Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's time I finally address this discourse. It's come up a couple of times in previous videos mostly as an aside, but I've never take a position on it either way. Well, today I do!

https://youtu.be/vNj75gJVxcE

Unfortunately I had to re-shoot the talking head thanks to a sanity check I realized I should make. A trip to the store revealed that not only was something I had witnessed not-at-all universal, but it also added a couple of visuals that improved the pacing at the beginning tremendously! It also made it a bit longer...

So, uh, I hope you like it and follow my reasoning. The Connextras follow-up (which addressed the sanity-check) is mostly edited and I'll get that up as soon as I can. 

Files

Power outlets are topsy turvy - but does it matter?

The answer may surprise you! Technology Connextras (my second channel where stuff goes sometimes) https://www.youtube.com/@TechnologyConnextras Technology Connections on Mastodon: https://mas.to/@TechConnectify This channel is supported through viewer contributions on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration! https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections

Comments

Elsie Hupp

I dunno about you but I prefer my electrical receptacles looking like disembodied faces frozen in existential horror.

Elsie Hupp

I think the preference in marketing materials comes from the perception that people buy less of things when they look like they were designed by Edvard Munch. 🙀

Elsie Hupp

carpe diem, memento mori, etc., etc.

Jesse Packard

There is no official guidance from any agency, and, in the 1 in a 10 million case, that's what your breakers are for, if, the GFCI that should be on the circuit does not catch it first. OH and arc fault breakers are becoming the norm.

Socram (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 08:00 I'm not sure why the American connectors haven't evolved like the Schukos did here. Namely, most modern molded plastic plugs have a very useful flare on the back of the plug to increase grip when removing from the socket. Sockets in new installations are seemingly also mostly installed horizontal like there in Chicago, except the plugs are rotated 90º from what the NEMA sockets are, so you can install multiple right angled connectors and they A: don't collide with each other and B: the cable hangs down. All these could be made without even risking breaking backwards compatibility. I don't comprehend why they aren't.
2023-09-24 20:01

bemusedHorseman

I'm conflicted on this one. On the one hand, it's a textbook case of "common agreed-upon usage dictates the standard, not the other way around", that the NEMA 5-15 standard has /become/ "ground pin on the bottom to look like a face", /because/ the supermajority of actual users say it's that way, regardless of the original creators' intent (which I do agree having the ground pin on top is objectively safer). ...But on the other, "GIF is pronounced like the peanut butter because that's what the original creator of the format said its pronounciation is" is a hill I'm determined to die on, contradicting my own statement on how standards "should" be redefined by their users. (But on the third hand, GIF's pronounciation isn't as one-sided as the "preferred" usage of NEMA 5-15 is. GIF has an approximately 50/50 split for the two pronounciations, whereas /nearly everyone/ thinks the outlet "should look like a face, because it IS a face"...)

Shanester366

In the commercial space, at least where I live, we pretty much exclusively install them ground up.

Elsie Hupp

Two things: (1) We Americans value the existential horror conveyed by the 😱 on the NEMA socket, and (2) Thanks the EU, the electrical socket of the future is just USB-C. Keep in mind that the EU can’t even standardize sockets between its member states, so the only country that has implemented IEC 60906-1 is South Africa, and, tenuously, Brazil, since the EU decided against it because idk reasons (read: bullshit). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60906-1

Elsie Hupp

North American electrical code still permits shared neutral between circuits, which makes full-circuit GFCI nearly impossible to retrofit, which is extremely annoying.

Technology Connections

I have noticed this in some commercial buildings, yeah. Both of the hotels I worked in, for example. But I'll have to keep my eyes open when I'm out and about because, at this point, I'm wondering whether the sideways convention around here is residential only...

Aaron the Tinkerer

Just wanted to share - every refrigerator I've ever had to unplug before my 2022 LG one has had a right-angle plug with the ground lead on top, so when the outlet has the ground at the top, the cord hangs straight down the wall. Almost like it was meant to be.

