BLEAK FUTURE; or, Time Stands Still (1982) (Patreon)
Content
The identity of ‘adolescent’ is a relatively modern concept in history, only truly emerging as its own distinct notion within the conditions of the working class political bloc in 19th century Europe. Under feudalism, one was either a dainty infant who was effectively a slave of the household, or, as soon one entered into a capacity to do actual physical labor, one was considered an adult in the making, with young women married off during their teenage years and males tending to go straight into apprenticing themselves into whatever craft that their family performed. But with the rise of industry and capitalism, the free labor that working class children and teenagers provided became acutely exploited, putting the most vulnerable members of the social ladder directly into many of the most harmful and precarious jobs sweeping chimneys and coal mining in the most narrow portions of caves, jobs that no sane adult bothered to do but that these working kids were forced into for pithy monetary reasons. Reform after reform was enacted, and the benefits that European organized labor fought for began to trickle down for rights and legality centered around what is or isn’t child labor, and thus the idea of the ‘adolescent’ emerged in legal terms as a child in teenage years who possessed the emerging qualities of adulthood but could not be subject to the same conditions and expectations. The rise of public schooling took most of these newfound adolescents out of the factories and streets and into the classroom, and the 20th century solidified this development.
Peter Gothar’s Time Stands Still is a Hungarian chronicle of what it meant to be one of these adolescent creatures living within a time of a shifting political landscape. It tells the tale of Dini and Gabor, two brothers orphaned by the tumultuous events of the 1956 Hungarian revolution, and follows them over the course of their schooling in the early 1960s, a time in which Hungary was transitioning from a period of Soviet-occupied state communist authoritarianism (this repression brought on as a response to the ‘56 revolution) and into a more liberal, decentralized political environment that would gradually lead Hungary to be another collapsing brick in the late-80s Berlin Wall. What remains striking about Time Stands Still is how it locates these political shifts within the young post-war generation that would eventually cause the collapse of the U.S.S.R., years before it ever became imaginable.
Dini is a downbeat kid, but it’s hard to blame him for being so dour when the world around him seems so effortlessly bleak and decrepit. The cigarette smoke of him and his classmates lingers in the softening light of a country on the eve of becoming something new and strange to the land of his counter-revolutionary, now defected, father. Dini and his brother Gabor are the receivers of a distinctly American culture, with the soft rock ‘n’ roll romantic crooning of Elvis echoing down the moldy rooms and dusty floors of his school, his circle of friends liberally drink Coca-Cola and chant the lyrics to these songs and have unabashed sexual encounters in a way that the headmasters of the school clearly recognize and disapprove of. One of them, Dini’s biology teacher, chastises him for his lax attitude, saying “Sex is a scared gift form God. And there is no philosophy, no political regime which can deny it.” Dini ends up internalizing this notion, caught between his earnest respect for his idealistic teacher who’s defended him in the past and his clear preference for a culture that the teacher disapproves of. Even as these new forms of culture make waves in the youth of Hungary, the moral and political commandments of Stalinism still hold a huge sway over the structures and society of Hungarian life, and Dini cannot fully extricate himself from that context, his eventual betrayal of his teacher’s values coming when his neglect of a prospective girlfriend, Magda, leads her to fornicate with his brother instead out of sheer spite. Dini’s identity as an adolescent is characterized by a movement away from the hierarchical reverence for his superiors based in the Stalinist Hungarian system, and towards a more relatively horizontal relationship with his peers, especially Magda, who he begins to assert his attraction to in an unsubtle way.
The film’s use of teenagehood is thus seen as a move away from a supposed ‘father knows best’ political structure of society mandated from top to bottom by the state, and in its place we see a growing generation of discrete individualists whose primary concern is the consumption of popular culture and navigating relationships based on the evaluation of personal relations instead of social or moral expectations. The adolescent, then, is seen as a category of the ideal capitalist subject, a semi-knowledgeable customer looking towards establishing a marketplace of ideas, not defined by their labor-power as such, which doesn’t exist as far as this film is concerned, but instead by their ability to make choices, the ‘free market’ has freed them from having to conform to Stalinist strictures, but has also demanded that they participate in relationships of consumption and exchange instead of solidarity. Later in the film, Dini, Gabor and Magda steal a car and make a halfhearted attempt to cross the border into Austria, their impish immaturity not really receiving any repercussions for such an action. Although it will be years before Hungary exits the Soviet bloc, these teens more or less already exist within the global capitalist sphere; society just has to catch up with them.
Time Stands Still is in many ways a classic youth film in the vein of artists like John Hughes. Scenes drift in and out, characters are ill-defined because their age itself lacks definition, their personal ambiguity is equal turns amusing and frustrating, the film gives them plenty of space to make mistakes and recognize them. Outside of a kitschy prologue and epilogue, Time Stands Still has an air of immediacy about it, a relevancy and relatability that is rare for youth films to always hold onto. It holds onto that same unstable emotional realm that Jia Zhangke’s Platform and many of Hou Hsiao-Hsien’s works do, a snapshot of a transition between one system and another, an emergence into a global consumerist market economy having an impact on those most affected by it, a sense that anything can emerge from this listless drama even though it’s been over 30 years since its release. We know the state of Hungary today, we know the political upheavals that will occur, but these characters don’t, and it embalms its evocation of adolescence, the weird miniature adulthood refracting into both ideas of communism and capitalism, how these small struggles of identity and relationships reflect large-scale changes in the social body writ large. Adolescence here is never truly finished or replaced; it’s just simply declared to be over for the sake of convenience. There’s always something different around the corner, even if you already see it coming.
(Requested by Matyas, a Patron. Thank you Matyas!)
Files
Previews only