Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Yep. I'm doing it! But only on Connextras.

https://youtu.be/eUywI8YGy0Y

So, this is mostly a "food for thought" type deal. I hope I made that clear in the video, and I'm sure there will be an endless stream of folks who a puzzled I didn't choose to get an induction stove - although I give my reasons.

I'm gonna be releasing this as soon as I get a thumbnail and chapter markers in place. So - pretty soon

Files

Gas stoves aren't really that fast - even standard electric is faster!

Really!

Comments

Rob Ottenhof

I think you're going to get a lot of responses to this. The pan must fit on the electric burner . If you do not do that, the burner will always turn off. 😉. It's still nice to see from Europe that it's so different in the US (The Netherlands) 😉

Carl Wandering

Calculate the cost to boil and the cost to roast a turkey comparing electric and gas. Bake a loaf of bread in gas and electric oven, see the difference.

Jim Hewlett

Still watching at the moment, but did you record the gas / kilowattage? Personally I always keep the lid on, but the pictures wouldn't be as informative. I guess a smaller ring or a frying pan with a lid would catch the heat better, but you wouldn't want to make coffee with frying-pan water. 27:41 Microwave?

MrHammond

I'm wondering about the quality of gas that you're using, if NOx is such a problem... But I guess you're right, we used to think that gas was so much better because you can regulate it so quickly, and as I grew up in the Netherlands, gas was pretty cheap back than. Now in Switzerland, I just have to take what the home I'm living in delivers... Electric glass ceramic does it fine for me. Meow from my Luke to your Reed, he watched very interested to the screen when Reed was meowing 😉

Evan Krall

The nitrogen and oxygen in NOx come from the air, and are basically inevitable side effects of having a flame. It has nothing to do with the purity of the fuel.

Mike Bird

I'd like to see the difference between a flat-bottomed pot like you have, and a wok. Heat is heat, so there shouldn't be much difference expect that our (2009) range doesn't do as well with cheap pots that have domed in the center. It works better with completely flat bottoms. Also, I think I inductive requires flat-bottomed girls, er cookware doesn't it? Good comparisons. But I know that Chicagoland started the super-sealed insulation movement in the 1980s (Ooh. Good topic for a video) with vapor barriers, 2x8 studs to allow extra insulation, and ridge vents among other things. But you need a REAL extractor for gas. Not one built into a microwave. That also has a fresh air input under the range or stovetop. There are heat exchangers to heat the incoming with the extracted outgoing, but by the time you can afford that, you could afford the whole line of celebrity chef cookware! 🙂

MrHammond

OK, yes, that was also something I was thinking... Firstly also coal gas, but I see that also in the US, that's not used anymore.

Nick Gully

Do you recommend that CO2 monitor?

Will G.

I have that same one it's a Hydrofarm APCEM2 Autopilot Desktop. It was recommended by SwiftOnSecurity in 2019. Her point was that indoor CO2 affects congnition/thinking at very common levels. I bought mine in April 2020 to test a training computer lab room at work that got very hot with dozens of computer and people at the same time. Never was able to test that because my job got sent home forever. But I still use it in my house to remind me when to open a window for fresh air. Edit: And CO2 levels are also a good proxy for air circulation in homes and offices. Let you know if you're getting enough air circulation to take COVID aerosols away.

Juho K

I wonder how the color of the pot bottom affects the performance of a radiant cooktop. A big part of the energy is in the form of infrared radiation but many pots have shiny bottoms which are not good at absorbing radiation. A pot with a black bottom should heat up faster in theory. However the fact that lifting the pot slightly above the glass makes boiling stop might suggest that conductive heat transfer is dominant.

