Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

No Sync Required Version: https://cinebingers.ca/LEpg3Ubh42 - For Patreon tier "Bingers on The Wall" or higher.

Movie runtime: 3:55:24

Files

Previews only

(Commentary & Rewatch) The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers - Patreon Version

Comments

Ph4ZeD

Yes Yes Yes perfect weekend coming

Nemo

Eyy, let's go. Was worried we wouldn't get them weekly, I salute your consistency. :)

JakeyShakeyBakeyBoy

Did y’all know Viggo Mortensen broke the internet with the number of toe fracture comments on Youtube the past decade? That aside I’m glad you’re having fun going through these movies again. My fave films of all time and favourite movie opening of all time. Very much looking mighty forward to the RoTK reaction - where most dudes cry lol (me included)

Simon Clifton

No pressure, but there’s 3 key scenes in the next one that your reaction will be measured against ;) In all seriousness, even as someone who came to the books before the films were made, these always get an annual rewatch and they are just beautiful. If I ever had to criticise, I’d say that even with the extended eds, they’re still too short…

Thexx

Thank you for this.

Jared Winn

I used to watch these with my roommate on my birthday every year. I’m glad to have these to have new friends to watch my favorite movies with ❤️

Shibby

There goes my plans lol

REDR58

Someone on Reddit about 10 years ago figured that Gandalf and the Balrog fell about 2.2 miles: https://www.reddit.com/r/theydidthemath/comments/227gkf/request_how_far_did_gandalf_and_the_balrog_fall/ One of my few disappoints with this movie is that I wish they had shown a bit more of Gandalf climbing the Endless Stair. Discussions of ways of carrying the One Ring make me think about the endless discussions of who or what can lift carry Mjölnir. Could an elevator lift Mjölnir? Gollum really looks his best in this movie, in the darkness and moonlight. In daylight he looks a little less convincing (for as amazing as he still looks!). It’s interesting how they make a point of showing the Wild Men pledging allegiance to Saruman but then they are never really seen again, not even attacking the village in the next scene.

Cubonemaker

Again, I’m so freaking excited to see this with y’all and nerd the fuck out.

Mastervodo

There is a cameo by the Awesome and Most Famous Canadian actor, Keanu Reeves during the 1st charge at Helm's Deep! He is with a contingent of Canadian Orcs that were on loan from the Canadian Special Operations Regiment. He is the one 15 rows back, 103rd from the left. Dressed in black with a.... weapon of some sort.

Mastervodo

Y'all need to get some Lembas as your snack for the last one!

djKENTO

good news George. Your wish about more Rohan is coming true. Later this year an official Lord of the Rings anime from the director of many Ghost in the Shell projects and was one of the background artists on Akira. it’s set in this continuity and Miranda Otto is returning. It also has the addition of Brian Cox. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt14824600/?ref_=nm_flmg_unrel_1_dr

Jesus F Christ

Cassie from Popcorn in Bed did a rewatch of the LotR extended editions with her sister Carly that had never seen them. When that moment came up, she said, "I'll tell her guys. When he kicked that helmet, he actually kicked it for real, and it was a real helmet, and he broke his toes." LOL She knew that would show up in the comments. https://youtu.be/GdkRJR-RhSU?si=h3HVnvZSUR7KuQj6&t=869

Jesus F Christ

The prologue reminded me that in LOTRO there are some quests that take you deep into the bowels of Moria and to that lake that Gandalf and the Balrog plummet into. Down there you also find the base of The Endless Stair, a long spiral staircase on a column that stretches from that lake shore, through Moria, and out of the mountain to the peak of Zirakzigil culminating in Durin's Tower, where Gandolf killed the Balrog and in the process destroyed the uppermost part of the Great Stair. A later quest takes you outside to Zirakzigil where you find the charred remains of the Balrog.

Monica Alarcon

Awwww damn. I can't watch this today... I think I might have to wait till Monday. Or perhaps watch it in parts...

Lola Lirola

What!?!? No way!! Please tell me this is real, I can't check out my copy now. I love this, I want it to be real!

David N

Its nice to see them watch a movie that they both love so much. Nothing but good feelings all around.

Odd Thomas

Eowyn is actually my second favourite character and I agree with George that she totally earns her heroism, starting as a lost princess before becoming a badass in ROTK. I love Arwen too but she's a little TOO perfect. Eowyn really has to work to get recognition. My favourite scene in the whole trilogy is Eowyn asking after Aragorn in Helm's Deep and Gimli telling her "he fell". The crestfallen look on her face and the music is just utter perfection. You see her heart break. Some other good Miranda Otto films: War of the Worlds (2005) and What Lies Beneath (2000)

Logan Kerlee

That dude that did the math is my hero. xD I really love it when things in films are broken down like that! It's so darn cool. :D

Monica Alarcon

And now I'm laughing at my earliest comment... I said "I'll just watch a little bit" and I'm now halfway trough... so screw my other commitments..

