Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

SECRET SONG Reaction: São Paulo (Night 3) (Patreon)

Published:
2023-11-27 03:46:44
Edited:
2023-12-21 01:54:21
Imported:
2026-09
Tags:

Content

on that Holiday Collection TV shit agaaiiiinnnnnnn 🎄

with a side of heavy Rep clowning, but look, we *did* know... in our souls... that it wasn't coming today 🙊 

Thank you so much to all of you for watching along with us all year long, we love you SO much! We will be doing our re-fathomings again from next week, which we hope you will continue to enjoy! 🖤

Files

Comments

Morgan Sanderson

I allowed the clowns to pull me into the clownery and ended up a clown

Maddy Stephens

Glad we all clown together 🐍🖤🤡

August

Don’t worry y’all,Rep is coming at midnight instead. Totally not in denial. She’s coming 🐍😅

brenda 🌸

“We knew in our souls” *put the rep merch on JUST IN CASE 🤡✌🏼 hahaha love you girls, immediately watching this reaction

Freyastendal

Wow you ladies are fast! And i wanted to ask if you could upload the surprise song template emily use?

brenda 🌸

Also Bonny had predicted these surprise songs as the last night of eras tour in previous videos! ✨nice!!!✨

Sara Rose

I'm all too unwell that we don't have another show until February 7th. 😭 Thank goodness we'll have re-fathomings to get us through! Thanks for all you do for us besties! ❤️

chatsandreacts

Hey!!! We use the template done by @SpotifySwiftie on twitter, they update it after each show too 🥰

Sophie

I can't wait for you to refathom MY SHOW next week ... A superior pair of songs if I do say so myself! 🤩

Amanda Mittelman

It’s the way I’ve been sitting it bed with really bad anxiety looking for something to watch to help calm me down when I get this notification. I hope you know these videos mean so much more than you could ever know to us

Inigo joaquin

“There will be no explanation” AND THE EMPIRSE STATE BUILDINGS POST?

chatsandreacts

Oh I hope this video can make you feel just a little better at the very least 🖤 sending you love Amanda!!

Alex Nibblett

Thank you so much for these you guys! I love seeing your chats while reacting, it's so fun to just watch and have a good time :D

Lauren Levitt

I didn’t believe it would happen today, but I am clowning for Rep TV announcement on New Year’s Day and release in February

nicole

Did you guys hear that she almost accidentally said “during the Rep… Eras tour”?! Reputation is clearly on her mind 😅

chatsandreacts

YES OMG WE DIDNT FATHOM UNTIL AFTER!! And then she said "you got in my head" STOPPP its a lot to know she knew about the clowning 😂

Ellie Vannest

in 2024, she’ll sing 164 secret songs!! (unless she adds more show dates of course)

Dara Sofia

We are absolute clowns lol!! But honestly not disappointed and other people shouldn’t too. We literally got 2 re-recordings this year, we’re really fed compared to other fandoms. It’s great though that most Swifties are taking this like a champ.

Drew

It’s time to go….. on a world tour she’s a MASTERMIND

Julia Fisher

I need y'all to know that as soon as she said she was resetting secret songs in 2024 I thought "omg Bonny and Emily could get ivy!" - manifesting already for you besties

Takara

I can’t believe Taylor slipped and almost said Rep tour 🤣 we got to her even if the clowning was wrong. I am manifesting Holiday Collection TV still 🎄 I can’t wait for more refathomings! Especially once y’all get into Travis era!!!

