Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 343903113.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

Over the last 3 weeks I have tested 8 different pancake motors and they all have one thing in common. They tend to get really hot when they have to drive an extruder pushing more than 30mm3 of filament. So hot that over time it would melt the carriage when it was printed in PLA/PETG and also hot enough that for fast printing the headroom of ABS/ASA would be pretty small. Too small for me since I want to push my printer to it's limits!

So I decided to evaluate different partners that offer 3D printing services for SLS sintered nylon parts. Nylon is heat resistant up to 154°C, so basically before a part would melt, the motor would lose all of its torque. It's also pretty cheap, I got all the parts for about $20 + shipping. Which was not as expensive as I thought it would be. Also, since nylon has a lower density, these parts are about 20% lighter.

I am still waiting for three other SLS sintered carriages that I ordered from different manufacturers.

My goal is to test the parts over the next 6 weeks and choose a partner to recommend in the BOM for the upcoming T250 beta release.

Files

Previews only

Comments

Z-Man23

Do they have options for different material inserts as well? Those look like brass. I haven't done any research into insert types myself, just a question for you.

Garry

will pa6-cf be better, i have some.

Andrii B

What about Nylon Carbon Fiber filament? I have a local brand that produces Nylon CF 10%. It is claimed to be lighter than regular Nylon. I assume that the difference will be 4-6% but still if you fight for every gr. Also commenters say that it less prone to warping.

Felix Kühn

If the shown part's are only about 20$, doesn't in make sense to order the fanduct also in nylon for a few bugs extra 🤔

The100

Yeah that's a good point, from an aesthetic standpoint not mixing colors would be the better option

The100

That would be fine but not that many people are used to printing nylon and also buying a whole spool of nylon for 30-40g of printed parts feels not good. And keep in mind that you have to keep nylon in a vacuumed storage otherwise it will get too wet to be printed

The100

Those brass heat inserts are mine. The parts came without them, not all services offer assembly, to go really bonkers you could use titanium Inserts for about 200x the price for a weight save of 4-5g

Andrii B

They sell 250g (12$) and 500g (24$) spools of this specific filament. But I was thinking about finding a company that can print with it.

Nick Parry

Have you looked at something like the nanoNG or using both a boden and direct drive at the same time so you can use a smaller motor at the head?