Elsie Hupp

As I understand it, the GIF split initially broke down as soft-G for people who learned about it in face-to-face corporate and academic settings and hard-G for people who learned about it in written text, i.e. the early Internet. So I’m pro-hard-G because soft-G is elitist (and uses non-standard phonetics to make a dubious pun). If you want a pun to stick, make a better contrived acronym than that! JFIF is a thing, so they could have literally made it JIFF, but they didn’t. Anyway I take the queer-theory approach to the NEMA 😱—it doesn’t have to be intentional to be canon.

Shanester366

Yea, its the standard here, but occasionally a client will want them with the ground down and we will do it. Its rare to see the sideways ones here, other than when there just isn`t the room to install it standardly. As an apprentice I was told the reason was as you stated in the video about falling stuff hitting the ground instead of the hot.

Baulderan

So here's something you might not have thought of: the fact that it looks like a face is a problem. Very young children are instinctively drawn to things that look like faces. By switches them upside down, you help protect young children from being instinctively drawn to them.

Technology Connections

I'm very surprised because I've had the exact opposite experience. Well, actually, not the exact opposite because I don't think I've /ever/ run across a right-angle plug with ground on top. But I wouldn't doubt they exist somewhere...

Elsie Hupp

I don’t know about you, but I think it’s important to teach small children not to stab people in the face with a fork lol

Technology Connections

This doesn't pass my personal sniff test, if I'm honest. Toddler-me still stuck a screwdriver into a sideways Chicago plug! And tamper-resistant outlets mostly solve this problem anyway.

Technology Connections

See, my central issue isn't that the ground on top wouldn't be safer (because it would be!) but that the majority of plugs don't even have the ground pin anyway. So it's a case of "this might, depending on how many other holes line up in the Swiss cheese model, provide some safety" against "so many things don't support ground-up orientation and there are better ways to solve these problems, anyway"

Elsie Hupp

I have two window air conditioners with right-angle plugs, and of course—of course!—they disagree with each other. But then again I grew up in suburban Chicago, and all the original ungrounded, unpolarized 1957 outlets in my parents’ house were mounted sideways. (Oddly, the boxes were square boxes with one-gang mud rings. It was trivially easy to install modern outlets, though, considering the grounded rigid conduit.) And while I completely rewired my apartment here in Brooklyn after moving in, IIRC the original 1926 electrical boxes for the very few outlets the place was built with were mounted sideways, too. (The boxes were one-gang boxes, but the fabric-wrapped aluminum wire was in grounded flexible steel conduit.)

Rob C

Might be why you are still around!

Elsie Hupp

I mean I have rewired table lamps to give them a ground pin, just like IIRC you did with your Sunbeam toaster back in the day. But personally I prefer Maximm 360° (which you can also find on Amazon): https://maximmcable.com/maximm-360/ I don’t think you can buy these as kits (e.g. for lamps), but I guess you could cut the receptacle end off of an extension cord and repurpose it if you wanted to, though.

Baulderan

Tamper resistant outlets do solve the issue, but honestly I've encountered only a single tamper-resistant plug in my life-- a kitchen plug in the first apartment after I moved out. Anecdotally, the only reason why I have ever heard of "grounded plug up" was to stop it looking like a face. And a search for "childproofing looks like face" shows me a LOT of sources, but weirdly now that I look for it they're all... electrical/plumbing services that now have that recommendation?

bemusedHorseman

I know there's one thing that everyone can agree on, though: the "I put the Christmas lights the wrong way up" special known as the double-male-ended Secret Cord™, is something that should never be created and, as a Home Depot employee that sometimes works in electrical, I look forward to the day a customer asks me about one and I get to /gleefully/* tell them why they're five minutes from becoming an ElectroBOOM video and they need to put the lights the right way up if they don't want to unalive themselves. ⚡ *(because it's so rare to get a "the customer is NOT always right" moment that corporate will actually back us up on, because telling a customer NOT to do something unsafe is one of the few times we're allowed to be blunt and tell a customer they're stupid)

Paul

I think that the reason the plugs of other countries have been standardized to a safer / more foolproof design is that those countries also have some of the exaggerated fear of electricity you've referred to. The outlet is not usually the cause of house fires (cooking and heating elements win there), and in 99+% of cases, even if the outlet shocks you, it's a mild flash burn to the tip of a finger. The hot and neutral both being right there keep the power from going anywhere else in your body. I work in an ER and I've literally seen more people get struck by lightning than get shocked from a outlet. And the outlet shock got a bandaid and shown to the door lol.

