Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Heyo!

There is a member on here that has chosen to stay anonymous, but in the spirit of giving, wanted to sponsor either a signed paperback/print.

In that same spirit of giving, I'll donate the print of the corresponding couple, so the winner of the giveaway will receive both a personally inscribed paperback of their choice + the couple print that goes with the book :)

The winner will be contacted before the new year!

To enter, comment here with your favorite character in the HCLU -

Thank you for being here, and looking forward to a story-filled 2026!

(and don't worry, IKYWT is still coming in the next two days)

Comments

Amy

Charlotte has been my long time favourite but im really starting to like Rose!!

Amanda

Emma

SJ

Emma Bordeaux

Tori

Charlotte and Sutton!

Alex

Charlotte…. Or Caroline!

Araz

Caroline Parker for the books. Rose Elliston for the broader HCLU!

Linda B

Caroline Parker!

Ilg

Caroline

Minx

I'm obsessed with Caroline Parker. Swoooooon

Shirley

Riley is actually my favorite 😊

D

Abbie

ellie

stunning charlotte ofc, also thank you to the person!! that's really sweet

Hendrien

Abbie is my fav !

Kathryn Crowley

While I’m a sucker for Regan as you know (she literally is my dream everything) I connect so much to Ellie… actually I connect to them both I CANT CHOOSE

Janet

Charlotte!

Sarah

Favorite HCLU character = Regan!

Erin Hubay

Right now? It's Rose without a shadow of a doubt. Even while I listen to midnight rain for the umpteenth time! That's how incredible it is

Angie Bobinger

My favorite character in the HCLU is Rose

Miranda

My favorite character is Charlotte!

Liz Hendrick

Charlotte but rose is a very close second

Mars

Charlotte 💯

Taylor H

Charlotte Thompson simp 🙋🏻‍♀️

Valeria Cabriolu

Ok this is a hard one.... I'll go with Caroline though

Chance

Gotta go with my prickly Rose 🤣

Margo Lack

It’s really hard to pick a favorite 🤣 Abbie

Tracey Kim

Painful to choose because I love them all for different reasons.. but right now it’s gotta be Maya 😍

melissa

Charlotte!!!

Sycpoet

Caroline!

tigeralice

Sutton has always been my favorite character

saks

Regan!

emily

I think Rose has started to really take the title for me, but before that, it was an incredibly close tie between Hannah and Charlotte.

Nicole S.

I gotta go with Abbie

Sarah

It’s so hard to pick just one, but Caroline will always hold that special place for me.

Alyssa

Rose has stolen my heart!

Mareike

charlotte thompson the loml 🥲

Jen

Charlotte

Ariana

caroline all the way ♥️ the true heartthrob of the hclu 🙂‍↕️

Alex Howard

Gianna, definitely Gianna

Michelle

Maya and all her patience

August

Charlotte is everything!!! Rose a close second🥹

Paula

Really hard to pick a favorite but Hannah 💯

Dianna Norman

Always with the hard questions. I love them all so much. I'll go with Hannah. I'm always partial to her and Caroline.

Jenell Johnson

Charlotte Elizabeth Thompson, specifically in Midnight Rain

hnicole

Charlotte 😩

lexi

gianna always

Réka

Charlotte

Amy Lyn

Probably Sutton or Reagan, love those two girls

Kate Shark

I think my favorite might be a tie between Caroline and Emma

Madison Sears

my girl Charlotteeee. i even name one of my kittens after her haha

Marie

I'd say Brooke is one of my favorites. Kind but gruff, dedicated to making her community thrive.

Sherri Alcott

It’s been Charlotte for 4 years, and I fear she’s about to be replaced by Rose 🫣

Emery Kavanagh

I’m gonna have to go with Ellie ❤️

Sasha O

Caroline

Robin

This is always the hardest question to answer because you've written so many beautiful characters. Overall, I reckon I'd have to pick Charlotte. Especially Midnight Rain Charlotte. Abbie though, is a close second. Mahalo and Aloha to the anonymous gifter ❤️

viviana

my #1 will always be charlotte but rose is a super close second and thank you to whoever sponsored this :’) <3 !

Jasmin

Gianna

Maria Esther

Gianna, if I had to choose, the answer would be Gianna… This was/is hard… like favorite TS song kinda of question 😂

Nyx0217

Charlotte 🌹

Liz

Taylor

Natalie

My favorite is Reagan I can’t decide if I want to be like her or date somebody like her

Sarah Watts

Charlotte, if I HAVE to choose...

