Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Oof. That thumbnail face.

https://youtu.be/Bm7L-2J52GU

I discovered recently while embarking on an experiment I explain at the end that electric water heaters, despite being about as basic a thing as you can get, have a genius operating scheme designed to make the most out of a limited power supply. So I made this video!

It's a bit rough-and-ready as it's an interim video (I was hoping to have a much broader electrification video done first, but it's taking more script work than I anticipated). Speaking of rough-and-ready, I will be busy this evening and so it'll be a while before I can complete the captions and stuff. But, as it's done uploading, feel free to enjoy!

Files

The simple genius of a water heater

Pretty clever, ain't it?

Comments

tinybatte

but…without the captions, how will I know what kind of jazz it is this time???

Juho K

Here it's recommended that the water heater temperature should be 60 °C and in no circumstances less than 55 because of legionella. Our heater is set at 70 °C and a mixing valve ensures that we can't get hotter than 60 °C water from the taps. The heater is only 60 liters but it's just fine for three people. There's also a one way valve in the inlet so when the water expands while heating it just comes out from the safety valve and goes to the drain. At least the safety valve won't be stuck closed if it is actually needed some day.

Sebastian K.

In my area (Europe/Austria) the water heaters are automatically turned on by the utility company at night - they use a special modulated frequency on the mains to active a relay that powers the boiler. It works without problems since decades and you also get a cheaper price.

John Vestrum

That's really neat! I still have a gas water heater, but it (and the furnace and dryer) are getting close to replacement age, so I'm looking forward to that home electrification video - especially with the High-Efficiency Electric Home Rebate Act kicking in this year.

Circuitmike

Great video! I thought I understood hot water heaters - I did not! I have a heat pump hot water heater now and they're pretty great! They take longer to get a cold tank up to temperature, but they're super efficient compared to resistive heating, and mine has a "hurry up and heat!" function that engages an electrical element if you want water in a (comparative) hurry. You push a button and both that and the heat pump kick on simultaneously and you get a full tank of hot water as fast as possible. This water heater also does the thing you described where it heats the water in the tank to well above the temperature you want to come out of the tap, thus "expanding its capacity," effectively. It's got a simple mixing valve right after the the output. Another neat thing about my current hot water heater is the fact that it uses an "impressed current anode rod." Its function is the same as the sacrificial anode you described except that it's got a small amount of electrical current running through it, meaning it's much smaller and lasts forever. The down side, as I discovered recently, is that if there's a problem with that circuit, the whole hot water heater shuts down. At least now I know how to fix it! My last house had a tankless water heater, heated with propane. It was pretty fantastic! And if you want to sit up yonder on your high horse about "changing your habits," feel free, but you've obviously never had a wife who enjoys your extra-deep bathtub, or a family. I don't have a family myself, but I can imagine a tankless water heater being a life saver in a situation where two adults are getting ready for work and two kids ready for school around the same time every day. The bit about the wife and the large tub, though, is entirely facts.

Mark Hesse

Thumbnail face looks like you're in the middle of disapproving or grudging applause. Maybe not apropos to the subject at hand, but it'll do. I'm also probably going to replace my gas furnace and gas water heater sometime this year so will be interested in your future videos, but in all likelihood will probably opt for whatever has the cheapest replacement cost.

Kyle Cuzzort

We had a tankless water heater and replaced it for a few reasons: 1. You couldn’t have ‘warm’ water, only ‘hot’. If you want warm water for hand washing or rinsing a bunch of vegetables without freezing your hands it wouldn’t hit the minimum flow rate to turn the heater on. 2. High-efficiency clothes washers don’t use enough water to ever have the hot water reach the washer. The heater has a cycle time of a few seconds and high-efficiency washers will be full before the hot water is going. 3. ‘The sandwich’ - if you turn off the hot water for a minute then the heater would have to do the full startup cycle. If one person got out of a shower and the next got in, they would have hot water in the lines until a 2-second slug of cold water came through from the heater startup cycle. Not fun. Now we have a ground source heat pump with a loop to a preheat tank (just a water heater with the electrical left disconnected) and that then feeds the primary water heater. We like long, hot, showers and even with 4 adult visitors at once we’ve never run out of hot water. One interesting thing about the GSHP pre-heating the water: in the summer, when the heat pump isn’t running (we don’t need AC here), our power bill doesn’t go down much. The water heater has to run resistive heat much more because the GSHP doesn’t preheat as often.