Rodrigo

I was there tonight and I love that we got an evermore song because it's my favorite album and I was wearing an evermore tshirt 🧡🌲

Daniela Lucero

I knew she would make us look like 🤡 but my theory is that she will wait until Melbourne on Feb 16th (112 days theory) to “do something bad” and release Rep that same day. Song o’clock in Melbourne will be early Friday morning on the US east coast and mid day Europe

angelina

Did you guys hear her little slip up of “rep” instead of “eras”?🤣

Megan

YES!! Really hoping that Bonny/Emily can get Ivy, Coney Island, Long Story Short, or Cowboy Like Me in the Australia shows! Evermore stans unite 🧡

Tess7

I was pulled into the clowning so hard lol all the tweets and IG posts by people in the TS universe. The Eiffel Tower even tweeted lol oh well. Ironically, I just rewatched your evermore birthday surprise video today. I laugh so hard at Bonny saying Karlie Kloss is not a mansion with a view 😂 while fathoming It’s Time To Go and Right Where You Left Me. I love that video. So it was fun to hear the song tonight

Mia Morgan

AHHHH i'm so excited to see you refathom Foxborough Night 2 and the Question...? speech...that was my show and it was WILD ☔️

River

I love that Bonny was singing It's Time To Go for a few bars before it HIT :-D I need to let you know that everyone on the discord was immediately like "this is how the girls can still get IVY"!

sydney

Obsessed with you guys and all you do, and Bonny’s reaction to “it’s time to go” is me every time an evermore song is played and im not in attendance lmao

kate

okay so i’ve been thinking — since she said it would be a surprise song reset maybe she will finally change some setlist things when she comes back in february?? whether that means IDSB and a rep announcement right away or even some more vault things and different choices for the 4 recent ones, that she’s setting it up to maybe finally follow through on saying she could change it😂😂 it might not change but i think if she were to change some things the new year would be the time to do it

Farah Canicosa

I think REP TV will come out in 2025. Because that would be YEAR OF THE SNAKE!! which means we'll get TS11 in 2024!!

learc

Can't believe we've been reacting to shows since march and its now the end of tour dates for 2023 ! Was so much fun to be apart of this 🥰 can't wait to continue the re-fathomings next week 💫 xx

Lish Marie

It would be fun to put on YouTube a mashup of some of your reactions of the most offensive secret song moments from this past year as like an end of year eras tour wrap up! ❤️

Joe Weaver

Next week's re-fathoming is a fun one. It's the weekend we got Question...? & the "I've never been happier" comment. Then after that it's New York weekend with all that craziness. May was a wild month on the tour.

Jenn Hamel

We swerved to the holiday collection in that video so many times, it’s iconic 😂😂😂

Mad Esme at the Plaza Athénée

A superior pairing of songs! It's Time to Go is so appropriate to end the American (North & South) leg of tour, since she's going away until 2024. At the same time, I disagree that it doesn't apply to her life currently. First there is the allusion to her masters, "He's got my past frozen behind glass but I've got me." She sure showed those evil S men exactly what she can do on her own. But also, I think it can apply to her current relationship situation. "Sometimes giving up is the strong thing Sometimes to run is the brave thing Sometimes walking out is the one thing That will find you the right thing" These lyrics can so clearly be applied to her relationship with Joe in hindsight. Her being strong enough and brave enough to leave Joe is the one thing that found her the right thing with Travis.

Jenny M

I wonder if Taylor is going to announce TS11 rather than announcing Rep TV in February next year.

Brandon Yip

The next time Taylor is going to be on a stage, it'll happen at around 5:00 in the morning in the US 😂

Persef

I GOT ITS TIME TO GO ON MY SHOW 😭😭😭😭😭 still cant believe it

Astrid Cedeño

Omg Bonny your reaction to it’s time to go killed me 😆

Jessie

DID YOU HEAR HER SAY "THE REP...ERAS TOUR" ????????

Yasmin

The secret songs reset just added a new layer of excitement!! Bring on Sydney N2 😎

kyra andrea

did you guys notice she accidentally said rep instead of eras (tour) and corrected herself hehehe

Anon_987

Loved this video!!! 💕💕

Jenna Bolmgren

That would actually be good marketing on YT for people to join your Patreon!

Janie

I just feel like it would be super goofy to drop a Christmas album on her birthday/half way into December! If it happens this year (and I hope it does) it feels like it has to be announced this week or it’s not happening 😩

Aaron D in SF

I love when you guys sing the first few lines and then process the song name. Can so relate.

