Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 526393576.mp4

Downloads

Content

Trying something a little different for office hours this time! Instead of pre-recording it, I answer your questions on an unannounced stream, the recording of which will only exist here on patreon. First questions starts at 3:50, first hour or so is answering patron questions, and the last 30 minutes are answering some random questions in the chat.

As a reminder, if you want to ask a question for me to answer on Office Hours, you can do so any time at this google form that will be my question collecting place until further notice. For this recording, I went back and tried to find any hanging questions on old posts, but I'm not going to do that moving forward. Also, if I missed a question you had posted/DMed somewhere, just add it on the form and I'll get to it.

I'm curious what people think of this version as opposed to the pre-recorded office hours I usually do---I like the polished quality of my other ones, but this way of doing it is so much easier that I think I'd be able to do it more regularly (like once a month instead of a few times a year) if the barrier to making them is a little lower. I imagine streaming on the channel will also direct more people to the patreon, but prioritizing patron questions and saving the recording only here still makes it somewhat exclusive. But if people really hate this version, idk maybe I'll keep doing the slower high effort ones. If you have strong opinions either way, let me know what you think.

also im so annoyed at myself, i spent a lot of time setting up my proper camera and mic for this stream and afterwards realized I was still recording with my laptop camera, womp womp. i'll get it next time

fatima

~~~~~~~

Mentioned links:

That xkcd comic: https://xkcd.com/435/

video on sciences hierarchy: https://youtu.be/LenX321o16c?si=fXVNjRVBW-G22y8y

Files

Comments

AJ Biffl

Thanks for the answer! I love your point about studying boundary conditions, it's got me thinking about how trying to build a fence can get at explicating the parts of science we care about or think are good, and what sort of things at the edges of "science" still carry that good, and if there are interesting things at the edges that might reveal other new things that are good to us too. You've given me a lot to think about :) ~^_~^_~^_~^_~^_~^_~^_~^_ About the whole 'hierarchy of sciences' thing, there's like something to be said that yes, you can explain *why* some chemistry things happen based on physics things, but that's a different thing than generating chemistry knowledge.

Tyler Evert

Regarding the "is assassinating scientists ok" question around 16ish minutes - I think part of what makes people wonder that is the hero mythos that people put into scientists. Oppenheimer is frequently cited as "the guy who did the nukes", but as you pointed out, they would've got somebody else. The idea that you can just get another scientist isn't culturally understood (at least in the west?), like how you can't just get another Batman. I'm also thinking specifically of the number of times you've talked about how there aren't any hero scientists making hero discoveries nowadays, because modern astrophysics is a huge team effort involving lots of "boring" number crunching. Same kind misconception I think.

David Lindes

Thanks for this! I watched the first 2/3 or so of it on YouTube, but was delayed, and so it kicked me off[0], but I'd been enjoying myself enough that I came back and found my spot here and watched the rest. Fun times. :) [0] I was hoping it wouldn't, since you mentioned at some point leaving it as unlisted, but I guess you went straight to private? Ah well. :)

Warren Shull

If it’s unannounced, how did people know it was happening?

Michael Roberson

I like these just as much as the video essays. 💯

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Thank you so much for the answer! Greatly appreciated and indeed what I wanted you to comment on, even though my question had been long and full of subquestion and even included reading material (sorry). I liked hearing your perspective on it and I'm definitely going to check the recommended reading!

phil e the theyby

I thought the format was perfectly fine, and if it’s lower effort and still comfortable for you, go for it! I definitely agree with the “being more specific” idea around intelligence. I’m not trying to say that folks who have traditionally been called “intelligent” (basically, folks who understand physics with relative ease) don’t have a talent that’s valuable! I just want us to be more clear about what those abilities are, and to get away from a hierarchy of certain people having more or less worth based on specific mental abilities. The flip-side of this (identifying things as “dumb” or “stupid “) feels just as relevant, especially when talking about people who disagree with us politically. Describing them as “stupid” reeks of eugenics, an idea explicitly endorsed by the movie Idiocracy (SarahZ’s video on the topic is really good). I don’t think describing something or someone as “dumb” is a slur or anything, but I think a lot of people who use that terminology think they’re helping, while they’re actually reinforcing ideas that make things worse. I don’t experience your responding to anticipated criticism as weakening your points at all. As someone from a philosophy background, I feel like this is just being rigorous and thoughtful in your perspective. People who don’t have that philosophy may see it differently. But for me, I think it’s good to be in conversation with other perspectives on our ideas, rather than just preaching to the choir. So I think anticipating and responding to common (and potentially good-faith) criticisms is VERY helpful, and it’s one of my favorite parts of your videos. Lots of great stuff in this Office Hours! Your response against people who say, “but astrology is used in these bad ways!” by pointing out that science and literally everything else is ALSO used in bad ways was something I never articulated, but is incredibly accurate and valuable to hold onto.

Matus Chochlik

Thanks for another nice engaging video! An anecdote to the point that being "good" at something doesn't automatically make you generally smart; I used to teach as a post-doc at a university and some of the biggest conspiracy theorists I've ever met were my older colleagues. One in particular for example published multiple papers in Science about the mathematical foundations of quantum computing. He also used to post flyers around the campus like "the EU wants to 'homosexualize' 1/3 of the people for the purposes of population control" and made multiple ethnic-supremacist comments.