Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

David from Anarchospirituality joins Breht to discuss Buddhism, Anarchism, Marxism, and more! After an introduction section, David gives a talk on Buddhism and Anarchism, and then he and Breht discuss the talk before launching into a wide-ranging discussion on anarchism v. marxism, Kropotkin, the Buddhist conception of Karma, individual and collective improvement and struggle, Darwinian evolution, differences between western and eastern approaches to spirituality, the question of revolutionary violence within Buddhism, and much more! 

Learn more about Anarchospirituality and his work HERE 

Check out Turn Leftist's interview HERE 

Check out Breht's talk on Buddhism and Marxism HERE 

Check out Red Menace's episode on Conquest of Bread HERE 

Files

Comments

Cookie

have a feeling this is gonna be mindblowing :D

White Hat Productions

Breht, could you do an episode on what it is actually like in Tibet right now and what it is like actually practicing Buddhism in a Socialist State? How it works with the government and laws and all? If you already did one and I missed it, I'm sorry.

Cookie

I want to chime in on that and suggest the writings in particular of Donald Lopez, who is a critic of a lot of journalism on Tibet re: the cultural revolution, Shangri-La myths and western fantasies of Tibet. Check out the book Prisoners of Shangri-La.

Cookie

Also, re: violence, the Sanskrit canon has a lot of “edge cases” where the Buddha discusses reasons why a bodhisattva might be required to violate conventional morality. There is at least one jataka story (past life account) where the Buddha had a trolley problem: in order to save the lives of a hundreds, he killed a murderous pirate.

Queermunist

What I still can't wrap my mind around is how karma is supposed to interact with self loathing. If my suffering is the product of my karmic debt, then I have no one to blame but myself. That's an extremely toxic mentality that I escaped with self love, but since the self is an illusion I'm really just loving a ghost? And if I just accept my suffering, why would I try to make my life better? Where's the self care?

Cookie

Queermunist you seem to have some quandaries that aren’t strictly about Buddhism itself, and more about life and suffering and self and maybe therapy is a better place some of these questions. I’m a licensed clinical social worker though and I want to at least address a couple things: 1. In Buddhism all blaming is victim blaming, because we’re all victims of samsara. There’s a mind-training slogan in Tibet: “drive all blames into one.” It’s literally the same attitude as “don’t hate the player, hate the game.” The player in this case being you. You don’t have to “blame” yourself for your karma just like I imagine you’d never blame someone else for their imperfect ways of we all try to cope with wage slavery or crushing debt. It's often more helpful to focus on the general karma of beings (which is to suffer, do fucked up things, harm others, and suffer more I.E. in the example of how inevitable it is that in order to eat we kill bugs through agriculture)) than to nitpick and get really hard on yourself. Getting discouraged and self-loathing is considered a huge distraction or devation in the Buddhist path, akin to but sort of opposite in flavor from getting really grandiose and narcissistic. The result is the same: excessive focus on concepts about yourself rather than *Doing* realistic things to improve your karma and life. 2. RE: “if i just accept my suffering, why would I try to make my life better?” The 4 noble truths (and Dialectical Behavior Therapy) both show how paradoxically, accepting the truth of your suffering is what leads to being motivated and able to actually change it. Accepting that beings are embroiled in chaos and misery, truly internalizing the knowledge of your own and other's existential torment, is what spurs us to do something to change ourselves. Rolling over and giving up, or succumbing to the ideological extreme of nihilism, is not the same as acceptance. In fact it's a sort of denial of reality, a denial of the little power you do have. The link below is from the woman who invented DBT. I use this video often with clients in therapy to begin describing what radical acceptance is. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OTG7YEWkJFI&t=14s&ab_channel=BorderlinerNotes In general, it kind of seems like your qualms about a lot of conceptual details is clouding your ability to do practical things that align with being a good person. That's really all that actually matters in Buddhism. Please feel free to reach out for more help. Cpcoppersmith@gmail.com

Cookie

Also re: loving a self-as-ghost, in Buddhism we practice seeing all phenomena as dreamlike, but practically functionally we acknowledge the self is real and consistent from day to day. When we talk about no-self or anatman in Buddhism, we never deny that you are physically real, that you feel a constant sense of your own continuity from day to day and moment to moment. It's only from the perspective of the ultimate truth (illusion) that you "don't exist" so to speak. From the perspective of relative truth (karma) you very much exist and your actions matter. IF you've seen the Matrix it's really similar: Neo's actions within the Matrix still matter, even though it's ultimately an illusion. He can be harmed, he can harm others, he can find the right or wrong people, etc. Let’s say you have a nightmare that your non-existent child dies. If I came to you in the nightmare and offered you reassurance, love and comfort, you might feel relief and cry on my shoulder. If, however, someone shook your shoulder and woke you up from the nightmare, you might feel disturbed, but you wouldn’t say "thank you for saving my child's life." You never had a child, it was purely a hellish phantasm of suffering. If anything, you'd say "thanks for waking me up." Until you’re capable of waking up, (enlightenment to the ultimate truth) all you can do is work with the karma of the nightmare: so, offer yourself and others reassurance, love, care, etc. Your actions matter.

Rev Left Radio

Ive always wanted to cover this issue, but have not because I need a very specific guest that can speak to issue in a really in-depth and principled way. That has always held me back on this topic in particular, but ill check out Lopez now! Might be just the guest ive been looking for!

Eric Laleer

This episode has given me a lot of direction in the past week. This talk led me to the turnleftist interview where David talked about his life. It moved me so much I set up a talk with David via his anarchospirituality page. I think I've found a path for my spiritual emptiness. I've come to realize I need to engage the world spiritually, as my functionally atheistic worldview is leading to a lot of aimlessness and depression for me honestly. Animist traditions have been speaking to me for the past couple years and I've decided it's time to dive in.

Cookie

Hell yeah!

Nika

Love the series on different religions, is there one on Judaism in the works? Something on the history of Bundism and Doikayt would be really awesome, not enough people know about it.

Philip M

Would really appreciate some response to my DM, I think. Graham Priest would be a very interesting guest.

Rev Left Radio

I would love to start moving into Judaism. I know perhaps the least about it, but am very very interested in learning more, especially about some of its mystical branches.