Michael Steeves

As an electrical engineer with some code experience, I always appreciate your research and getting things right! I do think the ground at the top being safer is a case of "Whataboutism". If it were a significant issue of kids being injured because of the crappy design, You'd better believe that regulators would do something about it!

Mike Gatch Photography

I wonder if the change in marketing and display has something to do with avoiding any potential lawsuits. Aside from that, I feel like it's more of a commercial/application specific practice.

triggthediscovery

Wouldn't bridging a connection to ground be equally problematic? Maybe not on the neutral line, but if you connect the hot wire to ground, I would expect a similar spark to bridging the two main pins.

Brooks Moses

I appreciate the plug on my fancy food processor, which actually has a finger hole through the middle to use to pull it out. (Search for "Breville power cord" and you'll find it. Also I just discovered they have a cord with that style of plug and a C13 computer-style connector on the other end, part number SP0010547. I am very tempted to get a couple for general use....)

Robert Sanges

This will go down in history as the second most important TC video - right after the amber turn signals one.

cole

soooo.. the real solution is have them sideways, with the neutral pins on top?

Brooks Moses

My brother-in-law had a pretty bad experience with an electrical shock as a young kid, but it was because of a case of "I can't pull this cord out with my hand so I'll use my teeth to grab the plug." Flash burns to the inside of the cheek are, I gather, really unpleasant. Still, that's anecdote, not data, and also I doubt the outlet shape would have made much difference (though using a three-prong plug in any orientation rather than a tiny two-prong one that fits in a kid's mouth easily probably would have.)

bemusedHorseman

To be fair I still get confused about the fact that the /widest/ pin isn't the Hot pin, you'd think the largest pin would be "the one the electricity comes 'out' of". Same logic with batteries, the positive terminal (with the bump) "should" be the one that the power comes out of...

Ryan Schaffer

Thank you for covering this topic! I saw an upside down plug just the other day in some new conatruction and it renewed my curiosity on the matter.

cole

yeah that gets me too

Elsie Hupp

On the upside, though, LEDs generally run at lower voltages. And under other circumstances this is what C1 connectors are used for. Sure, you can blow a fuse by plugging two C1 cords into the same device, but unlike with a male NEMA connector, you aren’t personally going to be conducting the electricity when you do so. All this is to say that line-voltage Christmas lights are basically designed to kill you, so low-voltage options are for the better.

Elsie Hupp

The real solution is that within our lifetimes most consumer devices will just use USB-C instead, so with the exception of large appliances most people will probably not have to deal with high-voltage receptacles anymore. (Basically, the transformers will move inside the wall, rather than being gigantic wall warts with high-voltage connectors within easy reach.)

Darryl Gerrow

Yeah…. My SNES power brick says no.

Peter Freese

I was kind of worried when I saw the teaser image, but I like where you ended up with this episode. I recall reading about this several years ago, and ended up with the same conclusion you arrived at. I wonder how much longer we'll be stuck with this plug/socket design.

clickallnight

I'll watch the video with an open mind, but I really prefer my outlets to look like little faces, soooo....

Afonso F. Garcia

This made me appreciate the recessed nature of schuko sockets

rubberduckjams

I had the unfortunate chance of touching the exposed ends of a Sony TV plug as a kid and I still have PTSD from that... It froze my hand on the plug for a few seconds until I fell on the floor paralyzed. Took me a while to start breathing again... I had no idea it was this dangerous.

Technology Connections

To be honest, I'm very skeptical we're going to see DC distribution in the home. It adds a new point of failure (whatever sort of power supply is feeding the branch), locks you into a set voltage unless we add even more layers of complexity, and adds a lot of losses. AC distribution is effectively lossless until you add a load, and then the losses within the AC system are minimal. I could be wrong, but it seems like moving to a DC future is way too much work for minimal gains or, quite possibly, negative gains.

