Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Alright, time for our first chapter discussion! Feel free to share whatever thoughts or questions you had about the reading, but if you want to participate and can't think of something to share, a prompt that might get things going is to share one point/quote you agree with and one you disagree with (thanks Tawfiq M for the prompt idea!)

As a note, the earlier you get your comments in here, the more likely it is someone will respond to them. Theoretically someone could respond whenever, but in general you'll get the most engagement within the week of a post.

Excited to read your thoughts!

Comments

aliin

I haven't finished ch1 in its entirety yet so I'll keep it short and mention a section that stuck with me: "to affirm that men and women are persons and that as persons they should be free, and yet to do nothing tangible to make this freedom a reality, is a farce." I've been on a nation-wide palestine protest this weekend in Berlin, and I live around 4 hours away from there (by car) and as I'm still too young for a ride this long on my own I started looking for people among friends and family who'd be willing to come with me as this was a big deal for palestine activism in germany and my surroundings do support the cause. In the end I found nobody from among my own friends and family, except for a singular person whom I had befriended at the local protests. And I have a big family! Mamy of thrm and my friends either found excuses (I knew they had time that day) or straight-up ignored messages and pleas. That was the moment where it really struck me especially after reading ch1 that realizing oppression is not equivalent to nor enough for acting upon it. It was a group of over 20 strangers (most of whom didn't even know each other, some I partly knew, some not at all) and my friend I ended up going with and it was the coolest group with the sweetest people I ever knew. People who were willing to act, to offer themselves as drivers and welcome strangers to their cars. It ended up being a once in a lifetime experience with memories and companionships I will hold dear to my heart for the rest of my life, the train ride back was just everybody offering snacks to each other, a highlight for me if a small one. Truly, having the right opinions is simply not enough.

Christopher Garcia

I think one of the things that I've ruminated on a lot both before reading this and during is the idea of being held back by fear and the denial of being influenced. I think of people who watch Fox News religiously, people who are locked in to their Facebook algorithms, or who get 10 letters a day begging for money to stop the scary socialists, and it really is clear how much it's an addiction. Propaganda conditions your brain to struggle to function without its constant presence, and it's ultimate trick is making you think you don't have a problem. That, in fact, you know more than any naysayers and are a true free thinker. I think that's why liberation is such a communal effort, it takes community and comradery to overcome an addiction. The big hurdle of course as always, is getting someone to understand they have a problem and maintaining the empathy required to help them despite how much they hurt the people around them. I do wonder if/how the book will further address that need for empathy, often texts like this get caught up in cries for revolution that, while justified, tend to ignore how quickly that passion can shut down any open communication between those who can't see why there's such an urgency in our tone. It's a tricky line to walk and not one all have the energy to maintain balance on.

RA

[My long response - maybe y'all can ask an LLM to shorten to understand me 😅] [My Summary] What I got from this first chapter is that Freire is defining what he believes "oppressed" is, then states that to mitigate the effects of being oppressed, one needs a special type of education (pedagogy) that will be distinct in that it elicits more direct participation of the oppressed in curating the educational experience. His definition of the oppressed is marked by "dehumanization," "existential duality" (modeling oneself after the oppressor), being fearful of freedom from oppression (learned helplessness?), and a power imbalance he briefly alludes to. [Initial Reactions] I've never read this book but have heard so much about it. From the jump, I'm elated to be able to get a vocabulary to describe many things I've always seen but didn't know there was a word for. For instance, "horizontal violence" (harming others with your same social status) and "Conscientização" (learning to perceive social, political, and economic contradictions). I've also heard in my organizing life the term "praxis" (taking ideologies then applying them through action) but never understood it. I'm excited to go through this journey and see what he thought was both the ultimate cause of all of this and the solution. So much has changed since he first wrote this, but yet things are similar. For instance, today, post-COVID-19 and with AI, and the internet, teachers have reported that many students at the tail end of high school can't even read or are cheating severely with AI. A pedagogy of the oppressed might not even work today unless it's in short-form video, disseminated through a Discord server, put in training dataset of an LLM, or gamified. [Critiques] The way he speaks about the oppressed needing to uplift the oppressor and preserve their humanity, too, is interesting. I think Freire isn't accounting for the fact that, unlike in fictional novels, in the real world some people never undergo any meaningful, transformational character development by the end of the story. For instance, they might die or lose power but still have the exact mindset of the oppressor because the factors making them this way are very deep (possibly biological for them even). Also, he just broadly uses the terms "the oppressor" and "dehumanization." I think my gripe with most works, even today, is that, like those who benefit from the current world system, Freire doesn't seem to talk much in chapter 1 about colonization and the westernization and Europeanization of this oppression. I think this could interfere with developing a remedy. Saying more education (from the oppressed somehow liberating them) is what colonizers or the western world needs plays into the "false generosity" he criticizes. It socially constructs those benefiting from and perpetuating coloniality as simple victims of ignorance and not people willfully and surgically suppressing knowledge they could use to dismantle their oppressive ways.

RA

Firstly, I'm happy for you to have your civil liberties acknowledge and not assaulted for peacefully protesting. The propaganda I've been raised w/ in US is that this is supposedly what separates the west from countries they don't like - liberal democratic freedoms. Of course it's violated incessantly here in the US. Anyway, glad you found comradery in the "over 20 strangers" who "were willing to act" and "make this freedom a reality" as Freire promotes. He defined the word "praxis" in this chapter to underscore this (one must act not just learn). I feel similar to you. Here in California, USA, there are many protest surrounding, violence against children, women, and unarmed men as well as adult abductions by this agency ICE. They've effectively been deputized to wear mask, plain clothes, have unmarked cars, to abduct even US citizens. There are reports that bad actors (random men) have now started masquerading as this gestapo like agency. Our president has called National guardsmen and marines here to California, USA to assault innocent citizens exercising their constitutional right to assemble and protest the government (i.e. "free speech"). I am wondering if I should go to protest as it's become increasing more autocratic here in US. I read one report of teenagers being charged with "attempted murder of federal officer" for simply throwing a single item at one of these people abducting adults. It's tough because I hear what Freire (and you) are saying. It is sometimes difficult to balance risk vs. reward. Also it's hard to quantify how much change I'd make engaging in direct action. I've considered content creation around US collapse and using the money to bail out anti-ICE/ anti-fascist protest. I tip my hat to you for protesting!

RA

Yeah, I think the rise of cable TV media and social media is something I'm interested in seeing how Freire addresses since these weren't really prevalent when it was first written. Today, as you're saying many aren't really getting their ideas from sitting in a classroom receiving propaganda but turning on a TV or social media and having it warp their perception of reality. It's tough because there are so many signals and noise it's always difficult to register ground truth.

Isaiah G

First physical read, been over the audiobook 2-3 times. In this chapter I've become fixated on the "sub-oppressor", to use Freire's term, or more precisely the aspects of both oppressor and oppressed that many folks hold by virtue of intersectional identity and class. I think I'm stuck on this because I'm firmly middle class, and recognizing the ways the middle class becomes addicted to its own comfort (fear of freedom) and practices/aims for oppression via prescription daily (like in any number of remote spreadsheet jobs where they train you to climb the career ladder). When freedom means sacrificing comfort, I think a lot of us feel the fear of freedom quickly and intimately. The later focus on a pedagogy that reveals limiting situations—situations that might be material, and therefore common across subjective experience—feels promising in addressing this, but it varies so much in practice. To that end, I relied on this book heavily in organizing a local poetry workshop, where I had to deconstruct a lot of assumptions instilled in me by traditional education—reading together vs me reading to them, allowing open-ended questions vs me providing (banking) answers, etc etc. I really think a pedagogy of the oppressed still needs to be more deeply understood and better implemented even in many community education and organizing spaces, so I'm really grateful for more and more ways to internalize the ideas here

