Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello all!

These last couple of week have been pretty slow-rolling for me, largely because I've been stuck on a script. I've moved around it and am working on something else, but I don't want to abandon that project - it's just a tricky thing to explore, as I talk about here.

https://youtu.be/FMIqxxbggJM

I'm looking for your input on whether to proceed with the topic. And, if any of you work in the residential HVAC business and can give some info, let me know.

For now, I'll be gathering B-roll today for the next main-channel video and can probably edit it together by the end of the day tomorrow.

Toodles!

Files

A very rambly update where I talk about two videos I kinda wanna do

Hello!

Comments

Michael Ford

Perhaps just call out the sites one could go to to get wholesale prices. Having that information can help negotiate the cost down. Maybe do it as a “this is how you research costs and calculate tonnage that is needed given the space.” Don’t even touch “this is dumb and hvac companies are bad for doing it” topic

Paul

I do think this is important, but I also think you're correct that you're going to get a lot of rage and pushback. People are going target your low number of examples (your friends and family), the fact you don't work in that industry, and the sheer cognitive bias of "I've always believed that I wasn't ripped off, so I must find a way to explain why that high cost is worth it". I think if you do this, I'd personally try to side step anger at the issue, and maybe make the focus of the video something like "Here are ways you can optimize energy loss and HVAC placement if you're looking for or building a house. Here are things you should consider when buying a new HVAC. Here is how you can price compare. Here is how to evaluate what this should cost." That kind of thing... And try to "inception" the audience to the conclusion that they should be annoyed, rather than being too annoyed about it yourself. Snark is good, anger is bad.

Edward Drozd

At least in the northeast, the retrofit issue is not just houses in the 30s. I grew up in a house in NJ with hot water heat and no AC at all except window AC units. My parents installed central air with an air handler in the attic (hot as anything for 8+ months of the year) and ducts only in the attic for the upstairs, not even in the walls to the downstairs.

Technology Connections

Yeah, the Northeast appears to be the region where hydronic heating hung on the longest for whatever reason. It's a shame it has taken ductless mini-splits so long to gain any traction here as I think they solve so many issues (but create a few, too - nothing's perfect!).

Technology Connections

Yeah, I've been struggling with pacing and balance. I could crowdsource more heat pump quotes, though, and maybe that would be a good idea. As-written now, I make it explicit that this is just personal anecdotes but I could make it go beyond that.

Edward Drozd

tillliving in the southern end of the northeast.And then you get, "well, ackchually, have a high-efficiency gas boiler for my hydronic heat, so even better than a heat pump" because that's what they have for heat, plus a bog-standard central air system, and they see themselves as most environmental, but maybe they are as of 20 years ago.

Reade Bramer

The quotes I’ve gotten just to put a mini split in my 30ish by 30ish detached garage have been unconscionable. Lots of folks are probably rightfully skeptical of DIY mini-split systems with pre-charged lines. But for the quotes I’m getting I could buy 3 DIY systems and still save money at the cost of like a weekend’s worth of work.

Mark Hesse

If you watched The 8-Bit Guy's video about going as long as he could during a hot Texas day using only energy from his solar panels and batteries, it make me wonder how much longer he could have kept up the experiment if his house and studio had been insulated to Illinois standards.

Louwrentius

Would it make sense for you - if you didn’t consider it already - to also cut a YT short from your larger video to maybe reach more people?

Chris Brosz

I am a sys admin for a mid size company and have to buy lots of "enterprise" equipment and hvac stuff. I think it really just falls down we need to be our own advocates and have some basic understanding of what we are requesting. I think a lot of businesses have been overrun by sales peoples who are just pushing higher numbers to pad their bottom line. A good engineer/hvac person should be able to explain to the person why something is needed and how they calculated it. And the person requesting it should spend a little time learning what they need to ask for and to smell bullshit. Side rant, I did a new build at 1750sq footage (not including the basement that I do have) and they put a 2 ton unit in. Arguably the house has better insulation but man does that thing struggle on the 95+ days. I wish they put in a bigger unit. And on more notes, have you seen those Midea Inverter Portable A/Cs? Holy crap they are so much better than ye old portable AC systems. Quite and I am hoping more energy efficient.

AJV

I very much hope you do wind up making that "business of HVAC" video. I bought a house in the mid-Atlantic region a couple years ago, knowing the AC unit was well beyond its recommended years of service. Now that temperatures are falling again, we're looking to finally price out a replacement — and thanks to all your videos I want to explore getting a heat pump (and making our gas furnace a secondary heat source). I've been worried about getting astronomically high quotes once I bring up heat pumps versus just-for-cooling units, so I would be eager to get any tips you've uncovered — or that you'd find as you prepared a video on this. P.S.: Is it possible that the new heat-pump incentives under the Inflation Reduction Act could have led to higher estimates? I feel like there's a lot of speculation about bigger tax incentives causing higher MSRPs in the EV market; curious if that kind of effect is actually real in either the car market or the HVAC market.

Mikah

If you don't mind my asking, where in the Mid-Atlantic are you? I'm in central VA and got a ductless mini split heat pump installed this past spring; none of the people I spoke to from any of the companies we got quotes from thought it was necessary to keep the old furnace or to have a backup beyond maaaaaybe keeping a couple space heaters on hand, and whether or not you keep the furnace could potentially affect the cost. Our quotes were quite high, but there were some complicating factors in our case (such as no existing ductwork and a layout that doesn't encourage airflow between rooms) that required a lot more labor than would be necessary if it's a 1-to-1 swap of AC to heat pump, and thankfully there were some reasonable financing options available. Also, our electric bills this summer have been FAR lower than I would have expected, which does help me feel better about the amount the system cost.