Shonnicus

My favorite. Big 3 reasons are in any order. Gandalf the White Battle Helm's Deep The excellent performance of Andy Serkis; Gollum vs Smeagol scene.

Skyruff

I love that each time Aragorn walks into frame Simone’s subtext is “my precious”.

REDR58

War of the Worlds is good, but Miranda Otto is barely in the movie. Check her out in: Love Serenade (1996) The Well (1997) True Love and Chaos (1997) with Hugo Weaving She is a main character in all of those movies and does a nice job in each of them.

Astraeos

Here again to say that y'all should really consider doing a little Patreon exclusive and throw up your reactions to some of the behind the scenes stuff from the Extended Editions. I think many of us would absolutely watch the hell out of that with you guys.

John

This was a great watch. Based on your comments during the movie I think you would really enjoy Kingdom of Heaven, John Noble is amazing in Fringe

REDR58

Let’s be honest, whenever a female character gets any crap from certain fanboys it’s more often than not just sexism. What makes the part where Legolas swings around onto the horse look so odd is that he seems to have no real leverage, sort of somehow pivoting backwards on his hand. Slow it down and you’ll see strange a move it is.

Jared Winn

Needed this tonight. Struggling real hard mentally and being around other diehards and between “not alone” and Sam’s monologue to close I am a wreck, but also so full of hope. Love you guys!

RLYtoxic

Brad Dourif did such a great job as Grima. He is also the voice of Chucky.

Grandalf

Brad Dourif is an incredible actor. Reminds me to recommend that you guys should watch Deadwood as a future TV series. The Deadwood movie that we finally got to wrap up the story of the unfinished series is decent enough to make the incredible first three seasons ,... is reactable a word? It is now!

Grandalf

Also Simone, for Gollum impressions, I cannot but this Critter sends Critical Role's own Art Dad, Liam O'Brien in his stead.

Simon Pegged Me

Brad Dourif plays Doc Cochran in Deadwood. That's only tangentially related to the discussion, but I felt I needed an excuse to ask you guys to watch the Deadwood series. So, there you are.

JLee

Wanted to make a rabbit stew for this rewatch (i've never had the chance to cook a brace of coneys) but didn't have time to go to the market that would have it. So instead it's going to have to be a nice fish stew, so juicy sweeeeet.

JLee

George [to Simone]: You don't want to do the thing they did in "Old Boy?" Me: I don't want to do anything that anyone did in "Old Boy," thank you.

Philipp Roensch

My favorite BTS fact: The riders of Rohan are mostly women, because the horse trainers just overwhelmingly were, In some stills you can see the ladies with glued on beards^^. Thank you for this continued commentary and wonderfully nerding out together.

simon brouillard

For more Viggo I would go with Eastern promises and A history of violence

Joe D. MacGuffinstuff

This is my favorite of the trilogy, because of the Gandalf reveal, and seeing him smite the balrog; also, Rohan is cool and the simultaneous Battle for Helm's Deep and the Last March of the Ents was awesome. Miranda Otto btw is in War of the Worlds, not a very big part though. Brad Dourif, Grima Wormtongue, is one of my favorite character actors ever, he's so good. He was in a scene once where his character tells a story about soldiers being tortured with rats in Vietnam and he did that tear drop thing, it was so effective, so was the rest of his performance. He was in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest too, but he was so young a lot of people don't recognize him, same with Christopher Lloyd and Danny De Vito.

Koonce

Simone I also recently geared a Barb in Diablo3! George for RoTK just do your hair like Arwen! lol. Thanks for the fun rewatch.