Amelia Stack

Caroline Parker, for all time.

Taryn Reynolds

queen Charlotte is the best ❤️‍🔥

Lucy

Gianna

Veronica

Gianna! Her character development is truly outstanding and her love for Riley melts me every time ♥️

ActuallyZ

I like Ellie because she looks me of Delphine from Orphan Black.

iris

Regan

Carrie Goff

Tough choice, but Sutton!

Shan

Regan!

Aimara

Sutton!

Melissa HW

My favorite character is Regan. 🫶🏼

Lucia G.

Caroline, no contest

Kate

Emma ☺️

MEK

So hard to choose, but Autumn!

Vivi

Gianna

Erica H.

Oooof, tough one. Gianna

Andy Howland

My favorite character has to be Ellie

Fred

Maya

M

After that meme I made, I have no choice but to say Sutton 😂 (but Charlotte is forever the Queen of serving angst 🧎🏻‍♀️)

Stephanie Leeth

1. This is very difficult 2. Love that you clocked the need to put a IKYWT disclaimer in here lol 3. Mmmmmmm I'll land on Charlotte a la MR. The kind of growth you can only really get when you've gone that far in the future 👩‍🍳🤌✨️

Kate Izell

Riley because she’s the most like my wife ❤️

Allie

Abbie!

Kelsee

Caroline Parker

Bailie

THE Charlotte Thompson (especially Midnight Rain Charlotte)

Kacie

Emma Bobemma! 🥰

Liz F

Given I’ve read WYLEI literally five times in the last week, it’s gotta be Caroline 😍

Diana Schneider

This is an insanely difficult choice. I like so many characters for different reasons. Charlotte, because she's got that Bette Porter vibe and TWW was my first read of your books. Sutton is smart and sweet and amazing. Caroline is hyper competent and that is so sexy. Reagan reminds me of me in a lot of ways, which is fun and kinda painful. Emma, when she finally lets herself relax and be herself, reminds me a lot of my wife.

Fernanda S

The one and only Gianna Beckett

heidstuff

Thank you annon donor! My fav character at the moment is Brooke. Steadfast, reliable, loyal, with a soft side she reserves for those she loves. 😍

Megan

Caroline

Shelby

So hard to pick just one 😫 but I think I’d have to go with Emma Bordeaux.

Jordan

Regan

Amy A.

There’s something about Taylor. ❤️

Sophie

Charlotte!

Jamie

Charlotte!

Iroshiyan

Regan Freaking Gallagher 💯

Jamie

Such a tough choice! But my girl Caroline has my heart

Maeba

CHARLOOOOOOTTE THOMPSON !!!

Caroline

As a Caroline, I should say Caroline, but I’ve gotta say Hannah!

Paulina

Definitely Charlotte!

Cass

One favorite...oh my. I think I need to give DTAS some love and go with Ellie Beckett. Very honorable mentions are Caroline, Rose, and Maya.

Skylar Briggs

It's a toss up between Charlotte and Sutton

Gabi

Abbie! (Ok I know it’s just prints but still 😋). If not, Taylor!

Taylor

rose!

Grace

Charlotte MR universe

Cam R

Sutton! & Brooke!

MK

Ahhhhhh!!!! How am I supposed to choose just one? I love Mia Sharpe. She is so badass.

Breanna VanDyke

I’m going to have to go with Charlotte Thompson, in every universe 😂

Krista B

Carolyn Parker

Ahrisuzumiya

Regan hands down. She's so relatable and just so loveable.

Daphne

Has to be Caroline for me. How she just treasures Hannah and Abbie makes me so happy.

Libby

Charlotte!

Lucía Velez

Right now it's probably Rose

Chus Lerma

Caroline Parker! Mu absolute favorite!!!

Oceia

Charlotte Thompson in any and every universe 😩

Sithara

Autumn fucking Alton!

Rishal

Caroline, hands down.

Mtc

Hannah dalton always and forever

Lisa Tillery

Caroline Parker! Thank you mysterious benefactor!

Nicole

Rose Elliston!

Laura McKenna

The one, the only, madam president Charlotte Thompson 🥰🥵

Allison

Brooke 🩵

Shelly

Charlotte 🫡 Tough to pick from so many great characters but she’s a boss babe!