Ian Cull

[second topic] builders build down to a price, only rules make them do better; our first Florida home (built around 2000) had single glazed windows! Going 4” to 6” outside walls is a cost that builders will avoid unless forced. I assume there’s some math somewhere about cost effectiveness working energy losses against materials/labor costs though who knows when such guidelines/rules get reviewed!

Robert Paulsen

Did you see that you made it onto Steve Mould's latest video?

Ian Cull

[first topic] I feel like discussions would be bad (putting viewers off) unless you can back up numbers - actual wholesale costs of your parents system, actual “energy needed” math for the building and then actual costs of a right sized system … probably too much to ask for but without that I worry the topic will fail

AJV

Not at all! I'm actually just up the road in northern Virginia, outside D.C. Honestly I could take or leave the gas furnace, but the old owner just replaced it in the last six years or so — along with the blower if I remember correctly — so I figure the cheapest route is just going to be replacing the box outside and a few other bits but leaving most of the inside stuff intact. I'd be concerned about mark-up where I live even _without_ possible HVAC industry shenanigans (it's just expensive to do anything up here), so I'm going to have to keep doing research for a little while before jumping in. Glad you saw the efficiency of your new system in this summer's energy bills! We ... are clearly going the opposite direction, as this AC unit soldiers on through its 27th or 28th summer. It's been a marvel that it's lasted so long with (apparently) good maintenance, but definitely not something I should keep relying on much longer.

Paul

You could. Regional averages would be ideal, I'd think. But I don't know how much work that would be to get. I think sticking to personal Alecdotes isn't a problem as long your main arguments are focused on the logic and science, keeping the stories as starting points and support, and the primary point as "here is what you should look at and think about when considering a home, HVAC, insulation, etc. Educate, and let any indignation or pushback against these companies and the system as it is come as a side effect. As an immediate example, I did not consider air handler location. Putting them in the attic is standard here. Now that seems stupid. My thoughts anyway, you know what you're doing :P.

Technology Connections

Addressing your PS, I thought about this and I'm leaning against that possibility. The three-head Mitsubishi quote was given before the IRA passed and I don't think the utility even offered a rebate at that point. It was still a horrid quote, though. Luckily for my folks, those rebates and tax credit made the cost what I would call reasonable. But it is disturbing to think that the incentives could (should?) have made the system no more expensive than a conventional swap-out.

Kevin Reid

[second topic] I'd love to see a video on the *general* topic of thermal considerations in building design — for example, never mind attics in particular, I bet a lot of people haven't even thought about the concept of “conditioned space” and what it means to build a structure with maintaining such a demarcation in mind. Or that outside walls need insulation and (if not thick enough) you may want to avoid running pipes through them. Or hey how about a video on the wonderful invention of double-glazed windows?

Technology Connections

I hadn't gotten to that point in the script yet, but as far as gauging equipment size, this is something I planned to address. Manual-J calculations aren't as good as actual data-gathering, and the thing is these days we totally have that! And as a matter of fact, I was able to use the historic energy usage data from my parents' smart thermostat to convince the company they went with to do a 3 ton unit (originally they wanted to do 5). I would welcome HVAC companies designing a sort of temporary thermostat replacement which can log that data and, combined with a system health check, spit out the heating and cooling requirements you /actually/ have.

The 8-Bit Guy

I would love to chat with you about this. I spent some time researching this topic a while back for a possible video on my channel, but eventually decided it wasn't a good fit for my channel. I did talk to some AC technicians (both former and current) and got a pretty good idea of what is going on with the outrageous costs.

The 8-Bit Guy

To be fair, my house was built in 1995, so almost 30 years ago. A lot of codes have changed regarding insulation in the last few decades. Most modern Texas homes are probably more efficient than mine.

Ewen McNeill

I feel like the first topic is best framed as “right sizing your heat pump for maximum efficiency” (especially talking about avoiding short cycling and why). And the second is perhaps best framed as “building design lessons the MidWest can teach you, and why you should pay attention”. If you can focus more on “here’s how it could be better” and less on “y’all are doing it wrong” the tone of the videos would probably feel better. People don’t realise the “obvious” until they know it :-) Ewen

Baulderan

I'm still watching the video and will comment if things change, but I'm *sure* that I watched a modern episode of This Old House and they were talking about oversized ACs and how HVAC companies are, indisputably, taking advantage of people. Contractors, much like mechanics, know that once they leave the house/you leave the shop, that's it. They won't see you for years-- maybe ever again. So they want to ring every last drop out of you. I think you should be honest and remind people that they will be taken advantage of if they don't go into a major purchase without previous knowledge. Whether that's HVAC, plumbing, carpentry. Hell even tailoring. Heat pumps aren't new, but people don't know they're not new. I personally was anti-heatpump because I didn't really know what it was or how it worked until I watched your video. I think that maybe framing it as "how to not get screwed by your HVAC guy" might be a good way to get positive engagement with the video's topic.