Isaiah G

To your point about the high school context, I work in education, and there’s lots of promising ideas about a pedagogy of the oppressed that in some moments relies on digital technology, but in other moments doesn’t at all. And it works! It’s much more about a lesson’s goals, and how student voice is incorporated, than any particular technology put toward the lesson’s goals, and we negotiate this constantly with edtech players who think AI will replace teachers

Preethi Basani

I still have about 8 pages left in chapter 1, which i will finish in the coming few days.Before I stop reading for the day, I just wanted to write my thoughts on what ive read so far. I have a lot more(almost highlighted every line lol) but to try to keep it under a page, these are the ones that stuck with me the most: I really enjoyed Friere’s framing of the fight against oppression as “an act of love opposing the lovelessness which lies at the heart of the oppressors violence”. I am currently also reading “all about love” by Bell Hooks and this quote reminded me of Hooks’ quote: “The search for love continues even in the face of great odds”. Putting these together gives a very hopeful reading that humanity will continue to fight for love and the end of dehumanization even when it feels utterly impossible. In line with this, Later on Friere also talked about the “necessity for constant control” . This reminded me of a Nemik from “Andor” (highly recommend for those that havent seen it) He says: “ the Imperial need for control is so desperate because it is so unnatural. Tyranny requires constant effort.” and “ Freedom is a pure idea. It occurs spontaneously and without instruction. Random acts of insurrection are occurring constantly throughout the galaxy.”. Now that I think about it, his manifesto in the show is probably at least partly inspired by Friere’s work. I also loved the emphasis on trust in the people. Trust is an act of love and for true liberation you must love people around you enough to trust them. Another quote that stood out to me was “Any situation in which "A" objectively exploits "B" or hinders his and her pursuit of self-affirmation as a responsible person is one of oppression. Such a situation in itself constitutes violence…” This helped me a lot with dealing with my own parent’s transphobia and rejection of me. I never conceptualized that as a violent act but reflecting after reading this, it absolutely was, and thus was a withholding of love. Not sure what will come of this realization but it's nice to have some vocabulary to better understand that. Finally turning to “what i disagreed with”. I don't think this is incompatible with this text or even a disagreement, but something i wondered about with regards to the conversation of the oppressed and oppressor existing in dialectics. From my experience the people can be either oppressed or oppressors in different axes of their lives. An example that demonstrates this is the rampant anti-blackness in many progressive movements. People that may be oppressed in terms of class, gender, etc can also be oppressors in race and perpetuate racism, etc. I’m curious to see if Friere tackles this in more depth later or if anyone here has any thoughts or insights into how exactly to make this work with whats in this text.

Rafael Andrade

About the current time: I would say we are not so different now than it was back then. AI and all those digital gadgets just intensify the educational model he will so much critique in the other chapters (It's impressive how similar apps like duolingo are from Skinner's Learning Machines in early 20 century). So Freire would be absolutely against any form of gamification of fast-content as education. About the oppressed uplifting the oppressors: This first chapter is very heavy in Hegel's ideas. And I guess the idea is to say how much dependent the oppressors are, so once the oppressed uprise they need to take the oppressors with them, or else they would just change places and the social structure wouldn't truly change.

Preethi Basani

I think that is super cool that you relied on this in your poetry workshop. How did you find it worked? Was it hard to do or did it come naturally? As a teacher myself, I'm excited to see how this book changes how I act both inside and outside the classroom!

phil e the theyby

I also very much found myself thinking about the oppressor-oppressed dialectic. I see it as a useful conceptual framework, but a bad way of "categorizing people." Because I think the reality is that all of us have some degree of oppressor and some degree of being oppressed within us. Anyone with any sort of privilege (which includes anyone who has an internet connection, money to contribute on Patreon, and the time to read this book and comment on it here) is benefitting from exploitation in some way, but most of us are immensely marginalized in other ways. So in reading "Pedagogy of the Oppressed,", I tended to view "oppressed" and "oppressor" as processes people have. While in terms of privileges and identity I definitely fall into "oppressor" more than "oppressed" categories, I do largely agree with Freire that the "oppressor" parts of me lead me to act in the ways he describes (being protective of what I have, dismissing or marginalizing the perspectives of others, and being unable to truly commit to the liberation of all people), while the "oppressed" parts of me are able to see and join into the struggle for collective liberation, and see how that struggle is necessary not only for the liberation of all oppressed people, but of all oppressors, INCLUDING the oppressor [parts] within me. That's not to say there aren't meaningful differences based on identity and the experiences of privilege or marginalization people have, because there ABSOLUTELY are; some people's life experience falls distinctly more into the "oppressed" experience, while others' falls markedly more into the "oppressor" experience. But I do think that all of us carry both, and if we're aiming to take responsibility for ourselves and our role in collective liberation, we need to start by analyzing and managing the oppressor and the oppressed within us, rather than concerning ourselves with where other people fall in the oppressor-oppressed dialectic.

Rafael Andrade

For a start: The pt-br foreword spend much of his pages discussing a lot of hegelian dialectics, and at first I thought it would a bit too much, until I started the first chapter. Freire uses so much of it the whole chapter, I would recommend the video "Intro to Hegel (& Progressive Politics) | Philosophy Tube", so to better understand the dynamics Freire is talking about (In the video Abigail talks about Master/Slave, but it's the same as the Oppressor/Oppressed). That's why he talks about the dehumanization of the Oppressor, because by depending so much on the Oppressed, the Oppressor can't define himself other than the negation of the Oppressed and by the material gains over them. While the Oppressed has the power to change the world and can understand themselves through their labor, but that's why the Pedagogy of the Oppressed is so important. Because this understanding and subsequent liberation can only happen once they develop this awareness in communion. Nietzsche sidetrack: That may be a bit of a stretch, but all this blends really well (in my mind) with Nietzsche's idea of liberation, and how the Oppressor's liberation can't come from resentment. As Freire says "When the education is not liberating the dream of the oppressed is to become the oppressor". The red elephant in the room: Something else that I think might help to understand Freire is to now he was a communist (I mean, it's really clear in the book, but maybe not so much for those that didn't read other marxists authors). Not only that, he was a communist in Brazil that was immediately arrested in 1964 when the militar dictatorship financed by the USA took power, and this book was written during his exile in the later years. He was not in any guerrilla, like Frantz Fanon, but he also stated that the Oppressed response can't be compared to the Oppressors actions. Because one comes from solidarity and the other to keep the status quo. If you want to understand more of this context there is the movie "I'm Still Here" from last year, but there is also the movie "Four Days in September" from 1997 (But also stared by Fernanda Torres). I really like how he opposes to the non-communicative approach, that only uses slogans and doesn't truly engage with the Oppressed. It makes me think a lot of how Science Communication happens in social media, and people saying "Believe in Science" instead of truly engaging with the subject of discussion. There is a great article about this "The Role of Lay People in the Production and Dissemination of Scientific Knowledge" (Callon, 1999). I guess the only disagreement I have it's how he separates the teacher's from the educational system, as if the teacher can always subvert the classroom. I know that's not exactly what he means but I feel like we are in much more of an Age of Accountability and teachers are being watched more now than in the experiences he talks about. Maybe that's a point to bring Freire's ideas to alternative learning environments ( like here :) ). I'm really not saying we should give up schools, but for me there is a gap that needs to be filled for how can a teacher truly engage with those ideas without being fired. Whoever does this has 100% the right to call himself a revolutionary leadership, as Freire calls teachers.

