IMPOVERISHED POLITY; or, City of God (2002) (Patreon)
Content
Some of the most compelling aspects of filmic language have much more to do with architecture and ambiance than the written narrative. Containing both the pictorial framing of painting but also the rhythm and cadence of music, film is a dynamic synthesis of several different strains of art that, ideally, projects the strengths of its technological format into a degree of intensity that washes over the prospective viewer like a visual tidal wave. 2002’s City of God plays as much with being a documentary mosaic of one of Rio’s most infamous suburbs as it does with being an interweaving story about the developing criminal gangs within it.
The film opens with its ending, a climactic build up to a confrontation between two of Cidade de Deus’ gangs, and then devotes the rest of its runtime to examining all the little moments and fragments that caused this battle to take place. The beginning, from an editing standpoint, really stands out from the rest of the film, an incoherent jumble of juxtaposed images, the camera dutifully following around a random soon to be slaughtered chicken as if it was our main character, leading us frenetically into the rapidly-escalating situation. This opening somewhat operates with an outsider’s prejudiced perspective of Rio as an unreasonably-violent and chaotic city, and much of the film operates with the lens of impassioned exploitation gleaned from playful self-aware crime films of the 90s, the Tarantinos and Guy Ritchies, using episodic storytelling as a way of giving empathy & humanity to each character, jumping from character to character as the story shifts its focus from the petty robberies of a small gang into the gradual formation of all-out warfare in the streets. Many times the character who will be the focus of a later segment will appear in an earlier segment in a smaller capacity, and the whole movie has the character of an interrelated chain of being, nothing existing within isolation but always gracefully flowing into the next portion like a torrential river. What results is an easy and intuitively pleasurable viewing experience of very unpleasant events, and perhaps this is the documentarian paradox of the film.
Even more than Tarantino and Ritchie, however, the greatest comparison to City of God that I can make is Kinji Fukasaku’s Battles Without Honor and Humanity series, another epic documentary-esque crime saga that fields a bewildering amount of characters and relies more on the despotic mood and atmosphere of its environment to carry its themes rather than a direct and simple line of storytelling. Fukasaku is equally as interested as City of God’s directors Meirelles & Lund in using garish brutality to punctuate every reel with a sense of urgency and gruesome horror, but even Battles Without Honor and Humanity never gets to the point of showing the killing of children. The yakuza are presented in that series as wild, to be sure, but they’re all more or less adults, they deal with other adults within their closed society. What remains striking about City of God is that its generational scope continually centers on the capacity and ease at which children and teenagers are just as capable of horrendous violence; it seems to a great degree that parental figures are more or less absent in the film, and when they are present, such as Knockout Ned’s father, they’re quickly disposed of by the volatile gangs in a hail of bullets. This isn’t a story about well-meaning but corrupted adults who willingly participate in the criminal underworld in order to accomplish their aims, City of God is a story about how so many youths of Rio never really had a chance to be anything but involved in the gang wars and the drug dealing. It’s entirely normalized, banal, and there’s little of an outside or governmental authority to give any context to this world, so the viewer is also conditioned to take it as it comes, to witness the daily atrocity right along with the moments of beauty and love, all of it in continuity with each other.
To a certain extent, this flattening out of the violence is itself the internal perspective of the closest thing the film has to a main character, the aspiring photojournalist Wilson Rodrigues, known throughout most of the film as ‘Rocket’. If the film itself is steeped in particular choices, such as when Knockout Ned is almost about to be held up at gunpoint while working as a bus-fare collector, but the robbers then decide against it after he gives one of them a free ticket. Ned later goes on to become one of the complicit leaders in the central gang war, and the film subtly asks the question of if it was better that he was to be robbed rather than put on the path that would lead not only to his own death, but to the deaths of so many others. At an earlier critical juncture, Rocket is given the easy chance to grab a gun and take revenge against Lil’ Ze, who had killed Rocket’s older brother in a previous segment after that brother had attempted to rob Lil’ Ze as a child. Rocket, in less than a few seconds, decides against doing it, and later begins documenting the ongoing war between Lil’ Ze and his chief rival Carrot, his pictures capturing the macho displays and death at the heart of the conflict. At so many times are these characters faced with the opportunity to kill, and most of the time they make that choice. By retroactively positing the ending of the story at the beginning, City of God seems to consider this dense succession of choices to be, to a large degree, fated, with the narrative clarifying each and every moment of importance, each brick building into the wall of Cidade de Deus’ history, every individual consumed by their own agency, everyone accountable for something, if not everything.
It is this grander design that is City of God’s strength as a picture. It deftly avoids the conservative platitudes of Rio’s favelas as being some sort of inevitable hellhole, because we see that it is also a place where true love blossoms and friendships are made. But it refuses to gloss over the problems of how easy it is for poverty to give way to violence and abuse. If there are no real parental figures in the film, it is because these children and young people have been deliberately disposed of and neglected to wander the streets of this era of Cidade de Deus. They are all to some degree responsible for the choices they make within this situation, yes, but they are not responsible for the situation itself, as the easy acquisition of guns and drugs creates an inherently unstable environment that magnifies the individual suffering of each person into a collective bloodbath that has no conclusion. Even at the end of the film, after both gangs have been extinguished by each other and their micro-empires seemingly dissolved, all the hundreds of guns that they’ve handed to impressionable children in order to make them foot soldiers has resulted in those children left now without even the authority of the younger adults, so these 10 year-olds talk tough about making hit lists for people they dislike and casually brandish guns while traipsing between alleyways. If they are left to become terrible killers, it is because it is easy and available for them to do so; the social architecture of Rio WANTS them to be this, because their poverty has been institutionalized, accounted for, and considered an expendable concern. City of God is a very slick and entertaining film, almost in spite of itself, because to acknowledge the complex situation of these children in this environment is to run against the general ignorance that pervades concerning marginalized communities like this. To tell a real story of this caliber, it requires a full portrait of lives that are caught in the middle of an impossible scenario, and to tell it in such a forceful way that its reality cannot be denied.
(Requested by David, a Patron. Thank you David!)
Files
Previews only