Cassandra Gelvin

I live in San Diego, and I have to admit that most of us are as baffled as you are about the attic ductwork, but from the other side. "Where would you put it, if not the attic?" We've got super-thin walls, and my house is on a slab. I was just listening to you, thinking, "I've been in my attic, the ductwork is like 1.5 feet in diameter. How on earth would that fit in my walls?" But I get it, most of that is insulation. Also, our AC/heater is in a utility closet and is SUPER noisy. When we moved into our house, it had central heating and no AC. And, well, it only technically had central heating. The house was foreclosed and flipped, and it seems like the previous owner was upset or something because the ductwork in the attic was basically shredded and useless. And since it was insulated, it was also (possibly) full of asbestos and a pain in the rear to find someone to test and/or remove. We eventually found someone fix the ductwork, and... well... it wasn't great. We had AC added, and the people we got it from (who primarily did business AC and the salesperson for a competitor who used to work for them said "yeah, we can't beat them") were at a complete loss as to why many of the things were done the way they were. There's a T-intersection right next to my eldest son's room where his register is, and it continues to another duct nearby, and we were informed that due to physics, his room would never get any of that air. So we've blocked off the other duct it continues to, but someday we want all this to be fixed. We looked into fixing it in 2020 and didn't end up doing it at the time, but I took some photos to explain it (on Reddit I think) and if you want to see what horrific-looking attic ductwork in San Diego looks like, you can see it here: https://imgur.com/a/NyMu8Wb

Mark L

I am an engineer and would be glad to review any scripts for technical content. I have been on quest to make my home more energy efficient. Just a couple of days ago did a simple spreadsheet model to estimate heat transfer through the ceiling, walls and windows, converting the data to kWh and cost. Not that hard with reverences to R and u factor you can find on the web. I now know what costs more, and what to try to do about it. As you mention, and well sealed/insulated house does not need such massive AC/heater units. Split packs are compelling, and has an advantage: if one fails, you can still heat/cool using the others with a few carefully placed fans. Central heating ensures misery when they fail.

Vertizontally

I'm from Arizona and I am just as baffled about the state of insulation as you- it has always driven me bonkers. Growing up, my grandparents had a ranch house in Yuma (15 minutes from the border of Mexico, out in the dunes) that was majority brick over a crawl space. The attic was minimal, and well insulated and the brick walls (which also had insulation pressed between the brick exterior and the drywall interior) provided much protection as well. The crawl space was partially set into the ground, which offered natural insulation for the duct work. This home had been there for a long time- since at least the 50's. It never got hot, at least not too bad. The sliding glass doors were a problem, but became less so as they closed in the porch they led out to. Our home, a few miles away further into the city of Yuma, was a bungalow adobe exterior home- where the exterior walls were a nice thick layer of adobe mud and the interior was your standard drywall. It was a newer home, maybe 70's. The AC was on the roof, unfortunately, but the home stayed fairly cool as the duct work was inside the rooms of the home. There was no attic, just a flat adobe roof. This ended up being an issue as water was trapped on the roof, and eventually it caved in. Despite the problems with this home, it was pleasant to live in considering the climate regularly got in the high 110's every summer. And since we lived on sand, the temps would drop very low at night despite the blistering afternoons. Having insulation for the hot and cold seemed to work great. Then we moved to Phoenix, which has a lot of newer homes than Yuma and holy moly. The thin drywall exterior paired with two-story homes and AC units that were ducted through that second-story attic made for a miserable summer over and over again. Multiple homes, same issue. We'd lose all the cooling through the walls and roof, and the second floor would get blistering because that's how thermals work. I have always hated it, and am seriously considering buying my own property to be able to drop my own adobe home on it. Or at the very least, I need a builder that is willing to put more than what seems like cardboard in the walls and attic.

Mark Hesse

I would've thought that a house built in 1995 would have been built with modern energy-saving techniques, but I suppose that the industry is just doing things as they always have--building them as cheaply and quickly as possible. I should take a look at the new homes they're building where I live in central MN. Interesting to see if they're building them with 2X4 or 2X6 walls.

Greg Morin

it's fine to talk about it but avoid judgment words like "greed". You're assuming motives when you make a value judgement like that. There is a whole range of reasons prices could be higher than you think they'd should be: your cost estimates for labor and materials and supplies is just wrong, that particular company is just terrible at doing things efficiently, they are just applying a rule of thumb heuristic to get a price which can be lazy but not necessarily motivated by "greed". Best answer to greed is more completion and it sounds like your own assessment was the $5k price was fair. But your parents had a quote from someone else. Totally different company. Did they get multiple bids? A lot of these guys have no business sense and you just have to get several quotes. Construction trades are often all over the place. Not just hvac. People have to know to not be afraid to get 3-4 bids. On the over sizing thing yeah that's insane. 4 tons! I almost choked on my food. I have a 3 tom covering 3000 sq ft and that is plenty. I can't imagine why anyone would suggest 4 tons for less than half that area. You should do a whole thing on how to size units yourself. It's not hard to do the estimates oneself. Then people would know to ask why are they getting such a crazy suggestion and know to ask about humidity control. I guarantee you the installers never get those questions. Gotta push back with knowledge. Also it's possible these oversized units are getting pushed due to subsidies (I know, your favorite topic lol) either where it makes the 4 ton cheaper (for the installer) than the 2 ton so they push that (because the subsidy is stupidly constructed to incentivize "more energy saved" without considering the appropriateness of the space the unit is put in. In my experience when _everyone_ is pushing something there is a centralized (eg government) incentive at work. And particularly so when the reasoning is just monumentally wrong. They can't be that stupid. My spidy sense says something else is going on to distort incentives so badly. I'd wager real money there is some kind of weird subsidy or energy efficiency mandate at play. And yes in the south we run duct work in the attic and crawl space. Yes it is brain dead but that's what they do. Only energy savvy folks like myself have to insist otherwise when we built our home recently. Spray foam helps a lot as it lets us put the attic in the house envelope. Our attic is conditioned now because of it.