phil e the theyby

Since the first time I've read this book, I've started making notes in books and underlying passages that really stand out to me or feel particularly impactful or meaningful. It was VERY difficult for me to not basically underline the entire damn book. It's clear that Freire is INCREDIBLY intentional with his words, and almost everything he says carries a ton of weight and stands on its own. Like I said in reply to Preethi's comment, I very much see the "oppressor/oppressed" categories Freire describes as broader processes rather than descriptions of specific groups of people, particularly in our modern economic system where so many of us rely on exploitative systems to like...feed and clothe ourselves. We are all oppressors, but we are also all oppressed; the constellation of oppressors and oppressed looks different for every person, and can't be treated as "equal" just because we all have both. That said, Freire does an INCREDIBLY accurate job of describing our modern political moment, and the fascist backlash to any sort of progressive change that's happened in the last fifty years. It is EERIE how spot-on his description of reactionary politics is...or it would be, if the pattern hadn't repeated itself so many times by the time Freire first wrote this book One quote that really stood out to me, when speaking of oppressors who aim to join the oppressed in the struggle for liberation: "Our converts... truly desire to transform the unjust order; but because of their background they believe that they must be the executors of the transformation. They talk about the people, but they do not trust them; and trusting the people is the indispensable precondition for revolutionary change." (60) This feels SPOT ON. I think that, as someone with a lot of privilege, I've had to become very aware of my tendency towards explaining or thinking that I understand the experiences of people who are marginalized in ways I'm not, as well as the desire to swoop in and try to make things better (I mean after all, isn't that what "using your privilege" is? ...I mean, it ISN'T, but that's certainly what I used to think). As someone who's in a mentoring/educating role fairly often, I've had to really learn how to give people the tools to walk their own path, rather than trying to lay out that path in front of them. And honestly, I still find this hard to do, because I can come up with compelling narratives (/paths) pretty readily and tell them in a way that feels convincing to people. When we don't have enough time and space with people to allow them to awaken their own conscientização, trying to give them "the right way to think" is an easy shorthand. But it's incredibly important for us to take that time, or to prioritize a slower journey that helps awaken their voices a little bit, than trying to "awaken them a lot" but having all of that growth come from me. This feels like a very important re-read for me, even though I think it was only about a year ago that I first read it. There's so much wisdom in this book, and I'm excited to be back diving into it, especially with the contributions of everyone else here!

Rafael Andrade

First of all, I'm really sorry about the problems with your parents. But I'm glad the book helped you find the words to express it, that's the whole point of Freire's methodology for literacy education, to give people the vocabulary to read the world and express themselves over it.

aliin

Gotta agree with you it was really hard NOT to underline evrything as every part felt soo relevant still!

Isaiah G

Thank you for being a teacher! Attendees said they got a lot from it. When teaching art it’s harder to connect to action, though I still aspire to it, so trying not to use that as my only metric for success. It was also my first one! The hardest part for me was making sure there were very few ways it could end up as me lecturing, which I’m already kind of prone to do. Lots of questions and challenging myself to build on ideas others shared rather than my own

AJ Biffl

> "...tend to ignore how quickly that passion can shut down any open communication" I love this point! It's such an important aspect of practical transformative action, spreading the message, bridging gaps, bringing people in, and I've never really seen anything that focuses on it. Based on Freire's background, this sort of practical consideration is exactly what I'm excited to see in the rest of the book

Alfalfafield

This is my first encounter with Friere, and so far I’m impressed with the clarity and power of his writing. I found this chapter to be very compelling. In particular, the foundational role of dehumanization in oppression and the centrality of “having” in the oppressor consciousness were concepts that really struck me. Probably the most important thread running through this chapter for me personally was Friere’s comments on the pitfalls that members of the oppressor class can fall into in their efforts to fight alongside the oppressed class. There were four that stood out to me (although maybe I missed some – if so, please let me know!): - Self-serving generosity, which actually perpetuates the conditions that necessitate the generosity. “An unjust social order is the permanent fount of this ‘generosity,’ which is nourished by death, despair and poverty. This is why the dispensers of false generosity become desperate at the slightest threat to its source.” - Recognizing the wrongness of oppression but rationalizing reasons to remain inactive. “Discovering himself to be an oppressor may cause considerable anguish, but it does not necessarily lead to solidarity with the oppressed...To affirm that men and women are persons and as persons should be free, and yet to do nothing tangible to make this affirmation a reality, is a farce.” - Attempting to address oppression without involving the oppressed. “To substitute monologue, slogans, and communiques for dialogue is to attempt to liberate the oppressed with the instruments of domestication. Attempting to liberate the oppressed without their reflective participation in the act of liberation is to treat them as objects which must be saved from a burning building.” - Struggling alongside the oppressed without trusting their ability to enact their own liberation. “These adherents to the people’s cause constantly run the risk of falling into a type of generosity as malefic as that of the oppressors...They talk about the people, but they do not trust them; and trusting the people is the indispensable precondition for revolutionary change.” His descriptions of saviour complexes and the insidiousness of generosity felt so vivid and contemporary, and it was easy for me when reading these passages to think condescendingly of different people or movements I’ve encountered that fit the patterns he identifies. However, I think it’s extremely important to take these ideas seriously as pitfalls that I personally can fall into (and in many cases, have fallen into) as a relatively privileged person.

AlexTheTutor

I love reading everyone’s responses: So deep and vast and full of different rich perspectives <3 I will share my own short perspective. I have read this book before, and I will read it again. I have been to Brasil dozens of times and lived with many people. The people I have met in Brasil, even though many of them have never read this book, they have lived this book. By next Monday, I will return to Brasil, and I can imagine one of them summarizing the decade we have spent together by saying to me… “Am I human? How can I be human if I have been dehumanized? By a broken family in a broken favela supported by a broken government? At each level there could be someone to oppress me: an older family member, a stronger person, a person with more power, a government. Our imagination is black and white: do I stay oppressed or do I become an oppressor? Those are the only two options…” “...Except, those are NOT the only two options: There is always an option to fight for freedom. In this way, happiness is not given out for free, we must always fight for happiness. Freire says that this awareness, this awakening, it’s painful. But, it’s not painful, not always at least, not when considering the enormous pain from the past of being oppressed. There was never such a thing as being oppressed by some abstract force such as a government, maybe there was in reality, but not by our immediate reality. The oppression most closely felt came from the ones closest, by some relatives. In fact, happiness first comes from the ability to end the cycle of oppression and begin a new cycle defined by happiness.” And that is what we have done for them (children who are almost adults now). They are so bright, so kind, so smart, so thoughtful, so inspiring. Because (as Freire may put it), we did not liberate them FROM any oppression (that only continues the cycle of oppression), we gave them an opportunity and modeled behavior such as gratitude and love. As Freire as said, education is an act of love, and thus an act of courage, and that is how we teach them, with courage. The last time I was in Brasil was in the beginning of the year, we all went out for pizza, me and 6 women who represent 4 generations. I asked a simple request: Please go around and say one thing you are grateful for to each person. We stayed there for 3 hours, laughed, cried, it was wonderful and beautiful.

phil e the theyby

Thank you for sharing this; it’s really beautiful. The idea that the oppression we feel the most comes from those closest to us really stuck with me, because it’s so true. It also gives a lot more hope; rather than thinking we need to fix an entire government to experience any sort of freedom, we can heal our immediate environment and the relationships with the people around us. Doing so gives us the strength and security to actually organize and change the larger governments and systems.

Jacques Vincelette

The teacher and the class can subvert until the education system catches them. Nitche's counter elite Superman upholds elitism in the entitled counternarrative of the narcisistic individual. I was blown away by Frieres' insight on real time emancipation through dialogue accross perspectives rooted in collaborative work.

Jacques Vincelette

Marvelous how "to take responsability for ourselves and our role in collectibe liberation" provides the key for our own emancipation. Crazy how emancipation and emasculation are misconstrued on entitlement.

Jacques Vincelette

Hence the importance of praxis as activism-reflection loop.

Jacques Vincelette

On June 12, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories announced that Chalk River Laboratories would be managed by American defence contractors Amentum and BWXT. (Maybe a small part of US plan to appropriate Canada). On June 13, nuclear scientists in Iran are murdered on the mea culpa that "atom for peace" was wishfull thinking given that military contractors have greater funding.

Jacques Vincelette

I protested with the nuclear scientist as Chalk River Laboratories this morning. Our contract includes a subjugation clause folding to "management's right to manage", we can not press for nuclear non-proliferation or divestment from weapons industry. The best I could offer was to dance in the street with colleages , even as our calls for world peace are reframed as a question of pay. Cleaning staff delayed by the traffic jam complain that they can't afford the idle gasoline or lost time. "Fin du monde. fin du moi, même combat".

