Against Method: Appendix 1/Chapter 16 (Patreon)
Content
Apologies for the late post—between some traveling and the extra long chapter I misjudged the time I’d need, and wow was this reading dense!
~~~~~
Chapter 16 - Finally, the kind of comparison that underlies most methodologies is possible only in some rather simple cases. It breaks down when we try to compare non-scientific views with science or when we consider the most advanced, most general and therefore most mythological parts of science itself
~~~~~
As interesting as the whole discussion of greek art/poetry was as an analogy to the shift between scientific cosmologies was, the part I’m interested in thinking more about was this passage from the introduction:
“One must remember those cases where science, left to itself, committed grievous blunders, and one must not forget the instances when political interference did improve the situation. Such a balanced presentation of the evidence may even convince us that this time is overdue for adding the separation of state and science to the by now quite customary separation of state and church. Science is only one of the many instruments people invented to cope with their surroundings. It is not the only one, it is not infallible, and it has become too powerful, too pushy, and too dangerous to be left on its own.” (Pg 164)
First I do take a little issue with his premise here—I don’t know that I think ‘science left to itself’ exists. When he talks about grievous blunders, I think about things like the creation of nuclear weapons. Some people will act like this was just an inevitable development in the progress of physics, but (and I have a whole video idea about this) there was no atomic bomb without a government that wanted to use it, provided the resources to make it, and incentivized scientists to work on it. Meaning this was not ‘science left to itself’. I’m wondering if there’s some better example of what he means that I’m missing, so if anyone can think of something I’d love to hear it, but I just can't even conceive of a ‘science left to itself’ to begin with.
All that aside, I am intrigued by the idea of separation of science and state. I certainly like the idea of a government not motivating its scientists with military aspirations and whatnot, but I also wonder how it would actually work. If not the government, who pays for science? Feyerabend seemed to speak very highly of patronage as a mode of funding science in an earlier chapter, but what would the modern equivalent of that look like? An idealistic answer might be something like patreon (it is a direct reference to patronage after all), but what I feel like it would actually end up being is like a venture-capitalist approach to science where it’s just billionaires instead of governments that push scientists to do whatever is useful for them. I mean I guess that's already happening to some degree with space exploration in the US being mostly privatized at this point. At this point it’s just hard to imagine developments in phyiscs/astornomy that don’t require obscene amounts of money, and bc capitalism idk how to separate that from science committing more “grievous blunders”. Curious if anyone else has thoughts on this point—what would science divested from the government look like?