Technology Connections

I wasn't planning to use the word "greed" in the script, but I do just want to clarify that it was indeed the same company that installed my system for $5k that did my parents' heat pump for $13k. We have mostly sworn off the other company because of all the issues we've had.

Aleksei Besogonov

Regarding the SEER units loss in ducted vs. ductless, it's caused by outside air intrusion. If you have multiple rooms that are cooled/heated the dampeners switching the air flow are only on the forward path (from the AC unit to rooms). But the air return ducts are everywhere, this creates pockets of lower pressure air in rooms that are not heated/cooled, and pockets of higher pressure in the other rooms. So the outside air leaks in, and hot/cold useful air leaks out. It's not a lot, but SEER units are inverse, like MPGs.

A R

I think it's absolutely worth getting the information out there about reasonable pricing and the value of energy retrofits, but you're right to be worried about the tone. Seems like the safest approach might be "consumer education", as in "how to get good pricing", rather than "HVAC contractors are greedy bastards". "How to size a system" and "where to buy wholesale" and "how to convince your electrician to do the whole job" might be decent angles that work. Also, maybe just calling out the price continuum of DIY < wholesale/install < subcontracted with pricing would be instructive enough. A "virtual energy audit" that encompasses attic insulation, ducting, and HVAC retrofit would have tons of long-term value as a reference for people - it ain't getting any colder out there in years to come...

Kris Asick

Silly question but have you considered just flat-out asking the HVAC companies around you about the price discrepancies in terms of installation costs vs. the work done and costs of the units themselves? Like, not in a rude way or anything but just out of confusion in terms of trying to understand what's going on. I mean sure, they may not give you an honest answer but it may reveal something you hadn't considered.

Dan ''Spiffy'' Neuman

These are really great ideas. (That said I am a midwesterner who loves snark so I'd be fine with the raw form too!)

Stephen Edmonds

I'm sure there was a segment on Ask This Old House ten years ago where the AC coil was freezing up, the cause being an oversized condenser

Stephen Edmonds

I'm Australian and have watched a a LOT of North American shows/videos about building/renovating houses, you would be more horrified about how we build things down here ;) When you started talking about building techniques the first thing that came to mind was Matt Risinger's videos, in particular the series where he built his own new house (except for reusing exisitng slab) with all the latest techniques. He also has videos where he goes to other places and shows different techniques. But is it too big a topic? Matt alone has dozens of videos.... Also I understand the idea of conditioning the attic. Keep the weather above the roof and make it usable space for storage and equipment.

Sam Katzenberg

Hi Alec, happy to discuss the HVAC industry with you, most of my experience is in commercial (Hotel and High-rise) but I have a lot of industry knowledge as I have my degree in HVAC and am a fill-in instructor at a local community college as well as on the curriculum advisement board. I am happy to lend any knowledge to you. Love your videos as they cross a lot of my other interests and hobbies.

Dean Gallea

Absolutely, do this topic: My friend took over a wine shop with an existing 3-ton Carrier mini-split system that works fine. She was told by a contractor that it was never "permitted" by the village, and would need that "service" done, including putting bollards in front of the ground-level outdoor unit to keep delivery trucks from hitting it. So, she contacted a local HVAC company, that happened to NOT be a Carrier dealer. The estimator told her that the outdoor unit was 5-ton and the indoor was 2-1/2 ton, so they were unmatched and would have to be replaced to be permitted. (They were lying, the units are matched according to Carrier's specs.) There is either total incompetence or total fraud in this industry!

Dean Gallea

As far as the attic-mounted air-handler, the fact is that, if properly insulated, the mass of the ductwork and even the unit housing, is relatively small and will cool pretty quickly. But I agree with attic being the wrong place for a HEATING system in a northern climate, because the temp difference is so large (like 60+ degrees at times), and there will be convective loss when the system is off.

Raul Ramos

While I haven't seen the vídeo yet, I do have some HVAC design experience, mostly on vehicles. I don't exactly know what you need, but do feel free to reach out

Patrick L

Agreed...consumer education approach would be the best way to still call out the shady factor without sounding like you are on a soapbox.

Peter

In regard to your question of why duct work is in the attic, note that locations where this is common tend to be climate zone 3 or lower (where basements are also less common). The midwest is climate zone 4 or higher with basements and is more likely to avoid putting the hvac equipment in the attic. As others have noted, the northeast has a lot of hydronic heating, though there are heat pump systems that can be used for those to replace the fossil-fuel boilers they may have now.

Peter

Also note that 2x6 walls in the midwest is also relatively "recent" (starting perhaps in the late 70s to early 80s). My parents' house in Michigan was built in the mid 60's with poorly-insulated 2x4 walls and insufficient insulation in the attic. On Matt R's channel, when he discusses insulated attics, he is talking about putting the R40+ insulation at the roof deck (some inside the attic, the rest on the outside surface).

Jeremy

@ 44:38, are you implying that time passing is because of patreon funding? I think that I'd like for time to run more slowly, but I also want good content. I also want to enable good content. Time also passed before I became a patreon. Maybe I should ignore the implication. May the future not rue my decision.

Afonso F. Garcia

12k$ for a Mitsubishi 3x multi split is basically being robbed. I just had one installed in my apartment in Portugal (and yes, hourly rates can’t really be compared but the equipment price is probably cheaper in the US) and paid 3.5k€ for it, of which around 1k€ was the installation costs.