Ana Noronha

I was there and it was the best night of my life

Allison

What if she announces Rep TV on the 16/2 and it drops after the show or during the show that night? There will be no explanation only reputation 🐍🖤 This would fit with the 112 day theory 🤣

ttpd-24

Hey ladies! Here is an idea, could we fathom a couple of the songs on the Eras Tour Pre Show Playlist. Some are soo telling. Eg. Florence and the Machine - King, Suki Waterhouse -Moves, King Princess -For my Friends . :) Just a thought

Julien Heideck

Have a nice day everyone! Love you besties! 💙

Alexander Toetsch

I think long story short is her hardest song to perform live.

Emelie

I saw a video on the rep outfit and they said that they don’t think she’ll change the outfit bc her reputation hasn’t changed throughout all those years… makes sense to me 🤷🏼‍♀️😄

Jessica

We’ll truly know Rep TV (or a new drop) is coming when Taylor changes her display picture back to Midnights 😆

Maya

ooh myy goood you could get ivy, mirrorball, cowboy like me, coney island, clean, is it over now, getaway car, .... I can't. But do you think she'll have the same rules for 2024? Because my shows are in July....

Jess.

Also, now we know officially that she and Travis have been dating since August, so that gives lots of insight into the Mexico surprise songs

Maya

wait but Christmas Tree Farm is hers already?

Emmie Kruger

I didn't even think about the fact that she could announce Rep but just not on tour....I mean I don't think she will but suddenly I don't feel all the way safe...

Caleb Allen

Ivy. Feb 25th. Please. I require it. And since Bonnie and Emily are at that show (?) I feel like it is MEANT TO BE!

Lisa

Bonny!!! She fathomed your calculations!!!😂

raheel

I will never get over Bonnie realizing it is „it’s time to go“ forever playing in a loop in my brain 😂😂😂

Darren Robison

the Empire State Building has some serious explaining to do

Zosia Dabrowski

Omg I listened to the lyrics of Florence’s King a couple days ago and wowee I can do vividly see how Taylor would have related to many parts of it

Zosia Dabrowski

Hoping for this as this is my show and would be the best night of my life 🤞🏻🤞🏻🤞🏻

Allison

I wish it was my show lol

Jule

The only reason she’s resetting is actually so I can get mirrorball at my show next year. I still haven’t recovered from her playing my two stan songs mirrorball and this is me trying at the very first weekend of the tour.

Hannah

Guysss if she announces Rep in February it might happen at one of your showssss!?! ILLEGAL!

Hollie

What if there will be no explanation, there will just be reputation and on the Friday show in either Tokyo, Melbourne or Sydney Karyn just pops up with the announcement that RepTV is out at midnight!!!

Alberto

Besties I don’t know if you already pointed this out in your videos but I feel like the biggest easter egg hinting at Holiday Collection TV is in the Mine TV snippet reel that she posted a few days before SNTV, where she holds the vinyl in a reaaaally weird way, first showing the light blue thumb (which then turned out to be a hint to 1989tv) and then two random fingers, one green and one red (christmas , colours, in the video it’s very clear). I’ve been thinking of this since then, but guys I really think we could get it this year 🥲🎄🎄 No one talk to me if I hear Christmases When you were mine tv in a few weeks 🤚🏼

Katie K

Bonny, I think we should just let your soul guide us completely in our Rep clowning!! So just let us know when you feel it and then we can get excited 😂🤡

Alberto

Also in the Karma MV coffee we have 1989tv at 8 (announcement in august), rep at 2 (announcement/release in february?) and then the time is between 11 and 12, and this would be perfect for the holiday collection, given that it would make sense for it to be released around the very end of november/beginning of december. Why would the clock hands point at that specific time if nothing happened? 🤡🎅🏼

Richard

God I really hate that word clowning. She will release Rep TV when she does. Fans should just enjoy 1989 TV for now. She gave us a lot since 2019. I am an OG from Tim McGraw and I just enjoy what she gives me and don't complain if Style is different and complain about Slut is not people expected because that is Taylor, she makes a song different than you expect a lot. It is her art. So I just enjoy what she gives me with it.

