DIRECT ACTION; or, Elite Squad (2007) (Patreon)
Content

The action film’s history with politics has been, to put it lightly, a troubled relationship. The lure towards immediate and gratifying violence, organized and directed towards a specific element either foreign or domestic, inherently orients the action genre towards the ‘extremes’ of the political spectrum, despite the mainstream central governments of almost every nation having a monopoly on that violence. To put it one way, violence in an action film is ‘exceptional’, rather than invisible, exercised clearly on screen in exciting ways, not in terms of intricate and subtle power relations; the economic violence of one class upon another, the racial violence of casual discrimination, these are not usually what is meant by ‘action’ in action film language. For films such as Jose Padliha’s Elite Squad, power of violence literally emerges from the barrel of a gun, and functions as a purifying force in an otherwise murky world of corruption and falsehood, action clarifies moral greyness and establishes simplicity and ‘purity’ of intent.
The film’s main character of Captain Nascimento is introduced as the tip of this spear, the one man who commands the titular Elite Squad of B.O.P.E into the thickets and brambles of Rio de Janeiro’s criminal underworld, or rather, OVER-world, because it is reinforced again and again by Nascimento’s narration and further shown to us that drug violence is the normal visible state of existence in Rio, and that the regular police force functions in an analogous capacity to the gangs, collecting protection money and enforcing claims towards various territories. Nascimento despises all of this normality, he holds in contempt the inherent corruption both in drug circles and within his own law enforcement, and for the first half of the film has tremendous anxiety over his actions ensuring that a mother’s son dies at the hands of his cartel employers even if Nascimento didn’t kill him himself at a police raid. Nascimento has anxiety over not living long enough to see his son be born, of not coming home to his wife, and his internal battle between his human empathy and the strict Manichean ideology that he must adhere to in order to do his job effectively is one in which there can be only one winner. The vocal narration of Nascimento is bold, precise, brutally honest, but on screen he’s constantly sweating, nervous, doubting himself, hesitating, his hands never stop shaking. “Honesty isn’t part of the game,” he quips at the beginning, and his refusal to be honest with his seething stress at his job results in the brutal violence that he and his police team inflict on others. The purity of the violence is a release for him, a destructive way to let off steam and abstract the inherent complexities of Rio’s law enforcement into a simple task with simple results, life or death, black or white, right or wrong.
Nascimento is smart enough to realize, though, that he’s part of a system, and that system requires further bodies as lethal has his in order to enforce its will. His obsession during the course of Elite Squad is to find a successor for his position in B.O.P.E., a man who will have the same ruthless pedigree that he has. Enter both Matias and Neto; the former an astute lawyer-aspirant who sees policing and adhering to the letter of the law as the same task, and the latter a proto-Nascimento whose passion and dedication for the job lend him a no-nonsense attitude. Nascimento’s narration leads us to see Neto has the natural and obvious successor to himself, as someone who circumvents the corruption of the police force in order to complete their missions no matter what. Matias, meanwhile, has many of the emotional faculties of Nascimento, and attempts to bridge the intellectual theories of Foucault with his life as a cop, with disastrous results. In the end, Matias is entirely molded by the violence that he participates in, and becomes an instrument of Nascimento’s will, molded to become an uncompromising killer in the same fashion that Nascimento had to force himself to become.
To say that Elite Squad is a proto-fascist, or at the very least right-wing film, is perhaps missing some of the point. Nascimento and Matias are never valorized for their crackdowns on crime, they’re never rewarded with anything but further corruption and pain for continuing to participate and validate this system. Elite Squad hedges its bets as being ‘documentarian’ to some extent, to solely portray a certain political attitude and not explicitly endorse it. As Nascimento becomes more emboldened in his beliefs, he stops taking his anxiety pills prescribed to him by his psychiatrist, and refuses to entertain the notion that his wife’s role in their marriage is anything but a relationship of him as an explicit tyrant and her as a subservient homemaker, and Matias parallels this ‘growth’ by rejecting his intellectual girlfriend and her elite college friends after one of them causes one of Matias’ fellow cops to be murdered in an assassination. This rejection of the ‘niceties’ and expectations of social life on their part constitutes a retreat and a focusing towards their ‘pure’ goal of combating the drug cartels.
If Elite Squad is a portrait of a fascistic way of life, a rejection of liberal-centrist social performativity, it doesn’t exactly flatter the subject of its portrait. Lula Carvalho’s garish hyper-saturated cinematography echoes the extreme use of color and light in Tony Scott’s 2004 film Man on Fire, which is a work that takes great care to undermine any innate virtue on behalf of its characters, save for the innocence of children. Elite Squad also has a precocious child character, a near-sighted boy precariously close to this drug violence who is gifted a pair of glasses by Matias. For these radically right-wing cops ensconced in the inherent compromises of the social system that they wish to ‘purify’, the notion of the innocent child is the perfect way for them to project all of their ideas of wholesome patriarchal goodness onto, Nascimento’s child is also a part of this, a nebulous idea of the human being free from worldly corruption and vice. It’s a fantasy of condescension, ultimately; Matias’ apparent generosity towards this half-blind child ends up setting Neto to be easily killed by the paranoid cartel gangs, and Nascimento’s dedication to surviving long enough to see his child be born reveals his sheer contempt and misogyny for his wife, yelling his misogynistic commands over her as if she was one of the B.O.P.E. cadets that he abuses into submission and compliance.
It’s easy to see Elite Squad’s elaboration of this attitude as, if not proto-fascist, at least proto-Bolsonaro, establishing an uber-cynical ideology where the decadent and lax liberalism of progressives results in further cartel deaths and mayhem, and the only way to cleanse Brazil and Rio of this corruption is to adhere to an anti-social authoritarian conservatism, to establish a clear hierarchy of ‘good guys’ and ‘bad guys’, to draw the lines in this urban warfare between the disposable social enemy and the teeming innocence that must be safeguarded from the corruption by an extreme and forceful application of violence by the elite vanguard of agencies like B.O.P.E. If Elite Squad isn’t ‘pro’ this position, it’s quite a compelling display of it, leveraging its social drama to hit all the points it needs to justify its characters and the hardened journey they undertake.
To what extent is the action film format culpable for encouraging right-wing ideology? One only has to look at the James Bond series, the Death Wish saga, and of course Dirty Harry’s infamous knowledge of mankind’s ‘limitations’. There is a populist strain of pro-militarism and pro-cop statements in hundreds of very successful film series, and Elite Squad and its sequel remain to this day some of the most profitable and widely-seen Brazilian films across the globe. What a native of Brazil or Rio might see as a more ‘neutral’ documentarian portrayal of police violence can come across to an American like myself as a despotic advocacy for social purges and authoritarianism. Elite Squad contains material to support both of these attitudes, but what gives that material any weight is that the film has the artistic integrity to show the cult-like mentality that could result in someone actually having the hard-line attitude that its characters develop. It’s a work of political materialism, and if it reflects on the state of current Brazilian politics or life, it does so because it reflects the innate social potential of places like Rio to create people exactly like Nascimento and Matias. Bolsonaro didn’t arise in a vacuum, and neither do works of art.
(Requested by Pierre-Benoit Gauthier, a Patron. Thank you Pierre!)