Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Malevolent: Chapter 249 [POLL]

  • Truth 414
  • Lie 17
  • 2025-01-20
  • 431 votes
{'title': 'Malevolent: Chapter 249 [POLL]', 'choices': [{'text': 'Truth', 'votes': 414}, {'text': 'Lie', 'votes': 17}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 1, 20, 20, 22, 5, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 431}

Comments

Quinn

Tell the truth!!! Yorick says that Alia “knew much about Mother Darkness and her desire for the talisman” Alia can write that down if Arthur lies!!! Alia can also “see into the hearts of men,” so she can almost certainly tell if Arthur is lying. Just tell them it was MD and that she wanted the talisman. Revealing that info doesn’t mean exposing their plans or Lilith or anything else. Arthur can relay almost everything that happened with the hag/witch without revealing anything of their greater plan. “Idk man, we went into this cave/tunnel and got stabbed by this hag but we used her medallion to revive me and we killed her so now her mom hates us and we want to keep the talisman because it’s powerful and can be useful” (insert how it’s healing properties can help *everyone* in their party, giving them an extra bonus in “showing” how much they care about their party)

growingdark

the “truth” will come out eventually anyway, so let’s go for it…we don’t know what Alia knows. but she for sure Knows.

Quinn

Precisely. (Also wondering/slightly concerned that she may know about John lol)

Eli Davis

I feel like if we lie Arthur will be offed again and that will probably reveal more than if we just tell them the truth

growingdark

oh yes! I just hope this isn’t a trap.……please Arthur use your brain you have two

maya.exe

Alia has the potential to be Lie Detector SupremeTM and we don’t know enough about her to comfortably lie and get away with it. Plus, there is enough to our story where we can tell the truth and not reveal the larger plot going on with Arthur + John.

alicyn

truth, 100%. we’ve already basically be told we made the wrong long game move with the talisman. lets not burn more bridges.

Rianne Wright

I think we’ve got to start being a bit more truthful here. We need more allies, and lying to the only people who we have to trust right now just seems counterproductive. We just burned our bridge with Mother Darkness so we’d probably be wise to try and keep the few remaining allies that we have.

keyraven

Telling them the truth could put them in danger. If they decide to stick by our side, and help us, it's not going to end well for them. Remember the Butcher, and Noel? Keeping them at arms length is best for everyone's safety.

Nicky

BJ lives to sow doubt and uncertainty. Don’t take his opinion on things too seriously / too close to heart.

Sasha

truth. we need allies. no more burnt bridges

Raven Fritz

100% Truth, but I still can't believe we kept the Talisman, that's a powerful and angry mother

Luna_de_maria

I'm so glad we're all on the truth side this week after last week's poll really screwed us. Agree with eveyone, no more burnt bridges, let's make allies

Thaelia

In previous truth vs. lie choices, truth has almost always been the right call. Coming clean with Yellow about the Glass of Cana, telling the truth to Daniel, etc. Also, we’re like 15 minutes into this journey and Vale is already suspicious of us, and Alia is already asking questions about MD. That’s not great. We don’t want to get caught in a lie, so I think we need to stick as close to the truth as possible. We can tell the truth about MD and the talisman without mentioning anything about Lilith, the day of wrath, or our intentions the Blackstone. Plus didn’t we establish that Alia can tell when people are lying?

Alexi

overcompensating for fumbling mother darkness so hard. lol

Ochy Dochy

Besty please help, our ex is batshit bananas

Oliver Byrne

I’m wondering if she’d keep the truth to herself if we were to lie to Vale. It’s a little early to be certain, but Alia has enough mystery surrounding her presence that I think that she has a different purpose for the journey. Something that Sir Vale and Antoine aren’t privy too.

Marina Bennett

Fish got me to flip to truth (not that it’s even remotely close lol) but we don’t know what was said while Arthur/John and MD were talking, he also went off on his own after she left. Sir Vale may already know everything or nothing at all, but this feels like a test.

alice🍒

guys I think the bridge with mother darkness was already burned when we killed her daughter😂

Krys Ren

Keeping the talisman was a mistaaaaaaaaaaake

Quinn

Precisely ✨ There was no saving us from her wrath, regardless of whether or not we kept the talisman — plus, Arthur was sassy as Hell from the start, so we definitely weren’t going to win her over in any way whatsoever 😂

Graham - Visceral-Viscera

can we not just say "she's a hag who tried to kill me and wants me dead but she can't" a half truth?