Kara Mills

All I could think is "what if they get stay stay stay again"

Jentallygirl

When she said she would reset the songs in 2024, she also said kind of quickly that there were still a lot of songs she wants to get through… so I think your short list of illegals is probably mostly still in play! 🙅‍♀️🫶

Lively_Ash

I don’t think she would do a holiday collection until the other re-records are out plus she’d be overshadowing Jason & Sabrina’s current Christmas stuff.

Rick V

Hey Guys, I really think this relationship with Travis is the main reason she is resetting her surprise songs in 2024. She’s happy and she wants to play happy songs. Therefore she gets to choose happier songs to play, at least most of the time. Just a suggestion.

Rick V

Now you guys get to fathom Ivy, and I get to laugh again when I watch your reactions in Aus when she doesn’t play it for you. Sorry it’s too funny.

Sarah

Whoa I just listened and yep I agree I can totally see why Taylor has King on the playlist!!

Sofía

y'all are so amazing, thank you for this videos!! It was fun watching your reaction and also to hear your opinions, hahaha the only ones i care about , have a wonderful rest of the year and can't wait for next year!!

Rick V

BTW, thank you for a new word in my vocabulary. “Clowning” as a verb. Probably been around awhile, but I hadn’t heard it used before that way. Anyway, I love you guys.

sofie sandrini

It’s time to go is so fucking good - evermore is just the best album

bisma ♡

is there anywhere we can download the surprise song checklist?

Roxyy

Glad my theory about opening the surprise songs back up in 2024 war right! I always thought she wouldn't just go until there's nothing left

Cristina

No but I need her to play Carolina and Beautiful ghosts...don't care when and where but it needs to happen those songs are so superior and people need to fathom

Jaimie C

thank you so much for these reactions this year! and your refathomings too!! will be back for those to finish off the year. 💖 you'll always have much love for it's time to go from me 🧡 it helped get through a bad time in my work life, and yes i left and found me the right thing. 😊 last night was fun for me - i wasn't fully expecting rep but watched just in case. as soon as she said she was playing Say Don't Go, i screamed at my partner, she's gonna play it's time to go on piano! but it took me about up to the chorus before i fathomed that she actually was playing it.😂 a happy day for me 🎉 evermore forevermore!🤩

F1Swiftie

They aren’t saying she’s re-recording it, just that it could be a secret song on tour.

Laurie Letendre

For 2024 I think it would be really fun if you guys did the Swift Ball predictions for every show! And you could tell us your predictions before filming your reactions to the Secret Songs. I would love that 😊

Jo

8 also refers to the 8th zodiac (Scorpio). 2 means February and 2nd zodiac (Taurus). First Friday in Taurus season is 4/26. That’s when she’ll release rep. Also, the karma music video is all tarot cards!!!!! Look up the justice card and the Devil card. Every scene is inspired by a tarot card. Tarot cards are also all about karma. Once I figured that out, it explained the so much (including the yellow beret, the moon & Saturn, all the infinity symbols). Other clues that point to 4/26 and 2/16 will be in the comments if anyone is curious!

Erica

I look forward to your videos after every show!! I get to relive the fun with you guys 💚

Jo

Clues to 4/26 release: (1) on the lavender haze map, 66 is over South Dakota and national South Dakota day is 4/26; (2) Taylor’s first rep surprise song in 2023 was in April and her 2nd was on the 26th of May at her 26th show; (3) her last rep surprise song in 2023 was paired with Me! - which was released on 4/26; (4) in the anti hero music video, Taylor begins the “everybody agrees” part with the hiss at the 4:26 mark and it lasts for 6 seconds; and (5) “rep tv” shows up in the sand in the lyric video for You Are In Love, which is 4 minutes and 26 seconds song on Spotify.

Jo

Clues to 2/16 announcement: (1) 2/16 fits the 112 day theory; (2) in the bejeweled music video, Danielle calls Taylor a snake and Danielle’s birthday is 2/16; (3) in the I Can See You music video, the computer shows 05/2220 (the slash represents a wire hanging between the numbers) - the music video is date stamped as 7/9 and 222 days after 7/9 is 2/16; (4) the lyric video for You Are In Love shows rep tv in the sand for 70 seconds and 70 days before 4/26 is 2/16; and (5) Taylor posted an Instagram on 10/29 where she says the number “6” in a very roundabout way and includes pictures from the night of 2/16 in 2016.