Henning Retzgen

In most european countries (at least I am sure for Germany) it has become really hard to find cook ware which is not induction compatible. Granted the induction plate makes an angry bussing sound, but man is it fast. And the cook top only gets hot (indirectly) where the pot sits. You can literally touch like half centimeter beside the pot without it even feeling warm. In the more expensive induciton cook toops you can combine the different induction fields to form a huge heated area. We have switched to induction 2 years ago and have never looked back. If you have something that is not induction compatible and you really have to use it, there are round metal slaps you can put an induction top which then heat up and you have a regular stove again. We had a regular electric stove before and it worked well. but induction is definetly a step up. It heats up in an eyeblink and also gets cool again much faster, so you have alot more precise temperature control. Since having the new stove I have become a bit of an induction fanboy :-)

tim1724

Yeah, the US began switching from coal gas to natural gas after WWII and the transition was complete by around 1960.

Jonathan Lang

Sounds exactly like my feelings towards induction stoves :) never going back!

PerfectlyAdequate

This was a pretty good video, and I still followed your arguments, but do you seriously not have an oven probe thermometer? Yeah I get you’re not “culinary adventurous” but I thoroughly believe everyone with an oven should have one, and it would have made this video x10 less subjective if you just filmed a thermometer readout. You even could have made graphs! Same with a kitchen scale! No complaints about you using a standard bottle for measuring, but why do that when you could have just measured x grams of water?

C

Here's an absurd workaround to a gas stove's thermal transfer inefficiency -- a set of cookware with fins on the bottom, to better extract heat from a gas stove. You might have mentioned it in the video, in which case I will be terribly embarrassed. https://turbopot.com (Of course, for all the other reasons you mentioned... gas is bad.)

C

Incidentally, on the subject of indoor CO2 -- I'm in a very new, fairly large building, which does have mechanical ventilation, but when my apartment is occupied, it sometimes gets up to 1300 ppm CO2 in here. I think the ventilation is being run well below its designed capacity in order to save money. Turns out "I have a CO2 meter" is a great way to get maintenance to say "Oh, you're one of THOSE people" and thus be branded some sort of crackpot.

Leslie Deana

I'll prefer a home with a gas stove for no other reason that if the power goes out in the area, I still have a way to cook and MORE IMPORTANTLY emergency heating of my abode in the winter.

Shuyang Sheng

As a Chinese who cook a lot, I'd say that despite everything you said about how it's possible to cope with an electric stove (and boy I did, for 8 years, I know my old electric stove better than I know my dog), when I finally switched back to a gas stove, the difference is night and day. Let me explain. First off, in Chinese culinary, we sautee and stir fry a lot. That means going on very high heat for very short amount of time, and then turning to low to add sauce and seasoning, then possibly back to high again. So for these dishes, it's all about precise timing, any delay or thermo inertia would be quite inconvenient. Lifting the pan is not the same as turning to low, because you obviously can't do seasoning while holding the pan with one of your hands, so your only choice would be to move to another unused burner, in which case, you either (1) can't find one because you are cooking multiple dishes simultaneously, or (2) you did find one, but it is cold, so the temperature of the food drops quickly while seasoning. Electrical stoves also aren't very friendly for steaming buns. Much like how breads are baked, when it comes to steaming buns and baos, steady thermo output is the key, and I found my electric stove unable to keep a steady output at any level. Its high (100%) is way too much power, causing too much boiling, hence too much steam. And for anything below 100%, it simply cycles on and off (e.g. 80% time on for an amortized 80% output). And this is very undesirable for buns: frequently getting and losing steam may cause the buns to collapse, resulting in a rock hard bun. And of course, wok tossing is a very much standard (also very Chinese, I know) technique that I do on a daily basis. Having flames that wrap around the wok makes a big difference, because otherwise you'd be fast-cooling your food while tossing. I do agree though, that electric stove doesn't feel slow to me at all. If anything, my gas stove feels much slower despite having relatively powerful 15000BTU burners, and it's quite obvious how (like you mentioned in an older video) a big chunk of the output was lost to heated air around the burners.

Ryan Butler

Wait you have a gas furnace? WTF. You did like a seventy part series on heat pumps. My whole existence is a lie.