Sierra

Gianna!

Casey Cressman

Charlotte Thompson in any universe! Caroline is a very close second.

Chris

Caroline. My first and forever favorite.

sandrakb

Caroline! 🙌

Bron

How can you make me choose from my babies? If I have to choose… Regan but ask me tomorrow and I’ll likely have a different answer.

Iris

You should win by virtue of Brooke being your favorite ❤️

Constantina

Tough one! Going with Charlotte Thompson. Happy Holidays- very sweet gesture ❄️

Jess Bullock

What a sweet thing for them to do! 🩷 I'm going to have to pick Caroline. I just adore her

AJT

Caroline

Iris

Newbie coming in for the win!

Iris

Caroline Parker ❤️

Abigail

Tough to pick between either half of my favorite couple (WYLEI) but I think I have to go Caroline!

lea

Will always adore Gianna the most🥹❤️ Regan and Sutton a close second tho

Megan

It’s so hard to decide between Riley, Gianna, Sutton, and Charlotte! 😩😩😩

Rebecca

Charlotte Thompson!

a

gotta be my girl rose

M

Without a doubt Regan!!!

Luce

Regan!!! <3 I'm very biased as the Snowball Effect was what indoctrinated me into the rest of the HCLU

Andi

Easily Charlotte Thompson😍

KT

Ugh. Choosing is hard. Charlotte Thompson is #1 because of her fantastic character development, no matter the universe. But he warmth, kindness, and gallantry of Caroline Parker puts her a hair's breadth behind Charlotte.

Andrea

Autumn

Angie

Gianna no middle name Makinen

sarrah

THIS IS AMAZING! This one is sooo hard for me because my first love was Gianna, then Charlotte, but I think my softest spot belongs to Rose ❤️❤️

Makenzie

This is so amazing! I love it! All your girls are amazing...but my gal Regan will always be my #1

Vicky Church

Gianna! But I love them all! ☺️

Lauren

my number 1 in every universe: charlotte thompson

Lucie

Today it’s Emma! Ask me again tomorrow!

Danielle Peddie

Tricky, but would have to go with Abbie!

Elle Dee

I'm going with the OG - Charlotte "Stunning" Thompson.

Kat

Maya, with Caroline being a very close second

Grasshopper

It has to be Sutton Spencer for me

Tebbers

Ellie because of how relatable she is

Amanda

Omg this is so hard but I have to say Charlotte Thompson. So many close seconds! Honestly, Autumn for me is also right up there!

Zaury Suarez

Charlotte from Midnight Rain.

Dianne

Sutton 🧡

Rodney Lopez

Despite my undying love for Charlotte, my favorite character is Ellie Beckett! When I was younger, I was almost exactly like her only with computers instead of biology.

Sue R.

Caroline Parker 🔥

Becks

Charlotte Thompson! 🥹

Amber Mitchell

Caroline Parker will forever have my heart. Rose is growing on me tho.

iamerikaonline

Absolutely Regan because she is HILARIOUS.

Eden

Midnight Rain version of Charlotte! But also flirting with the idea of Caroline the more acquainted I get..

Tiki

Ellie and Riley 😭

deshanay Goldsmith

I feel like my fantasy boo Taylor never gets any love

Alondra

Caroline 🫶🏽

kb

I adore Autumn and Maya. But in the printed/published HCLU it has to be Gianna.

Eden

And thank you to both the anonymous sponsor and Haley for this gift.

Amelia

Ahh hard to choose but charlotte?

Tanya

Charlotte will forever live rent free in my mind....which am I kidding?! All the HCLU ladies love rent free!

Nat Chen

Gianna and Riley are my favorite!

RomanceReadingJess

Midnight Rain Charlotte. There is something truly special about the version of Charlotte that knows exactly what it’s like to lose Sutton.

Lisa C

Charlotte Charlotte Charlotte

Kim Bond

Well, I'm currently listening to In The Long Run most evenings - Taylor is such a gem! But of course I would think that, being a workaholic cat lover who lives in a cottage. Regards.

Kris Nixon

Regan Girlfriend-Material Gallagher

Betts

Caroline 🫶🏼

Carol

Who doesn't want a Regan Freaking Gallagher in their life!

Bridget

charlotte, my beloved.