Ava Jeffs

I screamed so loud when I saw the news on the plane, so happy for you besties 💛 manifesting ivy always!!

Emma

Do you dare to get your hopes up about Ivy again now or will it be too much of a heartbreak if you started really hoping and lost it again?❤️

Miriam

Love you besties! This was such a fun addition this year and I'm so glad it'll continue next year. Thank you for all you do!

Daisy Ramirez

*Taylor starts playing the piano* Em: "this is not Christmas Tree Farm" 😂😂 Bonny's realization of it's time to go playing was everythingggg lol

Sam Briggs

This community/channel is one of my favorite things in my whole life 🩷

Jaime McKee

Imagine getting Call It What You Want (Happy Again Version)?

J R

I hope you vlog the rest of the shows you attend - that last one was SPECTACULAR xo

CamilleC

Bonny fathoming ITTG lyrics in real time was 👌 brain was braining 🤯

Julieta

I think she wants to recreate the “nobody physically saw me for a year” and comeback as she did with rep OG

Erin

mother has me super excited that i could get getaway car now 😭

Jana Grobbelaar

The first thing I thought was imagine if you got stay stay stay again. Not funny but lowkey hilarious.

chatsandreacts

wow this is a great idea, sometimes visuals are blocked on YouTube so I wonder if it would be okay or not! Thanks for the suggestion 💗

Travis

Since we are all looking for Holiday Collection TV - I would love to see you all rewatch and fathom The Making Of Christmas Tree Farm video on YouTube!

Aisha 🖤

Omg Bon 😭😭 no i can't when you realized 😭😭😭😂

Joe Weaver

"Pulling me into my clown" -- Bonny. 😂 you both are so funny.

Joe Weaver

Hmm...depends how many non album songs she does & if we have any new Vaults. But there's 85 shows scheduled so she needs 170 songs if no repeats. There's 204 album songs currently. 45 on the setlist. So she'll have to repeat a few. Or add Debut & rep Vaults!

Emmy

Nah I don't think she's hiding tho, like I think she'll still be seen out with friends and Travis.

Patty Minor

any chance of a reaction of the Eras movie when its available for rental in a couple of weeks?

Joe Weaver

We all did. 300,000 were watching Tess' live stream at one point. 😂

Jenny MacRunnel

I'm so happy she's restarting, it will make it more fun with more to guess from! I hope she does get to the ones she missed this year eventually. Guys--let's all stream Christmas Tree Farm on Dec 1st! It would be so fun for the fandom to get behind her Christmas song!

Joe Weaver

She had to reset them at some point. We're running out of songs. There's only 33 album songs left plus the random non album ones. And there's not a lot of fan favorites left so...can't leave these first shows in 2024 the scraps.

Joe Weaver

ivy in Tokyo. It can't happen again.

Carlie Leistikow

I can’t wait for the re fathoming a to happen. It was a pleasure to clown this year with everyone and I can’t wait to keep going with you all.

JeffreyC

Thank you for doing this for everyone, I joined around 5 months ago & you two are definitely the best people i've found this year

kate

omg thank you for writing all this out!!!! i think this theory makes sooo much sense and the timeline would be so good. somewhat would still love to get karma or ts11 in between these last re-records but also understand that taylor is ready to own her stuff and move past eras completely fresh.. either way, i think we will be well-fed again in 2024🤭🤭🤭

Jo

Ahhh thank you so much for reading this. This has all been living in my head since October and I finally had to get it all out because I haven’t seen anyone else talk about how all these things connect! My friends and I literally have a google doc of easter eggs because there’s just too much at this point. & I’m with you on wishing for TS11 but totally get Taylor may need some sort of division between her era of eras and TS 11.