Angela D. Mitchell

Wonderful re-reaction and discussion! Simone, I also love the addition of Theodred's funeral -- everything about it. For me it's where PJ's trilogy truly creates new magic in the films. And my favorite thing about PJ's adaptation (as with Eowyn & Theoden at the funeral) is that he takes the time to include moments of real grief, and this adds to the weight and cost of everything we see. The Fellowship collapsing after the loss of Gandalf. And then Theoden's incredibly moving, sad moment of weeping. Smeagol slightly recovering is so tragic, and I always feel so sad that (as in the books) Sam has zero empathy for him. Meanwhile, PJ's treatment of Faramir will always enrage me. PJ didn't like that in the book Faramir was never tempted so instead he reversed the entire Faramir/Boromir situation. Faramir was the stronger brother yet he doesn't hold out against the Ring for even hours. Boromir, the "weaker" brother, meanwhile, in PJ's version held out for MONTHS. So it makes no sense, and it trashes poor Faramir's character. The only good to come of it is that Frodo and Sam end up at Osgiliath, which is amazing. Miranda Otto has done a lot of other wonderful work -- most of it in television, very steadily across the past two decades. She was absolutely terrific in "Homeland," among many others. George, Elrond has the foresight of his people, and his vision of Arwen's future is 100% accurate. A lot of the Arwen/Aragorn stuff comes straight out of Tolkien's "The Tale of Aragorn and Arwen" from the Appendices. Everything he foresees for her -- right down to Aragorn's tomb and Arwen wandering to die among the trees alone -- is accurate and incredibly sad. The only thing he withheld from her there was that she and Aragorn would have children. As far as Elrond's POV on Aragorn and Arwen -- it isn't just that he doesn't want Arwen to die. It is the fact that it will be a permanent parting -- Elves and mortals go to a separate afterlife. So Arwen even after she dies will never see her father again, although she will be reunited with Aragorn. This is why it always touches me in RotK when Elrond shows up with Arwen in bridal dress, but although he smiles, he is also visibly weeping (Hugo Weaving is so wonderful). And I totally understand why Eowyn falls for Aragorn (who wouldn't?!!). The movies do such a good job of showing how lonely she is, and how trapped she feels. It's why the Grima scene is so damn good -- Brad Dourif does make him weirdly charismatic, and for me she pauses there for a moment because she is visibly paralyzed at being seen and understood. Yes, by an evil man -- but he perfectly describes her inner terrors as if she's made of glass. It's an amazing moment. I always love when she breaks free of him and tells him he's poison. Also, I laughed out loud at George's "The Ents just need a few Sequoia..." Wonderful reactions and discussions -- thank you to both of you!

Tomas Gaspar

I believe that Aragorm has also a vit of a cleric/healer on him...at least on a basic level.

Raven Dark

Just a thought I had while watching this reaction. When Pippin (or is it Mary? I sometimes get them confused) tells the Orcs "My friend is sick," in hopes that they'll help him, I don't think it's that he really thinks the Orcs will care. To me, it's more like, he's so desperate to help his friend because he looks on the verge of death, that he felt like he had to do something. I know Mary and Pippin can be dumb and silly sometimes, but I give him a pass on that one because the situation was so dire and he was acting in sheer desiperation. I actually didn't know most of the trivia you read out at the end, George. That's really cool about the horses, particularly because to me, they don't look like they've been digitally added. Good job, production team. Oh, and I agree about that scene where Legolas mounts the horse. I think it looks so silly because it's bad CGI. It looks too fake. Which is a shame, because for the most part the CGI in these movies still looks fantastic. There's a lot to love about these movies, and the LotR story as a whole, but one of the smaller aspects I really love is all the cool names for things. Nazgul, Warg, Uruk-hai, ect. They're just so cool. I also like a lot of the more English sounding names, like Helm's Deep. When it's done well, that part of worldbuilding is one of my favorite things about high fantasy. I'm sure there was more I wanted to say, but I can't remember any of it now. Thanks for another great rewatch, you two.

Amelie W

If you had just one "fuck" for the whole trilogy, here's where I'd use it. To replace the word "master" in Gimli's line "Give me your name, horse-master, and I shall give you mine." (Ancient joke from DM of the Rings where he rolls a 1 on his diplomacy check.) Aragorn has one level in Warrior and four in Ranger, according to some nerds who worked out how everything he does in the movies could be done by a non-superhuman, i.e. character level 5 or below. Possibly he'd still need a couple of attribute score bonuses from the Dunedain race template, but it could be done. If you're given some truly inedible food, it's probably best to say so. "I don't want to sound picky but I can't eat this, have you tried it?" or something like that. As long as you can choke it down, you can just call the flavor "special," "particular" or "unusual" to explain any weird faces you make. If there's one thing movie critics love it's exaggerating the flaws of women characters who love the leading men in any less than perfect way. If Eowyn died I'm sure they would have said that's a fair consequence for making eyes at Aragorn. They should just watch how gently he lets her down and try to learn something. Legolas is so mean, blocking Gimli's kill AND making him a liar after he said he'd "ease" that orc's "passing." I noticed today Aragorn has been wearing Boromir's wrist guards. You even saw him do something with his lower arms right after they sent Boromir on the boat! Only about tenth time I've watched the trilogy.