Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

One must admit when they have nothing fundamentally new or important to say, and one must greet this understanding with a degree of grace and humility. I sit down to write this comparatively-short essay to A Brighter Summer Day, a near-four hour film about a time period I never lived in, in a country I’ve never visited, with characters speaking in a language that I don’t, in a political environment that I don’t fully understand. None of this matters. If you qualify yourself only by what you don’t know, you’ve merely taken the first Socratic step towards wisdom, and that’s not enough. It’s not enough to admit your failure to comprehend something, although that is a start. It’s not enough to pretend a superficial degree of knowledge afterwards, as you’re essentially admitting to a socially-expected pretentiousness that says more about your willingness to lie to other people than it does about A Brighter Summer Day. I re-wrote this essay three times, each of them slightly less superficial than the last. This is my fourth attempt, and it must be my last.

How does one go about understanding an epic piece of art? Before we can even get to that, and how one defines A Brighter Summer Day as an ‘epic’, we must delineate what we actually mean by the term ‘epic’ itself, to explore epic contours, traverse the epic landscape. Landscape is a start; it’s not enough for that to mean ‘a piece of land set before us’, no, landscape is the arrangement of perspective, landscape isn’t ‘the land’ as such, but the land arrayed in such a way as to produce interesting qualities, to draw us towards a focus, to heighten and sharpen what is there, but also not there. A landscape is a piercing of a world, a totality based on exclusion. One may paint or photograph a forest in such a way that cannot exist in any other moment for any other perceiver; the ‘scape’ is SCOPE, near or there, far and away, set upon itself, conscious of its own detailing as an imaginal space rather than a contingent arena or biome. There are many such landscapes in A Brighter Summer Day, places of beauty and mirth and pain and budding love. What makes such landscapes ‘epic’?

Perhaps the epic lies in the specific intent of such landscapes, the Way of the way that various things are shown to us. A Brighter Summer Day, like most 20th century films, is composed of 24 still frames per-second juxtaposed against each other to indicate movement. What is this Way of film? The way of stillness and moment shown through the illusion of movement. Despite many films being composed entirely within this Way, we would not qualify them all as epics in the way that A Brighter Summer Day is. If this Way of films is its intent, then that intent can be used to show different individual things. It is within this individuality, perhaps, that the epic is found, the individuality of qualia, the variance of discrete moments.

Longer runtimes in the cinematic medium are usually associated with the ‘epic’, and one draws the obvious conclusion that such a longer runtime allows for this Way to show an abundance of such discrete moments, an artistic collection. This is not enough; we would not compare epic films such as Cabiria, Intolerance or Once Upon a Time in America to, say, the average television show, which would easily surpass the length of most epic films. If the television format has an ‘epic’ character, it is certainly not derived from runtime itself, as that would make every TV show into an epic. The long runtime is a Way of going about ‘epicness’, a convenient formatting for film, but not strictly necessary; rather, it is the specific juxtaposition of certain images and qualia that generates the epic, the epic as a genre and mode and signified set of relations.

What are these certain images? To approach this, to approach A Brighter Summer Day, we must employ a bit of apophatic writing. What AREN’T these images, what are not the images you find in a non-epic film? In A Brighter Summer Day, the lives of Xiao Si’r and his fellow precocious 60s Taiwanese youths are not solely made up of ‘important’ moments, or decisive conversations. Sometimes the camera lingers on a small boy fixing a broken radio, or a mother hoping that she doesn’t have to buy her son prescription glasses, or a drunk aimlessly wandering the streets at night. Not all of these events are strictly ‘needed’ to follow the main story of Xiao’s relationship with Ming and the two local street gangs, but they are precisely what is necessary for an epic film to be what it is. An epic is not simply a long depiction of an ‘important’ event or saga. It is a full depiction of life as it is found within a world, it is a space for existence itself, a Way of displaying possibility by examining a complex context. A non-epic film could be said to be, more or less, a depiction of a singular movement, a singular idea contained within a series of ‘necessary’ events and moments that all follow (to some degree) sequentially, whereas an epic film makes space for the apparently ‘unnecessary’, allows for a story to be told BY the addition of non-essential stories, not in spite of them.

The primary defining feature of A Brighter Summer Day, and all epics like it, is that its storytelling is circular, not linear; it flows through a time and space for these characters, but not on the character’s behalf, it isn’t cloyingly tethered to Xiao’s life in the way that it would be in a shorter, more compact version of its story. The strength of the epic is that it isn’t necessary in its necessity, it does not direct one towards what is important or meaningful, and instead prefers to create the space for meanings to arise within the portrayal of certain faculties of observation. The epic isn’t structured around ‘sequences’ in the artificial capacity that screenwriters tend to create films, the epic has little need of abstraction and montage; although it can use both, it is not beholden to their use as literal short-cuts of communicating importance to the viewer. A Brighter Summer Day isn’t ‘about’ something, it isn’t trying to insist itself upon its audience, it doesn’t have an easily expressed morality, politic or gesture that unites its use of form; it EXCEEDS these things because of its embrace of the ‘unnecessary’, because it gives space and breadth to the minute details of its characters and their world and isn’t uncomfortable with all of that. It’s meditative, to be sure, but not passive; its compositions and camera movements are deliberate, there is a rhythm to what is being shown to you, but it isn’t a rhythm with an obviousness to it, it’s not impressing itself to decide what shots and expressions should be short and what should be long, it has a quality of naturalism precisely due to its lack of self-consciousness, its direct engagement with shallow adolescent concerns in a deep way, it weaves its story through immanent psychology but doesn’t pass judgment, because to highlight one element would be to put another in the shadows. By creating a flat ontology for the Taiwan it portrays, it lures the viewer into a hypnagogic state, each scene feeling like its own small world within a larger set of worlds that reverberate and vibrate against and within each other.

I wouldn’t say that A Brighter Summer Day is interesting in the way that many other films are interesting. Its status as an epic affords it a sweep and scale that cannot be denied, but also cannot be fully approached (for me at the very least), a stature always lying somewhat out of reach, a film based on a real story that decidedly feels like it generates an altered state of consciousness far away from the structures of a casual film experience. And yet, it IS casual, it is relaxed, it dances around its subject matter with an odd dexterity and lightness of touch, it isn’t interested in the epic as an idea of heavy import or weighty thematic. It uses its layered macrocosm of Taiwan’s disputed political history as a surface charm, a spell that leads us to consider the daily events and messy lives of the impressionable youths who actually had to grow up in this 60s regime. If we search for a ‘deeper’ meaning, a ‘grander’ notion, that might be missing the point; the point might be, rather, that a young person like Xiao’s complex relationships with the world around them is important enough, that the shadow he casts is the grand shadow of history's universality finding itself embodied in the particular as such; that each person’s story is worthy of exploration and examination.


(Requested by Freddy, a Patron. Thank you Freddy!)

Comments

No comments found for this post.