Jamie B

Charlotte, all the way 🙌🏼

Miranda

This is a tough choice. I’d have to say my favorites are Charlotte and Gianna equally!

Mari

Caroline Parker 🫶

Dionna

This is tough but I’d say Caroline with Gianna being a close 2nd.

Ashley Hasson

CHARLOTTE is my girl! Hands down. And Emma is a close second 🤣

Sarah Elizabeth Davis

Autumn Alton for sure. Charlotte Thompson and Sutton Spencer equal second 🙂

Sarah Elizabeth Davis

Autumn is so underrated but I’m falling in love with her as she’s starting to unravel in IKYWT.

Sithara

I second this!

anna

i simply don’t think i can choose between them all, but riley and gianna have a special place in my heart😭

grinzme

Senator Charlotte Thompson!

fr0st

Caroline, no hesitation

Kelsey Langdon

This is a nearly impossible question to answer. I feel like it changes constantly, but if I had to pick right now I think it’s probably Ellie. I feel a kinship with her for so many reasons.

Jenni

Caroline from When you least expect it! It was probably the 3rd Sapphic book I EVER read and basically made me go "This. This is what I've been looking for"

WaitWhat

Riley. easy.

Anna S.

Midnight Rain Sutton

Lisa

I love maya and Abbie in the current Patreon stories! But published works my favorite character is Gianna

Lindsey

This is honestly so hard because all I love all of the characters in one way or another but if I HAD to choose one it would have to be Charlotte in any universe!

Raquel

Caroline

Heather V

Charlotte will always be my favorite

jojo

Caroline

MK

Her story’s still going but Rose has quickly become my favorite :) For finished stories: Charlotte

Fiorella LR

Can’t decide between Regan and Maya, it’s a tough one!

Allison

🤣 I love my girl Brooke!

Dino Odino

Midnight Rain Charlotte 💜

Jay Shah

Charlotte!!!!!!

JA’Lissa “Jax” M

Rose is my favorite because she is so complex and multi-layered. I can't help but root for her and wish her all the love.

Amber

I like Ellie. I feel her in my soul.

Shelley S.

Caroline Parker! I identify with her vibe and energy!

Meg

Caroline Parker

Aly

Caroline Parker!

Egie

Caroline!!! ❤️

Diana

Charlotte followed closely by Caroline :)

Isa

Charlotte Elizabeth Thompson 🫠

Mary Hollis Baird

Charlotte! So capable and so bad at feelings 🥹

Lindsay W

Caroline Parker!

Patricia

Riley and Gianna

Emily Russell

I am really loving Rose although her story is still unfolding! For completed stories, Charlotte is one of my favorites! I feel like I resonate with these two the most!

Shula

Gianna is my favorite character from the HCLU

Sheila

Sutton

Lori

Caroline!

Allison

So hard to pick but I’ll go with my first HCLU love, Caroline

Brigi

Charlotte! And I’m especially loving Charlotte from guilty as sin. Hello elevator scene

April Elle.

Charlotte - and all the characteristics she possesses from her power, to her vulnerability, not to mention her growth from TWW to MR.

Mar

Hannah!

DJ

Regan Freaking Gallagher

fruity judy

Brooke was my first relatable favorite. not literally relatable, but in a ~vibes~ way.

Ashley

Charlotte!!

Brittany

it’s always going to be charlotte

J

Taylor

phinx

That is a a conundrum of a question and a very loaded one, because everything you've written has been so frigging amazing. As you very well know haley I fell inlove with Sutton and Charlotte in those who wait Its why I fell inlove with reading But everything else after after including the bonus chapters and bonus books from here. Midnight Rain And guilty as sin The fact you gave Sutton's best friends their own love story. Reghan and emma Autumn and maya The fact that Charlotte's colleague's got theirs. BTW brilliantly done. Caroline and Hannah Abbie and Rose They're all fucking perfect excuse the language There's no one character you can just choose from everything you write is magic. But! If I had to choose it would be Charlotte and Sutton I can't choose between the two 🙊

Cherry Yeung

So hard to choose, they’re all my fave?? But I have to go with my gut and say Gianna 😍

Stacey Thurston-Woods

This is a tough one, but I think I’ll have to go with Charlotte.

Sara

This is so hard!!! Like, pick-your-favorite-Greek-god kind of hard! But since I've been religiously reading Haley in chronological order, I'll go with Charlotte

Deborah Harrington

Charlotte—always, but even more so in Midnight Rain.