Richard Bevan

Isn't this all relative. You will proudly show off the insulation and building standards for Illinois and people in Nordic countries (I live in Finland) will laugh and say it's what we had here 50 years ago and things have moved on a lot since then. From what I've seen of your videos, houses in the USA have air conditioning systems, but no ventilation system (exchanging inside air with outside air). In Finland this is not only mandatory but new houses must have a ventilation system heat exchanger to recover the heat lost from providing forced ventilation.

Mike Bird

Actually, about 30 years ago, they started installing furnaces in the US (or at least, Minnesota) with air exchangers built in. It helped take care of humidity issues when the 90%+ efficiency units came on board.

Mike Bird

I pay my gas company (Center point Energy in Minnesota) for whole house appliance repair. So if an appliance fails and they can't fix it (always the first option they try. Included in the plan) they have a maximum amount they'll pay to replace it, and let you find and buy. They have one other option on furnaces, heat pumps, and water heaters, where they'll do it themselves. When I was thinking of upgrading my furnace & A/C to heat pump, they sent me to one of their contractors. He was down to earth, said they'd been doing it since the 1990s, and talked to about cold-eeather heat pumps. He talked about sizing, and asked specific details about my house. Size, shade coverage, how much we use the basement, etc. He recommended that since we have the current furnace plumbed for methane ("natural gas") that we use that for supplemental heat during the 2 - 3 weeks a year it would be necessary. All in all he and the pricing was very reasonable. So yes, it varies greatly from company to company.

Sam Lowry

I had to look up what HVAC is as it is not something I am familiar with. It then became clear what it is later in your video. You seem to wonder if this would be a topic you could cover. I hear you talking about your displeasure with the industry and I phased out. All I really heard was a complaint about this industry, the workmanship and that they have a high mark-up. If this would be the subject of a video, I will likely not watch it. It would not teach me anything worth knowing. It would have no "aha" moment where you see something new on a common object. These moments are why I watch your videos.

Mark Thornton

I think you need to separate your thinking on sizing and pricing of systems. Oversizing seems to be a common problem for heating and domestic hot water here in the UK. Critics (check out Heat Geek videos on YouTube) suggest it's mostly due to outdated convention rather than enthusiastic up-selling. Gathering accurate requirements takes time and so costs money. Installing an undersized system would lead to complaints and costly work to rectify. Oversizing leads mostly just to cycling and inefficiency, but customers are less likely to notice or complain about that. Excessive pricing on the other hand is likely just an economic issue. If the demand exists from people willing/able to stand high profit margins then there's no incentive for companies to reduce their profit margins. One way to solve that could be a well-funded disruptor, which is increasingly what Octopus Energy looks like in Europe.

TheWebMachine

As someone who just spent over $24k for a 4-ton heat pump system, you definitely should cover this topic with all the ferver you can muster. If I had replaced my system in 2020, it would have "only" cost me $18k...you're telling me it cost $6k more due to *only* inflation over 3 yrs!? It stinks of price gouging. For context, I have 1900 sq ft in Texas. It was a one-to-one swap, spare moving from one-way AC to heat pump. Throw the entire industry under the bus; it's fraught with fraud and scams because AC can mean life or death down here. Back before I replaced my system, I needed the old system repaired. The first company I contacted charged me a $300 trip charge and then no-call/no-showed me 3 times until I reversed their fraudulent charge on my CC. I took a drive past their registered address to find an empty strip mall! A report to our state's corrupt AG's office has gone unanswered for 2yrs now. Then again, that is the unregulated nature of Texas. Plumbers, HVAC, etc...they all charge outrageous trip charges that don't get applied as a credit on the actual service charges. Then, because you're already hundreds deep in a non-refundable charge, you are over a barrel for whatever else they want to charge you because you aren't in a position to get a second opinion without expending hundreds more on someone else's trip charge. We need new regulations on "essential home service providers" like plumbing, electrical, and HVAC to protect homeowners from this type of predatory behavior. Edit: As an aside, we put HVAC and all the ductwork in *uninsulated* attics down here in TX...cuz fuck efficiency! Shit like that would be illegal in most other states with any sense.

Technology Connections

We are indeed behind on ventilation standards, yes. A lot of homes here are too sealed up, frankly. However, there are now (at least in Illinois, can't speak to other states) some minimum outside air requirements, and HRV/ERV systems are becoming more commonplace. The pandemic accelerated interest in that space. Another thing I'd appreciate having is a way to quickly exchange the interior air with outside air. Still air at night means that you really can't cool your house by opening windows unless there's quite a large temperature difference, and for whatever reason there's been little interest in designing a system to quickly force interior air outside. But, designing such a system in while also maintaining the airtightness of the structure when you're not using it would be challenging, I think. I suspect that's why we don't often see it.

Technology Connections

I suppose that could be another angle, here - it would be great if we had something other than Google reviews or whatever to help point people to better installers. I think in large part the scummier parts of the industry thrive by exploiting knowledge gaps, so if someone curated a list of go-to "honest" companies that would hopefully force prices down.

Totorose

I did not know about heat pumps until I found your channel. Too late for my home in Kentucky (where it would have been perfect) but I had to advocate for a heat pump in my new home in Chicagoland. I suspect you're referencing Four Seasons, I had to push them to get a heat pump quote. I eventually found Abt, which carries Mitsubishi but they could not get the hyper heat unit I wanted. Instead they quoted me a Bosch 3 ton 20 SEER unit with an ecobee 6 for $6200, that's with installation and removal of the old AC unit.