Friedrich Markgraf

I wonder how much energy is wasted by putting pots on burners that are much larger than the pot's flat bottom. It has been drilled into me since childhood not to do that because it's wasteful. It was so strange to see you not even mention it, even though you're a generally very mindful dude. Cultural differences in the details are fascinating!

M@trixX

It seems there's much larger variety of ranges in Europe than in the States. Gas stove with electric oven (as one unit) was quite common at some point. Gas stoves with flat glass cooking area exist (the flames are inside and they might be vented directly outside, so no fumes in your home, but thermal inertia would be the same as with electric). There is even a combination of two electric burners next to two gas ones. Electric induction range can cost as little as 400. And why the hell would you have the controls behind all the hot pots, instead of in front of them?

Jeff's bench

Is there a difference between natural gas vs propane stoves? I have a very old propane stove top with pilot lights.

Please enter your name

Damn... Induction stove is way too expensive in the USA... I bought my induction stove and my oven from IKEA, the stove was 500€ and the oven was 350€ and they're both fantastic. Yes the noise that induction stoves (or rather induction cookware) make is annoying, but you get over it real quick

Friedrich Markgraf

I realize this may have come across as an attack. It wasn't meant as such, I am actually wondering. Maybe it's a lot, maybe not – then again, how much longer would it have taken on a slightly-too-small burner, and is that bad for the cookware?

Technology Connections

Whole-home cold-climate heat pumps are simply too hard to get right now. I'm eagerly awaiting that situation to be fixed, but as it is now there is basically only one viable option and finding installers who are willing to work with it is hard. Basically, I'm living through the problems I highlighted in my videos on them. Until there are more and better options out there, running a 95 AFUE furnace doesn't bother me.

Technology Connections

Don't worry, it didn't feel like an attack! Part of the issue with this particular stove is that all the burners have a 6 inch inner section. A lot of my cookware is too big for that, but too small for the 9 inch sections. And I tested that big pot on the front-right burner set to the 6 inch setting, and it was so slow I gave up determining the time (it's literally in my notes as "too slow"). Also, for what it's worth, it still did that cycling routine set that way - lots of people keep telling me it's doing that because the pot is too small, but even the back burners do that completely covered with a pot. I'd like to know more about the thermal transfer mechanism of radiant cooktops because some of it feels mysterious. You would think that a *ton* of heat is escaping when the burner is bigger than the pot but... it really doesn't feel like that's happening. And the fact that the pot *must* be in contact with the surface to transfer heat means that the IR coming up from it clearly isn't doing the bulk of the heating. I suspect the pot reflects energy back and it gets trapped in the ceramic material (and when it's really hot it will incandesce as perhaps you've seen), which provides the buffer necessary for relatively stable heat output. But I'd need to track down whether there's any info on that to confirm.

Technology Connections

Ranges with gas cooktops but electric ovens are fairly common (they're called "dual fuel" here). Never seen a gas one with a flat top, though. As far as why the controls are at the back - honestly it's probably a combo of ease in wiring the device and tradition. However, parents with young children often prefer that as it keeps them out of reach. My mom, for instance, always felt that knobs on the front is a terrible idea for that reason. And honestly, it's not a big deal. The front burners are usually controlled by the outermost knobs, which means you can simply reach around (rather than over) the cooktop to control them.

Technology Connections

Practically, no. Propane has the advantage of having barely any global warming potential (methane is awfully bad when it leaks) but it's still a fossil fuel that you're burning in your home. The downsides are all there.

Technology Connections

There's more than one way to go about that, though. As it happens, I'm working on a video on home electrification - and stoves with batteries built-in (which allows them to use normal 120V circuits) are on the way, and they promise to work during power outages. Regarding using it as a heat source - personally, were I concerned about that, I would invest in a portable propane heater and keep a grill bottle of propane on hand rather than use that situation as reason to keep a gas stove. I'm actually considering doing a video on propane as a means of emergency energy storage as we have standardized "batteries" already in the form of those bottles.