Raphaël Royer

First of all, wow, I love his way of writting, his dialectical way of seeing concepts speaks to me! "But while both humanization and dehumanization are real alternatives, only the firs its the people's vocation. This vocation is constantly negated, yet it is affirmed by that very negation" Dehumanization is easy, it convinces you that your fear is justified. I love that he postulate that humanization is a vocation and their is always forces that tries to negate this way of seeing your fellow humans but that this confirms that humanization is the correct way. I have lived all of my life with this impulse of humanization without thinking about it. It's at the base of my world view and reading it in those terms is a revelation! " In order for the oppressed to be able to wage the struggle for their liberation, they must perceive the reality of oppression not as a closed world from which there is no exit, but as a limiting situation which they can transform " This gave me hope, I am often described as idealistic, but the minute you lose hope in making the world better is when you fall in nihilism and then it's over. I feel it's my task now, to make people believe a better world is possible! " They cannot see that, in the egoistic pursuit of having as a possessing class, they suffocate in their own possessions and no longer are; they merely have " This is what capitalism does to your brain, billionaires have lost their humanity a long time ago. My final thought on chapter 1 is that I cant wait to read the rest! What a profound thinker!

Quezacoatl

It's my second time reading Freire in a short while. What impresses me the most in his theory, and this is very clear from the beginning, is that his solution for the dialectical problem of the master/slave dialectic proposed by Hegel is the radical humanisation of both oppressed and oppressor. Dehumanisation of the oppressed seems to be a necessary prerequisite for oppression itself and is therefore in a certain way also a consequence of oppression. Because the oppressor must see the oppressed as less than human, he must also teach his children, that the oppressed are indeed less than human, which is quite important when you look at "pedagogy" (quite interessting also that Freire chose the word that is realted to children even though his methods are argubly more directed at adults). A consequence of the dehumanisation of the oppressed is the self-dehumanisation of the oppressor. This is echoed in a lot of (post)colonial philosophy, especially Fanon and Césaire, but also Baldwin, DuBois and Levinas. So the only way for the oppressor to reconnect with his own humanity is the re-humanisation of the oppressed. Since only the oppressed can truely achieve the end of their own dehumanisation through their own action, as action is what makes us human, the only way for the oppressor to achieve the end of their own dehumanisation is to support the oppressed in their own liberation.

Bob van Vliet

Any other (university) teachers here? How do we feel this relates to the pedagogy in our classes? Re-reading Ch. 1 for this week, I was most struck by the continual emphasis on not treating 'submerged' as objects but to always be radically committed to dialogue as subjects together in the world and to trust the 'unenlightened', so to speak, as being intelligent and capable of independent thought and reflection on their lifeworld. Translated to interacting with students who I hope to invite to look more critically at their education and societal role (I teach engineering design), I have tried hard the last few years to really engage with students in a humanist way, and to try and practice "co-intentional education" where it's not me lecturing ('sloganizing') at them, but to try and get us to a place where we can look at the world together, side by side. It's tough, though. Especially when the course is short, and you have to break through a lot of entrenched behavior and what they've come to expect from teachers/courses.

Bob van Vliet

Re "how he separates the teacher's from the educational system, as if the teacher can always subvert the classroom": On p. 28 (my Penguin classics edition), Freire writes about "the distinction between *systematic education* which can only be changed by political power, and *educational projects*, which should be carried out *with* the oppressed in the process of organizing them". In other words, he seems to be saying there that teachers can *never* subvert the classroom in a traditional institution. But I know from other writing that he didn't really believe that. Freire's own work was mostly outside schools.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I want to admit that the chapter bothered me a lot, more than I expected it to. I'm very aware that the writing must be read in context, that we have to take into consideration the time it was written, which authors informed Freire's perspective, and who he was writing for, and thinking about all that softens the blow a little, but still... I was uncomfortable with how formulaic the writing seemed to me. As I read, I couldn't help but want to question Freire: but what do you mean by freedom? What do you mean by liberation? What is it to be more human? What's the horizon you're working with here? What kind of society is the revolution striving towards? To propose a pedagogy of the oppressed, Freire first proposes a psychology of the oppressed, and I found it lacking. The way the writing describes oppressor and oppressed in a generic sense, without contextualizing specific existing oppressive relationships, felt stale to me. As the chapter progresses, I started to get more ‘into’ it, and I was able to find some passages that spoke to me and that I think could spark conversation. I was a little disappointed, though I’m still not sure if I’m disappointed with the text or with myself. Did I not ‘get’ it? Am I not as radical as I once was? Why does it feel so stale? Well, there were things I enjoyed, and specific passages I wanted to talk about, so I'll add those in another comment.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

There were some passages I found quite compelling or interesting, and others that brought specific questions to my mind and I thought these would be worth sharing. These stood out to me: “Humanity is a ‘thing’, and they possess it as an exclusive right, as inherited property. To the oppressor consciousness, the humanization of the ‘others’, of the people, appears not as the pursuit of full humanity, but as subversion.” this feels very real indeed. [regarding oppressor who want to fight alongside the oppressed] “they almost always bring with them the marks of their origin: their prejudices and their deformations, which include a lack of confidence in the people's ability to think, to want, and to know [...] Those who authentically commit themselves to the people must re-examine themselves constantly. This conversion is so radical as not to allow of ambiguous behavior. To affirm this commitment but to consider oneself the proprietor of revolutionary wisdom is to retain the old ways” I find this to ring very true. I have no aspiration of being revolutionary, or of being a leader, but I was a health care workers in a primary care setting, working with a very disenfranchised community, and the way most doctor and nurses treated people was very much doubting their ability to think and know and yes – even want. Me and my closest colleagues, on the other hand, engaged with the patients in groups and asked them what they were seeking at the clinic. What was health for them, and how could we help them achieve it? That was our way of committing to them and re-examine ourselves and our supposed ‘knowledge’ about healthy living. “Submerged in reality, the oppressed cannot perceive clearly the "order" which serves the interests of the oppressors whose image they have internalized. Chafing under the restrictions of this order, they often manifest a type of horizontal violence, striking out at their own comrades for the pettiest reasons.” This passage I did not like. I find it very naive, or purposefully ideological, to assert that “horizontal violence” is only a product of oppressive violence. Taking this way of thinking to its limit, we'd have to admit the possibility of a society without violence, which I think is bizarre (differently from a society without oppression, which I think we should strive towards). Violence is a part of life and a product of human interaction that always needs to be dealt with. There are several ways and models to manage violence and aggression, much less repressive and perverse than the ones currently in vogue in the urban west (talking about this particular one because it's what I'm immersed in) but to imagine violence as a symptom of oppression, a disease to be eradicated with the “right” type of society, seems very contradictory to me. Freire uses Fanon as a source here, and while I agree with Fanon’s argument, from what I know of his work, he doesn't share the perspective that violence can be eliminated. “The oppressed must see examples of the vulnerability of the oppressor so that a contrary conviction can begin to grow within them. Until this occurs, they will continue disheartened, fearful, and beaten” – in the 21st century, when so many of us can identify Bezos and Musk and Zukemberg and so on as “the uberoppresors”, how could we not feel fearful and disheartened? What vulnerabilities can we ever find in transnational corporations? “Liberation, a human phenomenon, cannot be achieved by semihumans.” while I understand and agree that oppression dehumanizes both oppressed and oppressor (though I have a gut feeling the dehumanization is much more intense in the oppressors) I think to suggest anyone is a semihuman is too much. We must strive to recognize humanity in all people, I believe. One thing the chapter had me thinking was: who are the “revolutionary leaders” of today? “Likewise, the oppressed (who do not commit themselves to the struggle unless they are convinced, and who, if they do not make such a commitment, withhold the indispensable conditions for this struggle) must reach this conviction as Subjects, not as objects. They also must intervene critically in the situation which surrounds them and whose mark they bear; propaganda cannot achieve this.” I really liked this! Of course I do :)