MrHammond

You're almost confirming the cliché we have here in Europe about the Americans, living in cheap, badly isolated houses spending a lot of energy on heating and cooling, and — except for a couple of exceptions, of which you are clearly one ;-) — not caring about that... So yes, even if I'm in Europe, I would love to see some videos about that! And also the scam in installation companies, I guess that happens here also. Another problem we have here is that there seems to be not enough capacity to install newer, energy-efficient systems, many companies are fully booked to a long period of time... That can also increase costs. BTW: attics are here usually used as storage space, in my previous house, there was indeed no isolation under the roof, you could only store stuff there that would not have any problem with getting hot, cold and dirty... Although in other houses, the space up until the top of the roof is used as living space, in contrast to the USA, space is extremely expensive here in Switzerland, probably a square metre of land costs more than a whole house in the USA... We tend to get the most out of it then ;-). O ja, I measured the walls here for you: 35 cm (13¾ inches) thick, which for me tend to be badly isolated... That depends of course also on the material the walls are made of, the house where I live is probably built in the 1960s, they tended to build very cheaply and badly here during that time...

Crissa Kentavr

Naw, alot of those methods were not implemented yet in the code then.

Sam Katzenberg

Just don't use Harry Tuttle, he has gone rogue.

Technology Connections

Honestly, that's fantastic to hear! I used Abt for the washer at my new place and didn't know they do HVAC stuff. That feels like a very reasonable quote - but it also makes me feel even worse for my folks. I think I'll just... not tell them about this

Crissa Kentavr

...unless it's the other end that fails.

Crissa Kentavr

They're in almost every building, though?

Frank Heitzman

Insulating under the roof deck instead of on top of the ceiling provides very useful storage space. I would usually specify 7 1/2" of closed cell Spray Foam Polyurethane insulation which provides R-49 and easily fits within the typical 2x8 or 2x10 rafter depth. This type of insulation also provides a vapor barrier which is important for both walls and roofs. The problem with 14" of fiberglass insulation above the ceiling is that you cannot create a good vapor barrier there because it will have holes in it from the staples and overlaps of the polyethylene membrane.

Mark L

so start a heating/cooling company review service. Have links to wholesale costs of the equipment. and let people post what they paid for the full purchase and install, and who did it. People will naturally migrate to the non-price-gougers, whose business will grow and the other companies will learn they need to compete or get out of the business. Might even encourage the honest to start selling and installing heat pumps at a fair price.

Frank Heitzman

I would like for you to go deeper into the issue of cost of heat pumps today and why there is so much markup. I priced a replacement heat pump system for my house. replacing. It came to $12000 even reusing my existing ductwork!

Mike Bird

On the last point, my parent's best friends after they retired and had moved to Arizona, were from Boston area, and when they moved to Az, The were shocked at slabs. So, he contacted some contractor friends in Ma, and they came out and dug a basement. They're cooling bill went down 200%. They set up a business to making a bunch of homes and had a shtick to pay the first 5 years of HVAC, as long as they didn't leave the windows and doors open on hot days. Edit: this was in the 1980s. I also remember the local (to Mn) DIY TV shows were talking about a new home design out of the Chicago area using 6" studs instead of the standard (back then) 4" studs.

Kevin Kostka

When my mother got her A/C replaced a few years ago, I asked them about going for the heat pump version of the model they were going to sell—A little bit oversized, of course—and the salesman straight-up said they couldn't do it because "heat pumps don't work in Wisconsin". The other two places we spoke with said the same thing while offering worse A/C units for more money. The HVAC industry feels fundamentally broken right now. Ignorance, greed, and outright hucksters seem to predominate, and there doesn't seem to be much push from within the industry to do things right and undercut the other companies by a bunch for better products. I think it's a hugely-important topic, but I also think it's a very entrenched and insular industry, so it's going to piss people off. [But I think everyday folks would be multiple times more pissed off to know how bad they've been screwed and for how long.]

Totorose

I also heard "heat pumps don't work in Illinois" when I was gathering quotes to replace the furnace/AC units in February. I had read an article that New England was pushing heat pumps and I would mention that to the salesperson and ask, why does a heat pump work in Massachusetts but not in Illinois?

Totorose

I found Abt by searching for a licensed Mitsubishi dealer because I wanted the Hyper Heat unit. My quotes are all from February 2023 so perhaps prices have changed since then. The quotes I got from Four Seasons were similar but the units (Lennox Merit 2.5 ton, 14 SEER, 17 SEER) just did not compare to the specs on the Bosch so I went with Abt. It was installed in March and so far I have been pleased (it was a champ during the hundred degree days) but there is one thing I wasn't prepared for and that is the defrost cycle on a cold day. The first time it happened I thought the unit was malfunctioning.

Matt Plachejo

My guess is they know you might get a tax rebate so they think you won’t mind paying higher prices?

Jimmy Dorff

So HVAC and hot water are in my attic. Chatting about a very expensive home design (not mine) I learned there is not a chance of a utility closet or anything like that. In a 6000 sq foot house they could not sacrifice any room, not even for a hot water heater. The trend is mounting tankless hot water on the exterior of the house.

Grant Pluntze

Your “my host is a battery” video seems much more plausible now! And I already thought it was! I’ve spent most of my life in the pacific north west and Colorado. I honestly did not know there were places where 2x6 exterior walls were common. Today I live in Idaho, where, as in many places right now the cost of housing is insanely out of control. I doubt any contractor could justify the additional cost of 6 inch exterior walls to any developer or buyer. It would take a radical change of mindset and probably codes to see us build more efficient houses. I think most people would say it’s not worth the cost. That said, I’m now angry knowing that I’ve spent my entire life believing that my houses were well insulated within reason.