Technology Connections

Since it's a good comparison, IKEA's cheapest induction cooktop option (non-portable) is $829, and their cheapest range with induction is $1399. That's one dollar more than I paid for the double-oven model, and as I said that feature is more important to me than having the induction cooktop (especially since $70 got me... an induction burner!). The pricing situation here is nuts.

Friedrich Markgraf

Thank you! German Wikipedia says in the article for Ceran (the first glass ceramic for stovetops) that it has high IR transmittance and low heat transfer (also why it stays relatively cool next to the burner). Says there the main mode of transport for heat to the cookware is radiation. So I would guess lifting the pot just applies the inverse square law to the amount of radiation reaching the pot. Or maybe there's some weird reflection thing going on between the pot bottom and the glass, but I doubt that; we'd not have shiny pot bottoms then.

Technology Connections

Well, there's clearly a lot of energy getting trapped in the glass - otherwise turning the burner off should quickly cause heating to stop. But it takes a solid minute for heat output to really fall off. That's why I find this perplexing.

Friedrich Markgraf

Maybe the heat is actually "stored" in the heating elements, not the glass itself? FWIW, I recorded your experiment on an induction stove and am about to upload that. Both for time as well as reaction time.

M@trixX

Thanks for the answer! It doesn't seem like a *big* deal, just weirdly uncomfortable - at least with gas if it's as hot as you say.

Friedrich Markgraf

The times in the video seemed very long to me, so I set out to repeat the experiment on my induction stovetop (230V country). Man, 4 liters is a lot! Had to get my biggest pot for that. Unfortunately, I used 4 liters, which is ~.2 liters more than 4 quarts, but we're not being super scientific here anyway. Video is here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hwq_aYwRgrQ The video is kinda long because I didn't speed it up. You can see in the lower-left corner when it switches from 0 (off) to P (POWER); you can also hear the beeps when I switch it on and off. 00:00 Start. You can hear the beeps and the induction hum (or rather the pot as it vibrates due to the induction). It gets quieter after a few seconds; it's not the mic lowering gain. 07:00 Water starts boiling 07:30 I switch it off. Switching off and on and playing with the power to demonstrate reaction speed. Note the relays clicking, and the delay of a few seconds from hitting P to the relays switching on. After that, water starts boiling again almost immediately. The stovetop is a Neff T59TS5RN0, I am using the PowerBoost feature. I believe that uses 7.4 kW of electricity. PowerBoost has some restrictions on how much power the rest of the stove draws. It automatically goes to 9 if I switch on too many other "burners". The water was as cold as it gets from the main pipe; stovetop and pot were at room temperature.

Friedrich Markgraf

Please excuse the snort (?) at 0:26. Now I wonder whether an induction stove in the US would be similarly quick, or if there are power restrictions in play.

Technology Connections

I should add that I've never seen a gas stove where the controls are at the back. It's generally only electric that places them there - and even then there are a few where the knobs are at the front. I assume that putting valves for gas on the back panel would make plumbing the gas lines ridiculous

Seán Byrne

A CO2 meter can also be fun to watch during an intense work out. We have a cross trainer in a room approx. 9m3 (90 sq ft). From a test with the door closed, the CO2 meter started at 580PPM and after 9 minutes on the cross trainer and a few minutes resting, it peaked about 1660PPM.

Richard Bevan

it would be nice to know why those combined microwave/extractor fans are so popular in the USA. It seems a bad idea to hang the microwave directly over the cook top - more so if the cook top is glass and dropping something from the microwave will smash the glass. I have never seen this style of microwave in europe.

Friedrich Markgraf

Probably because it saves space and there will be a wall outlet at that height for the extractor anyway. In Europe, you often have the built-into-a-cabinet style extractors. In truth, none of the above work very well. If you need great extraction, you need a real hood.

Circuitmike

This was a great video - thanks for doing it! One thing I've heard come up in the recent arguments over gas vs. electric vs. induction stoves is that induction stoves are supposedly more efficient than traditional electric. I'd love to hear more about that if you ever feel like doing a video about it. I can see where they'd be a little more efficient but I'm suspicious of them being far more so.