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Phil e your thoughts about the oppressor-oppresed dialectic deepened my appreciation for the chapter. Freire did not explore the dialectic the way you did, and your reading made the text more interesting to me, because it invites nuance to what I had felt was too formulaic, without straying too far from the ideas proposed in the text (deepening them without contradicting them)

Alfalfafield

I found the Hegelianism a bit much at times - maybe this stark polarized completely-oppositional way of thinking about oppressed and oppressors made more sense in rural Brazil in the 1960s? It certainly doesn't map well onto how I feel like oppression works in a contemporary North American context, where most people can be either oppressed and oppressor in different situations. If by "oppressor" Friere strictly means "the capitalist class", then the oppositionalism makes more sense IMO, but it would've been nice to spell that out a bit more explicitly :p

Alfalfafield

Not a university prof but I work in adult education, specifically teaching ESL to immigrants. In that context, teachers are definitely encouraged to centre student knowledge, experiences and goals - the so-called "communicative method" has been in vogue for the last few decades, and I feel like it must have been at least partially influenced by this school of thought. It's very much rooted in instructor-student dialogue, student-to-student knowledge sharing and support, needs assessments to determine course content, elicitation of student knowledge as an integral part of instruction, etc. However, it often feels like this methodology is at odds with a lot of institutional expectations re: curricula and assessment, and so how that plays out in the classroom is pretty variable. It's also a dramatic break from the type of instruction a lot of students have received in their first countries, which leads some of them to be skeptical - I've had a few students tell me they just want me to lecture and give them worksheets because that's how they're used to learning!

Shree Hari Mittal

Not a full fledged university teacher, but a TA. My teaching/explaining style in very small circles I realised as I read felt very close to what was described but since I have had to teach Uni lectures, the way Uni courses are structured with the time frame and learning lessons goals, all in the service of keeping up the accreditation of the Uni, which in turn is there to make workers not citizens, it is very very difficult to practice this mode. Especially more so in STEM I feel like that in Arts. The whole model currently doesn't and *cannot* allow for the type and way of education Paulo describes on a large scale uni level. We can still try to in all the ways we can, but I do think an entire course designed with this philosophy in mind is really difficult.

Djoran Keil

"What vulnerabilities can we ever find in transnational corporations?" I would argue that Tesla became vulnerable due to collective action as one example.

AJ Biffl

I'm really enjoying this so far. Quezacoatl got at this a bit in their comment, but it's really eye-opening to think about pedagogy as so fundamentally important to socialization as the general process of information transfer, for building revolutionary movements by bridging gaps and opening eyes (Christopher Garcia brought this up too). This book feels a lot like a practical how-to guide for building a revolution, and I'm loving it. I'm also loving seeing the flashes of Teaching to Transgress in here! Education as "the practice of freedom," chapter 5 "Theory as Liberatory Practice," a lot of the stuff about connecting to students and valuing experience. Can really see how this work influenced bell hooks. The thing I've been thinking about the most is from the preface: "the radical is never a subjectivist" (pg 38). Thing is, I am also a subjectivist (I think) - I think knowledge is constructed, that perception causes distortion, that "truth" and "reality" are a function of perspective more than anything else. And I've been struggling a lot with this consistent teaching in subjectivist ideologies that the struggle to make things better is an internal one - that suffering is caused by desire; that there is love to be found if one searches within; that acceptance is the road to happiness. But clearly, *hegemonic society causes suffering*. Systemic, inculturated practices of exploitation and oppression and violence cover the world over. But if you can just subjectively stop valuing human life and freedom, if you accept your surroundings and only seek inner peace, those material conditions never change. Freire uses the phrase "subjectivist immobility" in chapter 1 (pg 50). For me (and Freire helped catalyze this thought), I think the leap to objectivism and action is in communal experience, the things that we experience together. The "concrete reality" (pg 38) that we share gives a medium for sharing experience, and Action is a communal phenomenon - it takes place in communal spaces, shaping our shared surroundings. Then recognizing the "objective" as the platform for shared experience sort of self-justifies valuing liberty and life as prerequisites for sharing experience (and diversity, which enriches that shared experience). Then recognizing the concrete as the set of things that form our collective experience leads to recognizing structures of oppression as things which cause difference of experience. "Reality which becomes oppressive results in the contradistinction of men as oppressors and oppressed" (pg 51); hierarchy reinforces the oppressor/oppressed division as separate categories of experience. To "discover [the oppressor] 'outside' ourselves" (pg 45) is to recognize that social and historical forces do not turn oppressed into oppressor, but rather keep them separate, maintain that contrast in experience - advantage vs disadvantage, profit vs exploitation, voice vs silence. Individuals can experience both (as phil e mentioned, it's not actually a clean delineation), but it is the goal of hierarchy to keep them as far apart as possible. (quotes and page nums from 30th anniversary edition pdf)

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

This is very well said. The way you put it, the idea that dehumanization of the oppressed is both a prerequisite and a consequence of oppression, made me think of Minor Detail, a novel by Adhania Shibli which is told in two parts. It tells the stories of two Palestinian women in different moments in time and very different contexts (also very different POV and narrative structures). It's almost like in one story we get dehumanization as a prerequisite and in the other as a consequence. I already loved the book, but this connection made me appreciate it even more. It also got me thinking in the role art and cultural artifacts (such as stories) play into a pedagogy of the oppressed or a struggle for liberation.

phil e the theyby

I really appreciate your thoughts! I do admit to feeling a bit confused by your reaction to the passage that seemed to bother you the most, and I’d love to understand what I might be missing. To me, I didn’t read that passage as saying “all violence (or even all horizontal violence) is the result of oppression and we can therefore eliminate violence.” I read it as saying “oppressive orders lead to horizontal violence,” not that “all violence comes from oppressive orders.” I guess he MIGHT be saying that all HORIZONTAL violence comes from oppressive orders, but that could result from his definition of “horizontal violence” (i.e., if he defines it as “violence within oppressed classes a result of oppressive systems,” then any violence within oppressed classes that ISN’T the result of oppressive systems wouldn’t qualify as “horizontal violence,” but that doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist or isn’t violence. That said, I may be missing something, or may have misread other context around that quote, so I’d be happy to be corrected!

phil e the theyby

@Bob van Vliet have you read bell hooks’ “Teaching to Transgress” (a previous book club book on here)? It speaks really well to that experience of trying to break down students’ expectations of hierarchy in a university context. It’s definitely VERY challenging, and I applaud your attempts to address it.