Jeff Brown

I feel that these video ideas would be greatly enriched with background regarding engineering practice for system design and capacity requirements, cost estimates, and relevant data. I don’t doubt that HVAC installers sometimes take advantage of the ignorance of their clients and I feel that education may be a better antidote than a rant.

Grant Pluntze

I recently talked to a solar sales guy. They build the tax rebate into their quote. And not only that, they assume you will use that entire rebate as a down payment which would reduce the interest on the rest of the loan (assuming you’re not paying cash. ) I also got him to admit that there is a decent chance you won’t be able to receive the entire tax rebate for two or three years depending on how much tax you pay in a year.

Some Ed

As I understand it, there's actually been a fair amount of development in material sciences since the 1950s. R49 in the attic was a lot harder back then and it probably would've been asbestos. I mean, it *shouldn't* have been, as that's decades after we learned how toxic that stuff is. But it's my understanding that it was still quite widely used until some time in the 1970s simply because of lack of information flow and reluctance to use the less efficient alternatives that were available at that time. These days, as I understand it, we have insulation that's better at insulating than asbestos. At least some of it's still not exactly pleasant, but it's at least less likely to kill you. Some of it's new enough we may not be sure yet, though a lot more testing is needed these days than the no testing that was the minimum back in the day.

Some Ed

For what it's worth, I was in a bedroom that according to physics "would never get any of that air", but it was fine. It got *less* of that air than other rooms, but I tended to not want such extreme temperature control anyway. Even if they were right, a partial block would be sufficient to balance out the flow. Air T ducts don't need to be all one or all the other. That having been said, the partial block solution was implemented at the split, something that was a bit easier because we were looking at rectangular ducts between interior floors, so they weren't insulated and thus much easier to get into.

Jerrad Pierce

Manual J is only as good as the inputs (GIGO). And often contractors don't know or care enough to figure out how the home is built so you end up with results that may not be much better than "400 ft2 per ton"

Jerrad Pierce

It's not necessarily that thy are taking advantage, but that they do not want to deal with call backs. People expect instant arctic air because they just put in a new system, and so inappropriate equipment may be installed.

Jerrad Pierce

Much of the country has basements. But also, but it in the interior walls and chases in closets, etc. Fully conditioned mechanicals and ductwork is more efficienct, but requires more planning and can eat up a small amount of square footage; as if modern McManions are tight on space.

Jerrad Pierce

SEER is not inverse it's ust a weird mixed-system unit: Mean BTU of heat moved per Watt in. Ducted unit lose are not only because of duct losses, but the equipment itself will run less efficiently when ducted due to the airflow. The same model can easily have a 5-15% lower performance in a ducted installation.

Jerrad Pierce

This is making some gross generalizations. Efficiency improvements have been achieved through many avenues including scroll compressors and inverter drives. To say that all equipment with high efficiency ratings are cooking the books is disingenuous.

Jerrad Pierce

New homes in North American jurisdictions with a decent (i.e; modern IECC-based) building code have ventilation requirements, but these are typically met with unbalanced (exhaust-only) ventilation. However mandatory energy recovery ventilation is beginning to come in to play in many places, including Massachusetts.

Jerrad Pierce

Accurately assessing sizing is non-trivial, but some rough figures can be generated with something like the online Manual J calculator CoolCalc.com

Jerrad Pierce

There some websites that do the crowd-sourcing for you and provide approximate job costs for different regions. Your local utility may also have information on this, look for "incremental cost" studies. In fact, I seem to recall seeing one from ConEd for all sorts of electrification-related equipment a year or so ago.

Jerrad Pierce

If only more folks knew about the floor-based air handlers, which can easily fill the space of an old radiator and less objectionable than wall-mount for may people. The new saddlebag window heatpumps also look promising.

Peter

I would encourage you to watch the video I linked. The main issue is that the cooling coil is at a temperature above the dew point, so it doesn't extract moisture from the air (it still works fine at cooling the air).

Ryan Butler

The current system needs a brick thrower. You got a pile of bricks. If you break a couple of windows you weren’t aiming at and have to apologize. Swing away

Jerrad Pierce

I did, which is why I said the presenter was making gross-generalizations in his claim that increases in efficiency have been primarily through adjustments in SHR.

cole

I live in Phoenix(ish) and wow every single house I've lived in has had attic ducting, including one my parents had contracted to build themselves in 2015. This is probably the worst place to have attic ducting! What's worse is a lot of older homes around here have packaged rooftop ac units, the whole thing sitting in the sun while it's 115 degrees with absolutely no shade.

Peter

I see your concern; the video is a segment of a larger video, where the speakers are more clear that their concern is with the definition of SEER itself and not as much with the equipment used to achieve that number. The speakers themselves are advocates for the inverter drives and other improvements that are available in some equipment.

Peter

The piece of equipment you are thinking about for exchanging indoor air for outdoor air is called a whole-house fan (sometimes also mis-named attic fan). The difficulty with using one is that you don't want to use it when the outdoor humidity is high.