M@trixX

What is the function of the back panel on the gas stove then? Some buttons are visible, but yeah, I can clearly see you control the burners from the front.

Dr. Bjoern Bieber

LOL, exactly the same here. Even with the window tilted, door open and garden side window fully open to create a draft, it stays above 800 ppm.

Technology Connections

Yeah, I'm not super convinced that the efficiency is all that different. My datapoint is this: my portable burner pulls 1800W from the wall. That took 19:30 to boil 4 quarts. The radiant stove, meanwhile, running at ~2000W (I was timing the on/off times when it was cycling and it was very close to 20 seconds on, 10 seconds off, so 2/3 of 3000W) took 18:00/18:30 - and there the pot wasn't completely covering the burner so some was getting lost. Now, the portable burner is likely less efficient than a full-on stove hooked to 240V. But I suspect whatever transmission losses occur with a radiant stove are similar to the losses in the power electronics of an induction cooktop. Obviously induction still has advantages, and yeah it's probably a *tad* more efficient - but I find the claims of 50% more efficient to be quite dubious indeed.

Circuitmike

Thanks for the reply - that's pretty much what I figured as well. I have a pretty good handle on the technologies involved here and I just couldn't see how induction could be all that much more efficient than a standard electric heating element. It ultimately comes down to power delivered into the pot and its contents, as you mentioned in your video, and there's just not that much room for improvement over standard electric.

Ewen McNeill

My main reaction to this video is “y’all need a lot more ACH than you seem to be getting” (ACH = Air Changes Per Hour, with fresh breathable air). Starting at 800ppm CO2 is bad enough, but being stuck way over 1000 ppm for ages is terrible. Personally I’m getting concerned if I’m over about 600 ppm CO2, and taking urgent action over 800 ppm CO2 to reverse the trend (with the same 1 person source). Knowing y’all have “this is our air for the day” stuck inside your house explains how gas stove pollution suddenly became a news item again in the USA. Also the extractor fan running for the gas stove water heating and not the electric stove water heating probably reduced the ambient t loss (to extraction) in the electric test, saving a few seconds. (I understand you were doing it for the CO2 measurement.) Ewen

Lee Kinkade

I'm now a bit glad my house from 1938 is as leaky as it is. I really like my gas stove, and one thing this old house is, is ventilated. We have been using the large instant pot with the air fryer option as a small oven that doesn't heat the whole freaking room to make roasts and other foods that were limited to the summer previously, and now a George Foreman grill for many other things, and of course, an electric kettle to heat water.

lohphat

I just got an induction cooktop to play with (Duxtop 9610LS) and am impressed by the performance. However there are several issues: 1. Pulsed cooking. Unlike gas where there's continuous heat the pulsating behavior may be an issue in some cases. 2. The nice thing about gas is that there's visual feedback as to the heat/flame size. It's like the difference between an analog and digital clock. The digital clock is precise but the analog clock displays quantity (position on a clock face) -- you can infer/judge time elapsed or remaining much easier. I have to learn what each power level is with the induction to get a "feel" since there's no visual feedback. 3. At mid power settings there's a 21,000 Hz squeal when the loop is energized which sends my cat running to hide. An audio spectrum analyzer app for my phone confirmed it. It's quite loud. Different power settings generate different ultrasonic harmonics. It's not the fan motor, it's only generated upon loop activation. Also: Most people CAN'T replace their gas stoves. They're in old building were adding a new 240V line for the stove isn't an option. Also, adding a portable countertop induction unit may not be possible due to old wiring where one 20A 120V circuit serves the kitchen which blows the breaker when two high wattage appliances are used at once. e.g. microwave and kettle; adding an induction unit is a non starter when you need multiple appliances at once. The particulate matter from a properly serviced natural gas appliance is pretty small compared to vehicle emissions. I live in NYC. Natural gas is not the main problem -- traffic is the problem. I just turn on my kitchen exhaust fan to vent the CO2/CO/NOX.