Shree Hari Mittal

Having read everyone's thoughts on Chapter 1, one thing immediately jumps out to me is how similar the rest of the group is thinking about this chapter, including me. Especially nice almost all the quotes/sections of the books I heavily underlined are the ones that others also liked and as Preethi said, I want to highlight almost every line and RA said, so many concepts that I didn’t have the words for finally being put so beautifully. This is my first reading of this book, and I can clearly see the effect Paulo had on other thinkers(Marxist) that I have read before(Bell Hooks, John Berger). It really helped me in understanding them retrospectively and his ideas in this book much more deeply. I'll use the quotes and then expand what I thought of them. "..demand the transformation of the universities (changing the rigid nature of the teacher-student relationship and placing that relationship within the context of reality), propose the transformation of reality itself so that universities can be renewed, attack old orders and established institutions in the attempt to affirm human beings as the Subjects of decision,.."-Footnote 1, Chapter 1. This for me reads as if written directly in response to the current student protests in Universities all over EU-US. As I said in reply to Bob, who also said this, the current education system is antithetical to the type Paulo advocates for. The student intifada to support Palestine liberation is not only supporting Palestine, it is also a struggle to make our universities actually ours. “Freedom is not an ideal located outside of man; nor is it an idea which becomes myth. It is rather the indispensable condition for the quest for human completion.“ -Page 47. Preethi already mentioned this, but this to me seemed very much like Nemik's manifesto from Andor. Sorry to be the consumer who references a Disney show as a reference. But to me this is fundamental to understanding Paulo’s work. We, any oppressed, don't need the idea of freedom to be taught, it already exists within them, and in oppressors too. Pedagogy is required to connect the dots, to develop the framework which can explain the reality of oppression, thereby also giving the tools to dismantle it. This is exactly why he places so much importance on being with the masses, understanding their conditions and then talking to them rather than handing out the theory of liberation like a charity or be saviours. They already know and we already know about freedom! “In their unrestrained eagerness to possess, the oppressors develop the conviction that it is possible for them to transform everything into objects of their purchasing power; hence their strictly materialistic concept of existence. Money is the measure of all things, and profit the primary goal. For the oppressors, what is worthwhile is to have more—always more—even at the cost of the oppressed having less or having nothing. For them, to be is to have and to be the class of the "haves." As beneficiaries of a situation of oppression, the oppressors cannot perceive that if having is a condition of being, it is a necessary condition for all women and men.“ Page 58. I want to take a slightly different read here. Elon Musk constantly says “NPC” to people he deems less humans, because for the billionaire class, and the rich in general, are not fully humans because they don’t have enough *things*. That’s why they can easily view us simply as non-playable characters in a video game, who you can kill, run over whatever you want to do, because they are not the ones with a story, with character development and thereby human. I know Paulo is going for more here, but I just wanted to bring up today’s billionaire class in this context. “Sadistic love is a perverted love—a love of death, not of life. One of the characteristics of the oppressor consciousness and its necrophilic view of the world is thus sadism. As the oppressor consciousness, in order to dominate, tries to deter the drive to search, the restlessness, and the creative power which characterize life, it kills life. More and more, the oppressors are using science and technology as unquestionably powerful instruments for their purpose: the maintenance of the oppressive order through manipulation and repression. The oppressed, as objects, as "things," have no purposes except those their oppressors prescribe for them.“ Page 59-60. I want to connect this para and the ones around it to the current obsession that the rich have with AI. When reading Paulo, I also feel a deep love for Humans and Humanity. For all the things Humans do and can do when they are free. Here to me it explains so much why the rich have poured and are arguing continuously to pour all our resources into AI. It is the perfect “thing” to have, perfect purpose built tool, that can never rebel, develop *conscientizagdo*, as it currently exists and can be used to further oppression. It can deny the education we need, make our brains less critically engaged, essential for liberation. They use AI to paint and write, because in their continuous profession of being oppressor, they have completely fallen in love with death, as Paulo puts it, because AI is not alive in the way Paulo sees humans. He goes into detail how he differentiates Humans as a unique being different from other beings, because of their ability to exist as historic beings and be agents of change and affect their material conditions by understanding their place in history in chapters down the line. By constantly trying to define themselves as owners of things, the rich have fallen in love with AI, with death and it was going to happen one way or another. I will stop here since it’s already too long and because others have written very well on quotes that I also found interesting. I want to add 2 general points. For Paulo, the categories of oppressor and oppressed are fluid and very context dependent. He is rather flexible and recognises it himself how in different contexts the same group can be both. For me, it has been very enlightening trying to apply his words to context that I understand(if only slightly) but was very likely not in his mind, the caste system and the work of Dr. B R Ambedkar in India. Second, Paulo’s vision of society to me seems stated very clearly and steps to go there. His words on violence and its necessity but absence when the oppressor-oppressed categories are dismantled to me seem very radical, yet consistent within his framework. The dangers of a bureaucratic state and the necessity to ground any work done in a humanist tradition. These were my initial thoughts from the chapter, and some more but I should stop :)

Shree Hari Mittal

I'm also slightly excited to read Dr. Fatima's thoughts on the techniques of pedagogy itself and it's goals int the context of STEM education. I'm still trying to form my thoughts in a coherent way on this, but as someone doing PhD in Astro and teaching as well, would like to know her thoughts as well. Though I have a feeling they were expressed in the video on science education.

Djoran Keil

"Propaganda, management, manipulation—all arms of domination—cannot be the instruments of their rehumanization." This immediately made me think of the Audre Lorde quote, "The Master's Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master's House." Curious if they ever crossed paths but can't find any references that indicate they did.

Bob van Vliet

No I haven’t. I remember starting it at one point, but at the time I couldn’t really get into it. The writing style didn’t grab me as Freire’s did. I should give hooks another go, specifically with your remark in mind, thanks!

Warren Shull

My initial thoughts (before reading everyone else's comments): I actually read this for a college class in 2009, but suffice to say I've learned A LOT since then. The theme of "false generosity" will of course bring many examples to mind. I've thought of a way to phrase this pattern that I'm interested to run by all of you. Some of the decisions people make for themselves can be described as "penny-wise and pound-foolish," where someone is proud of a decision that brings small benefit while ignoring a decision with much larger cost. Similarly, many wealthy people who show an appearance of philanthropy are *penny-generous* and *pound-selfish*. (One example might be someone who donates a bunch of money to a private school while opposing the necessary reforms and tax increases to ensure that the public school system has enough money for basic functioning.) The phenomenon of oppressed people becoming oppressors, or wanting to, brought a couple things to mind: 1) How many of you have seen the CGP Grey video "Rules for Rulers," and does anyone have a lot of thoughts on it? 2) The other thing this brought to mind was the "temporarily embarrassed millionaire" attitude that (I'm told) many non-wealthy Republican voters tend to have. The quote on page 62: "Sharing [the oppressors'] way of life becomes an overpowering asipration" seems to describe this, as do the associations of the oppressor with "manhood" described earlier in the chapter. Another controversial thought that came to mind back then and still does now is that "trust[ing] in the oppressed and in their ability to reason" (p. 66) *should include children*. Many adults seem to assume that children aren't capable of reason below a certain age, but I have a lot of memories of being underestimated in this regard when I was a kid.

sentient

Is there a thread here for how absolutely backa&&ward and crazy making it is in education, health and stem fields that people are still talking aglow about the zio ethnostate!!!! It’s the same recipe every time in continuing education classes lately. Instructor or student brings up a paper about Isr&3l blithely, then it comes up in discussion again casually but like a creepy ad about how grossly glowing it is. Then they blather together for 10 minutes like necromaniacs!!!!! Having experienced this three times in one month, it really feels orchestrated. I experienced this pre 2023, but it’s on steroids as an academic ethnic clean$ing dog whistling call and response. It’s disgusting! They’re such big lunatics with power if you say something you’re railroaded over and over. Empire Conquest, Manifest Destiny… these fields are dominated by genocidal “neutrality!” Has anyone been able to stand up to this successfully? Sorry is this an okay thing to ask here, as this is literally the hardest encoding to move through

Travis

I have been procrastinating on writing a comment because this book, this chapter, sparked so many beautiful thoughts in me that I have been unsure how to convey in mere words. Mostly i feel like this chapter affirmed some long-held views of mine / provided language to give those views some structure. The biggest things for me are the importance of reflection/dialectical thought and autonomy in liberation. The superstructure and the individual are in dialogue with each other, and BOTH must be transformed to make a better world. I find Freire’s description of humanization and what it means to be human very compelling. But i would also be curious to see these ideas in dialogue with animism, disability rights, and even animal rights activism. I work with lab mice and raise my own meat, but being involved in activism has brought me into community with ARAs, and I don’t know how to navigate those relationships!

Dr. Fatima

I wonder if the generic-ness you (Maria) felt in Freire’s descriptions of oppressed/oppression comes from his ideas once being radical but now being standard in any discussion of power dynamics. I notice I have a similar feeling reading older texts that were first trying on ideas that are commonplace now. And while I agree that he’s not being very specific in his framework, in my reading of it that just meant I was filling in the ideas with examples from my own experiences/knowledge (which I think is a sign of useful theory, kinda like how bell hooks talked about it in our last book club https://www.patreon.com/posts/teaching-to-5-as-123037432). Regarding the split not mapping onto how oppression works today/here, I see what you (Alfalfa) mean, but also I don’t think this context and Freire’s framing are incompatible. I could see parallels in my own thinking both in how he described the oppressors psychology and the oppressed psychology. There were actually some sections I read twice, trying to read “as oppressed” and “as oppressor”, and in both cases I could generally make some meaningful connection. I wonder if by not spelling it out in a way that let’s the reader categorize themselves one way or the other changes how people receive the analysis?