MrHammond

You should look into the Swiss design, here they come mostly in triple outlets: those are all 120° apart, so the earth pin in all directions, but on the outside (I don't know if there are rules or assumptions on the horizontal receptacle being on top or on the bottom, usually I see them at the bottom though, and never have seen one with one that is vertical). Older designs are completely flat, just 3 times 3 holes on a flat plate, but the rules for new receptacles is that they need to be recessed, so you can't reach the pins when the pins reach the contacts. For two-prong plugs: until 2.5 Amps, Europlugs are used which have sleeved pins, above (like on a vacuum cleaner), usually solid pins without sleeves are used, for three-prong plugs: I've seen both. (the max. is 10A for the standard Swiss plug, for 16A, like the Schuko in Germany and a lot of other countries can handle, you need special receptacles that can handle thicker pins). When you have the old flat-design receptacles, the pins can reach out, I see it usually on my vacuum cleaner, as that cable is yanked around a lot... The big advantage of the Swiss design is that the plugs are rather small, for 3-prong connection only slightly thicker than a Europlug, unlike the bulky Schuko and British designs, although the last one is certainly the safest one.

MrHammond

BTW: the knife-at-the-wall-throwing game: 🤣🤣🤣 I really needed that one! 😃

MrHammond

I don't know how it is in other Schuko countries, but in the Netherlands, we used to have a flat design (better said: only a few mm recessed) into which a Schuko plug would fit, but it had no grounding... Funny enough, the 2-prong plugs designed for these outlets don't fit into a Schuko outlet, although there would be nothing against that from a safety perspective... I think these older plugs and outlets are no longer allowed in new installations, we used to file off part of the plugs so they could fit into Schuko outlets. When I moved to Switzerland, I decided to comply to the local regulations and left all Schuko and old Dutch stuff behind in the Netherlands and refitted everything I took with Swiss plugs.

Edverything

The knife gag got me so bad. Once again my wife is wondering why I'm laughing hysterically, and the answer is technology connections.

Jim Hewlett

I've been looking into high and low voltage wiring. the consensus seems to be that low voltage works well with minimal current but badly with high current. Modern stuff is generally lower current, but there are two counter arguments. One is that longer >6 metre wires are bad. the other in't really the 'fault' of low voltage but the connections have to be good because low voltage, low current equipment (LED Car lights) flicker when you bump. With the US type plug I would be very careful about fumbling with a cutlery knife in the kitchen. In the UK we like a 'built in' switch on the 'live' side. There is a variant that has a rubber tip to the rocker switch which melts and 'fails safe' if there's a bit of arcing.

Circuitmike

I will never NOT hate ground-on-top. Never. Also, speaking from personal experience, yes, you can get your spindly little kid fingers down there by the prongs and give yourself a spicy surprise! I assure you that's a mistake you'll only make once, and even when it happens, it's extraordinarily unlikely to kill you or do serious damage. The current will probably flow through one or two fingers and the resulting shock will cause you to rip your hand away from the plug in a right-proper hurry. Again - speaking from personal experience!

M Free

For me, it’s the right angle plug that makes the difference. Having a cord that loops up the wall and back down is demonstrably worse for both shock and tripping hazards. Hospitals may have adopted the ground up arrangement because almost everything they plug in is mobile, so this lets the cord go straight to the outlet, instead of looping down and then back up if it has a right angle plug.

For the Birbs (Jim Hooke)

In UK, Australia and New Zealand the active and neutral plug pins have to be insulated halfway to prevent access if plug isn't inserted fully. The UK has earth at the top

Evil Kyle

Exactly one time have I seen a cord with a right-angle plug that had the ground pin on top. (Unsurprisingly, it was plugged into an outlet that didn't, so the cord itself was still all catty-wompus.) So yes, that point is very much valid. Also, one thing I learned back in my residential wiring class is that if an outlet is installed sideways, the neutral pin should be on top for safety. Why Chicago generally disobeys that is anyone's guess.

Richard Bevan

Having grown up in the UK (almost all plugs are right angle) and now living in europe (mostly straight plug/cable design) I think the straight design is better. if you pull the cable by mistake the plug comes out of the wall, rather than strain the plug/cable and transfer the force to your laptop or whatever else is at the other end of the cable. And there is nothing worse than treading on a loose UK plug in your bare feet because the pins always seem to be pointing up. European plugs are not such a painful experience because they lie flat.