. He’s a serial killer, yes, but even worse than that in the eyes of the film is that he’s a LIAR, that he assumes the costume of the vagrant holy man while committing unspeakable acts. It’s that in-between space he’s condemned and killed for, not just for being a murderer, but for being so good at appearing to NOT be a murderer, for making his lynch mob originally think that he was a wholesome God-fearing pilgrim. He embarrasses the social body by his sheer existence and threatens its validity, so he is destined to be removed, and even more, his enjoyment in these crimes at the expense of the community’s egos means that they will blame him for all their own ineptitude. The community ceases to be stupid for not recognizing his true nature sooner, but instead, Harry paradoxically becomes all the more intelligent and capable for being able to do what he did; anything to avoid ridiculing the constructed harmony of the American social fabric.
Much of this objectified deviancy recalls the monstrous hybrids of Fritz Lang’s filmography; most notably Metropolis’ Mashinenmensch, one of cinema’s first robotic/cyborg characters, and M’s Hans Beckert, one of cinema’s first serial murderers. Mashinenmensch wears the replica human skin of Maria, a young working class woman, and using her appearance to discredit her, Mashinenmensch leads the laborers of a dystopian society to destroy the mass machinery that they’ve been made to operate, which causes mass floods to the lower portions of their city. Believing their children to be lost in those floods, the workers burn Mashinenmensch alive as the fires reveal her to be a robot. As for Hans Beckert, he is the unassuming serial killer of children in 1930s Berlin who is eventually hunted down by both Berlin’s police force and its criminal underworld, pleading his own inner psychological issues before a kangaroo court of gangsters. Night of The Hunter’s Harry seems to be of a kin with this earlier branch of movie antagonist, a peripheral individual on the boundaries of society who nevertheless exists and mimics the existence of a regular, acceptable person within that society, cloaked beneath a guise of normalcy before eventually being revealed as a ‘monster’. This idea that the acceptable social body is being covertly subverted by the illusory nature of these characters provokes an intense reaction from the social body itself, often manifested in organized mob violence that seeks to redress this foreign-but-not-foreign individual. Even worse than the violence being committed here is one of these individuals how society itself takes a blind eye to certain standards of ‘acceptability’; the fool doesn’t have to fool anyone, not really, they just have to fit into the role that society is expecting, and their actual terrible actions get glossed over, and when the social body ‘discovers’ this violence, they can definitely abide by atrocity, but they can’t abide by being ‘fooled’ by their own expectations. Appearance rules the roost.
Laughton as a director then opposes this ‘deviant’ in the climax of the film with Lillian Gish’s wholesome den mother of Rachel Cooper, who is the matriarchal sovereign of several homeless children and eventually comes to house and protect the young kids that Harry has been hunting across West Virginia. Almost an answer to the end of Fritz Lang’s M, with its injunction that mothers “Must keep closer watch over the children.”, Rachel takes a no-nonsense stance against Harry’s huckster attempts to trick her into letting him near the kids, not buying his story for a second and then wounding him with her trusty shotgun when he tries to sneak into her home. Casting Lillian Gish for this role is key, as she was the leading lady of several of D.W. Griffith’s early silent achievements in Birth of A Nation and Intolerance, an idealistic ingenue and eternal mother who, by 1955, could embody all the veteran virtues of that era that Laughton wished to channel into this film. If Mitchum’s Harry is shifty, mutable, manipulative, then Gish’s Rachel is stalwart, honest, and wise, the strong and caring feminine principle to balance out Harry’s cutthroat misogyny. Harry contorts Christian principles to justify his murderous persona, but Rachel embodies them in her generous kindness to the gaggle of children under her care, proudly stating “I’m a strong tree, with branches for many birds.” After Harry is sentenced to death, the ending sees Rachel sharing a happy and prosperous Christmas Day with her children, everything true and good put into its ‘rightful’ place, the microcosm of the ‘proper’ social order restored and functioning.
Perhaps one can see this as an internalized reflection of Laughton’s strategy in making The Night of The Hunter: all the explicit horror and uncomfortable ambiguity of the silent film era can be shown in Hays Code Hollywood, but at the end of the day, the ending must be unambiguously positive, the bad guy gets what’s coming to him, and the audience feels a moral catharsis. It’s a testament to the depth of the film’s technique that it can have its cake and still eat it.
(Requested by Matyas, a Patron. Thank you Matyas!)