Dr. Fatima

It’s interesting to hear about the assumption you deconstructed with this book through organizing a poetry workshop because I feel like the ones you listed remind me a lot of my own self-reflections about this book club. I’ll be honest, there was a good chunk of this chapter where I felt like Freire was reading me way more than I was reading him (the couple paragraphs starting with “In the light of what has been said…” on my page 36 hit like this for me especially). I know that my context (the internet, largely parasocial relationships) couldn’t have been in Freire’s head when he was writing this, and I do think that does have to inform how it’s approached just for the purposes of safety/sanity, but this whole chapter I couldn’t shake the idea that I should be trying to be more of a comrade and less of an authority in this space

Isaiah G

That’s real talk. I appreciate how much Freire emphasizes grounding discussion on the situation of the participants (I think in the last chapter), which is very difficult to do if you can’t expect extended time or space to build real relationships

Filip

Thanks for sharing your thoughts! When reading the part about how "the oppressors cannot perceive that if having is a condition of being, it is a necessary condition for all women and men" my thoughts went in a mostly similar but interestingly different way than yours. In my mind, it might be not that the lack of things makes people non-human in the oppressors' eyes, but rather that in their eyes those people are (by their essence) non-human and the lack of things is just evidence confirming it. As in, if they were fully human and worthy of consideration then they would have become rich like the oppressors, so the fact that they are not confirms that they are mindless automatons to be used and not considered.

phil e the theyby

@Not a Lady Maria thank you!! I find it really important to try to make sense of the text (any text, really) in a way that clarifies it and makes it as useful as it can be for me, so I’m glad what I shared was helpful to you in that way :)

phil e the theyby

@Dr. Fatima I think I’m in an oddly similar space (but with much less intensity and much smaller numbers). I’ve been organizing spaces at work for a while built on raising awareness around different cultural perspectives and experiences. Through many iterations of this, I’ve had many times where I’ve been WAY too much of an authority. I’ve recently started using a new approach (The Circle Way) that’s designed to create non-hierarchical dialogue. In my first attempt at using this structure (yesterday), I found that it was very easy for things to go completely off the path and the intention of the space. Because of that, I’ve kind of started to make a distinction between pedagogy and curation. I see pedagogy as how you’re teaching and engaging with whatever you’re trying to teach. In pedagogy, you want to be a collaborator and co-participant in the space. But I see CURATION as developing and maintaining the intention and structure of the space itself. Someone needs to define what you’re even trying to do in a space, and how you will broadly go about that. You can still encourage people’s autonomy and agency while doing so; anyone is welcome to leave the space if what it provides isn’t what they’re looking for. But someone has to actually set the initial parameters of what the space is, and maintain those parameters. And in online spaces where there are always a million other places people could go, curation is both valuable and compassionate. Basically, in an online environment that provides tremendous pressure to be an authority figure or a “thought leader,” I think you do an excellent job of curating rather than “leading.” You’ll always have more sway in the space than others (because the single unifying characteristic of everyone here is “gives Dr. Fatima money monthly,” and the space immediately stops existing whenever you decide it does…these are features of the space regardless of any actions you take), but I do largely see the ways you engage here as curatorial. tl;dr: idk man, I think you’re doing pretty good

sentient

Quick update: brought up the potential dangers of mentioning an occupying presence with banality, and the instructors understood and committed to changing that with awareness! First time that conversation has ever changed things! Interrupting normalization of all occupying entities and their intellectual exploits is becoming possible in some places!

Dr. Fatima

hmm i'm intrigued by this idea of pedagogy vs curation-- I've been thinking in terms of 'teaching' vs 'facilitating' which is pretty similar, but your thoughts on the distinction are really helpful, thanks!

cyphrsphyr

Chapter 1 Pg. 54 "But if the implementation of a liberating education...requires political power...and the oppressed have one,..." -Is this in reference to the 1992 movie 'Toys' where LL Cool J's character, Patrick, is explaining to Alsatia how he's a ~"military man, in a military world; yadda." Alsatia catches him off-guard by exposing the hypocrisy, both in him, his actions, and certainly the vomit he spuu'd. [end scene] Pg. 55 "It must take into account their behavior, view of the world, and their ethics." -Cops; white or POC. We know of oppressor cops. Some may have oppressor cops in their families, some families have cops whom are POC. Some of these POC cops have become oppressors. In this historically elevated position they too become the oppressor, whether they lead or engage with others in unethical activity. This ingraining oppression to POC and those that seek to dehumanize to humanize, see this ingraining met with reward from the superior suppressor. We should be aware of others. The younger class seems more patient with acknowledgement of their granted elevation, this cascade can come from outliers 35 years of age and above. And; we have all witnessed why they remained silent (35+). Fear of impunitve actions; "remain thwarting oppressive newfanglement". Pg 58 "The oppressor consciousness...everything is reduced to the status of objects at its disposal. -In my mind, selling our probiotics back to us.

Craig

Interesting reflections, Warren. I agree about children, within the realms of age appropriateness of course. As an adult, I've always had a good rapport with children and I think it's partly because I consciously trust them as my equal and see them as perfectly able to think and reflect on posed problems. I think this comes from a similar experience you mentioned about feeling underestimated as a child. I sort of understand this problem to be just another symptom of the internalised logics of capitalism (as an aside, this is my first substantive comment here, and I'll refer a lot to "the internalised logics of capitalism" across my participation).

Craig

Hi Shree, you brought up a point that's interesting for me as I see it quite a lot in online discourse, with regard to the idea that "the current education system is antithetical to the type Paulo advocates for". This is especially interesting because, having fairly recently done an MSc in education, my experience was very Freirean indeed. By that, I mean the entire programme was set up to encourage dialogue, and based on a "horizontal" learner-learner relationship where appropriate. I think these things usually exist in ranges where sometimes it's more didactic and sometimes more dialogic, but in my case was always aware of the process of engaging with what's said, rather than filling an empty vessel. That said, there will, at least I think, be moments where it's just appropriate for the transmission of information, perhaps like in teaching arithmetic, for example. But certainly in my own experience of higher education, I see a lot of Freire's influence.

Craig

Hi Alfalfafield, I'm interested in what you mean by Hegelianism. Could you elaborate on that in the context of the chapter? Personally, I think it perfectly describes the starting point for oppression, regardless of age, which to me seems to be in the reproduction of false consciousness. This is what, to me, is the point of the book - that humans need to be able to read the word and the world, as Macedo put it, in order to develop their own immunity to the manufacture of, for example, rage, which I think is just one of many salient examples in these times.

Craig

@phil e thanks for the recommendation. I've only read a few snippets of hooks from other authors' references, but the issue of student expectation is indeed one of the more pressing issues I have experienced myself. "teach me, teacher" is a common theme in my experience of working with adults, but quite different from (some) teenagers (certainly those from an affluent background and experience of private education) who were much more enthusiastic about their own participation in the process.

Captain Mikee

I think I've been feeling a similar "subjectivist" tension as a result of 12 step recovery. There's a version of the Serenity Prayer that ends with "and the wisdom to know that one [I can change] is me." Sometimes I get the message that we shouldn't be trying to fix the world, just our own addictive/dysfunctional behaviors. But... A very valuable shift I got from recovery is to focus on my actions and not results. That's led to two changes: - asking for what I want, and having the courage to risk hearing "no." I actually used to believe that asking for what I want is so bad that manipulating others is better! - listening to what other people want, instead of trying to read minds. I think that's led me to more genuine (humanizing?) interactions with people... when I actually succeed lol! But it also sometimes offers opportunities for solidarity and resistance. It's very uncomfortable to talk about this in meetings, which are generally expected to be "apolitical." So even though recovery has gotten me to this point, I think I need other tools to take it farther. And I'm constantly questioning if my political actions are motivated by projections of my own personal & family dysfunction. And maybe that's ok? I dunno, what do you think?