Joel Diaz

I went through some craziness over the last two years with hot water heaters. I tried to replace that anode rod, and it was screwed in there so tightly that the bolt head was stripped. Replaced the water heater with one of those heat pump hybrids. It was fantastic while it worked, but then it didn't. The warranty replacement was of three kind where you bring it back to the place of purchase and they refund you the money so you can buy whatever you want. I just took the money and put in a tankless unit since I didn't want to install a pole in my garage to go protect the water heater (that should have been done with the first replacement... Whoops). The tankless works well enough. I think it helps that we have a hot water circulation loop, so there isn't a long wait or that cold water sandwich.

Robert Sanges

Oh, that thumbnail. Pretty eye-catching, but you'll be blasted for click-bait!

illves

Thanks for the reminder I should get an expansion tank now that the plumbers pushed for a pressure reducing valve......

Jessica Wee

I think you look pretty great in the thumbnail!

Tnarg42

I grew up in a neighborhood that was built in the mid-1950s (midwest USA), and when I was a kid (1980s) many of the houses still had three meter sockets at the electrical service entrance. Apparently there was a time when electric water heaters in our area were metered separately, but only run at night. They would read each meter separately, and presumably bill at separate rates. At some point the electric utility backed away from that scheme, but the connections remained on the outside of some houses.

Gavin

In some countries the bottom element is connected to a separate "night power" power cable from the distribution box with a switch which only runs it on off-peak power. The switch can be a simple mechanical timer or it can be a smart controlled IOT style switch installed by the distribution network operator controlled in response to network demand.

Joe Kudrna

Excellent report! Thank you for enlightening us to this gem of simplicity. And you did hit the nail on head about using a water tank as a BATTERY. Thermal batteries are perhaps the best way to store extra energy, be it from solar (thermal or electrical) or grid producers. Case in point, you added a relay to turn the heater on and off, transforming a simple source of hot water into a money saving device! This year I am replacing my gas water heater with Hybrid (the love of you life heat-pump and heat element), the most popular ones are programmable too. Next on my list is a gas stove with electric (and your video on electric vs gas also very timely). One day when I need to change the AC unit, that will also go heat pump (right now I am keeping it alive, and set winter temp about 66). And to (literally) top it off, a PV Solar roof. The cost of all this conversion will pay for itself in as little as 5 years, max of 10, then its all money in pocket. Looking forward to when you do a video on Hybrid water heaters (stated to cost 1/4 of only element heater, and even half the cost to operate vs gas) PS! You can wrap entire tank in more insulation to reduce heat loss. I did.

clickallnight

This is really good! I just installed a water heater and wondered about he top/bottom element thing. With the insulation as good at it is, now much electricity do you save, turning it off during times of disuse?

Honorary Octopus

Wow. Waterheaters are a lot more complicated than I ever gave them credit for. Its such an innocuous part of everyday life I just never thought that much about it.. I guess I've taken it for granted until now. Great video.

Michael Dunn

I appreciated the part where you wrote "hot water heater" and then erased "hot" xD

Peter

I like using the sun to heat the water, and store the heat in a larger tank. The resistive heating element is just a back up in my case, heating the water a bit in the winter when there isn't enough sun.

Jeremy

Very good content. I appreciate the use of mostly degrees Celsius (even though I'm in the US, native born). For some power discussions degrees kelvin would make even more sense (and avoid idiosyncratic capitalization), but for resistive heating C and K are the same. Sure there's the rankine unit, but SI units (or SI adjacent units) are so convenient.

Seán Byrne

Here in Ireland, the bottom element is usually driven by a night tariff timer or an Eddi to heat using excess solar PV power. The upper element goes to a manual switch or countdown timer to boost if needed. That plumbing is also so simple compared to the complex pipework from our 3 coil 300L cylinder. It has two hot water outlets, one to the taps and the other to showers only so turning on/off taps don't affect the shower temperature. The upper heat exchange coil connects to our solid fuel back boiler stove and the middle and lower coils to our oil-fired boiler. The bottom coil can alternatively be connected to solar thermal, although rare now with the decreasing price of solar PV. Finally there is an optional pump to circulate the water between the top and bottom, so a solid fuel back boiler stove can heat the entire tank instead of just the top third.

toasterking

I needed this video like 9 years ago, when I first started messing with water heaters, out of necessity, as a property owner. I effectively learned everything I needed to regardless, but not nearly as directly nor eloquently as I would have via this video.

Michael Steeves

I've done some troubleshooting on tanks with blown elements before. I never understood the interlinked thermostats. Genius!

Michael Steeves

I was part of a "smart grid" pilot project a few years back. My water heater could be switched off remotely for 15 minute periods during times of high demand. Unsurprisingly I never noticed. They gave me a couple nice gift cards for taking part in the trial.