Erin M

I think you guys need to stitch together all the clips of you saying how much you want ivy, your sadness at losing it, and you’re hope that you might still get it. Post the video to TikTok and maybe you will actually get it

Erin M

I don’t think she will do the holiday album this year, and will save it for next year for two reasons: 1) she has shows in Canada next December, which is a better month to announce than November and would make more sense to sing Christmas songs during the acoustic section; 2) releasing it this year means competing with Travis’s brothers Christmas album for charity which is getting a big swiftie bump

Kaci

Thank you for 2023 ladies! Looking forward to 2024 with yous! Xoxo

jillystein69

Ok what if she adds I did something bad to the set list idk someone clown with meeeee 🤡

Katie

Perhaps she will do a few covers as secret songs

jaydaaa

now that all her songs are fair game for 2024, i really hope she stays away from jump then fall until october 26 and 27 because it’s my number 1 💔

IsolLazy

I need that start of the video energy! 😂❤️

Adélaïde K

We’re really learning words here !!😂

Courtney Graham

Did you guys hear her say at the beginning of acoustic set when she said “Here are Rep tour, something about y’all got that stuck inn my head” then corrected herself and said “The Era Tour”??? It’s hard to hear but she says it. During the guitar speech right at beginning

Breanna Jacques

Even though she is resetting the surprise songs for next year, she did say that there are still some songs that she hasn't done yet that she wants to make sure she gets to. So I feel like she's acknowledging peace and long story short and everything that we still need to hear, so I think she will continue to mix in songs that she has never done with "repeats" from 2023

Alyssa Malecha

I really think she will announce rep in February and it'll come out a couple of months later and then she'll announce debut and that will come out in the summer. And then maybe TS11 in 2025? It's so hard to know for sure since Taylor has gone rogue in the last few years but I don't think she'll announce a brand new album while she's on the eras tour since there would be pressure to add it to the setlist.

Mark 857

Taylor is releasing her extended cut of the Eras movie with Wildest Dreams, The Archer, and Long Live to streaming on her birthday!!

Monica Gaura

I really feel like the rep announcement is going to come on the first show back - as a way of kicking off the 2024 leg with something that’ll garner a lot of hype ✨🖤 Anyway, can’t wait for the re-fathomings! Thanks as usual for all the Taylor content 🥰

GIE

I’m so excited for the eras 2024, not just bc i will finally see it live (could you believe it????) BUT the time difference lol. Live streaming it during night time would be insane for me. I usually watched it during early morning or mid day. 😅

yara abi karam

You guys should check out the 112 days theory it makes soooo muchhhh senseeee it's actually offensive. You should also debunk the Easter eggs on the Spotify billboard announcing Taylor as the top global artist because ... there's an ORANGE VAULT IN THERE !!!

Georgina

I think you guys are really putting the Holiday Collection into the universe! I heard Christmas Tree Farm in 5 different shops around Montreal today

Dswiftie

I love u guys sooooo much!

alex

I‘m so happy that my wish / prediction (I’m sure others expected this as well) of her resetting the surprise songs in 2024 is true like I need the possibility of getting all my favorite songs again!! It’s a necessity🥹🥹 (Blocking out the fear of losing them all over again..)

Bianca Palacios

I went to all 3 shows in Rio, then 25/11 in São Paulo...THANK GOD she didn't announce Rep TV 26/11. 😂 Tried, but couldn't get tickets!! 🥹

Ellie Vannest

omg i never realized that she referred to them as “surprise songs” cuz you guys still call them “secret songs” lol

may el

i did the math for you guys!! so taylor will perform 164 surprise songs in 2024 (if theres no more dates added) and if my calculations are right, she currently has 172 songs she can perform (i didnt count some of the misc songs cause i just dont think she would do them) and if we add at least 5 vault tracks each from rep and debut tv, that would be 182 so some songs wouldnt get to be performed (im guessing songs she did last year)

Nadily Perandin

I was there (it was rare) and I'm actually SOBBING

peachysxnrise

Watching this after may 30th is so funny 💔

CassieLeigh123

It’s 2026 and we’re still clowning 🐍