Vanja

I agree that the perception that gas ranges are faster / hotter than electric is largely psychological. Another point in favor of that argument (which you may talk about later, I'm only about 2/3 of the way through) is that gas stoves leak far more heat. So not only do you get this sound and visual to confirm it's heating up, but additionally you feel that heat radiating from the flames. In actuality, this means that more heat is being lost / wasted by the gas range and is indicative of it being a less efficient heating method, but it certainly makes it feel like it's going faster.

David Weintraub

If your exhaust fan isn’t working and your house is sealed as tightly as you claim, you might need an intake fan that runs when you turn on your exhaust fan. A fan can only exhaust air if there is air to replace it. Newer houses with large exhaust fans have an intake fan (with heat exchanger) that pulls fresh air from the outside.

David Weintraub

I’m not sure if you’ll see this. I bought a new induction stove. The price was, as ny wife said, “You paid how much for that thing?” I just ran your boil water experiment on my stove. On the largest burner, it took three minutes 17 seconds to bring four quarts of water to a rolling boil. On the smallest burner, it took three minutes and 20 seconds to bring 4 cups of water to a rolling boil. That’s certainly worth the extra $1000 price premium over your mere electric stove. Thank god I’m not a midwesterner or I’d feel guilty. I was, what do you call it when people pay you to cook? Oh yeah, a professional chef. I’ve been using gas stoves my whole life, but decided due to my asthma and maybe not using so much fossil fuels, to go electric. I paid an electrician $350 on top of the price of the stove to install the needed outlet. Fortunately, I have 200 amp service and a spare breaker. I also had to replace my pots and pans, and still don’t have an Ibrik that works on the stove. The smallest burner needs a pot with a minimum diameter of 4.5”. Here’s my observations: * It took me a while to get use to the lack of heat around the burners. I’m stirring a sauce, and wonder if the stove is on. I feel nothing. The waste heat use to let me know how something was cooking. It’s funny stirring a sauce, not sure if it’s cooking, then suddenly see it thicken. Pot handles and lids don’t get that hot. It’s just weird I can be cooking something and just grab the handle and take a pot off the stove. * I have to make sure the burner fits the pot. If I use a too small of a pot, the burner won’t even turn on. It means I sometimes have to use the back burners to cook. However, since the air shove the stove doesn’t get hot, cooking on the back burners isn’t a problem. * Like a gas stove, the adjustment in temperature is instantaneous. * The kitchen doesn’t heat up. When I get cooking, our kitchen can get up to 95°F (35°C) and heat up the rest of the house. No more. * The oven heats up fast and is well insulated. On my gas stove, you could burn yourself on the stove top if the oven was on. The top just gets a wee bit warm even if I am baking pita bread at over 500°. * What I’m still not use to is opening the oven and getting whacked with a wall of hot air and a cloud of steam. This oven doesn’t vent. * I can’t smell of something is finished baking. I use to toss items in the oven knowing that I can smell when they’re done. Not this one. I have to use a timer and the oven light. And god forbid if something is burning. I won’t know until I open the oven and set off every smoke alarm on the block. * Speaking of smoke alarms. They no longer go off if I’m just cooking. * I can use the cabinets by my stove. I use to avoid putting things like oil in them because the heat can make them rancid. Spices would lose their potency. Now those cabinets stay cool and I can put things I want near the stove. * And my stove is spotless. If I spill something, I can wipe it up immediately. And with a glass top stove, I can wipe it down. I use to use oven cleaner on my stove top, and it still was coated with caked on grime. My stove still looks as good as new. I sometimes wonder if I even use it. It was this video that pushed me to move from gas. I’ve been thinking about it for a while, but electric stoves are so slow. We know that because the gas industry told us that. Plus, professional chefs cook with gas because the gas industry pays cooking shows to use gas. I’d like to thank you for shedding light on this issue.