JR Dalrymple

Coincidentally I have a similar box on the wall with the same exact red light. In my case my power company sees to it that light is off every weekday from 7AM to 11PM and as a result I get a great rate on the electricity used to heat water in my home. The price I pay is difficulty in getting a warm shower on cold MN weeknights. I have done my own experimenting however and using an enormous heater and a thermostatic mixing valve I’ve come up with a reasonable solution that only on the coldest of days and with lots of loads of laundry do I have to wait until morning to shower.

Don Eitner

Installing a water heater is a tankless job. Okay, I'll show myself out. :-)

Don Eitner

I now want to look into this aluminum rod thing which can be replaced to extend the life of the water heater. Never knew that was a thing.

Nicholas Carr

Intermatic has a timer for water heater time of day control, model WH40.

Kristian Høy Horsberg

In Norway we never built any domestic gas infrastructure, so we've been using electricity for most home heating needs for decades (even heating homes exclusively with resistive heating was not unusual). And it's great. With respect to water heaters, my experience is that even an old 3.6kW 200l single element water heater worked fine for a family of four. Granted, our water heaters are set to have a higher internal temperature maybe closer to 70°C, and mix the hot water with a little cold water when tapped, so the effective capacity is a little bigger, but still.

Julian Kaufmann

Thanks for yet another great video. As a former swiss electrician (now train driver) I can assure you that there is really no problem whatsoever with running your water heater only during the night. In Switzerland it's even mandatory to only run it at night. For that we have specific relays which only switch water heaters on at specific times. (Ripple control). These also pervent it of switching on during high demand times (e.g. around noon) when you would manually switch it on "daytime mode". For the concern about the legionella: We learned in apprentice that the water must be heated to 60°C to ensure itvis safe. (Older boilers were even heated to up to 80°C). Hope I could help.

Mike OReilly

Hi, I found this video really interesting. Here in the UK, hot water tanks are kinda seen as old tech. Most were heated by gas boilers and had the option of an electrically powered immersion heater (in case you needed hot water quicker). The systems were very untidy and used lots of space (cold tank in the attic, hot tank in a cupboard (usually in a bedroom) and a boiler somewhere (either as part of the gas fire or a stand alone unit), not to mention all the pipe work. Once these systems died they were often replaced with instant heat, combi boilers which is what happened in my home (the remnants of which are still to be found in the shape of various wall mounted switches, a thermostat and a few capped off pipes). The fact that the water holds its heat for so long afterwards kinda makes it more 'new technology' in the way that we are constantly looking for ways to store energy efficiently now. Ironic really.

AppleSnaps

I’ve never experienced any of these issues with our tankless. Having transitioned from tanks to tankless, it takes about the same amount of time for hot water to reach various taps.

Sylvan

Very excited for your home electrification video! This subject is interesting to me not least because I'm in the middle of my own home electrification project where I'm replacing a gas water heater with an electric one. I'll be putting it on a smart timer so it runs overnight and I also plan to add a thermostatic mixing valve and keep it at a higher temperature to extend the capacity. I'm using a highly insulated Rheem Marathon plastic tank that should last 40+ years. Anyway, loved the video and I'm curious to know more about the mystery box on your wall.

Robin Capper

In NZ have always had dumb network control of hot water for load management. They use either ripple relay or pilot wire network. The ripple relay network is remotely controlled via the low voltage (LV) electricity network whereas pilot relays are controlled via a separate pilot wire on the electricity network. Can turn off hot water to reduce peak load and during network repairs as they restore power.

The Legacy

At 7:18, you said 50 * C when you meant 40 * C. Whoops! 😅 Very interesting video, though! It begs the question how gas water heaters work. Much like a gas stove? And does it have the same issues as a gas stove when it comes to air pollution?

Michael Steeves

In the 1970s in Kenya the few electric water heaters around were required to be on a timer or some sort of similar signal to avoid running them during peak loads. A fragile grid required better tech than has been used in Canada for 50 years!

Michael Steeves

Interesting that my city in Atlantic Canada uses these Norwegian electric water heaters. The mixing valve allows for use of a smaller tank for the same amount of hot water.

Derek Martin

Gas tank heaters depend on generation just have a burner on the bottom. Older ones are pilot operated and need zero electricity to operate. They typically have much more power than electric models.

Asaf Sagi

Great video! It's really cool to know how these things work. We have them here in Israel, but they're commonly placed on the roofs of our buildings because a lot of us have solar arrays that heat the water during sunny days (95% of the year). Not photoelectric solar panels, just the actual sun heating the actual water. This allows me to have hot water all day while using zero electricity. While there isn't a Wiki page about it in English, the illustrations kinda explain it: https://he.wikipedia.org/wiki/%D7%93%D7%95%D7%93_%D7%A9%D7%9E%D7%A9