James D

I guess a way I might be interested in seeing it framed is, how to decide on an installer for HVAC equipment (are you getting a good price, do they do good work, what to look for in reviews / recommendations)

Kevin Smith

When we replaced the system in a rental house in Idaho several years ago, the installers happened to suggest a 2-zone system, which we went with. It was FANTASTIC being able to keep different floors at roughly the same temp. In 2020, almost no companies here in Eastern Washington even understood the concept. They kept pitching mini-splits rather than a 2 or 3 zone ducted central system. So we ended up using the only company that would do it. We love our 2-zone system, which didn't require any duct reworking. Doing a 3-zone would have been a lot of work, so we settled for having the main floor and basement on a shared zone. It would be great if you could include zoning somehow, since it improves efficiency but especially also comfort, if you have more than one story. Maybe that should be a whole video on it's own. Unfortunately, this company never suggested a heat pump. I wish I had better understood them, because I totally would have pushed for one. It would have saved us a ton of money (and cut our use of fossil fuels). When we replaced the AC in a Florida condo years ago, I think they were pushing for a 2.5 ton unit. I think I wanted a 1.5 ton, and I think we ended up compromising at 2. Which was still a bit oversized in practice. Yes, please help get the word out about proper system sizing.

Wolfin Core

I bet government incentives are playing a big role too. If the government will give you $3000 toward a heat pump, raise those prices $3000.

Ben Gott

When I moved into my home in southern CT in 2015, I had three companies come to give me a quote on replacing my furnace and installing central A/C. The first two companies suggested "Jurassic Park"-like tonnage for the A/C unit. When the rep from the third company came in, I showed him the other quotes, and he just laughed. "You install units this big," he told me, "you'll never get rid of the moisture. That's just malpractice." We had a longer discussion about it (standing in my basement), and he explained that Connecticut requires that an A/C system is enough to cool down the home to x degrees when it's y degrees outside. Even acknowledging that climate change is having a tremendous impact on the number of hot days we're having, he said that a lot of his competitors were trying to push more expensive, too-big units "just to be safe." But if your A/C isn't cycling long enough to get rid of the moisture in your home, that creates its own (significant!) issues. I told him that the "just to be safe" comment (which I'd heard from both of the previous salespeople) made me so angry because 1) that's not how HVAC systems work, and 2) preying on a homeowner's fear of doing it "wrong" so that you can sell a more expensive system is unconscionable. How many elderly people do we know who would hear "just to be safe" and say "Oh, well then, let's go with the 'safer' system (that just happens to cost $3,000 more)!"? Needless to say, I've used this company ever since and have recommended them to a half dozen friends who have needed new systems installed. They have never disappointed. (And I get a $175 credit each time, which is nice!)

Ahmad

Massively undersized ducts are another common issue I have seen, especially in upgrades. Installers often ignore the increased airflow requirements of newer, more efficient systems. A recent example I saw was a 1960s furnace in a 1000 sq ft mild climate home that was replaced with a 2-ton heat pump without changing the ductwork. The entire home was served with four 4-inch ducts (plus an always-closed bathroom register). That's only good for 4x20 = 80 CFM. The unit, per spec, ideally required 800 CFM, and at least 700 CFM. Unsurprisingly, the system was unable to cool or heat well. Two separate techs were unable to figure out anything wrong with it after checking pressures and air temperatures. After researching the airflows, I was confident enough to have a contractor replace the ductwork to my exact specs. Even then, the contractor was complaining that I am oversizing the ducts, even though I spaced the ductwork to a total of 875 CFM, which is not too high. Needless to say, the unit is now working fine after the ductwork upgrade.

Circuitmike

This may be my autism spectrum speaking, but I just can't understand why on earth you'd ever want to be tactful with these companies that are CLEARLY ripping us all off. It IS greed, and nothing more. If anyone has clear evidence to the contrary, sure, make a good-faith effort to investigate that possibility, but JESUS! At this rate, greed is going to cause the implosion of our society. Food, fuel, and housing are already to the point where people's lives are being destroyed.

Michael Abili

I’m glad I live in the south, specially central Texas. Most of the HVAC companies in Texas would rather undersized than oversized a unit.

Nathan K

Huh, I lived in Houston and (in my experience at least) it was hardly uncommon to blast a foot of insulation up into the attic without any rafter insulation.

Matthew

An HVAC installer friend of mine told me that the price they paid for the hardware would go down as the volume they sold went up. (The price difference was substantial.) I don't know if it was split by product category, but I could see this resulting in heat pumps being inexplicably more expensive because the sales volume was low. Location - Central Texas

Westinghouse

I'm late to the convo, but better late than never. After watching your video, I have two thoughts. One, you're right about central heating/cooling and that modern homes (x<30yrs) should be using this approach. Second thought, your concern over HVAC efficiency really takes root in passive environment control; insulation. Myself and many engineers who deal with facility management always need to take into account the "building envelope" and "fenestrations". I would suggest diving into ASHRAE materials on insulation and making a presentation on envelope materials, build orientation, and heat transfer. This is stuff some PEs literally think about for their entire career. An AC system will always be more efficient if you know how to first build an effective building envelope...and not put the duct work in the attic.

Brett Duane

Perhaps one of the reasons oversized heat pumps are suggested is for their heating capacity during winter. It's possible a 3-ton unit may be required to keep the house warm in the winter, but may be oversized for cooling during summer. Some winter performance data would be helpful. I also suspect installers don't know how to size ventilation ducting. The house I'm in has long tiny ducts that are further split into long tiny ducts that do a poor job of heating/cooling all the rooms upstairs, yet the master bed/bath (upstairs) got a short monstrous duct that is clearly overkill for the task. The installers did a better job downstairs.