AJ Biffl

Thanks for sharing! I really like that emphasis on actions and on asking/listening! Yeah that's a really good question and it's hard to say in general, but I'm inclined to point back to Feyerabend and say you can't separate reality from the observer even if you want to. Your perception shapes your perspective, and the personal baggage you bring into your worldview in no way invalidates or devalues it. Another word for it is "experience," and if your experience of reality doesn't motivate you, what else even could?

Hari Sood

Penny generous but pound selfish is a really cool phrase Warren! Totally agree on the underestimation of children point, and do think a lot of it comes down to power - if i think of this child as anlesser person, I can assert my authority more easily and get what I want from the relationship. What would change if we see children as full people, just less experience and security than adults?

Hari Sood

Interesting to reflect on this Craig! I wonder though in general how Freirean a course can be when it's delivered within the institutions we have - a truly dialogical education wouldnt have grades, or labels (eg Masters), or a clear start and end point etc... does a university course covering Freire fall into the trap of oppressor generosity he talks about??

Hari Sood

I continue to learn so much from you AJ 😅 this idea of bridging the subjective/objective divide by calling objective those experiences that we share feels really nice - and then yeah from there it means that any shared experience of oppression isn't just subjective, it becomes an objective reality that we then as people must be brave enough to witness, holdd and transform... or something! I hope you see this 😭

Hari Sood

Enjoyed reading your thoughts! I think it is important to remember that, even in a society where we are all truly liberated, there will still be episodes of injustice between people, for which anger, and sometimes violence, is justified. I like your thoughts on recognising these things as part of the human experience! Its definitely difficult as they feel unpleasant and so don't fit with this (probs colonial) view of like pure, peaceful humanity, more like an adaptable, caring and conscious humanity... which brings back the idea from the chapter of consciousness being a method!

Hari Sood

Not sure if u will see this Craig but I believe Alfalfafield is referring to the Hegelian master/slave arguments (that one of the first steps to liberation for the slave is to realise that the master is dependent on them (in a relational sense, in order to still be considered a master), rather than them being just dependent on the master, and so they have an identity themselves that goes beyond their master's perception/ownership of them... I think (both in what they are referring to and what it actually is!)

Hari Sood

I love the way you think and share thoughts phil!!

Craig

Hi Hari, thanks for your reply. I don't think Freire's pedagogy precludes any current institution or structured learning when the organisers and teachers have the flexibility to deliver the content dialogically. It's more about how it's done and the aims of the programme. I take your point about hierarchies and the potential for institutions to be part of the oppressive apparatus, but in my experience the programme I did was primarily aimed at raising critical consciousness through the content of an msc in education. This was explicit throughout, and implied in the form of engagement with said content and the teachers delivering it. It seems to me like this is just good practice when it comes to facilitating learning. I think we need to make distinctions between contexts (of course) in that, sure, an adult literacy course in the community might not require formal assessment - informal feedback alone might be more appropriate there - but then in the context of a university course, the student, by way of deciding to apply and such, has already determined their own needs analysis, if you will, and then it's up to the course to cater for those needs. But there still needs to be some level of assessment to demonstrate that indeed critical consciousness has been raised. Another example that comes to mind is with private education, in which dialogic pedagogy is often the norm - these can be the most elitist institutions, and absolutely part of the capitalist apparatus of oppression (not saying a university isn't), yet for the students attending, the delivery of largely the same content as is taught in state schools is done in a way that raises critical consciousness, rather than the state school example where it's highly likely to be transmission of information from "expert" or artefact to student brain for regurgitation in an exam. The latter is antidialogical, of course. I wouldn't say, at least not in my experience, that it was false generosity, as it was clear that all teachers aimed to facilitate critical consciousness so that the students themselves ultimately became agents of transformation, in their own contexts. And if someone went through the programme, for example, and ended up doing a PhD and all that, they could absolutely go on to become influential in the transformation of the programme itself if they actually had better ideas. I don't think I ever came across any kind of conservative, or gate-keeper type who was closed to new ideas coming from the students. And the more I think about it, the more strongly I feel about these points. Of course I don't know at all about other institutions or programmes, but I think it's a great topic to discuss as there is so much anti-educational nonsense spoken (especially) online these days. It really seems like there is - well let's be honest, we don't need to hedge our language much here - but there is certainly a top down agenda of promoting anti-intellectualism, in various ways, that is then repeated "in the wild" to discourage people from engaging in education, or perhaps in some cases to (over)compensate for perceived low educational achievement, among other factors.

Hari Sood

I don't think anyone will see this so j recording two thoughts... 1) I've loved reading the comments, everyone is so wise and there is as much, if not more, richness in the discussions here than the text by itself ✨️❣️ 2) I read this book about 6 years ago, reading through the same copy again now and seeing my old comments it's funny to see how much more politicised I have become - things that I struggled with before now seem like common sense. I am definitely changing in the right direction!

AJ Biffl

@Hari @Craig y'all raise a really interesting question of whether a critical, dialogical education can truly emerge in an institutional setting. Craig I'm interested to hear if you have pushback against this, but the example of private schooling as being "dialogical" rings sour to me. Those classrooms may be informal and open, but the 'transformation' being cultivated is still expected to take place within the existing social hierarchy. They are not entering into dialogue about the mechanisms of oppression in society and their experiences of them, they are having conversations about the curriculum. Which is surely more enjoyable than a banking-style lecture, but no more revolutionary than buying a rainbow mug on amazon. So I firmly disagree that the forms and aims of the education are all that counts, the material matters too. Also, for the example of a student in a university course "signing up" for grades and tests, I'm not sure I buy that. For most undergrads I've met, college is a required stepping stone toward some other goal (degree, maybe a job in a specific field), and they're not particularly invested in the form that education takes. Likewise, the students who ARE enthusiastic about the actual learning process aren't there to be tested or rewarded/punished by grades, they're there because the material is cool, which is just as easily facilitated in a dialogical style as an anti-dialogical one.

Hari Sood

Love the discussion here it feels really important! Following up on some of AJ's thoughts above - I think I agree that realistically we can't expect students to a) have done (or been able to do, given the information available to them) a rigourous needs analysis of all possible options and chosen equally between them, and b) to not be influenced by the relevative social power of the education they seek. For instance, I did a degree at University, partly because I was interested in the topic, partly because it was just the thing people around me did after school, partly to improve me job prospects. These COULD I guess then be considered fair ways to assess my needs (perhaps my need to be employable, who knows), but then we accept that these institutions aren't places of pure educational pursuit - they serve alternate purposes. If we then follow this through to its radical end, we would likely conclude that no University is a place of pure critical educational pursuit, and they are all muddied by complicated social dynamics. Perhaps a true pedagogy of the oppressed is decentralised, powerless, immeasurable, resilient, without end. For instance, I think I disagree that assessment is needed to show that critical consciousness is raised. It reminds me of the 'the revolution will not be televised' thoughts - the revolution won't happen in places where it can be measured, understood and broadcast. It will happen between people, behind the scenes, in the gaps, where suddenly you look back and everything is changed but you can't quite tell how it all happened. Similarly here, I don't think it is truly radical if it can be measured and assessed - once we do that, there is a value system in place on what is good/bad critical consciousness, controlled by a select few, and we end up back where we started. What about, say, a free-to-access, fully open debate group at a local community centre? Where there is no measure of change and learning but change and learning happens from participants engaging with each other? This to me feels closer to Frierian pedagogy than any University course. I think I also struggle with the private/state school conversation - there are plenty of amazing state schools, plenty of terrible private ones. I don't think private schools de facto teach better than state schools, I think the issues are more systemic than that. If we are talking about differences due to e.g. funding and resourcing, that conversation makes more sense to me!

AJ Biffl

Yeah correcting for funding I think removes almost all the differences between private and state schools