Pau

I think its Hanah and Caroline for me :)

Emily

Always Charlotte

AA

Brooke and Taylor

D

From the published work I think either Gianna or Carline.

SStone

Such a difficult question to answer haha. I think I’ll have to go with Sutton

charlie

Charlotte. Always. Although coming up a close second is Rose.

Emma S

Charlotte! With rose as a second!

Jessica Shervanick

I've written this comment over and over trying to decide on my absolute favorite bc I love them all so much lol But I'm gonna have to go with Caroline as #1

Jules

It’s a very tough choice but I think I’d have to pick Caroline as my favourite.

Dee

My favorite all the Time is Charlotte the beautiful

Gio

Very tough choice! I love so many of your characters that I would give up half of my library in exchange for the HCLU! At the end of the day though it has to be Charlotte, in any and every universe, followed and complemented by Sutton of course, they are just so perfect all the time!

Júlia

I’ve got a soft spot for Charlotte…

Mary

Tough one, but have to go with Brooke - she deserves a few votes

Eden Daniel Erez

I love both Gianna and Ellie so much!! Their friendship reminds me of mine and my best friend. Of how we started to talk and how we protecting each other.

Emery Kavanagh

I forgot to add how wonderful it was for this person to do so. ❤️

Karo

I'm torn between Caroline Parker and Brooke B Watson

Kate

Gianna. I love a patient queen.

Kaley

Regan she is such complex character that comes out of left field at first you think she’s just Sutton a chaotic best friend but little do you know she struggles with issues that she would never bring up I love it

Divya

Regan with Maya a close second

Jada

Charlotte and Autumn!

Conny

Caroline

Andrea

Caroline and Hannah

Gabby

Charlotte 🫶🏼

Iris

Brooke is so0o0o0 cute!

KJ

Caroline

bbyblu

i’ve gotta say Charlotte!

Hannah

rose

Leah Dembinski

Gianna is probably first, then Regan. They’re all so wonderful! Abby is fast becoming a fave as well

Biz

Charlotte! Especially Midnight Rain Charlotte

Kymberly

It’s hard to pick! Probably Sutton but Caroline is a fast second

Cyn

I love them all, but I have a soft spot for Regan.

Nikki

Charlotte (only because you asked for 1)

jordan

Sutton 🔥

Courtney

Sutton🤤🔥

Vesta Charleshouse

Caroline Parker. 100% hands down brilliant character

Kay

Sutton!

Siobhan Hind

Has to be Charlotte in Midnight Rain 😍🔥

Aylen

Charlotte Elizabeth Thompson

Heather

Caroline

Gabi

Charlotte 💜

Krista

Definitely Brook B Watson! And Autumn as a close second

Tarah

Charlotte! She is so delulu most the time I'm just laughing throughout the book😂

Jen D

Charlotte Thompson - loving Guilty as Sin! Happy holidays 😊

jill

team caroline! 💪

Cassi

Regan

Julia

Charlotte <3

May Walker

Regan fs highly relatable being clumsy and ADHD, Caroline is a close second

Lauren

I can't choose so I'm going with Hamish

sei

Sutton ❤️

Tiffany Erin

Charlotte!! ❤️ I also really love Regan!

Bella P

Regan, she’s one of a kind. Charlotte in Guilty as Sin is a close second

Taylor

Charlotte💘

XJ

Charlotte!

M P

Autumn!

Julianna Duso

So hard to choose, but I’m going go Mia.

Camille C.

Might be too late for this but just wanted to say Caroline Parker (because I'm an absolute sucker for simps) 😌👏

Jess

My favourite is Charlotte ❤️

Buba

Stunning Charlotte ❤️

anna

i’d like to change my answer to sutton😂😂

Emma

My fav is Charlotte!

Emma

Oh and Ellie! Thank you so much for writing a wonderful autistic character

Divya Rustagi

So hard to choose between Caroline and Gianna 🙇 given I just saw the amazing Trix's artwork I'll say Caroline

Divya Rustagi

Oh no someone said MR Charlotte I'm changing to that!

Nicole

Gianna

Caoimhe

Not sure if I'm too late here, and I've only read WYLEI and BTE (then *immediately* joining the Patreon, naturally) - but it has to be Caroline!